Right to Dividends of Stockholders in Philippine Corporations: Proprietary Rights

The right to dividends for stockholders in the Philippines is a critical aspect of proprietary rights in corporate law. This right hinges upon the nature of dividends as the distribution of profits or surplus, the requirements under the Corporation Code of the Philippines (R.A. 11232, also known as the Revised Corporation Code of the Philippines), and the corporation’s own financial health and discretion. Here's a detailed look at the specifics.

1. Nature of the Right to Dividends

Proprietary Right: The right to receive dividends is a proprietary right of stockholders, meaning it arises from ownership in the corporation. This right entitles stockholders to a portion of the corporation's profits or surplus when dividends are declared.
Not Automatic: The right to dividends is not an absolute entitlement; it requires both corporate profits and a formal declaration by the corporation’s board of directors.
Exclusion of Pre-emptive Rights: Unlike pre-emptive rights, which protect against dilution of ownership, dividend rights pertain only to profit-sharing and do not entitle stockholders to any direct influence over when dividends are declared.

2. Types of Dividends

Cash Dividends: Cash dividends are payments made in cash and are directly distributed to stockholders according to their respective shareholdings. The board must declare the dividends based on available retained earnings.
Stock Dividends: Stock dividends are payments made in the form of additional shares rather than cash. These dividends increase the number of shares held but do not immediately provide cash benefits. Issuance of stock dividends requires stockholder approval if they involve an increase in the corporation’s authorized capital stock.
Property Dividends: Though less common, property dividends involve the distribution of assets (non-cash and non-stock) to stockholders. Proper valuation and board approval are essential, as such dividends must align with both corporate interests and fiduciary duties.

3. Declaration of Dividends

Board of Directors' Authority: Only the board of directors has the authority to declare dividends, contingent upon the existence of retained earnings or profits. Without board approval, no dividends can be distributed.
Board Discretion and Fiduciary Duty: The board exercises its discretion in declaring dividends, guided by fiduciary duty to ensure the corporation’s financial stability. If a declaration of dividends could harm corporate operations or long-term interests, the board may lawfully withhold dividends.
Legal Limits on Retained Earnings: The Revised Corporation Code mandates that corporations cannot retain earnings beyond 100% of their paid-in capital without justifiable grounds (such as future investment plans). Retaining earnings without declaring dividends can expose the corporation to claims of withholding dividends in bad faith.

4. Stockholders’ Rights and Remedies

Right to Proportionate Share: Stockholders are entitled to dividends proportionate to their shareholding once dividends are declared. This proportionality maintains equity among stockholders, regardless of the size of the dividend payout.
Remedies for Unjust Denial: Stockholders have legal remedies if they believe dividends are being withheld unjustly. They may challenge the board’s decision in court, particularly if evidence suggests a breach of fiduciary duty. However, courts traditionally defer to the board’s business judgment unless there is a clear abuse of discretion or evidence of malfeasance.
Stockholder Suits: If withholding dividends appears motivated by bad faith or self-interest, stockholders may file derivative suits against the board. Derivative actions compel the corporation to declare dividends and provide redress for any breaches of fiduciary duty.

5. Taxation on Dividends

Tax Treatment of Cash Dividends: Cash dividends are subject to withholding tax, typically at a rate of 10% for Filipino citizens and residents, and at a higher rate for non-resident aliens or foreign corporations, depending on applicable tax treaties.
Stock Dividends and Tax Implications: Stock dividends are generally non-taxable, as they do not represent actual gains. However, if stock dividends are later redeemed or sold, they may incur capital gains tax depending on the nature of the transaction.
Documentary Stamp Tax: Stock dividends may attract documentary stamp tax (DST) upon issuance, whereas cash dividends generally do not.

6. Special Rules and Limitations

Stockholder Approval for Large Stock Dividends: If the corporation’s authorized capital stock is increased to accommodate stock dividends, a two-thirds stockholder vote is required, ensuring that substantial equity changes receive broad stockholder consent.
Restrictions on Dividends in Certain Circumstances: Corporations in distress or those receiving financial rehabilitation assistance may face temporary restrictions on dividend distributions. Regulatory bodies, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), may impose such restrictions to preserve corporate viability.

7. Jurisdictional and Regulatory Oversight

Role of the SEC: The SEC oversees corporate compliance and may intervene if a corporation’s dividend practices contravene shareholder rights or regulatory requirements. Stockholders can file complaints with the SEC if they believe the board is unjustly withholding dividends.
Regulatory Filings: Corporations must reflect dividend declarations in their financial filings with the SEC, disclosing both the amount of declared dividends and the retention of earnings.

8. Impact of Preferred Shares and Their Dividend Rights

Preferred Shares Dividend Priority: Holders of preferred shares are often granted priority over common stockholders regarding dividend distribution, with preferred dividends sometimes at a fixed rate. However, preferred dividends are typically cumulative, meaning unpaid dividends accumulate if they are not declared in one period, to be paid out before common stock dividends in future periods.
Participating Preferred Shares: In some cases, preferred shares participate in excess profits after common stock dividends are distributed. This feature allows participating preferred shareholders to receive an additional share of profits beyond their fixed dividend rate.

9. Withholding and Unclaimed Dividends

Withholding for Compliance: Cash dividends are subject to withholding, and corporations must remit the tax portion to the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) as required under the Tax Code.
Escheat of Unclaimed Dividends: Unclaimed dividends may eventually revert to the state under the principle of escheat, especially if the stockholder cannot be located for an extended period.