Collective Bargaining and Administration | LABOR RELATIONS

Below is a comprehensive, detailed, and structured overview of collective bargaining and collective agreement administration in the Philippines, referencing the constitutional mandates, statutory provisions under the Labor Code of the Philippines, implementing regulations, administrative issuances, key jurisprudence, and standard industry practices. This presentation is designed to encapsulate all relevant aspects with precision and depth.

I. Constitutional and Policy Framework

  1. Constitutional Basis
    The 1987 Philippine Constitution explicitly protects the rights of workers, including the right to self-organization, collective bargaining, and negotiations. Article XIII, Section 3 states that the State shall guarantee these rights and promote the principle of shared responsibility between workers and employers. This constitutional protection sets the normative cornerstone for all labor relations and the collective bargaining process.

  2. State Policy and Principles
    The State encourages free collective bargaining as a means of promoting industrial peace, social justice, and the democratization of employer-employee relations. The policy is to foster voluntary modes of dispute settlement, collective negotiations, and the full autonomy of parties in drafting their Collective Bargaining Agreements (CBAs).

II. Statutory Framework: Labor Code of the Philippines

  1. Pertinent Provisions
    Collective bargaining and its administration are primarily governed by Book V, "Labor Relations," Title VII of the Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended). Specifically:

    • Articles 255 to 272 (renumbered under DOLE Department Order No. 40-03, but traditionally cited as Arts. 255-267) cover the duty to bargain collectively, procedures for collective bargaining, the structure and content of CBAs, enforcement, grievance machinery, and related matters.

  2. Right to Bargain Collectively

    • Article 255 (Old Numbering): Grants employees the right to self-organization for purposes of collective bargaining.
    • The law recognizes that the exclusive bargaining representative (EBR), typically a duly certified or voluntarily recognized union, has the right to demand negotiations with the employer concerning wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment.

  3. Exclusive Bargaining Agent (EBA)
    Only the union duly certified as the exclusive bargaining representative of the appropriate bargaining unit has the legal standing to bargain with the employer. Certification elections, governed by the Labor Code and DOLE rules, determine which union represents the employees. Once certified, the union’s status as EBR endures for the duration of the CBA (usually five years, with certain mandatory renegotiation periods).

III. The Collective Bargaining Process

  1. Subjects of Bargaining
    Subjects of collective bargaining are divided into:

    • Mandatory Subjects: Wages, hours of work, terms and conditions of employment, and all other employment terms that directly affect employees.
    • Permissive (Voluntary) Subjects: Matters that may not be directly work-related but which parties may choose to negotiate for mutual benefit, such as union security clauses and social welfare programs. The parties have a legal duty to bargain in good faith regarding mandatory subjects. Refusal to do so may constitute an unfair labor practice.

  2. Bargaining in Good Faith
    The duty to bargain collectively implies:

    • Sincere desire to reach an agreement.
    • Reasonable meeting schedules.
    • Genuine exploration of proposals and counterproposals. Superficial or dilatory tactics, or outright refusal to meet, constitute bad faith bargaining and may be sanctioned as unfair labor practices.

  3. Procedure and Timeline
    Typically, a notice to bargain must be served within a certain statutory period before the expiry of an existing CBA. Under the Labor Code, economic provisions of a CBA are subject to renegotiation not later than three (3) years after its execution. The process usually involves:

    • A written notice from the union or employer to commence negotiations.
    • Exchange of proposals and counterproposals.
    • Series of negotiation meetings, possibly facilitated by a mediator from the National Conciliation and Mediation Board (NCMB) if the parties face significant difficulties. If unresolved, parties may resort to voluntary arbitration or invoke the intervention of the NCMB for conciliation-mediation services. In critical disputes affecting national interest, the Secretary of Labor and Employment may assume jurisdiction to avert a strike or lockout.

  4. Economic and Non-Economic Issues
    Negotiations generally cover two main categories:

    • Economic Issues: Wage increases, allowances, incentive schemes, benefits, bonuses, and other quantifiable conditions.
    • Non-Economic Issues: Grievance procedures, union security clauses (e.g., union shop or maintenance-of-membership), disciplinary procedures, health and safety standards, dispute resolution mechanisms, and due process protocols.

IV. Collective Bargaining Agreements (CBAs)

  1. Definition and Form
    A Collective Bargaining Agreement is a contract executed between the exclusive bargaining agent (union) and the employer, setting forth the negotiated terms and conditions of employment applicable to all workers in the bargaining unit. The CBA must be in writing and signed by the parties. Once concluded, it becomes the law between them.

  2. Required Provisions
    Under the Labor Code and DOLE regulations, a valid CBA typically contains:

    • Effective date and duration.
    • Coverage and scope of the bargaining unit.
    • Wages, work hours, leave benefits, and other terms of employment.
    • Grievance machinery and voluntary arbitration procedures.
    • Provisions on labor-management cooperation, if any. Some clauses are mandatory, especially the establishment of a grievance procedure culminating in voluntary arbitration.

  3. Duration and Renegotiation
    A CBA has a maximum term of five (5) years. However, the economic provisions must be renegotiated at least once in the 3rd year of the agreement. Non-economic provisions usually remain stable throughout the full five-year term, unless both parties mutually agree to reconsider them.

  4. Union Security Clauses
    Commonly included in CBAs are union security arrangements such as:

    • Closed Shop: Only union members can be hired and must remain members in good standing.
    • Union Shop: Non-members may be hired but must join the union after a certain period.
    • Maintenance of Membership: Employees who are union members at the time of CBA signing must remain members for its duration. These clauses must be negotiated in good faith and must not violate employee rights or public policy.

V. Grievance Machinery and Dispute Resolution

  1. Grievance Procedure
    Every CBA must contain a grievance machinery for the adjustment of grievances arising from the interpretation or implementation of the agreement and company policies. This is a step-ladder mechanism:

    • Step 1: Discussion at immediate supervisor or shop steward level.
    • Step 2: Elevation to higher management or union officers.
    • Step 3: Final review by top-level representatives of both union and management. Only after exhausting these steps without resolution may the dispute proceed to voluntary arbitration.

  2. Voluntary Arbitration
    If grievances remain unresolved through the contractual grievance machinery, the dispute is submitted to voluntary arbitration. Voluntary arbitrators or panels of voluntary arbitrators are chosen by mutual agreement of the parties. Their decisions are final, executory, and binding, subject only to limited judicial review. This mechanism seeks to maintain industrial harmony and avoid costly strikes or lockouts.

  3. Enforcement of CBA Provisions
    CBA stipulations are enforceable as contractual obligations. Non-compliance by the employer or union can be challenged through the agreed-upon grievance machinery and, if necessary, through arbitration. In some instances, the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) or regular courts may have jurisdiction depending on the nature of the dispute (e.g., interpretation of CBA provisions usually goes to arbitration; unfair labor practices or illegal dismissal claims go through NLRC).

VI. Administration of the CBA

  1. Role of the Union and Employer
    Effective CBA administration requires ongoing cooperation:

    • The union ensures that the employer complies with the terms, coordinates with members for grievances, and monitors workplace conditions.
    • The employer ensures consistent implementation of agreed-upon benefits, consults the union on policy changes, and abides by the established grievance procedures.

  2. Labor-Management Cooperation Mechanisms
    Many CBAs encourage or mandate the creation of labor-management committees or councils to address issues proactively. These fora handle matters such as productivity improvement, occupational safety and health, and employee welfare programs.

  3. Union Dues and Check-Off
    CBA administration often involves provisions on union dues and agency fees. By agreement, the employer may deduct union dues from employees’ wages (check-off) and remit these to the union. Such arrangements facilitate the union’s administrative and representational functions.

VII. Unfair Labor Practices (ULPs) and Good Faith Bargaining

  1. Employers’ ULPs related to Collective Bargaining
    Under the Labor Code, it is an unfair labor practice for an employer to:

    • Refuse to bargain collectively with the duly certified union.
    • Interfere with the formation or administration of any labor organization.
    • Discriminate in terms of conditions of employment to encourage or discourage union membership.
    • Violate the terms and conditions of a CBA without a valid reason.

  2. Unions’ ULPs related to Collective Bargaining
    It is likewise an unfair labor practice for a union or its officers to:

    • Refuse to bargain collectively with the employer.
    • Cause or attempt to cause an employer to discriminate against an employee who is not a member of the union.
    • Violate the terms and conditions of a CBA.

  3. Remedies for ULPs
    ULP complaints are filed before the appropriate Labor Arbiter at the NLRC, which may order reinstatement, payment of backwages, or other affirmative remedies. Cease-and-desist orders and directives for parties to resume good faith bargaining are also possible.

VIII. Role of Government Agencies

  1. Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE)

    • Oversees the registration of labor unions and issuance of certificates for exclusive bargaining representation.
    • Provides conciliation, mediation, and voluntary arbitration services through its attached agencies, primarily to prevent and resolve labor disputes.

  2. National Conciliation and Mediation Board (NCMB)

    • Offers free mediation and conciliation to help parties settle bargaining impasses and other labor disputes.
    • Encourages voluntary arbitration and provides a pool of accredited voluntary arbitrators.

  3. National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC)

    • Hears and decides labor cases that go beyond the scope of voluntary arbitration and grievance machinery, such as unfair labor practices, illegal dismissal, and other labor standards violations after mandatory conciliation processes have been exhausted.

IX. Jurisprudential Guidance

  1. Supreme Court Precedents
    Philippine jurisprudence has consistently reinforced:

    • The duty of both parties to engage in genuine and serious negotiations (good faith bargaining).
    • The non-interference by management in union affairs and workers’ right to self-organization.
    • The finality and binding nature of arbitrators’ awards, emphasizing the policy favoring voluntary arbitration as a primary dispute resolution mechanism.

  2. Landmark Cases
    Supreme Court decisions (e.g., Philippine Diamond Hotel & Resort, Inc. v. Manila Diamond Hotel Employees Union, G.R. No. 158075; General Milling Corporation v. CA, G.R. No. 146728) highlight the primacy of collective bargaining in industrial relations, clarify procedures for renegotiation of economic provisions, and underscore the mandatory nature of grievance and arbitration clauses.
    Cases also clarify that while the State intervenes only minimally, it does so when public interest is at stake, ensuring an atmosphere conducive to fair negotiations and stable labor relations.

X. Trends and Developments

  1. Tripartism and Social Dialogue
    Ongoing policy initiatives promote tripartism, involving government, employers, and workers’ representatives in policymaking. Such mechanisms strengthen collective bargaining by ensuring an environment that respects workers’ rights and encourages responsible employer behavior.

  2. Alignment with International Labor Standards
    Philippine collective bargaining policies are aligned with International Labor Organization (ILO) Conventions, particularly Convention No. 87 on Freedom of Association and Convention No. 98 on the Right to Organize and Collective Bargaining. Compliance with international standards reinforces the legitimacy and fairness of the collective bargaining framework.

  3. Evolving Workplace Issues
    Modern CBAs increasingly incorporate clauses on data privacy, alternative work arrangements (remote or hybrid work), health and safety protocols (especially after COVID-19), and anti-discrimination measures, reflecting evolving norms and regulations.

XI. Conclusion

The collective bargaining and administration framework in the Philippines is a robust, well-defined system anchored in constitutional mandates, codified in the Labor Code, enriched by jurisprudence, and facilitated by government agencies. It empowers workers and employers to craft agreements that establish fair wages, decent working conditions, and stable industrial relations. The process emphasizes good faith, cooperation, voluntary dispute resolution, and respect for the autonomy of the negotiating parties. Over the years, the practice of collective bargaining has proven essential in fostering industrial peace, social justice, and equitable growth in the Philippine labor landscape.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login