Effects of Commencement Order and Exceptions | Rehabilitation | R.A. No.10142 or the Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act | OTHER SPECIAL LAWS AND RULES

Under the Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act of 2010 (R.A. No. 10142) in the Philippines, rehabilitation is a legal process designed to revive distressed companies through court or out-of-court proceedings. This process involves creating a plan to restore the debtor’s financial health while maximizing creditor recoveries. Within the rehabilitation process, the "Commencement Order" plays a pivotal role in setting the framework for proceedings, rights, and obligations. Here’s a breakdown of the effects of the Commencement Order and its exceptions:

1. Commencement Order: Definition and Purpose

The Commencement Order is a court-issued order that initiates the rehabilitation process for a debtor corporation. Upon the filing of a petition for rehabilitation, the court will assess the merits and, if satisfied, will issue this order. The purpose of the Commencement Order is to:

  • Formally start the rehabilitation proceedings.
  • Provide protection and structure for the debtor and creditors.
  • Establish control over the debtor’s assets to prevent further dissipation.
  • Lay out rules on the conduct of parties during the proceedings.

2. Key Effects of the Commencement Order

The issuance of a Commencement Order has several critical effects on the debtor, creditors, and other stakeholders:

a. Stay or Suspension Order (Automatic Stay)

One of the primary effects of the Commencement Order is the automatic stay or suspension of all actions or proceedings against the debtor. The stay order is intended to:

  • Halt creditor actions, including foreclosure, collection suits, and enforcement of claims.
  • Preserve the debtor’s assets and business operations from further depletion.
  • Prevent disruptions in the rehabilitation proceedings.
  • Avoid preferential treatment of certain creditors over others.

Scope of the Stay Order:

  • Civil Proceedings: Any civil action against the debtor, including suits to recover claims, is stayed.
  • Enforcement of Claims: Creditors are prohibited from enforcing their claims against the debtor or its assets.
  • Foreclosure of Liens: All foreclosure actions are suspended, preventing the sale or seizure of secured assets.
  • Displacement of Management: The debtor’s management generally remains in place unless otherwise ordered by the court or unless a management committee is appointed.

b. Suspension of Interest Accrual

During the rehabilitation period, the accrual of interest, penalties, fees, and other charges related to the debtor’s liabilities is suspended. This helps control the financial burden on the debtor and prevents further escalation of its debt while it undergoes rehabilitation.

c. Binding Effect of the Rehabilitation Plan

Once a rehabilitation plan is confirmed by the court, it becomes binding on:

  • The debtor,
  • All creditors, including secured and unsecured creditors, and
  • Stockholders and other stakeholders.

This binding nature of the confirmed rehabilitation plan ensures that all parties adhere to the terms agreed upon in the proceedings, providing a clear pathway for debt restructuring and resolution.

d. Appointment of a Rehabilitation Receiver

In most cases, the court appoints a rehabilitation receiver upon the issuance of the Commencement Order. The receiver’s primary duties include:

  • Overseeing the debtor’s assets and business operations.
  • Reviewing the rehabilitation plan proposed by the debtor.
  • Ensuring compliance with the court orders and overseeing the plan’s implementation.
  • Acting as a neutral party to protect the interests of both creditors and the debtor.

3. Exceptions to the Effects of the Commencement Order

While the Commencement Order provides a comprehensive stay on creditor actions, there are specific exceptions outlined under R.A. No. 10142. These exceptions allow certain actions to proceed despite the stay order:

a. Criminal Actions

Criminal cases against the debtor or its management, directors, or officers are not stayed by the Commencement Order. Criminal liability is distinct from civil liability and is not affected by the rehabilitation proceedings.

b. Claims Arising After the Issuance of the Commencement Order

Liabilities incurred by the debtor after the issuance of the Commencement Order are not covered by the stay. This allows creditors to enforce claims for obligations created during the rehabilitation process, supporting ongoing business operations.

c. Actions for the Preservation of Secured Assets (With Court Approval)

Secured creditors may file a motion to request the court’s approval to continue actions if they can show that:

  • The assets are at risk of deterioration or loss of value, and
  • The continuation of proceedings would not prejudice the rehabilitation process.

This exception is aimed at protecting the rights of secured creditors without jeopardizing the debtor’s rehabilitation efforts.

d. Actions by the Government or Regulatory Agencies

Actions by government regulatory agencies, such as the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) or the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), are typically not suspended. The government retains its right to enforce regulatory compliance, taxation, and other obligations despite the rehabilitation proceedings.

e. Court Orders Allowing Specific Actions

In certain cases, the court may allow specific actions to proceed if it finds that:

  • The action is necessary for the preservation of the debtor’s assets or business operations,
  • It will not prejudice the rehabilitation efforts or undermine creditor interests.

4. Termination of the Effects of the Commencement Order

The effects of the Commencement Order, including the stay on creditor actions, will typically continue until:

  • The Rehabilitation Plan is Confirmed by the court, and the debtor begins implementing the plan.
  • Rehabilitation Proceedings are Terminated, either because the court finds the rehabilitation infeasible or the plan has been fully implemented.
  • Conversion into Liquidation: If rehabilitation is not viable, the court may convert the proceedings into liquidation. In such cases, the Commencement Order is lifted, and the liquidation process begins.

5. Conclusion: The Balance of Interests in the Commencement Order

The Commencement Order in R.A. No. 10142 serves to balance the debtor’s need for a reprieve to reorganize its finances and creditors' right to recover their claims. It offers both a shield and a structured framework for all parties to negotiate a sustainable path forward. By staying creditor actions, suspending interest accrual, and confirming a court-approved rehabilitation plan, the law provides a comprehensive approach to corporate financial recovery in the Philippines, while certain exceptions ensure that secured creditors and the government can protect their interests if needed.