Petition for Allowance of Will and for Letters of Administration with Will Annexed (Rules 75-79) | Testate | Judicial | Settlement of Estate of Deceased Persons | SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS

Below is a comprehensive, methodical discussion of the judicial settlement of a testate estate in the Philippines under Rules 75 to 79 of the Rules of Court, focusing specifically on the petition for allowance (probate) of the will and for the issuance of Letters of Administration with the Will Annexed. This includes doctrinal highlights, procedural requirements, and pertinent considerations under Philippine law.

I. OVERVIEW: TESTATE ESTATE SETTLEMENT

When a person dies leaving a last will and testament (testate), the law provides specific procedures to give effect to the decedent’s wishes. Judicial settlement of a testate estate involves:

  1. Probate (Allowance) of the Will – A court proceeding to ascertain the will’s validity (i.e., due execution, the testamentary capacity of the testator, freedom from vitiated consent, compliance with formal requirements).
  2. Issuance of Letters Testamentary – If an executor is named in the will and is competent, willing, and qualified to serve.
  3. Issuance of Letters of Administration with the Will Annexed – If no executor is named in the will, or the named executor is deceased, incapacitated, or otherwise unwilling or unsuitable to serve.

The relevant statutory basis is primarily Rules 75 to 79 of the Revised Rules of Court of the Philippines. Supplementary principles may be found in the Civil Code and jurisprudential rulings on probate, wills, and succession.

II. KEY LEGAL PROVISIONS AND PRINCIPLES

A. Rule 75: Production of Will; Allowance of Will Necessary

  1. Delivery of Will (Sec. 1)

    • The custodian of a will must deliver it to the court having jurisdiction or to the executor named in the will within 20 days after learning of the testator’s death.
    • Failure to deliver may subject the custodian to damages.

  2. Necessity of Probate (Sec. 2)

    • No will passes either real or personal property unless it is duly proved (probated) and allowed by a proper court.
    • Probate is mandatory for a will’s dispositions to have legal effect on the distribution of the estate.

  3. Who May Petition for Probate (Sec. 3)

    • Any executor, devisee, legatee, or other interested person may petition the court to allow the will.

  4. Venue (Sec. 1, Rule 73 and Sec. 1, Rule 75)

    • If the decedent was a resident of the Philippines, file the petition in the Regional Trial Court of the province (or city) where the deceased resided at the time of death.
    • If the decedent was a non-resident, file it in any province (or city) where the decedent had estate, and the petitioning court will have jurisdiction over all assets in the Philippines.

B. Rule 76: Allowance or Disallowance of Will

  1. Contents of the Petition (Sec. 1)
    The petition must state:

    • The jurisdictional facts (e.g., residence of decedent, place of death).
    • The names, ages, and residences of the heirs, legatees, devisees, and executor(s) named in the will.
    • The probable value and character of the property.
    • The name of the person for whom letters are prayed (if any).
    • If the will has not been delivered, the petitioner must state the reason(s).

  2. Notice of Hearing (Sec. 3)

    • The court will fix a time and place for proving the will.
    • Publication of the notice (with the full text of the Order or the gist thereof) in a newspaper of general circulation once a week for 3 consecutive weeks is required, along with personal notice to interested parties in the Philippines.
    • Failure to provide proper notice invalidates the probate proceeding.

  3. Opposition to Probate

    • Any person interested may file a written opposition contesting the allowance of the will, usually citing grounds such as:
      • Lack of testamentary capacity (testator was of unsound mind or legally incapacitated at execution).
      • Undue influence, fraud, or mistake.
      • Non-compliance with the formal requisites (e.g., improper attestation, signature, or witnesses).
    • The court will conduct a trial on these issues.

  4. Allowance or Disallowance (Sec. 9)

    • After hearing and evidence, if the court is satisfied the will was duly executed and the testator had testamentary capacity, it will allow the will.
    • If the will does not conform to the formalities or if legal infirmities exist, the court disallows the will.

  5. Effects of Probate

    • Once the will is allowed, its dispositive provisions become the law of the case for the distribution of the estate, subject to mandatory legitimes and other rules on forced heirship under the Civil Code.
    • The order allowing a will is generally binding (res judicata) upon all persons unless set aside on appeal or in a proper action under exceptional circumstances.

C. Rule 77: Probate of Holographic Will; Republication and Revival

While Rule 77 also covers certain aspects of reprobate (probate of wills proved in foreign countries) and revival of revoked wills, the main takeaway is:

  • Holographic Will – Must also be probated in court. A holographic will is entirely handwritten by the testator and must be dated and signed. The same requirement of probate, notice, publication, and hearing applies.

D. Rule 78: Letters Testamentary and of Administration

  1. Who Shall Be Appointed Executor or Administrator?

    • If the will names an executor, and that executor is competent, the court will issue Letters Testamentary to that person.
    • If the named executor fails to qualify or is disqualified (e.g., convicted of a crime involving moral turpitude, unsound mind) or is unwilling to act, the court will issue Letters of Administration with the Will Annexed to a qualified person.

  2. Qualification and Bond

    • Executors or administrators must post a bond unless the testator expressly provides that no bond is required, and the court sees no necessity for it.
    • The bond ensures faithful performance of duties and indemnifies interested parties from malfeasance or negligence.

  3. Order of Preference

    • When selecting an administrator with will annexed, the court generally follows an order of preference:
      1. Surviving spouse.
      2. Next of kin.
      3. Principal legatee or devisee named in the will.
      4. Other legally competent persons.
    • The preference is subject to the court’s discretion and the best interest of the estate.

E. Rule 79: Opposing Issuance of Letters Testamentary; Petition and Contest for Letters of Administration

  1. Grounds to Oppose an Executor’s Issuance of Letters

    • Minority (below 18 years old).
    • Unsound mind.
    • Conviction of an offense involving moral turpitude.
    • Unfitness or incompetence to execute duties of the trust.
    • Conflict of interest or any valid legal ground that might impede faithful performance.

  2. Procedure

    • Opposition is filed during the hearing for issuance of letters.
    • An evidentiary hearing may ensue, after which the court decides if the named executor or proposed administrator should be appointed.

III. PETITION FOR ALLOWANCE OF WILL AND FOR LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION WITH WILL ANNEXED

A. When to File Such a Petition

  • No Qualified Executor: When the will either does not name an executor or when the named executor:

    1. Is deceased;
    2. Refuses to accept the trust;
    3. Is legally disqualified due to unsoundness of mind, conviction of a crime, etc.;
    4. Is otherwise unsuitable (e.g., conflict of interest, proven mismanagement, or hostility to the estate’s best interests).

  • Simultaneous Filing: The petition can simultaneously pray for the allowance (probate) of the will and the appointment of an administrator with the will annexed in the event the named executor cannot serve.

B. Contents of the Petition (Typical Form Requirements)

  1. Caption: Indicate the court (Regional Trial Court), branch, and the title of the proceeding (e.g., “In re: Petition for the Probate of the Will of [Name of Decedent] and for Issuance of Letters of Administration with the Will Annexed”).
  2. Allegations:
    • The decedent’s name, place of residence, and date of death.
    • The fact that the decedent left a will (attach a copy if available).
    • Names, ages, and addresses of the heirs, legatees, devisees, and persons interested in the estate.
    • The probable value of the real and personal estate.
    • The reasons the named executor (if any) cannot serve (or that there is no named executor).
    • A prayer that the will be allowed (admitted to probate) and that Letters of Administration with the Will Annexed be issued to the petitioner or another qualified person.
  3. Verification: The petition must be verified by the petitioner.
  4. Attachments: Certified true copies of the Death Certificate (if available), the will, and other relevant documents.

C. Procedural Steps

  1. Filing the Petition:

    • Pay the required docket fees.
    • Ensure the petition is filed before the court of proper jurisdiction and venue.

  2. Court Order Setting Hearing:

    • The court issues an Order stating the date, time, and place of hearing, directing publication and personal notice to all interested parties.

  3. Publication and Service of Notice:

    • Published once a week for three (3) consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the province or city where the proceeding is pending.
    • Personal notice to heirs, devisees, legatees, and known creditors.

  4. Opposition (if any):

    • Interested parties may file a written opposition.
    • If no opposition is filed, or if opposition is overruled, the court proceeds with the evidence for probate.

  5. Presentation of Evidence:

    • Due execution and testamentary capacity are proved usually by at least one of the subscribing witnesses (or, if they are unavailable, other evidence showing authenticity and due execution).
    • If holographic, at least three (3) witnesses who can identify the testator’s handwriting and signature or other conclusive evidence.

  6. Court Determination:

    • If satisfied that the will was duly executed and the testator was of sound mind, the court issues a decree allowing the will.
    • The court then passes upon the request for appointment of an administrator with the will annexed.

  7. Issuance of Letters of Administration with the Will Annexed:

    • The appointed administrator files a bond, takes an oath, and letters are issued, conferring authority to administer the estate according to the will.

  8. Inventory and Further Proceedings:

    • The administrator must submit an inventory within three (3) months (or as directed by the court) and will then proceed with estate administration under the supervision of the probate court until final distribution.

IV. SALIENT POINTS AND PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS

  1. Jurisdiction:

    • Strictly followed based on the decedent’s last residence or location of the estate if non-resident.
    • The court that first assumes jurisdiction has primary control over the proceedings.

  2. Notice and Publication:

    • Essential for due process and to vest the court with authority to probate the will. Failure to publish or provide notice as required can nullify the proceeding.

  3. Burden of Proof:

    • The proponent (the one petitioning for probate) must prove due execution and testamentary capacity.
    • The contestant (opponent) must present credible evidence on any alleged defects (e.g., fraud, undue influence, insane delusion, forced execution).

  4. Res Judicata Effect of Probate:

    • A final order allowing the will is binding on all parties who participated or were given notice, subject to appeal or extraordinary remedies.

  5. Administrator’s Duties and Limitations:

    • The administrator with the will annexed essentially performs the same functions as an executor—collecting assets, paying debts, managing the estate, and distributing the net residue in accordance with the will, subject to court approval.
    • Must render accounts to the court periodically.

  6. Foreign Wills (Rule 77)**:

    • If the will was already probated in a foreign country, it can be re-probated in the Philippines if it affects local property. The petitioner must prove compliance with foreign law in the execution of the will, plus compliance with Philippine rules for reprobate.

  7. Holographic Wills:

    • Must be entirely written, dated, and signed by the testator. No witnesses required at the time of execution, but the same probate procedure is required with the presentation of handwriting experts or credible witnesses attesting to the authenticity of the handwriting.

  8. Substantive Rules on Succession:

    • Even if the will is allowed, the distribution of the estate must respect mandatory legitimes of compulsory heirs under the Civil Code (e.g., forced shares of the surviving spouse, legitimate children).
    • The probate court, as a rule, only determines the extrinsic validity of the will. Issues regarding intrinsic validity (e.g., whether certain devises violate legitimes) are typically tackled after the will’s allowance, unless the invalidity is apparent on the face of the will.

V. SAMPLE OUTLINE: PETITION FOR ALLOWANCE OF WILL AND FOR LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION WITH WILL ANNEXED

Below is a brief, generic outline often followed in drafting such a petition:

  1. Caption and Title:

    Republic of the Philippines
    Regional Trial Court
    [Judicial Region], Branch [#]
    [City/Province]

    In the Matter of the Petition for the Allowance of the Will of [Name of Decedent] and for Issuance of Letters of Administration with the Will Annexed,
    Sp. Proc. No. [___]

    Petitioner,

  2. Prefatory Allegations:

    • Allegation of petitioner’s legal capacity and interest.
    • Statement of decedent’s name, residence, and date of death.

  3. Allegation of the Existence of the Will:

    • How the will came into the custody of the petitioner or that the will is in the court’s custody.
    • That the will was executed in accordance with law, or basis for believing so.

  4. Names and Addresses of Heirs, Devisees, Legatees:

    • Essential to serve notice and fix jurisdiction.

  5. Statement Regarding Executor:

    • If the named executor is unwilling, deceased, or incompetent to serve.
    • Petitioner’s fitness to be appointed, or the suggested administrator with the will annexed.

  6. Reliefs and Prayer:

    • That the will be allowed (admitted to probate).
    • That after due hearing, Letters of Administration with the Will Annexed be issued to the petitioner (or another qualified person).

  7. Verification and Certification Against Forum Shopping.

VI. CONCLUSION

A Petition for Allowance of a Will and for Letters of Administration with the Will Annexed is the procedural avenue when a decedent leaves a will but either fails to designate an executor or the named executor is unqualified, unable, or unwilling to serve. The key steps involve:

  1. Filing and docketing the petition in the proper Regional Trial Court;
  2. Notifying interested parties (through publication and personal service);
  3. Proving due execution and testamentary capacity in a probate hearing;
  4. Securing court approval of the will; and
  5. Obtaining Letters of Administration with the Will Annexed for the qualified administrator to lawfully settle and distribute the estate according to the testator’s wishes, subject to Philippine laws on compulsory heirs and legitimes.

Observing all procedural requisites and ensuring compliance with the substantive rules on wills and succession is imperative. The probate court’s final order allowing the will confers validity upon the testator’s dispositions, and the appointed administrator then administers the estate until complete distribution under court supervision.

Disclaimer: This discussion is a general overview and is not a substitute for personalized legal advice. Specific cases may vary depending on factual circumstances, local rules, and emerging jurisprudence. Always consult the applicable laws, rules of court, and a legal professional for individual concerns.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login