Filing of responsive pleadings (RULE 11) | Pleadings | CIVIL PROCEDURE

A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO THE FILING OF RESPONSIVE PLEADINGS (RULE 11, PHILIPPINE RULES OF COURT)

Disclaimer: The following discussion is a general guide based on the Philippine Rules of Civil Procedure (as amended). It does not constitute legal advice. Always consult the updated text of the Rules of Court and relevant jurisprudence for precise application.

I. OVERVIEW

In Philippine civil litigation, Rule 11 of the Rules of Court governs the filing of responsive pleadings, chiefly the filing of an Answer to a Complaint or other initiatory pleading. Alongside the rest of the Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 11 was substantially revised in the 2019 Amendments to the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure.

Responsive pleadings are crucial because they join the issues in a case, enabling the parties to present their claims and defenses. Failure to file a timely and proper responsive pleading can lead to default under Rule 9 and waiver of defenses under certain circumstances.

Below is a methodical breakdown of the critical provisions and key points under Rule 11 and related rules.

II. TIME TO FILE RESPONSIVE PLEADINGS

A. Time to File an Answer (Section 1, Rule 11)

  1. General Rule (Defendant in Ordinary Civil Actions)

    • A defendant is required to file an Answer within 30 calendar days from service of summons and a copy of the Complaint.
    • The counting of the 30 calendar days starts the day after the defendant is validly served with summons.

  2. Defendants Served Outside the Philippines (Extraterritorial Service)

    • Under Rule 14, if summons is served outside the Philippines, the defendant generally has 60 calendar days from receipt of summons and the Complaint to file an Answer.

  3. Republic of the Philippines or Its Agencies

    • When the defendant is the Republic (or any of its agencies/instrumentalities), it typically has 60 calendar days from receipt of summons to file an Answer, unless a specific law or special rule provides otherwise.

  4. Effect of Certain Motions on the Period to Answer

    • If the defendant files a Motion for Bill of Particulars, a Motion to Dismiss, or similar preliminary motion, and the motion is denied, the defendant must file the Answer within the balance of the period to which they were entitled at the time the motion was filed, but not less than 5 calendar days from the defendant’s receipt of notice of denial.
    • If the motion is granted in part (e.g., Bill of Particulars), the defendant has the remaining period to answer, counted from service of the more definite Complaint, but not less than 5 calendar days.

B. Time to File an Answer to an Amended Complaint (Section 2, Rule 11)

  • When the Amended Complaint is Filed as a Matter of Right
    If the plaintiff amends the Complaint before an Answer has been served (i.e., an amendment as a matter of right under Rule 10), the defendant must file a responsive pleading within 30 calendar days from service of the amended pleading.

  • When the Amended Complaint is Filed by Leave of Court
    If the amendment is made after the Answer is already filed or requires leave of court (with substantial or material amendments), the defendant must file an Answer within 15 calendar days from receipt of the order admitting the amended pleading, unless the court provides a longer or shorter period for justifiable reasons.

C. Time to File an Answer to a Counterclaim or Cross-Claim (Section 4, Rule 11)

  • A counterclaim or cross-claim is typically included in the defendant’s Answer. The opposing party who is served with a counterclaim or cross-claim must file an Answer within 20 calendar days from service (unless the court, for compelling reasons, allows a different period).

D. Time to File an Answer to a Third- or Fourth-Party Complaint (Section 5, Rule 11)

  • A third-party defendant (i.e., a person brought into the case by the original defendant to answer for all or part of the plaintiff’s claim) must file an Answer within 30 calendar days from service of summons and the third-party Complaint.
  • If there is a fourth-party complaint (or further), the same rules apply, with the period also being 30 calendar days from service of summons.

III. EXTENSIONS OF TIME TO FILE AN ANSWER

Under the 2019 Amendments, the Rules have become stricter in granting extensions. Courts are discouraged from granting pro forma or repeated motions for extension.

  1. First Extension

    • A litigant may ask for an extension of up to 30 days to file an Answer, subject to the court’s discretion, and only upon a showing of meritorious reasons.
    • Such motion must be filed before the expiration of the original period to file an Answer (i.e., before the 30-day period lapses).

  2. Subsequent Extensions

    • As a rule, only one extension may be granted by the court, and no further extensions shall be allowed except for highly meritorious or exceptional reasons.

  3. Prohibition on Stipulated Extensions

    • Parties cannot validly stipulate among themselves a longer period for the Answer beyond what the court allows. The extension to file an Answer is always subject to court approval.

IV. CONSEQUENCES OF FAILURE TO FILE AN ANSWER

If the defendant (or any party required to answer a claim against them) fails to file an Answer within the prescribed period (or the period validly extended by the court), the claiming party may proceed under Rule 9 (Default). Key points:

  1. Declaration of Default

    • Upon motion of the claimant, the court may declare the defending party in default if it determines that the failure to answer is unjustified.
    • Once declared in default, the defendant loses standing to present defenses and is generally not entitled to notice of subsequent proceedings (with limited exceptions).

  2. Relief from Order of Default

    • The defending party may seek relief from default (by motion under oath) before judgment is rendered, showing a valid cause (fraud, accident, mistake, or excusable negligence) and a meritorious defense.
    • After judgment, the party declared in default may file the usual remedies such as a motion for new trial, appeal, or petition for relief from judgment under Rule 38, if grounds exist.

V. REPLY (Rule 6 vs. Rule 11 Cross-Reference)

Under the 2019 Amendments, the filing of a Reply (to address new matters or averments in the Answer) is not generally mandatory, unless the court orders or the defending party raises matters that the plaintiff must specifically deny or refute:

  • If a Reply is warranted, it must be filed within 15 calendar days from service of the Answer (or other responsive pleading).
  • Failure to reply does not automatically deem the new allegations in the Answer as admitted (unlike before). However, it may still have strategic implications if the Answer raises certain defenses that the plaintiff does not contest or clarify in a Reply.

VI. SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS

  1. Affirmative Defenses

    • While Rule 8, Section 5 and Rule 9, Section 1 govern affirmative defenses, a party must generally raise all affirmative defenses in the Answer, including those relating to jurisdiction, prescription, lack of cause of action, improper venue, and so on.
    • If any of these defenses are not raised in the Answer (or in a motion to dismiss filed prior to the Answer), they may be deemed waived (subject to exceptions, like lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter).

  2. Verification and Certification of Non-Forum Shopping

    • Every initiatory pleading and certain responsive pleadings with a counterclaim or cross-claim must contain a verification and a certification against forum shopping under Rule 7. Non-compliance can cause the pleading to be treated as unsigned or a mere scrap of paper.

  3. Motions Attacking the Pleadings

    • A party can file a Motion to Dismiss (limited grounds under the 2019 Amendments) or a Motion for Bill of Particulars before filing an Answer.
    • If these motions are denied, the period to answer resumes—the defendant must be vigilant about the remaining days to file the Answer. The rules guarantee at least 5 calendar days from notice of denial.

  4. Third-Party (and Further) Complaints

    • A defendant who believes that another person (the third-party defendant) is liable for all or part of the claim against him may file a third-party complaint under Rule 6, Section 11. In turn, that third-party defendant has to file an Answer under the same time rules as for an original complaint (30 calendar days).

  5. Judicial Affidavit Rule and Case Management

    • Under the Revised Guidelines on Continuous Trial and the Judicial Affidavit Rule, litigants must also be mindful of the early submission of witness affidavits and documentary evidence. While not strictly part of Rule 11, these rules interact with the timeline for pleadings and set the pace for pre-trial and trial.

VII. PRACTICAL TIPS AND BEST PRACTICES

  1. Calendar All Deadlines Strictly

    • The counting of days under the 2019 Amendments is in calendar days, not working days. Plan and file promptly.

  2. Move for Extension Early, If Needed

    • If you cannot file the Answer on time, file a motion for extension before the original period lapses, stating meritorious reasons.

  3. Raise All Defenses

    • Include all possible defenses in the Answer (or via a timely motion to dismiss, if the ground is allowed). The stricter “omnibus motion rule” and the prohibition on piecemeal defenses can bar defenses not raised initially.

  4. Verify and Attach the Certification Against Forum Shopping

    • If your Answer contains a counterclaim that is in the nature of an initiatory pleading (e.g., a permissive counterclaim), ensure it has the verification and certification or it may be dismissed.

  5. Pay Attention to Amended Complaints

    • If the plaintiff files an amended complaint, carefully check if it’s amendment as a matter of right or by leave of court. The applicable answer period (30 or 15 days) depends on this distinction, and the court might also fix a different period.

  6. Coordinate with Co-Defendants

    • If you are facing cross-claims or counterclaims from co-defendants, watch the separate timeline (20 days) for filing your Answer to those.

  7. Prevent Default

    • If you miss the deadline to answer, you risk default. Seek prompt legal remedies or file your Answer as soon as possible if the delay is curable.

VIII. CONCLUSION

Filing responsive pleadings under Rule 11 is a critical procedural stage in Philippine civil litigation. Strict compliance with the prescribed periods, content requirements, and formats is crucial to avoid waiving defenses or falling into default.

The 2019 Amendments have tightened timelines and discouraged undue delays, reflecting the Supreme Court’s aim for speedier and more efficient litigation. Every litigator must be meticulous in computing deadlines, raising all possible defenses at the earliest opportunity, and complying with verification and certification requirements.

By mastering Rule 11, litigants safeguard their right to be heard and defend claims effectively in Philippine courts.

Key References:

  • 2019 Revised Rules of Civil Procedure
  • Rule 11, Rules of Court
  • Rule 9 (Default); Rule 10 (Amended Pleadings); Rule 14 (Summons)
  • Relevant Supreme Court Circulars (e.g., Continuous Trial Guidelines)
  • Jurisprudence on Motions to Dismiss, Default, Affirmative Defenses, etc.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login