Classification of Actions | CIVIL PROCEDUREClassification of Actions | CIVIL PROCEDURE

CLASSIFICATION OF ACTIONS UNDER PHILIPPINE CIVIL PROCEDURE
(Based on the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure, as amended, jurisprudence, and prevailing legal doctrines in the Philippines.)

1. Overview

Under Philippine Remedial Law, an action is a formal demand of one’s right in a court of justice through the filing of a complaint or petition. The Rules of Court provide for various classifications of actions, each bearing implications on jurisdiction, venue, and service of summons, among other procedural considerations. A comprehensive understanding of these classifications is crucial for properly instituting civil suits.

2. Primary Classifications

The primary classifications of actions under the Rules of Court (particularly Rule 2) are:

  1. Ordinary Civil Actions
  2. Special Civil Actions
  3. Criminal Actions (not within the scope of the present topic but referenced for distinction)
  4. Special Proceedings (also not strictly within “actions,” but discussed for clarity)

Within ordinary civil actions, a further subdivision exists based on subject matter and nature of the relief sought, namely:

  • Real Actions vs. Personal Actions
  • Actions In Personam, In Rem, and Quasi In Rem
  • Local vs. Transitory Actions

We focus on those most relevant in civil litigation: Ordinary Civil Actions (and their sub-classifications) and Special Civil Actions.

3. Ordinary Civil Actions

3.1 Real Actions vs. Personal Actions

Under Section 1, Rule 4 of the Rules of Court:

  1. Real Actions

    • Definition: Actions affecting title to or possession of real property, or an interest therein.
    • Examples:
      • Action to recover title or possession of land.
      • Action to foreclose a real estate mortgage.
      • Action to remove a cloud on title or quiet title.
    • Venue: Real actions must be filed in the Regional Trial Court (RTC) of the province/city where the real property or any part thereof is situated. This is a rule on venue that is mandatory (i.e., it is local in nature).

  2. Personal Actions

    • Definition: Actions where the subject matter is not real property, and the plaintiff seeks the recovery of personal property, enforcement of a contract or obligation, or recovery of damages for injury to person or property.
    • Examples:
      • Action for sum of money.
      • Action for damages based on breach of contract.
      • Action for the recovery of personal property (e.g., replevin).
    • Venue: Personal actions are generally transitory and may be filed where the plaintiff or defendant resides (at the option of the plaintiff) or, in the case of a corporation, where its principal place of business is located, unless the parties validly stipulate on a different venue.

Significance:

  • The classification between real and personal actions primarily affects venue. A misclassification can lead to improper venue and possible dismissal or transfer of the suit.

3.2 In Personam, In Rem, and Quasi In Rem Actions

Nature of the obligation or the object of the suit also classifies actions into:

  1. In Personam

    • Seeks a personal judgment against a defendant.
    • Requires jurisdiction over the person of the defendant.
    • Example: An action for collection of a sum of money based on a contract.

  2. In Rem

    • Directed against the thing itself (the property or status), rather than a particular defendant’s personal liability.
    • Requires that the court acquire jurisdiction over the res, usually through seizure of the property, publication, or posting of notices.
    • Example: Annulment of marriage (status of the person), petitions for probate of a will, land registration proceedings.

  3. Quasi In Rem

    • An action directed against a particular person but seeks to subject the person’s property or interests to the judgment of the court.
    • Jurisdiction is primarily over the property.
    • Example: An action to attach or garnish property to satisfy a personal claim.

Practical Effects:

  • Service of Summons:
    • In in personam actions, personal or substituted service is required for the court to acquire jurisdiction over the defendant’s person.
    • In in rem or quasi in rem actions, publication and service by any other means allowed by the Rules may suffice, provided the property is within the court’s jurisdiction.

4. Special Civil Actions

Special Civil Actions (Rules 62 to 71) are governed by specific rules different from or supplementary to those that govern ordinary civil actions. They include:

  1. Interpleader (Rule 62)
  2. Declaratory Relief and Similar Remedies (Rule 63)
  3. Review of Judgments and Final Orders or Resolutions of the Commission on Elections and Commission on Audit (Rule 64)
  4. Certiorari, Prohibition, and Mandamus (Rule 65)
  5. Quo Warranto (Rule 66)
  6. Expropriation (Rule 67)
  7. Foreclosure of Real Estate Mortgage (Rule 68)
  8. Partition (Rule 69)
  9. Forcible Entry and Unlawful Detainer (Rule 70)
  10. Contempt (Rule 71)

Each of these actions has distinct procedural requirements, such as specific prescriptive periods, venue, joinder of parties, and remedies.

5. Local vs. Transitory Actions

Another way the law classifies actions is based on venue:

  1. Local Actions

    • Must be filed where the property is located (similar to real actions).
    • Strict rule; jurisdiction over the property or the location is crucial.
    • Typically involve real property or issues that can only be litigated in the place where the subject property/subject matter is situated.

  2. Transitory Actions

    • May be filed where the plaintiff or defendant resides (at the option of the plaintiff), assuming personal actions.
    • E.g., suit for damages due to a contractual breach may be filed at the plaintiff’s or defendant’s place of residence (or principal office).

6. Importance of Correct Classification

  1. Proper Venue

    • Real (local): Must be filed where property is located.
    • Personal (transitory): Plaintiff’s or defendant’s residence (or principal place of business if a juridical person).
    • Misclassification can result in dismissal for improper venue or forum shopping.

  2. Jurisdiction

    • The nature of the action (especially if it is in personam, in rem, or quasi in rem) dictates how the court must acquire jurisdiction (either over the person or the property).

  3. Nature of Relief and Proceedings

    • Special civil actions follow different rules from ordinary civil actions (e.g., the requirement for a prior demand in Forcible Entry or Unlawful Detainer, necessity of posting a bond in Attachment or Replevin, etc.).

  4. Service of Summons

    • In an in personam action, the defendant must be served personally or by substituted service.
    • In an in rem or quasi in rem action, the property must be under the court’s control (attachment, publication, etc.), and summons by publication may suffice to meet due process requirements.

  5. Pleading Requirements

    • The complaint must clearly allege the ultimate facts that make the action either real or personal, in personam or in rem, or one of the special civil actions. Insufficient or erroneous allegations may lead to improper classification.

7. Interplay with Legal Ethics

  1. Duty of Candor and Good Faith:

    • Lawyers must classify actions correctly and file in the correct venue. Deliberate misclassification to harass or vex an opposing party is a violation of ethical standards and may lead to disciplinary action.

  2. Avoidance of Forum Shopping:

    • Classifying an action improperly and re-filing in a different court to gain advantage or delay can constitute forum shopping. Lawyers have an ethical duty to refrain from such improper tactics.

  3. Professional Responsibility:

    • Counsel must ensure that the client’s cause of action is accurately pleaded. Failure to do so, whether intentional or by gross negligence, may subject the lawyer to administrative or disciplinary liability.

8. Sample Basic Forms for Complaints (General Outline)

While the exact content of pleadings will vary, below is a general template illustrating how one might structure the allegations in a Complaint, with focus on the classification of the action. Note: Always tailor the complaint to the specific Rule (ordinary or special civil action) and factual circumstances.

8.1 Complaint for a Personal Action (e.g., Sum of Money)

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
[Judicial Region]
Branch [___]
[City/Municipality]

[Name of Plaintiff],
       Plaintiff,
  -versus-                                Civil Case No. _______

[Name of Defendant],
       Defendant.
  
x--------------------------------------------x

                              COMPLAINT

Plaintiff, by counsel, respectfully alleges:

1. Plaintiff is of legal age, [citizenship], residing at [address], where he may be served with notices, orders, and other court processes.
2. Defendant is of legal age, [citizenship], residing at [address], where summons may be served.
3. On [date], Plaintiff and Defendant entered into a Contract of Loan wherein Defendant borrowed [amount], payable on [due date].
4. Despite repeated demands, Defendant has failed to pay the amount due.
5. As a result, Plaintiff suffered damages and is entitled to attorney’s fees and litigation costs.

PRAYER
WHEREFORE, premises considered, Plaintiff prays that judgment be rendered ordering Defendant to pay:

a) The principal amount of [amount];
b) Interest thereon at the rate of [__%] per annum from [date] until fully paid;
c) Attorney’s fees of [amount or reasonable sum]; and
d) Costs of suit.

Other reliefs just and equitable are likewise prayed for.

[Date and Place of Filing]

[Signature of Counsel]
[Name of Counsel]
[Roll of Attorney’s No.]
[IBP No., MCLE Compliance No.]
[Office Address & Contact Info]

8.2 Complaint for a Real Action (e.g., Recovery of Possession)

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
[Judicial Region]
Branch [___]
[Province where the property is located]

[Name of Plaintiff],
       Plaintiff,
  -versus-                                Civil Case No. _______

[Name of Defendant],
       Defendant.
  
x--------------------------------------------x

                              COMPLAINT

Plaintiff, by counsel, respectfully alleges:

1. Plaintiff is of legal age, [citizenship], residing at [address].
2. Defendant is of legal age, [citizenship], residing at [address].
3. Plaintiff is the registered owner of a parcel of land located at [address of the real property], covered by Transfer Certificate of Title (TCT) No. [___].
4. Sometime in [month/year], Defendant unlawfully entered and occupied a portion of the said property without Plaintiff’s knowledge and consent.
5. Despite demand, Defendant refuses to vacate the property and surrender possession to Plaintiff.

PRAYER
WHEREFORE, premises considered, Plaintiff prays for judgment:

a) Ordering Defendant to surrender possession of the subject property to Plaintiff;
b) Ordering Defendant to pay reasonable compensation for the use and occupation of the property from [date] until he vacates the same;
c) Awarding attorney’s fees and costs of suit.

Other reliefs just and equitable are likewise prayed for.

[Date and Place of Filing]

[Signature of Counsel]
[Name of Counsel]
[Roll of Attorney’s No.]
[IBP No., MCLE Compliance No.]
[Office Address & Contact Info]

9. Practical Tips

  1. Always Verify the Proper Classification: Before drafting your complaint, verify whether it is real or personal, local or transitory, and whether you must proceed under ordinary civil action or a special civil action.
  2. Check Venue Requirements: Failure to file in the proper venue may cause the case’s dismissal or transfer.
  3. Observe Jurisdictional Amounts: If it is a money claim below the jurisdictional threshold (e.g., within the jurisdiction of first-level courts, such as the Metropolitan Trial Court, Municipal Trial Court, Municipal Trial Court in Cities), it must be filed accordingly.
  4. Follow the Applicable Rule: If you are dealing with a special civil action, read and apply the specific rule (Rules 62-71). Certain special civil actions (e.g., certiorari under Rule 65) have specific requirements such as verifications, certifications against forum shopping, and time frames.
  5. Summons and Service: Determine the appropriate mode of service (personal, substituted, extraterritorial, or by publication) based on whether the action is in personam, in rem, or quasi in rem.
  6. Ethical Considerations: Maintain honesty in allegations, comply with the certification against forum shopping, and advise clients properly regarding the correct classification and venue.

10. Concluding Summary

Classification of actions in Philippine civil procedure—whether real or personal, in personam, in rem, or quasi in rem, local or transitory, or ordinary versus special civil actions—directly influences venue, jurisdictional requirements, service of summons, and overall strategy in litigation. Mastery of these distinctions ensures compliance with procedural rules, protection of clients’ rights, and upholding the ethical standards of the legal profession. Familiarity with the Rules of Court, relevant jurisprudence, and the interplay of Remedial Law with Legal Ethics is indispensable for any lawyer or law student aiming for excellence in litigation practice.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login