Supplemental Guidelines on the Implementation of the Mental Health Policy and Program in the Workplace, Labor Advisory No. 19, September 15, 2023 | Disability and Death Benefits | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

On September 15, 2023, the Philippine Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) issued Labor Advisory No. 19, Series of 2023, providing supplemental guidelines for implementing Mental Health Policies and Programs in the workplace. This advisory builds upon DOLE Department Order No. 208, Series of 2020, and aligns with Republic Act No. 11036, known as the Mental Health Act.

Key Provisions of Labor Advisory No. 19-2023:

1. Access to Mental Health Services:

   • Employers are mandated to ensure that employees have effective access to mental health and self-care services. This includes utilizing resources such as the Department of Health's (DOH) Lusog-Isip mobile application, which offers mental health support and information.

2. Referral to Health Facilities:

   • Employees requiring mental health services should be referred to appropriate facilities, including DOH-retained hospitals and rural health units, for consultation, screening, diagnosis, medication, treatment, and psychosocial support.

3. Work Accommodations and Arrangements:

   • Employers are encouraged to provide reasonable accommodations for employees needing medical attention due to mental health conditions. These accommodations may include:
     • Paid leave benefits in addition to existing leave entitlements under company policy, collective bargaining agreements, the Labor Code, and special laws.
     • Flexible work arrangements, such as rescheduling work hours or adopting telecommuting practices.
     • Other supportive benefits as deemed appropriate.

4. Confidentiality and Data Privacy:

   • Employers must uphold the confidentiality of all information and medical records related to employees with mental health conditions. This is in compliance with Republic Act No. 10173, or the Data Privacy Act of 2012, to prevent unauthorized access, alteration, disclosure, or any unlawful processing of sensitive information.

5. Reporting Requirements:

   • An Annual Medical Report Form must be submitted to the DOLE, detailing:
     • The number of mental health cases handled or referred to service providers.
     • Activities and programs implemented to promote mental health within the workplace.

Context and Legal Framework:

The issuance of Labor Advisory No. 19-2023 reinforces the Philippine government's commitment to mental health, as established by the Mental Health Act (Republic Act No. 11036) enacted in 2018. This Act emphasizes the promotion of mental health, the protection of rights for individuals with mental health conditions, and the integration of mental health services into the nation's healthcare system.

In 2020, DOLE released Department Order No. 208, which provided initial guidelines for implementing mental health policies and programs in the private sector. Labor Advisory No. 19-2023 serves to supplement these guidelines, ensuring that employers adopt comprehensive mental health policies that include:

• Advocacy, information dissemination, education, and training on mental health.
• Mechanisms for work accommodation and reintegration of employees with mental health conditions.
• Assurance of confidentiality for all information related to employees' mental health conditions.
• Support mechanisms facilitating access to counseling and other mental health services.

Implications for Employers and Employees:

Employers are required to develop and implement mental health policies and programs tailored to their specific workplace environments. This includes providing access to mental health services, ensuring confidentiality, and accommodating employees' mental health needs through flexible work arrangements and additional leave benefits.

Employees, on the other hand, are encouraged to utilize the mental health resources and support systems made available by their employers. They should also be aware of their rights concerning confidentiality and the accommodations they are entitled to under the law.

In summary, Labor Advisory No. 19-2023 underscores the importance of mental health in the workplace and delineates the responsibilities of employers in fostering a supportive and inclusive environment for employees with mental health needs.

Rules on referral to third doctor | Disability and Death Benefits | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

Rules on Referral to a Third Doctor under Philippine Labor Law

In the context of disability and death benefits under labor law and social legislation in the Philippines, the referral to a third doctor arises when there is a disagreement between the findings of the company-designated physician and the employee’s chosen physician regarding the employee’s fitness to work or disability grading. The procedure is governed by jurisprudence, notably in cases involving seafarers under POEA contracts, and by the Labor Code and its implementing rules. Below is a detailed discussion of the rules and jurisprudential principles on this subject:

---

1. Legal Basis

The rules on referral to a third doctor are primarily rooted in:

• The Philippine Overseas Employment Administration-Standard Employment Contract (POEA-SEC) for seafarers, particularly Section 20, which outlines the duties of the company-designated physician, the process of contesting medical findings, and the procedure for referral.
• Labor Code of the Philippines, as supplemented by relevant social legislation (e.g., Employees’ Compensation Act).

---

2. Company-Designated Physician’s Role

The company-designated physician has the primary responsibility to assess the medical condition of an employee who suffers from work-related injury or illness. This physician must:

• Issue a medical assessment or final disability grading within the prescribed period (usually 120 to 240 days, depending on the circumstances and compliance with legal and procedural requirements).
• Certify whether the employee is fit to work or assign a degree of permanent disability.

Failure to issue a timely and complete medical assessment may result in the presumption of permanent total disability in favor of the employee.

---

3. Dispute with the Employee’s Chosen Physician

If the employee disputes the findings of the company-designated physician, they may consult their own physician of choice. The employee’s physician may issue a differing opinion on:

• Fitness to work, or
• The degree of disability.

---

4. Referral to a Third Doctor

If a conflict arises between the assessments of the company-designated physician and the employee’s chosen physician, the third-doctor referral rule applies:

A. Who Can Initiate Referral?

• Either the employer or the employee can initiate the referral to a third doctor, provided there is a conflict between the findings of the two prior physicians.

B. Binding Nature of the Third Doctor’s Findings

• The findings of the third doctor, mutually agreed upon by both parties, are final and binding on both the employer and the employee.

C. When Should Referral Be Made?

• Referral must be made immediately or within a reasonable time after the issuance of the conflicting medical opinions.
• Delays in referral or failure to invoke the third-doctor rule may prejudice the case of the party responsible for the delay.

D. Procedure for Referral

• There is no fixed procedural requirement for the referral, but it is generally expected that the parties agree on the third doctor and cooperate in the referral process.
• The cost of the referral is typically borne by the employer.

E. Employer’s Obligation to Act Promptly

• Employers must act promptly in addressing the dispute and in facilitating the referral process. Failure to do so may result in a presumption in favor of the employee’s claims.

---

5. Jurisprudence on Third-Doctor Referral

Philippine courts have consistently emphasized the importance of compliance with the third-doctor referral rule in cases involving disability claims. Key rulings include:

A. Vergara v. Hammonia Maritime Services, Inc. (2008)

• Established the 120/240-day rule and clarified that the referral to a third doctor is the mandatory recourse in case of conflicting medical findings.
• The third doctor’s decision is final and binding.

B. Wallem Maritime Services, Inc. v. Tanawan (2016)

• Highlighted that failure to invoke the third-doctor referral process results in the binding effect of the employee’s chosen physician’s findings if they are supported by substantial evidence.

C. Elburg Shipmanagement Phils., Inc. v. Quiogue, Jr. (2017)

• Clarified the procedural aspects of invoking the third-doctor rule, emphasizing the need for prompt and reasonable action by both parties.

D. C.F. Sharp Crew Management, Inc. v. Taok (2020)

• Reiterated that a valid referral to a third doctor must be mutually agreed upon and conducted in good faith.

---

6. Practical Implications

For Employees:

• Ensure that disagreements with the company-designated physician’s findings are substantiated by a credible medical opinion from a qualified physician.
• Promptly request referral to a third doctor if disagreement arises.

For Employers:

• Strictly observe the timelines and procedural requirements for medical assessments and third-doctor referrals.
• Facilitate the referral process and act in good faith to avoid adverse rulings.

For the Third Doctor:

• The third doctor must be a mutually agreed-upon, independent medical expert who will issue an impartial assessment based on the employee’s condition.

---

7. Key Takeaways

• The third-doctor referral rule is mandatory in resolving disputes over medical findings.
• Failure to comply with this process can significantly impact the outcome of disability or death benefit claims.
• Both parties must act promptly, reasonably, and in good faith to ensure compliance with the rule.

This framework ensures fairness in the resolution of disability claims, balancing the rights of employees and employers.

POEA Standard Employment Contract – Sec. 32 POEA Standard Employment Contract | Disability and Death Benefits | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

LABOR LAW AND SOCIAL LEGISLATION: POEA Standard Employment Contract – Section 32 (Disability and Death Benefits)

The POEA Standard Employment Contract (SEC), issued by the Philippine Overseas Employment Administration (POEA), provides the standard terms and conditions governing the employment of Filipino seafarers onboard ocean-going vessels. Section 32 specifically outlines the rules on disability and death benefits for seafarers and their beneficiaries.

---

A. Overview of Section 32

Section 32 of the POEA Standard Employment Contract is a critical provision in safeguarding the rights of seafarers and their dependents. It provides:

1. Enumerated Occupational Diseases and Conditions: Lists compensable illnesses and injuries.
2. Compensation for Disability: Defines the schedule of disability benefits based on the severity of the condition.
3. Compensation for Death: Outlines benefits payable to legal beneficiaries upon a seafarer’s death.
4. Procedures for Medical Assessment: Establishes the procedures for medical treatment and disability grading.
5. Exclusions from Liability: Specifies conditions under which claims are not compensable.

---

B. Coverage

Section 32 applies to Filipino seafarers employed under POEA-approved contracts. The benefits cover:

• Disabilities resulting from work-related illnesses or injuries sustained during the term of employment.
• Death occurring during the employment contract, whether due to work-related causes or natural causes while onboard or ashore during employment.

---

C. Key Provisions

1. Disability Benefits

• Compensable Disabilities: A seafarer is entitled to disability benefits for illnesses or injuries that:
  • Are work-related.
  • Occur during the term of the contract.
• Grading System: Section 32-A provides a detailed schedule of disabilities and corresponding grades (Grades 1 to 14), with Grade 1 being the most severe.
  • Grade 1 Disability: Entitles the seafarer to the maximum disability benefit.
  • Grade 14 Disability: Entitles the seafarer to the minimum benefit.
• Permanent Total Disability (PTD): Even if not explicitly covered by the grading, a seafarer may be entitled to full compensation if the condition results in a complete inability to perform usual work.
• Compensation Amount: The POEA SEC sets a cap on disability benefits, typically based on the seafarer’s rank and contractual provisions.

---

2. Death Benefits

• Amount of Compensation: In the event of death during the term of the contract, the legal heirs (spouse, children, or parents) are entitled to death benefits:
  • US$50,000 for the primary beneficiary (spouse or children).
  • US$7,000 additional benefit per child (up to four children under the age of 21).
• Repatriation and Burial Expenses: The employer is responsible for the cost of repatriating the remains and covering burial expenses.

---

3. Medical Procedures and Certification

• Mandatory Reporting: The seafarer must report any illness or injury sustained during employment.
• Company-Designated Physician:
  • The seafarer must undergo treatment and assessment by a company-designated physician.
  • The physician must issue a final medical assessment within 120 days (extendable to 240 days in certain cases) to determine the degree of disability.
• Second Medical Opinion:
  • If the seafarer disagrees with the company-designated physician’s assessment, they may consult a doctor of their choice.
  • Disputes may be resolved through a third doctor jointly chosen by the employer and the seafarer, whose decision is final and binding.

---

4. Work-Relatedness of Illnesses

Section 32 includes a list of occupational diseases presumed work-related if certain conditions are met, such as:

• Diseases due to physical, chemical, or biological factors in the work environment.
• Cardiovascular diseases or hypertension resulting from stressful working conditions.
• Musculoskeletal injuries due to repetitive strain or physical labor.

---

5. Exclusions

The employer is not liable for disability or death benefits if:

• The injury or illness is due to the seafarer’s willful misconduct, negligence, or pre-existing condition not disclosed during the pre-employment medical examination (PEME).
• The seafarer’s condition arose after the contract period or during an unauthorized absence.

---

D. Jurisprudence on Section 32

The Philippine Supreme Court has issued landmark rulings interpreting Section 32, emphasizing the following:

1. Liberal Interpretation in Favor of the Seafarer: Any ambiguity in the POEA SEC is resolved in favor of the seafarer, given the protective mantle of labor law.
2. Permanent Total Disability: Even if the condition is graded lower under Section 32-A, a seafarer may be deemed totally disabled if unable to return to sea.
3. Work-Connection: The Court has ruled that even non-listed illnesses may be compensable if causally linked to the nature of the seafarer’s work.

---

E. Recent Amendments and Developments

The POEA regularly updates the Standard Employment Contract to align with international standards, such as those under the Maritime Labour Convention (MLC, 2006). These updates ensure better protection for Filipino seafarers while addressing evolving maritime challenges.

---

F. Practical Steps for Claiming Benefits

1. Immediate Reporting: Report any illness or injury to the employer and seek medical attention promptly.
2. Medical Records: Keep thorough documentation of treatment and assessments.
3. Consult Legal Counsel: In case of disputes over compensation or disability grading, seek assistance from labor lawyers or accredited unions.

---

Section 32 of the POEA Standard Employment Contract remains a vital instrument in protecting the rights and welfare of Filipino seafarers and their families, ensuring compensation for the risks inherent in maritime work.

Labor Code, Article 198 | Disability and Death Benefits | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

Article 198 of the Labor Code: Disability and Death Benefits under Social Legislation

I. Overview: Article 198 of the Labor Code of the Philippines primarily addresses the provision of disability and death benefits for employees under the Employees' Compensation Program (ECP). This provision operates within the framework of Presidential Decree No. 626, as amended, which institutionalized a state insurance program for workers suffering work-related injuries, diseases, or death.

The article underscores the obligation of employers to secure their employees under the ECP and ensure access to benefits administered by the Social Security System (SSS) for private sector employees or the Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) for public sector employees.

---

II. Scope of Coverage:

1. Employees Covered:

   • All employees, whether permanent, temporary, or casual, are covered, provided they are enrolled in the Employees' Compensation Program.
   • It applies to employees in both the private and public sectors.
   • Self-employed individuals and voluntary SSS members are excluded.

2. Risks Covered:

   • Work-connected disability or death, arising from accidents, illnesses, or diseases during the course of employment.
   • The injury or disease must be shown to have been acquired or aggravated during work.

---

III. Benefits under Article 198: Employees or their beneficiaries are entitled to the following benefits under the ECP:

1. Disability Benefits:

   • Temporary Total Disability (TTD):
     • Compensation is provided during the period the employee is unable to work.
     • Benefits include a daily income benefit equivalent to 90% of the average daily salary credit (ADSC), not exceeding 120 days (extendable to 240 days for exceptional cases).
   • Permanent Partial Disability (PPD):
     • Compensation for loss or impairment of body parts or functions.
     • Benefits vary depending on the specific injury and are computed based on a schedule of disabilities prescribed by the law.
   • Permanent Total Disability (PTD):
     • Benefits for cases of permanent incapacity to perform gainful work.
     • Monthly pension equivalent to the employee's ADSC, subject to minimum and maximum limits.

2. Medical and Rehabilitation Services:

   • Coverage for necessary medical, surgical, and hospital treatment, as well as rehabilitation services to restore work capacity.
   • Includes prosthetics, therapy, and other medical supplies or devices.

3. Death Benefits:

   • Provided to the primary beneficiaries (e.g., spouse, children) or secondary beneficiaries (e.g., parents) in the absence of primary beneficiaries.
   • Lump-sum or monthly pension, depending on the employment contributions and ADSC.

4. Funeral Benefits:

   • A fixed amount provided to the family or designated beneficiaries of the deceased employee for burial expenses.
   • As of recent amendments, the funeral benefit is ₱30,000.00 but may vary based on prevailing regulations.

---

IV. Conditions for Compensation:

1. Causality:

   • The illness, injury, or death must be work-related or aggravated by employment conditions.
   • Occupational diseases listed under the ECC guidelines are presumed compensable. For unlisted diseases, proof of causation is required.

2. Timeliness:

   • Notice of injury or illness must be reported to the employer within five (5) days from occurrence. Failure to report may bar claims unless justified.

3. Good Faith:

   • Claims must not be fraudulent or intended to deceive. Misrepresentation can result in denial or penalties.

---

V. Administration and Claims Process:

1. Responsible Agencies:

   • The Employees’ Compensation Commission (ECC) oversees policy formulation and implementation.
   • The SSS administers benefits for private-sector employees, while the GSIS administers benefits for government employees.

2. Filing of Claims:

   • Claims for disability or death benefits must be filed with the SSS or GSIS, supported by appropriate documentation, including medical reports and employment records.

3. Adjudication and Appeals:

   • Denied claims may be appealed to the ECC and subsequently to the Court of Appeals or Supreme Court as necessary.

---

VI. Employer Obligations:

1. Registration and Contributions:

   • Employers must register employees under the SSS or GSIS and remit contributions for ECP coverage.
   • Failure to register deprives the employer of the right to contest claims and makes them directly liable for benefits.

2. Workplace Safety:

   • Employers must maintain safe working conditions to prevent occupational injuries or diseases.
   • Non-compliance with safety standards may result in administrative or criminal liability.

---

VII. Limitations and Prohibitions:

1. Exclusive Remedy Rule:

   • ECP benefits are the exclusive remedies for work-related disability or death, precluding civil claims unless due to gross negligence or intentional harm by the employer.

2. No Duplication of Benefits:

   • Employees cannot claim compensation under both ECP and regular social insurance for the same contingency.

3. Prescriptive Period:

   • Claims must be filed within three (3) years from the date of injury, illness, or death, beyond which the right to compensation is barred.

---

VIII. Recent Amendments and Jurisprudence:

1. Updates on Benefit Amounts:

   • Recent increases in funeral and disability benefit rates reflect adjustments to inflation and cost-of-living changes.

2. Landmark Cases:

   • GSIS v. De Leon (2016): Clarified that aggravation of a pre-existing condition may render it compensable.
   • ECC v. Sanico (2019): Emphasized strict compliance with the causality requirement for unlisted occupational diseases.

---

IX. Conclusion: Article 198 ensures the welfare of employees through disability and death benefits under the Employees' Compensation Program. Its provisions reflect the state’s commitment to protect workers and their dependents from the adverse effects of employment-related risks, balancing the needs of employees with the responsibilities of employers. Proper understanding and implementation are crucial for safeguarding the rights and obligations under this critical aspect of labor law.

Disability and Death Benefits | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

LABOR LAW AND SOCIAL LEGISLATION: DISABILITY AND DEATH BENEFITS IN THE PHILIPPINES

The Philippine legal framework for disability and death benefits is primarily rooted in the Labor Code of the Philippines, Social Security Act, Employees’ Compensation Act, and various related regulations. Below is a detailed and meticulous discussion:

---

I. DISABILITY BENEFITS

Disability benefits are granted to employees who suffer work-related injuries or illnesses that result in partial or total disability. They are governed by both private employment law (Labor Code) and state insurance systems like SSS, GSIS, and the Employees’ Compensation Commission (ECC).

A. Categories of Disability

1. Permanent Total Disability (PTD)
   Defined as a disability that permanently prevents an employee from performing any gainful occupation. Examples include loss of two limbs, total blindness in both eyes, and insanity.

2. Permanent Partial Disability (PPD)
   Refers to the loss or impairment of a specific body part or function that reduces earning capacity but does not completely prevent employment. Examples: amputation of a finger, hearing loss in one ear.

3. Temporary Total Disability (TTD)
   Applies when the employee is unable to work for a certain period due to injury or illness but is expected to recover.

B. Benefits Under the Labor Code and Employees’ Compensation Act

1. Income Benefits

   • Compensation is provided for loss of income due to disability.
   • The benefit is equivalent to 90% of the average daily salary credit (ADSC), subject to a maximum and minimum threshold.

2. Medical and Rehabilitation Services

   • Injured employees are entitled to immediate and adequate medical care, including rehabilitation services.
   • These include hospitalization, therapy, and prosthetics as necessary.

3. Disability Retirement

   • Workers who meet the criteria for permanent total disability may also qualify for disability retirement benefits under SSS or GSIS.

C. Filing Process

1. Report of Injury
   The employer is required to report the injury to the Social Security System (SSS) or ECC within 3 days.

2. Documentation

   • Claimants must provide medical records, employment records, and proof of injury or illness.

3. Adjudication
   Claims are evaluated by the SSS/ECC, and disputes may be elevated to the ECC Appeals Division or the courts.

---

II. DEATH BENEFITS

Death benefits are provided to the beneficiaries of an employee who dies due to a work-related injury, illness, or during the performance of their duties.

A. Beneficiaries

1. Primary Beneficiaries

   • Legal spouse (if not legally separated) and dependent legitimate, illegitimate, or legally adopted children.

2. Secondary Beneficiaries

   • If no primary beneficiaries exist, death benefits are paid to dependent parents or other legal heirs.

B. Coverage

Death benefits are governed by:

1. Social Security Act of 2018 (Republic Act No. 11199)
   Provides benefits for private-sector employees.

2. Employees’ Compensation Act (Presidential Decree No. 626)
   Grants benefits to employees who die from work-related causes.

C. Benefits

1. Monthly Pension

   • SSS: Dependents receive a monthly pension equivalent to the member’s total credited years of service.
   • ECC: Grants a fixed monthly pension for primary beneficiaries.

2. Lump Sum Benefit
   If the deceased employee does not meet the minimum contributions for a monthly pension, the beneficiaries receive a lump sum equivalent to their contributions.

3. Funeral Benefits

   • SSS: A fixed funeral grant (currently Php 40,000).
   • ECC: An additional funeral grant (Php 30,000 under ECC rules).

4. Medical Reimbursement

   • Covers medical expenses incurred by the employee prior to death due to a work-related injury or illness.

D. Filing Process

1. Notification by Employer
   Employers must file an employer's report of death within 3 days of the incident.

2. Claim Application

   • Beneficiaries submit death certificates, proof of relationship, and other required documentation.
   • Claims are filed with SSS or ECC.

3. Adjudication and Appeals
   Decisions by the SSS or ECC may be appealed to the Employees’ Compensation Appeals Board (ECAB) or higher courts.

---

III. RELATIONSHIP TO OTHER LAWS AND PROGRAMS

A. Overlap with Social Security Benefits

SSS provides additional disability and death benefits outside the Employees' Compensation Program, but double compensation is prohibited for the same contingency.

B. PhilHealth

• Provides hospitalization and medical expense coverage for illnesses and injuries but does not directly provide disability or death compensation.

C. DOLE Labor Standards Enforcement

• Ensures employer compliance with safety standards to prevent work-related injuries and fatalities.

D. Seafarers and Overseas Workers

• Governed by special laws and contracts, such as the POEA Standard Employment Contract, which provides specific benefits for seafarers and OFWs who suffer disability or death while deployed.

---

IV. RECENT JURISPRUDENCE

1. Disability Claims in Seafarers

   • Cases such as Vergara v. Hammonia Maritime Services emphasize the need for medical certifications from company-designated physicians within 120-240 days.

2. Dual Coverage Disputes

   • In cases like ECC v. Supreme Court of the Philippines, it was clarified that ECC benefits are distinct and complementary to SSS or GSIS benefits.

3. Cause of Death

   • Rulings often hinge on whether the illness or injury is work-related, as in San Miguel Foods, Inc. v. Rivera.

---

V. COMPLIANCE AND PENALTIES

1. Employer’s Obligation

   • Employers are required to remit contributions to SSS, ECC, and other relevant programs.
   • Failure results in penalties, fines, and criminal prosecution.

2. ECC Monitoring

   • The ECC has the mandate to investigate and ensure compliance with reporting requirements and benefit distribution.

3. Employee Awareness

   • Workers are encouraged to report unsafe conditions and file for benefits promptly to avoid prescription of claims.

---

This comprehensive overview of disability and death benefits ensures that workers and their families are adequately protected against the risks associated with employment in the Philippines. For further case-specific advice, consultation with a labor law expert or a legal counsel specializing in social legislation is essential.

Portability – R.A. No. 7699 | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

Portability – Republic Act No. 7699 (Portability Law)

Republic Act No. 7699, also known as the "Portability Law," was enacted on May 1, 1994, to provide Filipino workers with enhanced social security coverage and benefits. This law addresses the issue of portability in social legislation by allowing contributions from different pension systems to be credited towards a worker's retirement, disability, and other benefits. Below is a detailed explanation of its provisions and implications.

---

I. Objective of R.A. No. 7699

The Portability Law aims to:

1. Promote Continuity of Coverage: Ensure that workers who move between different types of employment (private and government) can retain their social security benefits by consolidating their contributions.
2. Encourage Mobility in Employment: Remove barriers to employment transitions between the private sector, government service, or other covered entities without losing social security contributions.
3. Ensure Adequate Social Protection: Provide sufficient retirement or disability benefits for workers even if their contributions are spread across different systems.

---

II. Scope of Coverage

The law applies to:

1. Private Sector Workers: Covered by the Social Security System (SSS).
2. Government Workers: Covered by the Government Service Insurance System (GSIS).
3. Workers with Dual Membership: Employees who have worked in both the private and public sectors at different points in their careers.
4. Voluntary Members: Individuals contributing to either SSS or GSIS under voluntary coverage schemes.

---

III. Key Provisions

1. Definition of Portability:

   • Portability refers to the transfer or combination of credited years of service (contributions) across two systems (SSS and GSIS) to meet eligibility requirements for retirement, disability, survivorship, or other benefits.

2. Totalization of Contributions:

   • Contributions from both SSS and GSIS are combined or "totalized" to determine eligibility for benefits. For example:
     • If a worker contributed 7 years to SSS and 8 years to GSIS, their total credited service would be 15 years, which meets the 10-year minimum for retirement under either system.

3. Benefits Payment:

   • Each system pays its proportionate share of benefits based on the total contributions made to that system.
   • For example:
     • If a worker’s total credited service is 15 years (7 in SSS, 8 in GSIS), SSS will pay 7/15 of the retirement benefit, and GSIS will pay 8/15.

4. Eligibility for Retirement Benefits:

   • A worker must have a combined total of at least 120 months (10 years) of contributions to qualify for retirement benefits.
   • The worker must meet the minimum age requirement:
     • SSS: 60 years old (optional retirement) or 65 years old (mandatory retirement).
     • GSIS: 60 years old with at least 15 years of service for retirement under GSIS rules.

5. Disability and Survivorship Benefits:

   • The principle of totalization also applies to disability and survivorship benefits, ensuring that contributions across systems are not forfeited.

6. Conditions for Transferability:

   • Contributions must not have been previously refunded.
   • The individual must not be receiving similar benefits from either SSS or GSIS at the time of claim.

7. No Double Benefits:

   • Workers cannot claim full benefits from both systems independently. Only proportionate benefits based on totalized contributions are paid.

---

IV. Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR)

1. Coordination Between SSS and GSIS:

   • SSS and GSIS are required to coordinate and establish mechanisms for the seamless transfer or combination of contributions.
   • Both agencies maintain records to verify a worker’s total credited service.

2. Application Process:

   • Claimants must file their applications with the system they last contributed to (either SSS or GSIS).
   • The receiving agency processes the claim and coordinates with the other system for computation and payment of benefits.

---

V. Key Benefits of R.A. No. 7699

1. Enhanced Security for Workers:
   • Workers benefit from uninterrupted social protection despite employment shifts.
2. Increased Accessibility:
   • Easier qualification for retirement and other benefits.
3. Encourages Employment Flexibility:
   • Workers can freely move between sectors without fear of losing their social security contributions.

---

VI. Examples of Application

Scenario 1: A Private Employee Transfers to Government Work

• A worker contributes to SSS for 8 years before transferring to a government job and contributes to GSIS for another 7 years. Under the Portability Law:
  • Total years of service: 15 years.
  • The worker is eligible for retirement benefits, which will be paid proportionally by SSS and GSIS.

Scenario 2: A Government Employee Shifts to the Private Sector

• A worker contributes to GSIS for 10 years, then moves to the private sector and contributes to SSS for 5 years. Under the Portability Law:
  • Total years of service: 15 years.
  • The worker qualifies for benefits, proportionately shared by both GSIS and SSS.

---

VII. Limitations and Clarifications

1. Proportional Sharing of Benefits:

   • The benefits are calculated based on the contributions to each system, which may result in lower total benefits compared to uninterrupted contributions in a single system.

2. Refunds and Forfeitures:

   • Workers who previously refunded their contributions in either SSS or GSIS cannot include those refunded periods in the totalization.

3. Dual Pensions:

   • Workers cannot receive separate pensions from both systems for the same period of service.

---

VIII. Practical Implications

The Portability Law underscores the importance of ensuring that workers maintain records of their employment and contributions to both SSS and GSIS. Proper documentation and timely filing of claims are critical to avoid delays or denial of benefits.

---

IX. Conclusion

Republic Act No. 7699 serves as a cornerstone of social legislation in the Philippines by providing a robust framework for portability of social security benefits. It ensures that Filipino workers enjoy continuity of coverage and protection throughout their careers, regardless of employment transitions. By fostering collaboration between SSS and GSIS, the law addresses the evolving needs of the modern workforce while upholding the principles of equity and social justice.

Benefits | Government Service Insurance System Law - R.A. No. 8291 | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

LABOR LAW AND SOCIAL LEGISLATION

III. SOCIAL LEGISLATION

B. Government Service Insurance System Law - R.A. No. 8291

3. Benefits

The Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) operates under Republic Act No. 8291, also known as the "GSIS Act of 1997." This law outlines the benefits granted to members of the GSIS, which includes government employees, their dependents, and beneficiaries. Below is an exhaustive list and explanation of benefits under the GSIS Law.

---

A. SOCIAL INSURANCE BENEFITS

1. Compulsory Life Insurance

   • All GSIS members are automatically covered by a life insurance policy.
   • Types of Coverage:
     • Enhanced Life Policy (ELP) for regular members.
     • Optional Life Policy (OLP) for members who wish to augment their existing coverage.
   • Benefits:
     • Death benefits for beneficiaries.
     • Funeral benefits to help with burial expenses.
     • Accrued dividends (if applicable).

2. Retirement Benefits

   • Provided to members who have rendered service and reached retirement age or completed the required years of service.
   • Modes of Retirement:
     • Under R.A. 8291:
       • Eligibility: Minimum of 15 years of service and 60 years old upon retirement.
       • Options:
         • 5-Year Lump Sum: Member receives a 60-month pension upfront with a resumption of monthly pensions after five years.
         • Cash Payment and Pension: Lump sum equivalent to 18 months' worth of the Basic Monthly Pension (BMP) and a corresponding monthly pension thereafter.
     • Under R.A. 1616:
       • Gratuity-based benefit for those with at least 20 years of service.
       • Refund of personal contributions without government counterpart.
     • Under P.D. 1146:
       • Older law applicable to members prior to R.A. 8291; offers a similar benefit structure to R.A. 8291.

3. Disability Benefits

   • For members who are rendered permanently or temporarily disabled.
   • Categories:
     • Permanent Total Disability (PTD): Lifetime monthly pension or cash benefit.
     • Permanent Partial Disability (PPD): Lump sum or monthly pension based on the degree of disability.
     • Temporary Total Disability (TTD): Daily cash benefit for the duration of the disability, up to 120 days (extendable to 240 days).

4. Survivorship Benefits

   • Granted to the qualified beneficiaries of deceased GSIS members or pensioners.
   • Eligibility:
     • Primary beneficiaries: Legal spouse and dependent children.
     • Secondary beneficiaries: Designated individuals or legal heirs (if no primary beneficiaries exist).
   • Types of Benefits:
     • Lifetime monthly pension for eligible spouse.
     • Dependent children receive an equivalent of 10% of the BMP until they reach majority age.

5. Funeral Benefits

   • Provided to assist with burial and funeral expenses of deceased members or pensioners.
   • Fixed amount of PHP 30,000 to PHP 50,000, subject to periodic adjustments by the GSIS Board.

---

B. LOAN PRIVILEGES

1. Policy Loan

   • Members can borrow against their life insurance policy's cash value.

2. Consolidated Loan (Conso-Loan)

   • Combines salary loans, emergency loans, and other loan accounts into one.

3. Emergency Loan

   • Available during calamities or emergencies declared by the government.

4. Housing Loan

   • Assistance for members to purchase, construct, or renovate a house.

5. Educational Loan

   • Available to assist members in funding their children’s education.

6. Pension Loan

   • Exclusively for old-age pensioners, subject to age and pension rate limitations.

---

C. SEPARATION BENEFITS

• For members who leave government service before qualifying for retirement benefits.
• Types:
  • Cash Payment: Refund of accumulated personal and government contributions, plus interest.
  • Deferred Pension: Members with at least 15 years of service but below the minimum retirement age (60) may receive a pension upon reaching retirement age.

---

D. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION (EC) BENEFITS

• Provides compensation for work-related contingencies.
• Coverage:
  • Sickness or injury.
  • Permanent disability.
  • Death resulting from work-related causes.
• Benefits:
  • Daily sickness allowance.
  • Monthly disability pension.
  • Funeral benefit for work-related death.

---

E. OPTIONAL BENEFITS

• Members may avail themselves of optional products offered by GSIS, such as additional life insurance or housing benefit schemes.

---

F. PORTABILITY LAW BENEFITS

• Under R.A. 7699, members who transfer between the GSIS and the Social Security System (SSS) may combine their service years from both institutions to qualify for retirement, disability, or survivorship benefits.

---

Key Notes:

1. Beneficiaries:

   • Primary: Legal spouse, dependent children, and legitimate/illegitimate parents.
   • Secondary: Designated individuals or legal heirs.

2. Contributions:

   • Members contribute 9% of their monthly salary, while the government (as employer) contributes 12%.

3. Claim Requirements:

   • Proper documentation such as proof of membership, service record, and necessary medical or legal certificates.

4. Administration:

   • The GSIS Board of Trustees oversees policy implementation and benefits adjustments.

5. Exemptions:

   • Members of the judiciary, constitutional commissions, and uniformed personnel have their own retirement systems but may be covered under GSIS for specific benefits.

---

This comprehensive guide on GSIS benefits ensures members and beneficiaries understand their entitlements, the conditions for claiming them, and the corresponding procedures under R.A. 8291.

Dependents, Beneficiaries | Government Service Insurance System Law - R.A. No. 8291 | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

LABOR LAW AND SOCIAL LEGISLATION > III. SOCIAL LEGISLATION > B. Government Service Insurance System Law - R.A. No. 8291 > 2. Dependents, Beneficiaries

The Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) is governed by Republic Act No. 8291, also known as the GSIS Act of 1997. The law mandates the provision of social security benefits to government employees and extends such benefits to their qualified dependents and beneficiaries. Below is a comprehensive discussion on dependents and beneficiaries under R.A. No. 8291.

---

1. Definitions

Dependents

Under Section 2(b) of R.A. No. 8291, the term dependent refers to:

1. The legitimate spouse who is the primary dependent of the member.
2. Children, whether legitimate, legitimated, legally adopted, or illegitimate, provided they are:
   • Unmarried,
   • Not gainfully employed, and
   • Below 21 years of age, or if over 21, are incapacitated and incapable of self-support due to a physical or mental disability that existed before reaching the age of 21.

Beneficiaries

The law defines beneficiaries as:

1. Primary beneficiaries:
   • The legitimate spouse, and
   • The legitimate, legitimated, legally adopted, or illegitimate children who meet the qualifications stated above for dependents.
2. Secondary beneficiaries:
   • If there are no primary beneficiaries, the dependent parents shall qualify as secondary beneficiaries.
   • In the absence of dependent parents, any designated person(s) or legal heirs under the Civil Code will serve as the beneficiaries.

---

2. Prioritization of Beneficiaries

R.A. No. 8291 establishes a clear hierarchy of entitlement to benefits:

1. Primary beneficiaries are entitled to the benefits first.
2. Only in the absence of primary beneficiaries will secondary beneficiaries become entitled to claim GSIS benefits.
3. If there are no secondary beneficiaries, the benefits will accrue to the member’s legal heirs as determined by the Civil Code.

---

3. Benefits Extended to Dependents and Beneficiaries

The GSIS provides the following benefits, which extend to dependents and beneficiaries under specific conditions:

a. Life Insurance Benefits

• Dependents and beneficiaries of a deceased member may receive proceeds of life insurance policies, which can include:
  • Basic Life Insurance and
  • Optional life insurance, if availed.

b. Survivorship Benefits

• Survivorship benefits are extended to qualified dependents and beneficiaries of a deceased GSIS member or pensioner. These include:
  • Survivor’s Pension for the primary beneficiaries:
    • A monthly survivorship pension equivalent to 50% of the deceased member’s Basic Monthly Pension (BMP).
  • If there is no primary beneficiary, a lump sum is granted to secondary beneficiaries.

c. Funeral Benefits

• The GSIS provides funeral assistance, which is currently set at a fixed amount, regardless of the classification of beneficiaries. The funeral benefit aims to assist in the expenses related to the member’s burial.

d. Dependency Allowance

• Dependents, particularly the children of the member, may receive allowances as part of the pension or retirement benefits package, subject to GSIS policies and the member's entitlements.

e. Retirement Benefits

• Upon the death of a retired member, survivorship pension benefits may be passed on to the primary beneficiaries. Secondary beneficiaries or legal heirs may receive a lump sum if no pension is due.

---

4. Special Rules on Beneficiaries

• Designation of Beneficiaries:
  • Members may designate their beneficiaries for certain benefits. However, the designation of beneficiaries is limited to those allowed under the law.
• Hierarchy:
  • The law prohibits a member from displacing qualified dependents in favor of other individuals not recognized as beneficiaries under the law.
• Conflict of Claims:
  • In cases where multiple claims arise, GSIS applies the hierarchy of beneficiaries strictly. Spouses and children have primary rights over other relatives or designated individuals.

---

5. Legal Provisions Related to Disputes and Updates

• Beneficiaries must regularly update their records with the GSIS to avoid disputes regarding entitlements.
• In cases of disputes:
  • The GSIS has the authority to resolve issues regarding the eligibility of dependents or beneficiaries.
  • Appeals may be brought to the courts, but GSIS determinations are given weight unless proven contrary to law or regulations.

---

6. Documentation Requirements

To claim benefits, dependents or beneficiaries must submit appropriate documents, including:

• Birth certificates,
• Marriage certificates,
• Death certificates of the member, and
• Medical certificates in cases involving incapacitated children or dependent parents.

---

7. Penalties for Fraudulent Claims

• R.A. No. 8291 imposes penalties for individuals attempting to defraud the GSIS by misrepresenting their status as dependents or beneficiaries.
• Sanctions include criminal liability, repayment of benefits received, and disqualification from future claims.

---

Conclusion

R.A. No. 8291 upholds the welfare of government employees by ensuring that their qualified dependents and beneficiaries receive adequate social security benefits. Members and their families must understand their rights and responsibilities under the law to avoid disputes and ensure compliance with GSIS requirements.

Coverage and exclusions | Government Service Insurance System Law - R.A. No. 8291 | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

Labor Law and Social Legislation: Government Service Insurance System Law (R.A. No. 8291) – Coverage and Exclusions

The Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) Law, codified as Republic Act No. 8291, governs the social insurance system for employees in the Philippine public sector. Below is a meticulous discussion of the law’s coverage and exclusions, as mandated by the GSIS Act of 1997.

---

1. Coverage under R.A. No. 8291

GSIS primarily covers government employees, except for those specifically excluded under the law. The following are included in the coverage:

A. Compulsory Membership

1. Permanent Employees of the Government

   • All employees with permanent status working in government offices, including:
     • National Government
     • Local Government Units (LGUs)
     • Government-Owned and Controlled Corporations (GOCCs) with original charters
     • Constitutional Commissions (e.g., Commission on Audit, Commission on Elections, Civil Service Commission)

2. Regular Employees in Government

   • Employees holding regular employment status in government service, irrespective of salary grade or employment level.

3. Elective Officials

   • Officials elected by the public, such as:
     • Barangay Captains and Kagawads receiving regular salaries.
     • Mayors, Governors, and other local officials, provided they do not opt to waive membership.

4. Contractual and Casual Employees

   • Individuals employed on a contractual or casual basis, provided they do not fall under any exclusion and have employer-employee relationships with government entities.

5. Uniformed Personnel

   • Members of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP), Philippine National Police (PNP), Bureau of Jail Management and Penology (BJMP), and Bureau of Fire Protection (BFP).

---

2. Exclusions from GSIS Coverage

Certain individuals, even if connected to government service, are expressly excluded from mandatory GSIS membership:

A. Specific Exemptions

1. Members of the Judiciary and Constitutional Commissions

   • Justices and Judges, as well as employees of the Judiciary, are covered under separate retirement and benefits systems managed by the Judiciary.
   • Employees and officials of Constitutional Commissions (e.g., COA, CSC, COMELEC) can also be exempted if covered by a special law.

2. Contractual Employees Without Employer-Employee Relationship

   • Consultants and job-order employees who are not considered government employees under existing Civil Service laws.

3. Barangay Officials Receiving Honoraria

   • Barangay officials whose compensation consists solely of honoraria, allowances, or other forms of financial aid, not classified as regular salaries.

4. Employees of GOCCs Without Original Charters

   • Employees in GOCCs created under the Corporation Code (e.g., private corporations owned by the government) are covered by the Social Security System (SSS), not GSIS.

5. Temporary and Substitute Employees

   • Personnel hired temporarily without a fixed tenure or clear employer-employee relationship are excluded.

6. Non-Permanent Teachers or Instructors

   • Part-time lecturers or those working under contracts without tenure in state colleges or universities.

B. Voluntary Waivers

• Certain elective officials may opt to waive membership, provided the decision is made in writing and in compliance with GSIS rules.

C. Coverage Under Special Laws

• Individuals covered under retirement or pension laws specific to their agencies (e.g., military or police pension systems) are excluded from GSIS coverage.

---

3. Mandatory Contributions

For those covered under GSIS:

1. Both employee and employer contribute monthly premiums based on the employee’s salary.
2. Contributions are mandatory for all members unless expressly excluded.

The law provides penalties for employers who fail to remit contributions on time, emphasizing the compulsory nature of GSIS membership for those eligible.

---

4. Special Coverage Rules

1. Dual Employment

   • Government employees with dual roles (e.g., teaching positions and local elective posts) are covered for both positions unless expressly excluded by law.

2. Rehired Retirees

   • Rehired retirees receiving pension benefits may not be covered unless they waive the continuation of pension benefits and resume contributions under GSIS.

3. Overseas Employment

   • Public sector employees on temporary overseas assignments are required to continue GSIS membership.

---

5. Legal Framework and Interpretation

• Legislative Intent: R.A. No. 8291 aims to ensure social security and welfare for government employees, while carefully delineating exclusions to avoid overlaps with other benefit systems.
• Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR): The GSIS Board issues rules clarifying coverage and exclusions, subject to administrative guidelines and judicial review.
• Judicial Precedents: Courts have upheld GSIS exclusions for individuals not meeting the statutory criteria, emphasizing strict interpretation of the law’s coverage provisions.

---

Conclusion

The coverage and exclusions under R.A. No. 8291 reflect a deliberate balance between inclusivity for public sector employees and practicality in administration. Proper classification of employees is critical to ensuring compliance with the law and avoiding disputes related to contributions and benefits. For specific cases or disputes, consultation with GSIS or legal professionals specializing in labor law is advised.

Government Service Insurance System Law - R.A. No. 8291 | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

Comprehensive Guide on the Government Service Insurance System Law (R.A. No. 8291)

The Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) is a government-owned and controlled corporation established to provide social security benefits to government employees, as mandated under Republic Act No. 8291, also known as the “Government Service Insurance Act of 1997.” Below is an exhaustive discussion of the key provisions, structure, benefits, and implications of this law.

---

1. Coverage of GSIS

R.A. No. 8291 mandates the compulsory membership of the following individuals:

• Government Employees: Permanent, temporary, or casual employees of the Philippine government, including national agencies, local government units (LGUs), state universities and colleges, and other government instrumentalities.
• Elected Officials: Provided they are receiving regular compensation.
• Judiciary Members and Constitutional Commissions: Justices, judges, and officials of constitutional commissions.
• Uniformed Personnel: Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP), Philippine National Police (PNP), Bureau of Jail Management and Penology (BJMP), and Bureau of Fire Protection (BFP).

Excluded Employees

• Contractual employees not receiving fixed compensation.
• Barangay officials who are not receiving monthly compensation.

---

2. Contributions

• Employee Share: Regular employees contribute 9% of their monthly salary to GSIS.
• Employer Share: The government, as the employer, contributes 12% of the employee's monthly salary.
• The contributions are deducted monthly from the employee’s salary and remitted by the employing agency to GSIS.

---

3. Benefits under R.A. No. 8291

GSIS provides a comprehensive range of social security and insurance benefits to its members. Below are the key benefits:

A. Life Insurance Benefits

• Compulsory Life Insurance (CLIP): Automatic coverage for active members.
• Optional Life Insurance (OLIP): Members may opt for additional insurance with higher premiums for greater coverage.

B. Retirement Benefits

• Eligibility: Members who have rendered at least 15 years of government service, are at least 60 years old, and are not receiving any retirement benefits under other retirement laws.
• Options for Retirement Benefits:
  • 5-Year Lump Sum and Pension: A lump sum equivalent to 60 months of the pension is provided upfront, with a monthly pension thereafter.
  • Cash Payment and Pension: A cash payment equivalent to 18 months’ worth of the pension and a monthly pension immediately thereafter.

C. Separation Benefits

• Eligibility: Employees who leave government service but do not qualify for retirement.
• Benefits:
  • Below 3 Years of Service: Refund of employee contributions.
  • 3 or More Years of Service: Cash benefit equivalent to 100% of the average monthly compensation (AMC) multiplied by the years of service.

D. Unemployment Benefits

• Members involuntarily separated from service due to redundancy, retrenchment, or reorganization are entitled to unemployment benefits. The amount is equal to 50% of the AMC, payable for two to six months.

E. Disability Benefits

• Temporary Disability: A cash benefit equivalent to 75% of the AMC for the duration of disability.
• Permanent Total or Partial Disability: Lifetime pension or a cash benefit, depending on the degree of disability.

F. Survivorship Benefits

• Dependents of a deceased member are entitled to survivorship benefits, which may include:
  • Monthly Pension: For the primary beneficiary (spouse or children).
  • Cash Payment: For secondary beneficiaries.

G. Funeral Benefit

• A fixed amount provided to assist in burial expenses of a deceased member or pensioner.

---

4. Loan Privileges

GSIS members may avail of various loan products, including:

• Policy Loan: Loans against their GSIS life insurance policy.
• Salary Loan: Loans based on salary levels.
• Emergency Loan: Financial assistance during emergencies or calamities.
• Educational Assistance Loan: Loans for the education of dependents.

---

5. Legal Obligations of Employers

• Employers are required to deduct and remit contributions promptly. Failure to do so may lead to administrative and legal sanctions, including penalties and surcharges.

---

6. GSIS Fund Management and Investments

GSIS ensures the sustainability of its funds through prudent management and investment in government securities, equities, real estate, and other permissible instruments.

---

7. Administration and Dispute Resolution

Board of Trustees

• The GSIS is governed by a Board of Trustees, which formulates policies for its operations.

Dispute Resolution

• Members may file claims and appeals regarding disputes in benefits with the GSIS Claims and Appeals Committee or elevate the matter to the appropriate judicial or quasi-judicial body.

---

8. Coordination with Other Laws

R.A. No. 8291 operates alongside other laws like the Labor Code, Social Security Act, and PhilHealth Act, ensuring comprehensive social protection. Overlapping benefits are resolved by determining the most favorable outcome for the member.

---

9. Penalties for Non-Compliance

Violations of R.A. No. 8291, such as non-remittance of contributions, are penalized with fines, imprisonment, or both under applicable laws. Government agencies may also face sanctions.

---

10. Amendments and Updates

While R.A. No. 8291 provides the framework, periodic amendments through administrative orders or subsequent legislation may refine its provisions to align with changing socio-economic conditions.

This law underscores the Philippine government's commitment to providing a safety net for its employees, balancing social insurance, and financial security measures to ensure their welfare during active service and retirement.

Benefits | Social Security System Law - R.A. No. 11199 | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

Social Security System Law (RA No. 11199): Benefits Overview

Republic Act No. 11199, also known as the Social Security Act of 2018, governs the Social Security System (SSS) in the Philippines. This law consolidates provisions on social security benefits to ensure better coverage and protection for workers and their dependents. Here is an exhaustive discussion of the benefits under the SSS as provided by the law:

---

1. Overview of Benefits

The SSS provides members and their beneficiaries with protection against the following contingencies:

• Sickness
• Maternity
• Disability
• Unemployment
• Retirement
• Death
• Funeral expenses

Each benefit is subject to eligibility requirements, computation based on contributions, and specific conditions as prescribed by law.

---

2. Types of Benefits

a. Sickness Benefit

• Eligibility:
  • The member must have at least three (3) months of contributions within the 12-month period immediately preceding the semester of sickness.
  • The member must be unable to work due to sickness or injury.
  • All leave credits must be used up.
• Amount:
  • Daily cash allowance equivalent to 90% of the member's average daily salary credit (ADSC).
  • Payable for a maximum of 120 days in one calendar year.
• Filing Period:
  • Must be filed within 60 days from the start of illness.

b. Maternity Benefit

• Eligibility:
  • Female members with at least three (3) months of contributions within the 12-month period preceding the semester of childbirth or miscarriage.
• Amount:
  • Cash allowance equivalent to 100% of ADSC.
  • Duration:
    • 105 days for live childbirth (additional 15 days for solo parents).
    • 60 days for miscarriage or emergency termination of pregnancy.
• Additional Notes:
  • The benefit is now available for all covered female members regardless of civil status.

c. Disability Benefit

• Eligibility:
  • Member must be unable to perform work due to permanent total or partial disability.
  • At least one (1) monthly contribution before the semester of disability.
• Types:
  • Partial Disability: For specific loss of body functions or parts.
  • Total Disability: For conditions such as complete loss of eyesight or severe impairments.
• Amount:
  • Monthly pension or lump-sum payment based on number and amount of contributions.
  • Monthly pension includes an additional allowance of PHP 500.

d. Unemployment Benefit

• Eligibility:
  • Must have paid at least 36 monthly contributions, 12 of which should be within the 18 months before the involuntary separation.
  • Must not be over 60 years of age.
• Amount:
  • Cash benefit equivalent to 50% of the member's ADSC.
  • Payable for a maximum of two (2) months.
• Conditions:
  • Applicable only for involuntary separation (e.g., retrenchment, redundancy).

e. Retirement Benefit

• Eligibility:
  • At least 120 monthly contributions.
  • Member is 60 years old (optional retirement) and separated from employment or self-employed.
  • Compulsory retirement age is 65 years.
• Types:
  • Monthly Pension: Payable for life for qualified retirees.
  • Lump-Sum Payment: Equivalent to the total contributions paid plus interest, granted if the member has less than 120 contributions.
• Additional Notes:
  • A retiree receiving a monthly pension is entitled to a 13th-month pension every December.
  • Dependents’ pension is also provided for qualified beneficiaries.

f. Death Benefit

• Eligibility:
  • At least one (1) monthly contribution before the semester of death.
• Types:
  • Monthly Pension: For primary beneficiaries (spouse and dependent children).
  • Lump-Sum Payment: For secondary beneficiaries if there are no primary beneficiaries.
• Amount:
  • Computed based on the contributions and credited years of service.
  • Includes a PHP 500 monthly allowance.

g. Funeral Benefit

• Amount:
  • Lump-sum cash benefit ranging from PHP 20,000 to PHP 40,000, depending on the number of contributions.
• Eligibility:
  • Payable to whoever paid for the funeral expenses.

---

3. General Provisions on Benefit Computation

• Average Daily Salary Credit (ADSC):
  • Computed by dividing the total salary credits for the last 60 months by the number of days in that period.
• Monthly Pension Computation:
  • Formula considers credited years of service (CYS) and ADSC.
• Credited Years of Service (CYS):
  • Based on the total number of contributions divided by 12.

---

4. Supplemental Allowances

• Additional monthly allowances:
  • PHP 500 for disability and death pensioners.
  • 13th-month pension for retirement and death pensioners.

---

5. Filing and Processing of Claims

• Claims must be filed within the prescriptive periods set by the SSS.
• Online filing options are now available via the SSS website or mobile app.
• Members should ensure complete documentation for faster processing.

---

6. Funding and Sustainability

• Contributions from employees, employers, self-employed individuals, and voluntary members finance these benefits.
• RA No. 11199 provides for contribution increases and adjustments to ensure fund viability and expanded coverage.

---

7. Recent Amendments and Key Provisions

• Universal access to maternity benefits.
• Introduction of unemployment insurance.
• Gradual increase in contribution rates (current at 14%, increasing incrementally to 15% by 2025).
• Expanded coverage for overseas Filipino workers (OFWs).

---

Understanding and availing SSS benefits require timely compliance with contribution requirements and adherence to filing procedures. The Social Security Act of 2018 aims to provide equitable and adequate social protection to all covered members.

Dependents, Beneficiaries | Social Security System Law - R.A. No. 11199 | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

Dependents and Beneficiaries under the Social Security System Law (R.A. No. 11199)

The Social Security Act of 2018 (R.A. No. 11199) governs the Social Security System (SSS) in the Philippines, providing benefits for members and their dependents. This law outlines the qualifications, rights, and scope of benefits for dependents and beneficiaries. Below is an exhaustive discussion on these provisions:

---

I. Dependents under R.A. No. 11199

Definition

A "dependent" refers to individuals related to the covered SSS member who may receive certain benefits in the event of the member's death or disability.

Eligible Dependents

Under Section 8(k) of R.A. No. 11199, the following are considered dependents:

1. Legal Spouse - A legitimate spouse who is dependent upon the member for support.
2. Child/Children - Includes the following, provided they are:
   • Unmarried
   • Not gainfully employed
   • Below 21 years of age
   • If over 21, they must be incapacitated and incapable of self-support due to physical or mental disability that existed before age 21.
   • Legitimate, illegitimate, legally adopted, or legitimated children are all eligible.
3. Parents - If wholly dependent upon the member for support.

---

II. Beneficiaries under R.A. No. 11199

Definition

A "beneficiary" is the individual or group of individuals designated to receive SSS benefits such as pensions, death benefits, or other claims upon the member’s death or upon qualification under specific benefit programs.

Types of Beneficiaries

R.A. No. 11199 distinguishes between two categories of beneficiaries:

1. Primary Beneficiaries

   • Includes the legal spouse and dependent legitimate, legitimated, legally adopted, and illegitimate children of the deceased member.
   • Order of Priority:
     • If both legitimate and illegitimate children exist, legitimate children take precedence. However, illegitimate children are entitled to half the share of legitimate children.
     • Legal spouse and dependent children share equally in the absence of a conflict.

2. Secondary Beneficiaries

   • In the absence of primary beneficiaries, the dependent parents of the deceased member will receive benefits.
   • If no parents qualify, the benefits may go to any individual designated by the member before death.

3. Designated Beneficiaries

   • Members may designate specific individuals as beneficiaries through their SSS records.
   • Designated beneficiaries only receive benefits if no primary or secondary beneficiaries exist.

---

III. Rights and Benefits of Dependents and Beneficiaries

A. Death Benefits

Dependents and beneficiaries are entitled to a lump-sum payment or monthly pension in the event of the member's death. The specific allocations are as follows:

• Primary beneficiaries receive a monthly pension.
• Secondary beneficiaries or designated beneficiaries receive a lump-sum payment if no primary beneficiaries exist.

B. Disability Benefits

Dependents of a permanently disabled member are entitled to an additional allowance on top of the basic monthly pension:

• This allowance is P250 per dependent child (maximum of five children).

C. Survivorship Pension

Upon the death of a pensioner, the dependent spouse receives 100% of the pension for life or until remarriage. Children entitled to dependents’ allowance continue to receive their share of the pension.

D. Funeral Benefits

Beneficiaries or any person who pays for the funeral expenses of the deceased member is entitled to receive a funeral grant ranging from P20,000 to P40,000, depending on the member's contributions.

E. Maternity Benefits

Although not strictly dependent-related, maternity benefits indirectly affect dependents as they provide financial aid to the mother during childbirth.

---

IV. Conditions Affecting Dependents and Beneficiaries

1. Disqualification of Dependents/Beneficiaries

   • A spouse who has remarried after the death of the member ceases to qualify for survivorship benefits.
   • A child who marries or becomes employed ceases to qualify as a dependent.
   • Fraud or deliberate misrepresentation to claim benefits can result in disqualification and legal penalties.

2. Conflicts in Claims

   • The SSS resolves conflicts in claims based on the hierarchy of beneficiaries as outlined in the law.
   • Legitimate relationships take precedence unless legal proof to the contrary is provided.

3. Updating of Beneficiaries

   • Members are encouraged to update their list of beneficiaries regularly to reflect changes in marital status, birth of children, or adoption.

---

V. Administrative and Legal Considerations

1. Proof of Dependence

   • The burden of proving eligibility as a dependent or beneficiary lies with the claimant.
   • Documents such as birth certificates, marriage certificates, and medical records may be required.

2. Contesting Beneficiary Claims

   • Disputes over beneficiary claims are resolved by the SSS, and appeals may be made to the Employees’ Compensation Commission or courts of law.

3. Penalties for Misrepresentation

   • Fraudulent claims or misrepresentation by dependents or beneficiaries can result in criminal charges, imprisonment, and fines under R.A. No. 11199.

---

VI. Key Legal References

1. Section 8(k) - Definition of dependents
2. Section 13 - Survivorship benefits
3. Section 14 - Funeral benefits
4. Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) of R.A. No. 11199

By adhering to the principles of equity and fairness, the Social Security System ensures that its benefits reach the rightful dependents and beneficiaries, as prescribed under the law.

Coverage and exclusions | Social Security System Law - R.A. No. 11199 | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

Social Security System Law (R.A. No. 11199): Coverage and Exclusions

The Social Security Act of 2018 (Republic Act No. 11199) establishes the comprehensive framework governing the Social Security System (SSS) in the Philippines. This law aims to provide social security protection to Filipino workers and their beneficiaries, covering contingencies such as sickness, maternity, disability, retirement, death, and other unforeseen economic risks.

Coverage

The SSS law ensures coverage for both mandatory and voluntary members, categorized as follows:

---

A. Mandatory Coverage

1. Private Sector Employees

   • All employees not over 60 years old, including:
     • Workers engaged in commerce, industry, or services.
     • Employees on probationary, regular, or fixed-term status.
   • Coverage starts upon hiring, regardless of employment duration or nature of the job.

2. Self-Employed Individuals

   • Individuals earning income through their labor, business, or practice of profession.
   • Examples:
     • Freelancers.
     • Business owners.
     • Independent contractors.
   • Coverage is mandatory for self-employed persons whose income is not less than ₱1,000 per month.

3. Household Helpers (Kasambahays)

   • Domestic workers earning at least ₱1,000 per month.
   • The employer is required to register the helper and remit contributions.

4. Overseas Filipino Workers (OFWs)

   • OFWs up to 60 years old.
   • Compulsory for land-based and sea-based workers under the jurisdiction of Philippine agencies.

5. Persons in the Informal Economy

   • Workers in non-traditional employment arrangements or with no formal employer-employee relationship but earning at least ₱1,000 per month.
   • Examples:
     • Market vendors.
     • Public utility vehicle drivers.

6. Government and Private Sector Dual Employees

   • Employees who work both in government (covered by GSIS) and the private sector (covered by SSS) are subject to dual coverage for their private employment.

---

B. Voluntary Coverage

1. Separated Members

   • Former employees who wish to continue paying contributions to maintain eligibility for benefits.

2. Voluntary OFWs

   • OFWs who choose to continue their coverage after becoming permanent residents in other countries.

3. Non-Working Spouses

   • Legal spouses of SSS members who are not earning but are dependent on their partner’s income, provided they pay contributions based on the working spouse’s last monthly salary credit.

4. Filipino Permanent Residents or Naturalized Citizens Abroad

   • Formerly covered individuals who wish to continue contributing as voluntary members.

---

C. Expanded Compulsory Coverage

Under R.A. No. 11199, the law also expanded the coverage to include:

• Kasambahays with less than ₱1,000 monthly income.
• OFWs regardless of monthly income level.

---

Exclusions

The following individuals or groups are excluded from SSS coverage:

1. Government Employees

   • Government personnel covered by the Government Service Insurance System (GSIS), including:
     • Permanent government employees.
     • Military and police personnel.

2. Foreign Nationals

   • Foreign nationals employed in the Philippines but who are:
     • Covered under their home country’s social security system.
     • Protected by bilateral or multilateral agreements.

3. Non-Working Individuals Below Income Threshold

   • Individuals with no declared income or below ₱1,000 monthly income are generally not mandatorily covered unless voluntarily enrolled.

4. Employees Aged 60 and Above

   • Workers over 60 years old who are already receiving retirement pensions are excluded from SSS coverage.

---

Important Provisions

1. Universal Coverage

   • The law adopts a framework of universal coverage, seeking to include all Filipinos under social security protections eventually.
   • It imposes obligations on employers, employees, and self-employed individuals to comply with registration and contribution requirements.

2. Employer Obligations

   • Employers are mandated to:
     • Register their employees with the SSS.
     • Deduct and remit monthly contributions on behalf of employees.

3. Contributions

   • Contributions are based on the prevailing schedule of monthly salary credits and are shared between the employer and the employee (for employed individuals) or solely borne by the self-employed or voluntary member.

---

Penalties for Non-Compliance

• Employers who fail to register their employees or remit contributions may face penalties, including:
  • Fines.
  • Imprisonment.
  • Payment of delinquent contributions with interest.

Conclusion

R.A. No. 11199 aims to provide robust social protection for Filipinos through inclusive coverage and comprehensive benefit packages. Employers, employees, self-employed individuals, and other stakeholders must comply with the law to ensure the security and well-being of the workforce and their families.

Social Security System Law - R.A. No. 11199 | SOCIAL LEGISLATION

LABOR LAW AND SOCIAL LEGISLATION > III. SOCIAL LEGISLATION > A. Social Security System Law - R.A. No. 11199

Introduction

Republic Act No. 11199, also known as the Social Security Act of 2018, was enacted to amend and expand the Philippine Social Security System (SSS). The law modernizes the SSS, enhancing its capacity to provide meaningful social security benefits to Filipino workers, self-employed individuals, and voluntary members.

Below is an exhaustive discussion of its provisions, salient features, and implementing rules:

---

I. Objectives of R.A. No. 11199

1. Universal Coverage: To ensure that every Filipino is provided with adequate protection against economic and social distress due to disability, sickness, maternity, old age, death, and other contingencies.
2. Sustainability: To strengthen the SSS fund by adopting actuarial soundness to secure long-term benefits for members.
3. Efficiency: To enhance the operational capabilities of the SSS, ensuring efficient delivery of benefits and services.

---

II. Salient Features of R.A. No. 11199

1. Expanded Coverage:

   • Mandatory Membership:
     • Private-sector employees, household helpers, and overseas Filipino workers (OFWs) are mandatorily covered.
     • Includes self-employed individuals earning at least ₱1,000 per month.
   • Voluntary Membership:
     • Includes non-working spouses of SSS members, OFWs who do not fall under mandatory coverage, and former members who wish to continue contributions.

2. Enhanced Benefits:

   • Increased pension benefits, allowing periodic adjustments in pension levels.
   • Inclusion of unemployment insurance for members who lose their jobs involuntarily.
   • Additional benefits for maternity leave and sickness.

3. Flexible Contribution Scheme:

   • Regular adjustments to contributions to ensure fund viability.
   • Increased contributions from 11% to 12% starting 2019, with provisions for further increments up to 15% by 2025.
   • Contributions shared between employers (8%) and employees (4%).

4. Unemployment Insurance Benefit:

   • Qualified members can claim financial assistance for up to two months.
   • Conditions:
     • At least 36 months of contributions, with 12 months made within the 18 months preceding unemployment.
     • Certification of involuntary separation from the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE).

5. Actuarial Solvency:

   • Institutionalized provisions for periodic actuarial studies to ensure fund sufficiency and long-term viability.
   • Authority granted to the SSS to adjust benefits, contributions, and investments to maintain solvency.

6. Governance:

   • Reorganization of the SSS Board to include representatives from labor, employers, and the government.
   • The President of the Philippines is authorized to appoint members of the board.
   • Board members are held accountable for the efficient management of funds.

7. Penalties and Enforcement:

   • Imposition of stricter penalties for employers failing to remit contributions.
   • Civil and criminal liabilities for fraudulent claims and misrepresentation.

---

III. Covered Benefits under the Social Security Act of 2018

1. Sickness Benefit:

   • Daily cash allowance for members unable to work due to illness or injury.
   • Conditions:
     • At least 3 months of contributions within the 12-month period preceding the illness.
     • Certification of sickness by a qualified physician.

2. Maternity Benefit:

   • 105 days of paid maternity leave for live childbirth, with an additional 15 days for solo parents.
   • Coverage includes miscarriage or emergency termination of pregnancy.

3. Retirement Benefit:

   • Monthly pension for members reaching the age of 60 (optional retirement) or 65 (mandatory retirement).
   • Lump-sum payment is an alternative for members who do not qualify for monthly pensions.

4. Disability Benefit:

   • Monthly or lump-sum cash benefits for members suffering from partial or total permanent disability.
   • Medical certification and proof of disability required.

5. Death and Funeral Benefits:

   • Monthly pension for primary beneficiaries (spouse and children).
   • Lump-sum funeral assistance for burial expenses.

6. Unemployment Insurance:

   • Temporary financial aid for members who are involuntarily separated from employment.

---

IV. Administrative Powers of the SSS

1. Collection and Enforcement:

   • Authority to collect contributions and impose penalties on delinquent employers.
   • Garnishment of bank accounts or other assets of employers refusing to remit contributions.

2. Investment Management:

   • Authority to invest in government securities, equities, real estate, and infrastructure projects to grow the SSS fund.
   • Investments are subject to strict fiduciary regulations.

3. Rule-Making Authority:

   • Power to issue rules and regulations consistent with the Social Security Act.
   • Adjustments to benefits and contributions are made through board resolutions.

---

V. Penalties for Violations

1. Employer Violations:

   • Failure to remit contributions: Fines ranging from ₱5,000 to ₱20,000 per affected employee.
   • Imprisonment of 6 years and 1 day up to 12 years.

2. Fraudulent Claims:

   • Imprisonment of 6 years and 1 day up to 12 years, plus full restitution of the fraudulent claim.

3. Obstruction of Enforcement:

   • Fines and imprisonment for individuals obstructing the enforcement of SSS rules.

---

VI. Implementation and Monitoring

1. Digital Transformation:

   • Integration of online platforms for contributions, benefit claims, and inquiries.
   • Mobile applications and digital kiosks for member convenience.

2. Collaboration with Other Agencies:

   • Partnership with DOLE for unemployment insurance certification.
   • Collaboration with government financial institutions for investment opportunities.

3. Annual Reporting:

   • SSS is mandated to submit annual reports on fund performance, actuarial studies, and governance reforms to Congress and the Office of the President.

---

Conclusion

R.A. No. 11199 represents a significant milestone in the development of social security in the Philippines. By expanding coverage, enhancing benefits, and ensuring sustainability, the law seeks to provide meaningful protection for Filipino workers and their families. Its successful implementation depends on efficient governance, strict enforcement, and active participation from stakeholders.

SOCIAL LEGISLATION

LABOR LAW AND SOCIAL LEGISLATION > III. SOCIAL LEGISLATION

Social Legislation in the Philippines encompasses laws aimed at promoting social justice and protecting the rights of marginalized sectors of society, particularly workers, women, children, and persons with disabilities. It operates as an extension of the constitutional mandate to uphold social justice and is implemented through various labor and welfare statutes. Below is a comprehensive overview of Social Legislation under Philippine Labor Law.

---

A. Constitutional Foundations

1. Social Justice and Human Rights

   • Article II, Section 10: The State shall promote social justice in all phases of national development.
   • Article XIII: The Constitution devotes an entire article to social justice and human rights, covering labor, agrarian reform, housing, health, and marginalized sectors.
   • Section 18, Article II: Recognition of labor as a primary social economic force, promoting full employment and equality of opportunity.

2. Labor Rights

   • Right to self-organization, collective bargaining and negotiation, peaceful concerted activities, security of tenure, humane working conditions, and a living wage.

---

B. Key Social Legislation

1. Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442)

The Labor Code embodies social legislation in the workplace and is divided into multiple books addressing employment, human resources development, labor relations, and social welfare.

• Book III: Conditions of Employment

  • Minimum wage laws and compliance with the regional wage boards.
  • Overtime pay, night shift differential, and other compensable work arrangements.
  • Protection for working women, including maternity leave, safe workplaces, and prohibition of discrimination.

• Book IV: Health, Safety, and Social Welfare Benefits

  • Employees’ Compensation Program (ECP): Provides for compensation to workers or their dependents in case of work-related sickness, injury, or death.
  • Social Security Act (RA 8282): Establishes SSS benefits for private-sector employees.
  • Government Service Insurance System (GSIS): Provides similar benefits for public-sector workers.
  • National Health Insurance Act (RA 11223): The Universal Health Care Act ensures health insurance coverage through PhilHealth.
  • Occupational Safety and Health Standards (RA 11058): Mandates safe work environments and imposes penalties for violations.

2. Social Security Act of 2018 (RA 11199)

• Mandates compulsory social security coverage for employees in the private sector, self-employed individuals, and voluntary members.
• Benefits include:
  • Sickness
  • Maternity
  • Disability
  • Retirement
  • Death and funeral
  • Unemployment insurance benefits

3. Universal Health Care Act (RA 11223)

• Automatic inclusion of all Filipinos into the National Health Insurance Program.
• Strengthens the role of PhilHealth in providing health insurance benefits.
• Promotes preventive, promotive, curative, and rehabilitative health services.

4. Magna Carta of Women (RA 9710)

• Comprehensive law ensuring women’s rights and gender equality.
• Mandates equal opportunities in employment and prohibits discrimination.
• Ensures maternity leave benefits and reproductive health services.

5. Expanded Maternity Leave Law (RA 11210)

• Grants 105 days of maternity leave for female employees, with an option to extend for an additional 30 days without pay.
• Solo parents are entitled to an additional 15 days.

6. Solo Parents’ Welfare Act (RA 8972)

• Grants additional benefits to solo parents, including:
  • Flexible work schedules.
  • Parental leave of seven (7) days annually.
  • Prioritization in social programs such as housing and education.

7. Philippine AIDS Prevention and Control Act (RA 11166)

• Provides protection and non-discrimination for workers living with HIV/AIDS.
• Mandates confidentiality of HIV status and prohibits termination based on medical conditions.

8. Anti-Age Discrimination in Employment Act (RA 10911)

• Prohibits employers from refusing employment, imposing compulsory retirement, or discriminating against employees based on age.

9. Expanded Senior Citizens Act (RA 9994)

• Provides additional benefits to senior citizens, including discounts, tax exemptions, and free medical and dental services.

10. Persons with Disabilities (PWD) Laws

• RA 7277 (Magna Carta for Disabled Persons): Promotes employment and prohibits discrimination against PWDs.
• Tax incentives are provided to employers who hire PWDs.
• Accessibility laws require reasonable accommodations in workplaces and public spaces.

11. Anti-Violence Against Women and Their Children Act (RA 9262)

• Protects women and children from abuse and provides remedies such as protection orders and support mechanisms.
• Employers must grant ten (10) days of leave to victims of VAWC.

12. Barangay Micro Business Enterprises Act (RA 9178)

• Provides incentives, such as tax exemptions and simplified procedures, to encourage micro-entrepreneurship in barangays.

---

C. Implementing Agencies

1. Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE)

   • Ensures compliance with labor laws and social legislation.
   • Mediates disputes and oversees the implementation of labor standards.

2. Social Security System (SSS) and Government Service Insurance System (GSIS)

   • Administers social security benefits for private and public sector employees.

3. PhilHealth

   • Manages the health insurance system under Universal Health Care.

4. National Housing Authority (NHA)

   • Provides housing assistance to marginalized sectors.

5. Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD)

   • Implements welfare programs such as cash transfers, subsidies, and disaster relief.

---

D. Recent Developments and Trends

1. Transition to Universal Health Care

   • Expanded coverage and benefits under PhilHealth.
   • Decentralization of health service delivery.

2. Stronger Protections for Gig and Platform Workers

   • Calls for new legislation to regulate the gig economy and ensure protections for freelancers and independent contractors.

3. Digitalization of Labor Transactions

   • Online systems for labor complaints, benefits processing, and employment documentation are being implemented to improve access and efficiency.

4. Climate Resilience and Labor Policies

   • Development of programs addressing climate change impacts on employment, particularly for workers in vulnerable industries like agriculture.

---

E. Challenges in Implementation

1. Compliance Issues

   • Non-compliance with minimum wage laws and benefits remains a significant challenge.
   • Lack of enforcement capacity by DOLE in remote or informal sectors.

2. Undercoverage of Informal Sector Workers

   • Majority of the workforce remains unregistered under formal social legislation, limiting their access to benefits.

3. Funding and Sustainability

   • Concerns over the financial sustainability of SSS, PhilHealth, and other welfare programs.

4. Lack of Awareness

   • Many workers and employers are unaware of their rights and obligations under these laws.

---

Conclusion

Social Legislation in the Philippines serves as a cornerstone of the country's labor and welfare system. It reflects the constitutional commitment to social justice and protection of marginalized sectors. While progress has been made, challenges in enforcement, funding, and inclusion persist. Continuous reforms, awareness campaigns, and efficient implementation are crucial for achieving the full potential of these laws.

Civil Code and Labor Code | Prescription of actions | JURISDICTION & REMEDIES

Prescription of Actions under the Civil Code and the Labor Code

I. GENERAL CONCEPT OF PRESCRIPTION

Prescription refers to the limitation of time within which a legal action may be brought or rights may be enforced. It serves as a bar to stale claims, encouraging diligence among parties and ensuring legal certainty.

In the context of labor law, the prescription of actions is vital in balancing the rights of employees to claim benefits and the employer's right to protect against protracted liability.

---

II. PRESCRIPTION UNDER THE CIVIL CODE

The Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act No. 386) contains general rules on prescription that may apply to labor disputes if not specifically governed by the Labor Code. Relevant provisions include:

1. Ordinary Actions:

   • Article 1144: Actions upon a written contract, obligations created by law, or judgment must be filed within 10 years.
   • Article 1145: Actions upon an oral contract must be filed within 6 years.
   • Article 1146: Actions upon an injury to rights of another or a quasi-delict must be filed within 4 years.

2. Actions Involving Payment of Wages or Other Monetary Obligations:

   • Article 1139 states that rights are not demandable after they have prescribed, except those exempt by law.

The Civil Code provisions are residual in nature; they apply only when no specific provision under the Labor Code governs the situation.

---

III. PRESCRIPTION UNDER THE LABOR CODE

The Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended) contains specific provisions on the prescription of actions, especially tailored to labor rights and remedies.

1. Money Claims Arising from Employer-Employee Relations:

   • Article 306 (formerly Article 291): All money claims arising from employer-employee relations must be filed within 3 years from the time the cause of action accrued.

     • This includes claims for wages, overtime pay, holiday pay, night shift differentials, separation pay, and other monetary benefits.

     Important Points:

     • The prescriptive period is three years, reckoned from the date the employee’s cause of action accrues.
     • Failure to file within this period extinguishes the claim.

2. Illegal Dismissal Cases:

   • Article 306 does not apply directly to illegal dismissal cases, as these are governed by the four-year period for filing under Article 1146 of the Civil Code.
   • However, claims for back wages or separation pay resulting from illegal dismissal fall under the three-year prescription period.

3. Claims Under DOLE’s Visitorial and Enforcement Powers:

   • Under Article 128, the Secretary of Labor or their representatives may enforce compliance with labor standards even without a complaint. These actions may be subject to a three-year prescriptive period, as specified under the Labor Code.

4. Union-Related Disputes:

   • Article 258: Actions to question the validity of the certification election or union-related disputes must be filed within 30 days from the occurrence of the disputed act.

5. Prescriptive Period for Voluntary Arbitrators:

   • When parties submit disputes to voluntary arbitration, the prescriptive period depends on the terms agreed upon in their collective bargaining agreement (CBA). Absent such terms, general Labor Code rules on prescription apply.

---

IV. CASE LAW INTERPRETATIONS

Philippine jurisprudence has clarified several key issues on prescription under both codes:

1. Reckoning Period:

   • The prescription period starts when the cause of action accrues, or when the act or omission that gave rise to the claim happens.
   • For continuing violations, prescription runs from the date of the last act of violation.

2. Applicability of Civil Code Rules:

   • The Supreme Court has consistently held that Civil Code rules on prescription apply only when the Labor Code is silent. For example:
     • Illegal dismissal cases fall under the four-year prescriptive period under the Civil Code.
     • Money claims or labor standards violations fall under the specific three-year period under the Labor Code.

3. Waiver and Suspension of Prescription:

   • Prescription may be interrupted by extrajudicial demands, the filing of a case, or written acknowledgment of the debt by the employer.
   • Waivers of prescription are not favored unless explicitly provided by law or collective agreement.

---

V. POLICY CONSIDERATIONS

The difference in prescriptive periods reflects the nature of labor disputes:

• Shorter periods (3 years) for monetary claims prevent accumulation of liabilities that could harm business stability.
• Longer periods (4 or 10 years) for non-monetary claims, such as illegal dismissal, recognize the profound impact on employees' livelihood.

---

VI. SUMMARY OF PRESCRIPTIVE PERIODS

Type of Claim	Prescriptive Period	Legal Basis
Money claims (wages, benefits)	3 years	Labor Code, Article 306
Illegal dismissal	4 years	Civil Code, Article 1146
Quasi-delicts	4 years	Civil Code, Article 1146
Written contracts	10 years	Civil Code, Article 1144
Oral contracts	6 years	Civil Code, Article 1145
Union disputes (e.g., certification)	30 days	Labor Code, Article 258

---

VII. CONCLUSION

Understanding the prescription of actions under the Civil Code and Labor Code requires distinguishing between general civil law principles and the specific provisions of labor law. The application of these rules ensures the swift resolution of labor disputes while protecting the interests of both employees and employers.

Prescription of actions | JURISDICTION & REMEDIES

Prescription of Actions Under Philippine Labor Law and Social Legislation

The prescription of actions in labor law pertains to the period within which a claim or action must be filed to avoid being barred by the lapse of time. Prescription is governed by specific provisions of the Labor Code of the Philippines, special laws, and jurisprudence. Below is a detailed discussion on this topic, including legal bases, nuances, and notable cases.

---

1. Governing Provisions in the Labor Code

The Labor Code of the Philippines sets the prescriptive periods for filing certain actions:

• Money Claims (Art. 306, formerly Art. 291):

  • All money claims arising from employer-employee relationships must be filed within three (3) years from the time the cause of action accrued. These include claims for unpaid wages, overtime pay, separation pay, and other benefits.
  • If the claim is not filed within this period, the right to file the action is extinguished.

• Illegal Dismissal Cases:

  • No specific prescriptive period is provided in the Labor Code, but jurisprudence has consistently held that actions for illegal dismissal must be filed within four (4) years under the general rule in Article 1146 of the Civil Code.

• Violation of Labor Standards and Social Legislation:

  • Actions involving violations of labor standards laws (e.g., nonpayment of minimum wage, noncompliance with safety standards) generally follow the three (3)-year prescription period under Article 306.
  • Claims arising from social legislation like the Social Security Act, Pag-IBIG Fund Law, and PhilHealth Law may have specific prescriptive periods under their respective statutes.

---

2. Exceptions to Prescription Rules

Certain circumstances may suspend or interrupt the running of the prescriptive period:

• Fraud or Concealment:

  • When the employer conceals the cause of action through fraud or deceit, prescription is deemed to run only from the time the employee discovers the cause of action.

• Continuous Violations:

  • For continuing violations, such as the failure to pay minimum wage or overtime pay, the prescriptive period is reckoned from the date of the last violation.

• Union Activities and Unfair Labor Practices (ULPs):

  • Actions for ULPs, as defined under Article 294, must be filed within one (1) year from the occurrence of the act constituting the ULP.
  • In cases involving dismissal due to union activities, the broader four-year period for illegal dismissal may apply.

---

3. Special Rules in Social Legislation

• SSS, PhilHealth, and Pag-IBIG Contributions:

  • The prescriptive period for employer obligations to remit contributions is ten (10) years based on jurisprudence, as these obligations are deemed impressed with public interest.
  • For employees’ claims for benefits under these laws, the prescriptive periods are set by their respective statutes. For example, claims for benefits under the Social Security Act generally prescribe in ten (10) years.

• Claims for Damages or Penalties:

  • For claims arising from violations that result in damages or penalties (e.g., death benefits under social legislation), the prescription period may vary, depending on the type of action or remedy sought.

---

4. Procedural and Jurisdictional Matters

• Filing in the Correct Forum:

  • The prescription period is jurisdictional; filing the complaint in an improper forum (e.g., a civil court instead of the NLRC) does not interrupt the prescriptive period.
  • For labor claims, the proper forum is usually the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) or the DOLE, depending on the nature of the case.

• Interruption by Extrajudicial Demand:

  • An extrajudicial demand (e.g., a demand letter) can interrupt the running of the prescription period. However, jurisprudence requires that the demand be unequivocal and timely.

---

5. Notable Jurisprudence

Several Supreme Court decisions have clarified the application of prescription rules in labor cases:

• "Republic vs. Asiapro Cooperative" (G.R. No. 172101, 2019):

  • Clarified that obligations with public interest, such as those involving remittance of government-mandated contributions, prescribe in ten years.

• "Santos vs. Servier Philippines" (G.R. No. 202573, 2016):

  • Ruled that the three-year prescriptive period for money claims begins from the time the employee knew or should have known of the violation.

• "Ilaw at Buklod ng Manggagawa vs. NLRC" (G.R. No. 91980, 1991):

  • Held that the filing of an illegal dismissal complaint interrupts the prescriptive period for other monetary claims related to the dismissal.

---

6. Practical Implications for Employers and Employees

• For Employers:

  • Maintain clear and accurate records of all employment-related transactions to defend against stale claims.
  • Address employee complaints promptly to avoid potential liability for continuing violations.

• For Employees:

  • File claims as soon as possible to avoid prescription.
  • Seek legal advice promptly to ensure compliance with procedural rules.

---

Conclusion

Understanding the rules on prescription in labor law and social legislation is critical to protecting the rights of both employers and employees. The interplay of statutory provisions, case law, and procedural rules highlights the need for vigilance in asserting and defending labor claims.

Remedies | Voluntary Arbitrator | JURISDICTION & REMEDIES

LABOR LAW AND SOCIAL LEGISLATION > II. JURISDICTION & REMEDIES > H. Voluntary Arbitrator > 2. Remedies

Under Philippine labor law, voluntary arbitration is a mechanism for resolving labor disputes through mutual agreement between the parties, where a neutral third party (the Voluntary Arbitrator or VA) resolves issues outside the traditional labor courts. The remedies available under this system, as governed by relevant laws, jurisprudence, and administrative regulations, are as follows:

---

1. Nature of Remedies Issued by a Voluntary Arbitrator

• Binding Decisions: Awards or decisions issued by a Voluntary Arbitrator are final, binding, and executory. These decisions have the same force and effect as final judgments of a court.
• Execution of Awards: Remedies can include monetary awards (e.g., unpaid wages, separation pay, retirement benefits) or injunctive relief (e.g., reinstatement of employees or ceasing an illegal activity).
• Specific Relief: The Voluntary Arbitrator may order compliance with collective bargaining agreements (CBAs), resolve deadlocks, or address violations of labor standards laws.

---

2. Scope of Remedies

• Labor Standards and Benefits:
  • Unpaid wages, overtime pay, holiday pay, and other statutory benefits.
  • Claims for separation pay, retirement benefits, or back wages when warranted by the evidence.
• CBA Enforcement:
  • Compliance with provisions in CBAs, including economic and non-economic benefits.
  • Resolving ambiguities in the interpretation of CBA terms.
• Reinstatement:
  • Ordering reinstatement of employees illegally dismissed.
  • This remedy may include full back wages and other compensable benefits.
• Non-Monetary Relief:
  • Cease-and-desist orders to stop unfair labor practices or other violations.
  • Recommendations for corrective actions to improve labor relations.

---

3. Process of Enforcement of VA Awards

• Execution Through Labor Arbiters:
  • Under Article 276 of the Labor Code (as amended), decisions of Voluntary Arbitrators are enforced by the Labor Arbiters of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC).
  • The prevailing party may file a motion for execution before the NLRC for implementation.
• Appeal and Judicial Review:
  • Remedies are limited due to the final and binding nature of VA decisions.
  • A petition for review may be filed with the Court of Appeals via a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court, alleging grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction by the Voluntary Arbitrator.
  • The Supreme Court may also review VA decisions but typically only for exceptional issues of jurisdiction or grave abuse.

---

4. Grounds for Setting Aside or Modifying a VA Decision

• Grave Abuse of Discretion:
  • If the VA acted in a capricious, arbitrary, or whimsical manner.
• Lack of Jurisdiction:
  • If the matter resolved by the VA is outside the scope of voluntary arbitration as agreed upon by the parties.
• Violation of Due Process:
  • If a party is not afforded a reasonable opportunity to present its case.

---

5. Special Considerations in VA Remedies

• Voluntary Arbitration Clause:
  • The VA’s jurisdiction and authority derive from the arbitration agreement or the CBA’s arbitration clause. Any remedy must be within the bounds of the arbitration agreement.
• Effectivity and Duration:
  • Remedies typically take effect immediately unless otherwise specified in the award.
  • Compliance may be time-bound or ongoing, depending on the nature of the relief.

---

6. Limitations on Remedies

• No Punitive Damages:
  • Voluntary Arbitrators cannot award punitive damages, as their role is limited to resolving labor disputes based on law, equity, and agreements.
• Scope of Jurisdiction:
  • Remedies are confined to labor-related issues agreed upon for arbitration. Matters such as criminal liability or purely civil disputes fall outside the VA’s authority.

---

7. Advantages of VA Remedies

• Speed and Efficiency:
  • Voluntary arbitration is often faster than formal court or NLRC proceedings.
• Finality:
  • Decisions are generally final and unappealable, ensuring speedy resolution of disputes.
• Flexibility:
  • Parties can design customized remedies suited to their specific needs or industry practices.

---

8. Practical Implications for Parties

• Employers:
  • Must ensure compliance with VA awards to avoid execution proceedings.
  • Proactive negotiation during arbitration helps shape favorable remedies.
• Employees:
  • Remedies provide robust protection for rights, especially for CBA violations.
  • Awareness of available remedies and procedural enforcement is crucial for full benefit.

---

9. Relevant Jurisprudence

• San Miguel Corporation v. NLRC (G.R. No. 119293):
  • Affirmed the finality and binding nature of VA awards.
• Oceanic Bic Division v. Romero (G.R. No. 164476):
  • Clarified that VA remedies are subject to limited review under Rule 65.
• Globe Telecom, Inc. v. Florendo (G.R. No. 192529):
  • Emphasized the enforceability of VA awards through NLRC mechanisms.

---

10. Procedural Framework

• Initiation:
  • Filing of a Request for Arbitration by one or both parties.
• Arbitration Hearing:
  • Presentation of evidence, witnesses, and legal arguments.
• Award Issuance:
  • Decision rendered based on the merits, CBA terms, and applicable labor laws.
• Execution:
  • Award executed via labor arbiters of the NLRC or enforcement through judicial processes.

---

In conclusion, remedies under voluntary arbitration provide a critical avenue for efficient and binding resolution of labor disputes. These remedies uphold labor rights while fostering cooperative labor-management relations.

Jurisdiction | Voluntary Arbitrator | JURISDICTION & REMEDIES

Voluntary Arbitrator: Jurisdiction

Definition of Voluntary Arbitrator

A voluntary arbitrator refers to any person chosen by the parties in a labor dispute to resolve their conflict outside of the formal judicial system. This method is preferred for its speed, cost-effectiveness, and expertise in labor relations. Voluntary arbitration is governed primarily by the Labor Code of the Philippines, as amended, and relevant jurisprudence.

Jurisdiction of a Voluntary Arbitrator

The jurisdiction of a voluntary arbitrator is delineated under Article 275 (formerly Article 261) of the Labor Code. It states:

1. Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) Disputes

   • A voluntary arbitrator has exclusive and original jurisdiction to resolve disputes that arise from the interpretation, implementation, or enforcement of a Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA). This includes:
     • Clarifications on ambiguous provisions.
     • Issues regarding the application of specific terms.
     • Violations of the terms agreed upon in the CBA.

2. Other Labor-Management Disputes

   • The arbitrator’s jurisdiction also extends to other disputes agreed upon by the parties in writing, even if they are not explicitly covered in the CBA. This includes grievances or specific issues voluntarily referred to arbitration.

3. Statutory Wage Orders and Benefits

   • Voluntary arbitrators may resolve disputes involving the interpretation and application of wage orders and labor standards benefits, provided such disputes are referred to them by agreement of the parties.

4. Other Jurisdictional Basis

   • Matters arising from labor-management relations that the parties agree to submit to voluntary arbitration, including those typically under the jurisdiction of the Labor Arbiter, may also be handled, subject to mutual consent.

Procedural Jurisdiction

1. Parties’ Agreement

   • Jurisdiction is rooted in the voluntary agreement of the parties. This can occur through:
     • An arbitration clause in the CBA.
     • A subsequent written agreement to submit the dispute to arbitration.

2. Exclusivity

   • Once parties submit their dispute to voluntary arbitration, the jurisdiction of the voluntary arbitrator is exclusive. Courts and administrative tribunals, including the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC), generally lose jurisdiction over the matter.

3. Scope of Authority

   • The arbitrator’s authority is limited to the specific issues submitted for arbitration. They cannot rule on matters beyond the scope of the parties’ agreement.

4. Binding Nature

   • The arbitrator’s decision or award is final, executory, and binding upon the parties. Judicial review is allowed only on limited grounds, such as fraud, evident partiality, misconduct, or excess of jurisdiction under Republic Act No. 876 (The Arbitration Law) and applicable Supreme Court rulings.

Remedial Framework

1. Initiating Voluntary Arbitration

   • Disputes are referred to a voluntary arbitrator through a written submission agreement or as mandated in the arbitration clause of a CBA.

2. Selection of Arbitrator(s)

   • The parties mutually select one or more arbitrators. The process may involve:
     • A sole arbitrator.
     • A panel of arbitrators, typically composed of one representative from each party and a neutral chairperson.

3. Arbitration Proceedings

   • The arbitrator conducts hearings and receives evidence. Procedures are less formal than in judicial settings, and technical rules of evidence do not strictly apply.

4. Enforcement of Award

   • The decision or award is enforced through a writ of execution issued by the voluntary arbitrator or through the courts if necessary. Under Article 276 (formerly Article 262-A) of the Labor Code, the award has the force of law.

Jurisprudential Clarifications

1. Exclusive Jurisdiction Over CBA-Related Disputes

   • The Supreme Court consistently affirms that voluntary arbitrators have exclusive jurisdiction over disputes involving the interpretation, implementation, or enforcement of CBAs (e.g., Ludo & Luym Corp. vs. Saornido, G.R. No. 126446).

2. Voluntary Nature

   • The agreement to arbitrate is crucial. Courts have underscored that arbitration proceedings are invalid if one party did not freely consent (e.g., Pantranco North Express, Inc. vs. NLRC, G.R. No. 103667).

3. Judicial Review

   • Limited to exceptional cases such as lack of jurisdiction, grave abuse of discretion, or violation of due process.

4. Authority to Rule on Arbitrability

   • Voluntary arbitrators can determine whether a dispute is arbitrable within the scope of their agreement.

Practical Considerations

1. Cost-Effective and Expedient Resolution

   • Parties often prefer voluntary arbitration due to its streamlined process and lower costs compared to litigation.

2. Specialized Expertise

   • Arbitrators, often with backgrounds in labor relations, bring subject-matter expertise that enhances the quality of resolutions.

3. Confidentiality

   • Unlike court proceedings, arbitration is private, protecting sensitive information about the employer-employee relationship.

Key Legislative References

• Labor Code of the Philippines, as amended (Articles 275-276).
• Republic Act No. 876 (The Arbitration Law).
• Republic Act No. 6715, amending provisions on arbitration under the Labor Code.

Summary

The jurisdiction of a voluntary arbitrator in labor disputes is rooted in the mutual consent of the parties, with exclusive authority over CBA-related disputes and other issues voluntarily submitted. Decisions are final and binding, subject to limited judicial review. Voluntary arbitration is a vital alternative dispute resolution mechanism, promoting industrial peace and efficient resolution of labor disputes.

Voluntary Arbitrator | JURISDICTION & REMEDIES

Voluntary Arbitrator (VA): Labor Law and Social Legislation

Voluntary arbitration is an alternative dispute resolution mechanism where disputes arising from labor and employment relationships are resolved by an impartial third party, called the Voluntary Arbitrator (VA). It is enshrined in Philippine labor laws and jurisprudence as a vital process for maintaining industrial peace.

---

1. Legal Framework

The provisions governing voluntary arbitration are primarily found in the following:

• Labor Code of the Philippines:
  • Article 260: (formerly Article 273) Designates the role and jurisdiction of Voluntary Arbitrators.
  • Article 261: (formerly Article 274) Defines the jurisdiction of Voluntary Arbitrators.
  • Article 262: (formerly Article 275) Grants powers to Voluntary Arbitrators to resolve disputes.
  • Article 262-A: Outlines enforcement mechanisms for VA decisions.
• Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) Issuances:
  • Implementing rules and guidelines for voluntary arbitration, such as DOLE Department Order No. 40-03.

---

2. Definition and Role of Voluntary Arbitrator

A Voluntary Arbitrator is:

• A third party chosen by the disputing parties (employer and employee/union) to resolve disputes voluntarily submitted for arbitration.
• Can be an individual or a panel of arbitrators.
• Accredited by the National Conciliation and Mediation Board (NCMB).

Role:

• Resolves disputes arising from the interpretation, enforcement, or implementation of Collective Bargaining Agreements (CBA).
• Decides on grievances that the parties agree to submit for arbitration.
• Provides a binding and final resolution, equivalent to a court judgment.

---

3. Jurisdiction of Voluntary Arbitrator

The jurisdiction of a Voluntary Arbitrator is exclusive for the following cases:

1. Disputes Arising from CBAs:
   • Interpretation or enforcement of terms.
   • Implementation of benefits agreed in the CBA.
2. Grievances:
   • Matters referred to voluntary arbitration as agreed in the grievance machinery of the CBA.
3. Other Disputes Submitted by Agreement:
   • Any labor-management issue voluntarily agreed to be resolved through arbitration.

---

4. Powers and Authority

Voluntary Arbitrators have quasi-judicial powers, including:

• Conducting Hearings: They may summon witnesses, require submission of evidence, and conduct hearings similar to a judicial process.
• Rendering Decisions: The decision is binding, final, and executory.
• Imposing Penalties and Awards: Includes ordering the payment of monetary benefits or other remedies as necessary.
• Subpoena Powers: Issue subpoenas for documents or witness testimony.

---

5. Remedies and Procedures

Submission of Disputes to Voluntary Arbitration

• Mandatory Arbitration Clause: CBAs typically include a clause that mandates the use of voluntary arbitration for resolving disputes.
• Submission Agreement: If no prior agreement exists, the parties may voluntarily sign an agreement to submit specific issues for arbitration.

Filing of a Case

• The aggrieved party files a request for arbitration with the NCMB.
• The NCMB facilitates the selection of a Voluntary Arbitrator.

Arbitral Proceedings

1. Selection of Arbitrator:
   • The parties may choose an arbitrator from the NCMB-accredited list or appoint their own.
2. Hearing:
   • Flexible procedures but must observe due process.
   • Parties present evidence and arguments.
3. Decision:
   • Must be rendered within 30 days from submission of the case or as agreed by the parties.
   • Final and executory unless questioned under extraordinary remedies.

Enforcement of Decisions

• Decisions have the same effect as a court decision and are enforced by the Regional Trial Court (RTC) if necessary.
• Monetary awards are executed through writs of execution.

Appeal

• Decisions of a Voluntary Arbitrator are not appealable to the NLRC or DOLE.
• Review is available only through a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court, on grounds of grave abuse of discretion.

---

6. Advantages of Voluntary Arbitration

• Speedy Resolution: Avoids the prolonged process of litigation.
• Cost-Effective: Less expensive than formal court proceedings.
• Confidentiality: Proceedings are private, unlike court hearings.
• Expertise: Arbitrators are typically knowledgeable in labor law and industrial relations.

---

7. Key Jurisprudence

Several landmark Supreme Court decisions highlight the principles governing voluntary arbitration:

• Lopez Sugar Corporation v. Federation of Free Workers (G.R. No. L-75700): VA decisions are final and executory unless a Rule 65 petition demonstrates grave abuse of discretion.
• St. Scholastica’s College v. Torres (G.R. No. 100158): Emphasized the exclusivity of VA jurisdiction over CBA disputes.
• San Miguel Corporation v. NLRC (G.R. No. 121992): Reinforced that VA decisions cannot be appealed to the NLRC or DOLE.

---

8. Challenges and Improvements

Challenges:

• Lack of Awareness: Many workers and employers are unaware of voluntary arbitration as an option.
• Limited Arbitrators: Shortage of accredited arbitrators in certain regions.
• Implementation Issues: Delays in enforcing arbitral awards.

Suggested Improvements:

• Enhanced training and accreditation for arbitrators.
• Increased promotion of voluntary arbitration through DOLE programs.
• Legislative amendments to provide more robust enforcement mechanisms.

---

9. Conclusion

Voluntary arbitration is a cornerstone of industrial relations in the Philippines. It promotes the efficient, equitable, and amicable resolution of labor disputes, contributing to industrial peace. The finality of decisions and the expertise of arbitrators underscore its importance as a preferred dispute resolution mechanism under Philippine labor law.