Execution of judgments for money | How a judgment is executed | Execution, Satisfaction, and Effect of Judgments (RULE 39) | CIVIL PROCEDURE

Below is a comprehensive, step-by-step discussion of execution of judgments for money under Rule 39 of the Rules of Court (Philippines), incorporating the relevant provisions, procedures, and significant points that every lawyer (and law student) should keep in mind. While the 2019 Amendments to the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure have streamlined some processes, the fundamental principles governing execution of money judgments remain substantially the same.

I. Overview of Execution of Judgments for Money

A “judgment for money” typically orders the losing party (the judgment obligor) to pay a sum of money to the prevailing party (the judgment obligee). The court’s judgment becomes enforceable once it attains finality or when execution pending appeal is properly granted.

Execution is generally the final stage of litigation—the method by which the successful party collects what is due under the judgment. In money judgments, the usual modes include:

  1. Voluntary payment by the obligor.
  2. Levy on personal or real property of the judgment obligor and subsequent public auction sale.
  3. Garnishment of the obligor’s debts or credits (including bank accounts) to third persons.

Statutory Reference: Sections 9 to 16, Rule 39 of the Rules of Court, as amended.

II. When Execution May Issue

  1. As a Matter of Right (Sec. 1, Rule 39)

    • A writ of execution may be issued as a matter of right if the judgment has already become final and executory (i.e., after the lapse of the reglementary period to appeal or, if appealed, after the judgment of the appellate court becomes final).

  2. Discretionary Execution / Execution Pending Appeal (Sec. 2, Rule 39)

    • In certain cases, the prevailing party may move for execution even before the judgment has attained finality. This requires showing “good reasons,” subject to the sound discretion of the court.
    • This is not the usual route for money judgments but remains an option if justified by extraordinary circumstances.

III. Issuance and Contents of the Writ of Execution

Once the judgment has become final or a motion for execution pending appeal is granted, the court will issue a writ of execution directed to the sheriff or a proper court officer. The writ states:

  1. The name of the court, the case number, and the title of the case.
  2. The dispositive portion of the judgment.
  3. A directive to the sheriff (or other proper officers) to enforce the judgment in accordance with the rules.

IV. Sheriff’s Actions to Enforce a Money Judgment

A. Demand for Immediate Payment (Sec. 9, Rule 39)

Upon receipt of the writ, the sheriff must:

  1. Demand from the judgment obligor the immediate payment of the full amount stated in the writ of execution, plus lawful fees and costs.
  2. If the judgment obligor pays voluntarily, the sheriff must turn over the amount to the judgment obligee or to the court.
  3. The sheriff must issue an official receipt for any amount received.

Importance:

  • This step ensures that the obligor is first given a chance to pay voluntarily before resorting to more intrusive methods like levy or garnishment.

B. Levy on Personal or Real Property (Secs. 9(b) and 12, Rule 39)

If the obligor fails to pay immediately (or within a reasonable time given by the sheriff), the sheriff proceeds to levy on the obligor’s properties, starting with personal properties (if sufficient), and then real properties, if needed.

  1. Personal Property First

    • The rule generally mandates that personal property be levied before real property, if the proceeds would suffice to satisfy the judgment.

  2. Manner of Levy

    • The sheriff must describe the property in detail in the levy, and serve notice to the obligor and any interested third parties if known.

  3. Exempt Properties

    • Certain properties are exempt from execution by law (e.g., family home, ordinary tools or implements necessary for livelihood, items of minimal value, etc.). The sheriff must take care not to levy on exempt properties.

C. Garnishment (Sec. 9(c), Rule 39)

Garnishment is used when the judgment obligor has credits, bank deposits, or other personal property in the possession or control of third persons.

  1. Notice of Garnishment

    • The sheriff serves a notice of garnishment on the person holding the obligor’s property (the “garnishee”), directing that no payment or transfer be made to the obligor.
    • The garnishee must then deliver such credits or property to the sheriff (or hold them subject to the court’s orders).

  2. Effect of Garnishment

    • Once garnished, the property is effectively in custodia legis, meaning it is under the control of the court.
    • The garnishee must comply; otherwise, the garnishee can be held liable for the value of the garnished property or for contempt.

D. Sale of Levied Property at Public Auction (Secs. 12-15, Rule 39)

If the obligor does not pay despite the sheriff’s demand, or if garnished accounts are insufficient, the sheriff will sell at public auction the personal or real property levied upon.

  1. Notice of Sale

    • A written notice of the time, date, and place of the auction sale must be given to the judgment obligor and posted in at least three public places for a required period (at least 3 days for personal property; at least 20 days for real property).
    • For real property, notice must also be published once a week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation if the assessed value is above a certain threshold set by the rules/law.

  2. Conduct of Public Auction

    • The property is sold to the highest bidder.
    • The sheriff then issues a certificate of sale to the purchaser.

  3. Disposition of Proceeds

    • The proceeds are used to satisfy the judgment debt, plus interests, costs, and sheriff’s fees.
    • If any surplus remains, it is returned to the obligor. If insufficient, the obligee can proceed against other properties of the obligor until the judgment is fully satisfied.

E. Redemption of Real Property (Sec. 27, Rule 39)

For real property sold on execution, the judgment obligor or his successor-in-interest has a one-year redemption period from the date of registration of the certificate of sale. Within that period:

  1. The judgment obligor (or successors) can redeem by paying the purchase price at the auction sale plus the required interest.
  2. If redeemed, the sheriff (or purchaser) issues a certificate of redemption, and the title reverts to the judgment obligor.
  3. If there is no redemption within one year, the sale becomes absolute, and the purchaser is entitled to a final deed of sale and eventually the consolidation of title in his or her name.

V. Special Situations and Key Points

  1. Partial Satisfaction

    • If partial payment is made (voluntarily or through levy/garnishment) and it does not fully cover the judgment, the sheriff continues to enforce the writ until the judgment is fully satisfied or there are no more leviable assets.

  2. Third-Party Claims (Sec. 16, Rule 39)

    • If a third person (not the obligor) claims title or right to possession of the levied property, the third person files an affidavit of ownership or right of possession.
    • The sheriff does not automatically stop the levy; the claimant may file a separate action to vindicate ownership or may post a bond to release the property from execution.
    • The court will determine in an appropriate proceeding who has superior rights over the property.

  3. Exemptions from Execution (Sec. 13, Rule 39 & relevant statutes)

    • Examples:
      • Family home (subject to certain conditions in the Family Code and relevant laws).
      • Tools or implements used in trade or profession.
      • Articles of minimal value, personal necessities, or government-owned properties not used for proprietary functions.
    • The sheriff must carefully determine which properties are exempt.

  4. Satisfaction of Judgment (Sec. 44, Rule 39)

    • Once the judgment award is fully paid, the judgment obligee must execute a satisfaction of judgment (acknowledgment) which should be filed with the court.

  5. Sheriff’s Return

    • After enforcing the writ (whether fully satisfied or not), the sheriff must make a return to the court detailing the manner of enforcement and the amount paid or collected.

  6. Motion to Quash or Recall Writ

    • If there are valid grounds (e.g., the judgment was already satisfied, the property is exempt, there are procedural defects), the obligor may move to quash or recall the writ of execution.
    • The court will hear and resolve such a motion.

VI. Common Practical Considerations

  1. Prioritization of Properties

    • Practitioners often coordinate with the sheriff to locate the most easily leviable properties (e.g., bank accounts, vehicles, machinery) for swift satisfaction.

  2. Bank Garnishment

    • Garnishment of bank accounts is a frequent method. Notice is served on the bank, freezing the account up to the judgment amount.
    • Bank secrecy laws do not prohibit garnishment of a known account; however, unknown or undisclosed accounts remain protected in the absence of a court order identifying them.

  3. Interest Computations

    • Ensure correct interest computation per the judgment (legal interest or stipulated interest).
    • Include legal interest on judgments from finality until satisfaction (if so provided by law or the judgment).

  4. Bond in Case of Indemnity

    • If the sheriff is uncertain as to the ownership of the property or receives a third-party claim, the successful party may post an indemnity bond to allow the sale to proceed, subject to the risk that the third party might later prevail in a separate action.

  5. Coordinating with Local Rules

    • Some localities require additional documentation or fees, or coordinate with particular offices for the conduct of public auctions, especially for real properties.

  6. Ethical Conduct

    • Lawyers must deal with the sheriff and the parties in good faith, refrain from misrepresenting property ownership, or from pressuring the sheriff to ignore procedural safeguards.
    • Avoid conflict of interest, e.g., representing both the buyer at the auction and the party with the right to redeem.

VII. Relevant Legal Forms

While this outline focuses on substantive and procedural rules, here is a short guide on the typical forms involved:

  1. Motion for Issuance of Writ of Execution

    • Filed by the prevailing party, stating that judgment is final and executory (or citing grounds for discretionary execution).

  2. Writ of Execution (issued by the court)

    • Formal command to the sheriff to enforce the judgment.

  3. Notice of Garnishment (sheriff’s document)

    • Served on the garnishee, stating the amount and ordering the garnishee to hold or deliver the obligor’s funds/properties.

  4. Notice of Levy and Notice of Sale

    • Detailed descriptions of the properties to be levied or sold, plus the time, date, and venue of auction.

  5. Certificate of Sale

    • Issued to the purchaser of levied property after a public auction.

  6. Certificate of Redemption

    • Issued when the obligor redeems real property within the redemption period.

  7. Return of Writ (Sheriff’s Return)

    • Reports how the writ was executed and the outcome.

VIII. Conclusion

Rule 39 of the Rules of Court provides a clear, structured approach for executing money judgments in the Philippines. The key points to remember include:

  • Demand for immediate payment before levy or garnishment.
  • Levy and garnishment as primary tools when the obligor refuses or fails to pay.
  • Compliance with notice requirements in cases of public auction.
  • Observance of redemption periods for real property.
  • Respect for third-party claims and exemptions from execution.
  • Accuracy in accounting, interest calculation, and ensuring satisfaction once the judgment is paid.

Proper execution ensures that the successful party can collect what is rightfully due while protecting the rights of the obligor and any third persons. Lawyers must maintain ethical standards, follow the procedural prerequisites scrupulously, and ensure each step in the process—from obtaining the writ to delivering the sheriff’s return—is consistent with the Rules of Court and jurisprudential guidelines.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login