Control | Perfection of Security Interest | R.A. No. 11057 or the Personal Property Security Act | SECURED TRANSACTIONS

Topic: Control in the Perfection of Security Interests under the Personal Property Security Act (R.A. No. 11057)

---

I. Overview of R.A. No. 11057 - The Personal Property Security Act

R.A. No. 11057, also known as the Personal Property Security Act (PPSA), was enacted in the Philippines to modernize the country's framework for securing transactions with personal property as collateral. The Act facilitates the use of movable assets as collateral, making it easier for businesses, especially SMEs, to access credit. The Act covers the perfection, priority, and enforcement of security interests over personal property.

Perfection of a security interest is critical under R.A. No. 11057 because it establishes the secured party’s rights against third parties. Among the methods of perfection, control is a specific method applicable to certain types of collateral, such as deposit accounts, electronic securities, and investment properties. Control as a method of perfection gives priority to the secured party who has control over the collateral.

---

II. Perfection of Security Interests by Control

The concept of "control" under the PPSA is a unique way to perfect a security interest that confers special rights and advantages to the secured party. Perfection by control is typically associated with certain types of intangible or electronic collateral where the secured party must have a level of dominion or exclusive access over the property.

A. Definition of Control

Under the PPSA, a secured party has "control" over specific types of collateral when they have exclusive authority to direct the disposition of the collateral or otherwise restrict the debtor’s ability to deal with it without the secured party’s consent. Control signifies an elevated level of security for the secured party, providing them with a superior right to the collateral, especially in cases of conflicting claims.

B. Types of Collateral Perfection by Control Applies To

The PPSA explicitly provides that control as a method of perfection applies to the following types of collateral:

1. Deposit Accounts
2. Investment Property (e.g., stocks, bonds, and other financial instruments)
3. Electronic Securities and Similar Intangible Assets

Each type has specific provisions under which a security interest may be perfected by control.

---

III. Methods and Requirements for Establishing Control

The PPSA and its Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) provide detailed guidelines on how control over various types of collateral can be established.

A. Control over Deposit Accounts

To perfect a security interest in a deposit account by control, the secured party must satisfy one of the following conditions:

1. Control Agreement: The debtor, the secured party, and the depository bank enter into an agreement where the bank agrees to follow the instructions of the secured party regarding the disposition of funds in the account without further consent from the debtor.

2. Secured Party as the Account Holder: The secured party is listed as the owner of the deposit account, giving them inherent authority over the account.

3. Bank as the Secured Party: If the depository bank is also the secured party, control is established by default since the bank inherently has authority over the account.

These arrangements provide the secured party with direct or indirect control over the deposit account, effectively allowing them to restrict the debtor’s access or use of the account funds.

B. Control over Investment Property

A security interest in investment property can be perfected by control if:

1. Securities Account Control Agreement: Similar to deposit accounts, a tripartite agreement is entered into by the debtor, secured party, and securities intermediary (broker or depository), allowing the secured party to direct the securities intermediary regarding the disposition of the securities without requiring further debtor consent.

2. Delivery of Certificated Securities: If the investment property consists of certificated securities, control can be achieved by physically delivering the certificate to the secured party with proper endorsement or transfer.

3. Registration in the Name of the Secured Party: The security interest can also be perfected by control if the investment property (such as shares or bonds) is registered in the name of the secured party, effectively transferring authority over the investment.

C. Control over Electronic Securities and Similar Intangibles

For electronic securities and other intangible assets, perfection by control typically involves the secured party obtaining the exclusive right to instruct or control the disposition of the securities. This can often be arranged through agreements with entities that hold or manage the electronic records, similar to control agreements with depositories or intermediaries in cases of investment property.

---

IV. Legal Effects and Priority of Control in Security Interests

Perfecting a security interest by control gives the secured party significant advantages over other creditors:

1. Priority: A security interest perfected by control has priority over security interests perfected by other methods, such as registration. This priority ensures that the secured party with control is first in line to claim the collateral in the event of debtor default or bankruptcy.

2. Protection against Competing Claims: Since the PPSA provides that control gives the secured party priority, other creditors or parties with competing claims are subordinate to the interest of the party with control, provided the control agreement or arrangement is valid and enforceable.

3. Enhanced Enforcement Rights: By having control, a secured party can more readily enforce their rights in case of default, as they often have direct access or authority to dispose of the collateral without needing to take further legal action.

---

V. Practical Considerations for Secured Parties and Debtors

A. Advantages for Secured Parties

For lenders or creditors, perfecting by control is a preferred method because it provides a stronger security position. They gain prioritized access to the collateral, which is essential in the case of insolvency or default. It also simplifies enforcement since control allows for direct management or liquidation of the collateral.

B. Implications for Debtors

While control agreements secure financing by offering lenders added protection, they limit the debtor’s access to, or use of, the collateral. Debtors need to consider the impact on liquidity, as the secured party’s control may restrict their ability to manage or utilize assets, especially if these assets are essential to their business operations.

C. Control Agreements as Binding Instruments

Since control agreements play a crucial role in establishing control, they must be crafted with legal precision. The agreement should clearly outline the rights and obligations of all parties involved, including any limitations on the debtor’s access to the collateral, specific powers of the secured party, and conditions for enforcement.

---

VI. Conclusion

The concept of control in the perfection of security interests under R.A. No. 11057 offers a robust mechanism for securing transactions involving certain types of personal property. By achieving control, secured parties can ensure that their interests take precedence over others, providing them with a more enforceable claim in cases of debtor default. Control agreements are central to this process, necessitating careful legal drafting to ensure they meet statutory requirements and effectively secure the creditor's interest. For both creditors and debtors, understanding the implications of control is essential for navigating the secured transactions landscape under the Personal Property Security Act.

Possession | Perfection of Security Interest | R.A. No. 11057 or the Personal Property Security Act | SECURED TRANSACTIONS

Perfection of Security Interest by Possession under R.A. No. 11057 (Personal Property Security Act)

The Personal Property Security Act, or Republic Act No. 11057 (R.A. No. 11057), is a landmark Philippine law designed to facilitate secured transactions involving personal property. One of the crucial aspects of the Act is the perfection of security interests in personal property. Under this law, perfection of a security interest can be achieved through several methods, including by possession of the collateral. Here is a detailed analysis of the topic based on the provisions of the law and pertinent considerations in practice.

1. Definition and Purpose of Perfection

Perfection of a security interest is a process that establishes the secured party’s claim or right in the collateral against third parties, making it enforceable against other creditors or claimants. This process serves to publicize the secured party’s interest, creating priority over other claims or liens on the same collateral.

In the context of R.A. No. 11057, perfection can be achieved through various methods, including possession, registration, or control, depending on the type of collateral involved. For tangible movable property, possession is one method to perfect the security interest, particularly when the property does not have a readily available registration system or where possession serves as effective notice.

2. Perfection by Possession under R.A. No. 11057

Section 13 of R.A. No. 11057 outlines perfection of a security interest by possession, specifically for security interests in tangible movable property. Key points regarding perfection by possession are as follows:

• Applicable Collateral: Perfection by possession is typically relevant for tangible personal property, such as machinery, equipment, inventory, and other physical assets.

• Role of the Secured Party: To perfect the security interest through possession, the secured party or a designated third party must physically possess the collateral. This possession acts as public notice to third parties, signaling that a security interest exists on the property.

• Effect of Possession: Once the secured party has possession of the collateral, the security interest is perfected, which means the secured party’s interest in the collateral is enforceable against third parties, including other creditors and potential buyers of the collateral.

• Third-Party Possession: R.A. No. 11057 allows the secured party to designate an agent or trustee to possess the collateral on its behalf. However, the designated third party cannot be the debtor, as possession by the debtor would undermine the purpose of notifying third parties of the secured party’s interest.

3. Advantages of Perfection by Possession

Perfection by possession provides several practical benefits, including:

• Priority: A perfected security interest by possession generally has priority over subsequent interests or claims in the collateral by other creditors.

• Immediate Perfection: Unlike registration, which may take time, perfection by possession is effective immediately upon taking possession of the collateral, assuming the other requirements of R.A. No. 11057 are satisfied.

• Notice: Physical possession serves as a strong form of notice to third parties, particularly if the collateral does not have an electronic or public registration system, as is often the case with personal property.

4. Requirements and Limitations

• Continuous Possession: For perfection by possession to remain effective, the secured party or its agent must maintain continuous possession of the collateral. Loss of possession may jeopardize the perfected status of the security interest, potentially reducing the secured party’s priority.

• Debtor’s Inability to Possess: As noted, the debtor cannot serve as the custodian or possessor of the collateral for perfection purposes. If the debtor retains possession, the security interest cannot be considered perfected through this method.

• Transferability of Possession: The secured party may transfer possession to a third party without impairing the perfected security interest, provided that the transfer complies with the Act’s requirements.

5. Legal Effects of Perfection by Possession

• Enforceability Against Third Parties: A security interest perfected by possession is enforceable against third parties, including subsequent purchasers, other creditors, and lienholders. This is particularly significant in insolvency scenarios, where the perfected interest through possession gives the secured party priority over unsecured creditors in the distribution of assets.

• Retention of Possession in Default Situations: Upon the debtor’s default, the secured party with perfected possession may retain or dispose of the collateral in accordance with the terms of the security agreement and the provisions of R.A. No. 11057.

6. Impact of Perfection by Possession on Priority Rules

Under R.A. No. 11057, security interests perfected by possession are subject to the Act’s priority rules. Typically, security interests perfected by possession rank higher than unperfected interests. However, priority between competing perfected interests may depend on the timing of perfection and other specific provisions of the Act.

7. Practical Considerations

• Costs and Logistics: Perfection by possession may require the secured party to bear the costs associated with storing, safeguarding, and insuring the collateral. Additionally, the logistics of maintaining continuous possession can pose challenges, especially if the collateral is large or perishable.

• Alternative Perfection Methods: Secured parties often evaluate whether possession is the optimal method of perfection. For some types of personal property, registration might be a more practical or cost-effective method, depending on the nature of the collateral and the business relationship between the parties.

• Legal Risks: If possession is lost, the secured party risks losing the priority status of the security interest. Consequently, secured parties should establish protocols to monitor and maintain possession or promptly act to re-establish perfection if possession is compromised.

Conclusion

Perfection of a security interest by possession under R.A. No. 11057 is a viable and often preferred method for tangible movable property, given its effectiveness as notice and immediacy in establishing priority. However, it requires meticulous compliance with possession requirements and consideration of practical issues such as cost, logistics, and continuous control over the collateral. This method is particularly advantageous when there is no accessible registration system for the type of collateral involved.

Registration | Perfection of Security Interest | R.A. No. 11057 or the Personal Property Security Act | SECURED TRANSACTIONS

Perfection of Security Interest Under the Personal Property Security Act (R.A. No. 11057)

The Personal Property Security Act (R.A. No. 11057), enacted in 2018, provides a framework for creating, perfecting, and enforcing security interests in personal property in the Philippines. This law modernizes the secured transactions system in the country, aiming to improve access to credit by allowing individuals and businesses to use movable assets as collateral.

1. Perfection of Security Interest: Overview

Perfection of a security interest is a crucial step that makes a security interest enforceable against third parties and preserves the priority of the secured party’s claim over the collateral. In the context of R.A. No. 11057, perfection generally requires the registration of the security interest with the designated registry. However, perfection may also be achieved through possession or control of the collateral, depending on the nature of the personal property involved.

The objective of perfection is to put third parties on notice that the secured party has a claim or interest over the collateral.

2. Registration of Security Interest

The default and primary method of perfecting a security interest under R.A. No. 11057 is through registration. The registration process provides public notice and establishes priority in the event of competing claims to the collateral.

a. Registration System

Under R.A. No. 11057, the Registry of Security Interests in Personal Property (referred to as the "Registry") is established. This Registry is an electronic, centralized database operated and maintained by the Land Registration Authority (LRA), which records notices of security interests in personal property.

Key features of the Registry:

• Electronic System: Registration is done electronically, facilitating efficient recording, search, and retrieval of notices.
• Accessible to the Public: The Registry can be accessed by interested parties, allowing them to verify the existence of any security interests on a specific personal property.
• Notice-Filing System: The Registry follows a notice-filing system rather than a document-filing system, meaning that only a notice of the security interest is filed rather than the entire security agreement.
• Non-Judicial Filing: Registration of security interests is an administrative procedure, not requiring court intervention.

b. Registration Process

1. Filing a Notice: To perfect a security interest through registration, the secured party must file a notice of the security interest with the Registry. This notice should contain:

   • Identification of the secured party and the grantor (debtor),
   • A description of the collateral,
   • The term of the registration, and
   • Any other required information as prescribed by implementing rules.

2. Description of Collateral: The description of the collateral in the notice should be sufficiently detailed to enable interested parties to identify it. General descriptions such as "all personal property" are acceptable if they reasonably identify the property subject to the security interest.

3. Electronic Signature and Verification: Filings are typically made electronically, and the identity of the parties involved can be verified through electronic means, streamlining the process and reducing the risk of error or fraud.

c. Term and Duration of Registration

A registration notice can be effective for a maximum period specified at the time of filing. Once registered, the security interest is considered perfected for the duration stated in the notice. The registration may be renewed before its expiration to maintain perfection, with each renewal extending the perfection for an additional period.

d. Amendments and Termination of Registration

• Amendments: If there are any changes in the terms of the security interest or additional collateral is added, the secured party can amend the registration notice accordingly.
• Termination: Upon satisfaction of the underlying obligation, the secured party is required to file a termination notice in the Registry, effectively releasing the lien on the collateral.

3. Other Methods of Perfection: Possession and Control

While registration is the primary method for perfecting a security interest, R.A. No. 11057 allows perfection by possession or control in specific instances.

a. Possession of Tangible Collateral

Perfection by possession is applicable when the secured party takes physical possession of the collateral, primarily relevant for tangible movable property, such as equipment, inventory, or vehicles. Possession by the secured party serves as a public notice and thus perfects the security interest.

b. Control of Certain Intangible Collateral

In cases involving certain types of intangible collateral (such as deposit accounts, electronic securities, or investment property), perfection may be achieved by establishing "control." Control occurs when the secured party has a legally recognized means to exercise authority over the collateral without requiring additional consent from the grantor.

For instance:

• Deposit Accounts: Control over a deposit account may be established if the secured party is the depository bank or has an agreement with the bank allowing it to withdraw funds.
• Electronic Securities or Investment Property: Control is achieved if the secured party has authority over the securities in an account or if it is registered in the name of the secured party.

4. Effectiveness and Priority

Upon perfection, the security interest is enforceable against third parties. However, the priority of the security interest—determining the order of claims in the event of debtor default or insolvency—depends on the time and method of perfection.

a. Priority by Date of Registration

Generally, the priority of security interests is determined by the order in which they were perfected. The first secured party to perfect its interest (through registration, possession, or control) generally has priority over subsequent interests in the same collateral.

b. Exceptions to Priority Rules

Certain types of security interests, such as purchase money security interests (PMSIs), may enjoy super-priority if perfected within specified timeframes and conditions. PMSIs, which secure credit provided to acquire specific personal property, can gain priority over earlier-filed security interests.

5. Enforcement and Public Notice

The primary function of registration is to provide public notice of the security interest, enabling other creditors, potential buyers, or other interested parties to verify any claims on the personal property.

a. Search Functionality

The Registry allows parties to search for registered security interests based on the debtor's name, the collateral description, or the registration number. This helps creditors assess the risk of extending credit and assists purchasers in verifying claims before acquiring personal property.

b. Enforcement Against Third Parties

A perfected security interest is enforceable not only against the debtor but also against third parties, including buyers, other creditors, and trustees in bankruptcy. The priority established through perfection enables the secured party to claim the collateral ahead of unsecured creditors in case of default.

6. Conclusion

Perfection of a security interest under the Personal Property Security Act (R.A. No. 11057) is a critical step to enforce the rights of a secured party against third parties. Through the centralized electronic Registry maintained by the LRA, the law ensures transparency, accessibility, and prioritization of claims in personal property. Registration, possession, and control are recognized methods for perfection, with the Registry serving as a public notice system essential for managing and resolving competing claims over personal property assets.

By adhering to these provisions, creditors and secured parties can protect their interests, thus enhancing the overall efficiency and accessibility of credit markets in the Philippines.

Perfection of Security Interest | R.A. No. 11057 or the Personal Property Security Act | SECURED TRANSACTIONS

Perfection of Security Interest under R.A. No. 11057 or the Personal Property Security Act

1. Introduction to Perfection of Security Interest

The Personal Property Security Act (R.A. No. 11057), enacted in 2018, reformed the legal framework governing secured transactions in the Philippines, particularly in relation to movable or personal property. One of its core features is the perfection of security interests, which plays a critical role in establishing priority rights over collateral in case of debtor default or bankruptcy. The concept of "perfection" in secured transactions ensures the enforceability of the security interest against third parties, clarifying the order of rights over a debtor's assets.

2. Importance of Perfection

The perfection of a security interest is a pivotal step in the lifecycle of a secured transaction. It ensures:

• Third-party enforceability: A perfected security interest is enforceable not only against the debtor but also against third parties, including creditors.
• Priority: Perfected interests generally have priority over unperfected ones in claims on the collateral.
• Notice: Perfection serves as a notice to third parties that a security interest exists on the property.

Without perfection, the secured party risks having its interest subordinated to later-perfected security interests, liens, or claims by other creditors.

3. Methods of Perfection under R.A. No. 11057

The Personal Property Security Act provides specific methods for the perfection of security interests, which are enumerated as follows:

• Registration: The primary method of perfection under R.A. No. 11057 is through registration. The secured party must file a financing statement with the Registry of Personal Property Security Interests (RPPSI). Once registered, the security interest is perfected and becomes effective against third parties. The act establishes that the registration serves as constructive notice to third parties.

• Possession: In some cases, the perfection of a security interest can be achieved by taking possession of the collateral. This is common for assets such as goods, negotiable documents, or financial instruments. When possession is taken by the secured party, perfection is achieved without the need for registration.

• Control: For certain types of collateral, such as deposit accounts, electronic securities, and other specific assets, the security interest may be perfected by "control." This means that the secured party has an arrangement or legal capacity that effectively gives them exclusive control over the asset, such as a deposit account under a control agreement with the account holder and depository institution.

• Automatic Perfection: Some security interests may be perfected automatically under specific circumstances, such as a purchase-money security interest (PMSI) in consumer goods. In such cases, registration or possession may not be required to perfect the interest, though limits and conditions apply.

4. The Personal Property Security Registry

The law mandates the establishment of an electronic Personal Property Security Registry (PPSR), a centralized online registry administered by the Land Registration Authority (LRA). The registry system is accessible online, allowing for efficient and transparent filing, searching, and retrieval of records regarding personal property security interests. This digital registry reduces paperwork, speeds up the perfection process, and provides a reliable public record of perfected security interests.

5. Financing Statement and Its Content

For a security interest to be perfected by registration, a financing statement must be filed. This statement must contain specific information, including:

• The names and addresses of the debtor and secured party.
• A description of the collateral subject to the security interest.
• Information sufficient to identify the type and nature of the security interest.

The financing statement must be accurate and complete, as errors can result in a failure to perfect the security interest or invalidate the registration altogether. However, minor errors that do not mislead third parties may be deemed acceptable under the law.

6. Duration and Renewal of Registration

The standard duration for a perfected security interest through registration is five years, after which it lapses unless renewed. The secured party can renew the registration by filing a continuation statement before expiration, extending the security interest's perfection by an additional five-year term.

Failure to renew the registration before its lapse results in the loss of perfection, rendering the security interest unenforceable against third-party claims that may arise thereafter.

7. Priority of Security Interests

The order of priority among competing security interests generally depends on the order of perfection. Specifically:

• First to perfect, first in right: Priority is determined by the date and time of filing, possession, or control. The first secured party to perfect their interest has the highest priority.
• Special Priority Rules: The Act includes specific priority rules for certain types of security interests, such as purchase-money security interests (PMSIs). For instance, a PMSI in inventory may have priority over conflicting interests if the PMSI is perfected by registration before the inventory is delivered to the debtor and if notice is given to existing secured creditors.

8. Rights upon Default

Upon the debtor’s default, the perfected secured party has enforceable rights against the collateral. Depending on the specific terms of the security agreement and the security interest's type, the secured party may:

• Take possession of the collateral (if not already in possession).
• Sell or dispose of the collateral in a commercially reasonable manner.
• Retain the collateral in full or partial satisfaction of the secured obligation, subject to notice and debtor’s consent.

9. Consequences of Non-Perfection

A failure to perfect a security interest can result in significant consequences:

• The secured party may lose priority to other creditors with perfected security interests.
• The security interest may be unenforceable against third parties, limiting the secured party’s rights to recover on the collateral.
• In cases of debtor insolvency, unperfected security interests may be subordinate to the claims of a bankruptcy trustee or other creditors.

10. Conclusion

Perfection of security interests under R.A. No. 11057 is a critical mechanism to protect secured parties' rights in personal property. By providing structured methods of perfection, clear priority rules, and an electronic registry system, the law facilitates a transparent and efficient system for secured transactions, promoting creditor confidence and supporting credit access in the Philippines. Secured parties must meticulously follow these perfection requirements to safeguard their interests, ensure enforceability, and maintain priority over other claims on the debtor’s collateral.