Subsidiary Penalty | Penalties | REVISED PENAL CODE – BOOK ONE

Subsidiary Penalty under the Revised Penal Code (RPC) of the Philippines

Definition and Purpose
The subsidiary penalty is a secondary or substitute punishment imposed on a convicted individual who fails to pay the pecuniary penalties (fines, costs, or indemnities) imposed by the court. It ensures that the penalty is not rendered ineffective due to the convict's insolvency or inability to pay.

Legal Basis

• Article 39, Revised Penal Code: Subsidiary imprisonment is specifically addressed in Article 39 of the Revised Penal Code (RPC), as amended. This provision explains when and how a subsidiary penalty is imposed for failure to satisfy fines.

---

Key Provisions of Article 39 (RPC)

1. Applicability

   • Subsidiary imprisonment applies only when the convict is unable to pay fines imposed as part of the sentence.
   • It is not applicable if the penalty imposed is purely imprisonment, nor does it apply when fines are voluntarily paid.

2. Computation of Subsidiary Imprisonment

   • The duration of subsidiary imprisonment is determined by converting the unpaid fine into days of imprisonment.
   • Conversion Rate: One day of imprisonment for every ₱8.00 of unpaid fine.
   • Maximum Duration:
     • For Light Penalties: Up to one-third of the principal penalty, but not exceeding 30 days.
     • For Other Penalties: Not exceeding the duration of the principal penalty.

3. Exclusions and Limitations

   • Habitual Delinquents: Subsidiary imprisonment is not applicable to habitual delinquents as defined in the RPC.
   • Maximum Limits: The subsidiary penalty cannot exceed the duration of the principal penalty.

4. Application to Different Sentences

   • Subsidiary imprisonment is cumulative when there are multiple fines imposed. Each unpaid fine is converted individually, and the subsidiary penalties for each are served successively.

5. Nature of Imprisonment

   • The convict serving subsidiary imprisonment is not considered a detention prisoner but rather a convicted prisoner serving a penalty.

---

Examples of Application

• Example 1: Fine for Grave Felonies
  A convict sentenced to reclusión perpetua (which does not include a fine) cannot be subjected to subsidiary imprisonment since no fine is imposed.

• Example 2: Fine for Light Offense
  A convict fined ₱200 for unjust vexation fails to pay the fine. The unpaid amount is converted to 25 days of subsidiary imprisonment (₱200 ÷ ₱8 = 25 days).

• Example 3: Multiple Fines
  If a convict owes ₱1000 and ₱500 under two separate cases and cannot pay either fine, the subsidiary penalties are computed separately (125 days for the first fine and 62.5 days for the second fine).

---

Amendments and Jurisprudence

• RA 10159: The fine-to-subsidiary penalty conversion rate of ₱8 per day was retained in this amendment. However, subsequent jurisprudence reflects adjustments in certain circumstances to align with contemporary realities.

• Jurisprudence:

  • In People v. Diaz, the Supreme Court ruled that subsidiary penalties are mandatory unless explicitly excluded in the judgment.
  • In People v. Ong, it was clarified that the subsidiary penalty is imposed only if the convict fails to pay the fine, and this does not extend beyond the principal penalty.

---

Related Concepts

1. Civil Obligations in Criminal Cases:

   • If indemnities or restitution are not paid, the convict is civilly liable, but this does not automatically convert to subsidiary imprisonment.

2. Good Conduct Time Allowance (GCTA):

   • The convict serving a subsidiary penalty may earn time deductions under the GCTA law, reducing the period of imprisonment.

---

Practical Implications

1. Ensuring Justice: The subsidiary penalty ensures that convicts are not excused from their penalties solely due to insolvency.
2. Rights of the Convict:
   • The convict retains the right to petition for alternatives, such as partial payments or installment arrangements, subject to judicial discretion.
3. Enforcement and Execution:
   • The court issues a writ of execution to enforce the pecuniary penalty. If the fine remains unpaid after diligent efforts, subsidiary imprisonment is implemented.

Conclusion

Subsidiary penalties are a critical mechanism in the Philippine criminal justice system. They uphold the principles of fairness and accountability, ensuring that monetary penalties are not evaded. While limited by the principal penalty's duration and certain exclusions, the subsidiary penalty reflects the balance between retribution and practicality in enforcing justice.