Buying property under CLOA in the Philippines

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws, regulations, and their interpretations can change over time, and individual circumstances vary. If you have specific legal questions or concerns regarding a Certificate of Land Ownership Award (CLOA) property, consult a qualified attorney or contact the Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR) or other relevant Philippine government agencies.

1. Introduction to CLOA

A Certificate of Land Ownership Award (CLOA) is a legal document issued by the Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR) under the Philippines’ Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program (CARP). It formally recognizes a qualified farmer (or agrarian reform beneficiary, often referred to as an ARB) as the owner of a parcel of agricultural land that was formerly under land reform coverage.

CLOAs were introduced under Republic Act No. 6657, otherwise known as the Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Law of 1988 (CARL), and subsequent related legislation. Under CARP, landowners over a certain landholding limit had to distribute their excess land to qualified tenants or farmworkers, making it possible for these beneficiaries to receive CLOAs as proof of ownership.

2. Key Legal Framework

  1. Republic Act No. 6657 (Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Law of 1988)

    • Established the general framework for agrarian reform in the Philippines.
    • Provided mechanisms for land distribution, including the issuance of CLOAs to farmer beneficiaries.

  2. DAR Administrative Orders

    • DAR frequently issues administrative orders (AOs) to clarify rules and guidelines concerning CLOA issuance, transfer, and cancellation.
    • These AOs also outline the processes for selling or transferring land awarded under CARP and set penalties for violations.

  3. Republic Act No. 9700 (CARPER)

    • The Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program Extension with Reforms (CARPER) extended and reformed the original CARP.
    • Further clarified the qualifications of agrarian reform beneficiaries and the processes involved in land transfers.

3. Prohibitions and Restrictions on CLOA Lands

3.1 Ten-Year Holding Period

Under the law, land that has been awarded through a CLOA generally cannot be sold, transferred, or otherwise conveyed by the original awardee within ten (10) years from the date of award. The rationale behind this restriction is to prevent premature disposition of agrarian reform land and ensure that beneficiaries truly benefit from the program instead of quickly selling their awarded lands.

3.2 Transfer Only to Qualified Beneficiaries

Even after the 10-year holding period, CLOA lands typically cannot be sold or transferred to just anyone. The land must usually remain in the hands of a person who can continue its agrarian reform purpose—often meaning:

  • Another qualified agrarian reform beneficiary (farmer or farmworker), or
  • The government (through DAR) for re-allocation to another qualified beneficiary, if certain conditions apply.

3.3 Continued Agricultural Use

CLOA land is restricted in use. Any attempt to convert CLOA land to non-agricultural uses (e.g., residential, commercial, or industrial) typically requires a land-use conversion process and prior approval from DAR. Unauthorized conversion can lead to penalties and possible cancellation of the CLOA.

4. Buying CLOA Property: What to Know

4.1 Waiting Out the Prohibited Period

Because of the legally mandated holding period, it is generally impermissible to buy CLOA land directly from a beneficiary who is still within the 10-year restriction. Parties who attempt to bypass this rule risk:

  • Nullification of the sale,
  • Cancellation of the CLOA, and
  • Legal sanctions from DAR.

4.2 Verifying Eligibility of Both Parties

Even if the land is beyond the 10-year restriction period:

  1. Seller’s Clearance: The seller (original beneficiary) must have complied with all obligations under the agrarian reform program (e.g., fully paid amortizations to Land Bank of the Philippines, if applicable).
  2. Buyer’s Qualifications: The buyer must be legally allowed to own or acquire agricultural land under agrarian laws. The DAR typically requires that the buyer be either:
    • A qualified agrarian reform beneficiary (i.e., someone who actually tills or intends to till the land), or
    • Someone explicitly allowed by DAR regulations (for instance, under certain reclassification or land-use conversion orders).

4.3 DAR Clearance and Procedures

A sale or transfer of CLOA land often requires DAR clearance. This clearance certifies that the sale is legal and valid under agrarian reform laws. To obtain DAR clearance, you generally need:

  1. Application for DAR Clearance: Filed with the DAR provincial or regional office that has jurisdiction over the land.
  2. Supporting Documents: Including the original CLOA, proof of full payment of amortizations (if still on installment with Land Bank), tax declarations, and other relevant documentation.
  3. Approval: DAR will verify compliance with agrarian reform requirements (e.g., has the 10-year holding period passed? Are the buyer and seller qualified?). If approved, DAR issues the clearance, allowing the parties to proceed with the transaction.

4.4 Land Valuation and Pricing

CLOA lands are often subject to government-assessed values, especially if the original beneficiary is still paying amortizations to the Land Bank. Once those payments are complete, the value might be updated. Prospective buyers should:

  • Verify if the land was fully paid for or if there remain any liens, mortgages, or encumbrances.
  • Check tax obligations and real property taxes with local government units.

5. Cancellations and Common Pitfalls

5.1 Grounds for Cancellation of CLOA

DAR can cancel a CLOA if:

  1. The land was awarded to an unqualified beneficiary.
  2. There was misrepresentation or fraud in the issuance.
  3. The beneficiary violated restrictions (e.g., illegally sold or abandoned the land).
  4. Unauthorized conversion of agricultural land for other purposes without DAR approval.

Once a CLOA is canceled, the land reverts to government disposition or may be subject to further proceedings. The occupant or current possessor might lose the property entirely if the grounds for cancellation are proven.

5.2 Common Mistakes When Buying CLOA Lands

  • Purchasing Too Early: Attempting to purchase during the 10-year prohibition period, or purchasing from a beneficiary who has not completed their obligations.
  • Not Verifying Buyer Eligibility: Even if the 10-year period has elapsed, the buyer must generally be a qualified agrarian reform beneficiary to hold title to CLOA land.
  • Skipping DAR Clearance: Failing to obtain DAR Clearance can nullify the transaction.
  • Non-Compliance with Payment Obligations: A CLOA that has unpaid amortizations to the Land Bank or unpaid taxes may complicate or invalidate the sale.

6. Land-Use Conversion Considerations

A separate but related process is land-use conversion, wherein agricultural land is converted into residential, commercial, or industrial use. For CLOA lands:

  1. DAR Approval is mandatory for any proposed change in land use.
  2. Unauthorized conversion can lead to penalties, fines, or criminal liability, as well as cancellation of the CLOA.
  3. Even if conversion is granted, there may be recovery of land-use conversion fees or other equitable remedies required.

7. Steps to Legally Acquire CLOA Land

Below is a simplified guide if you are looking to legally acquire property currently under a CLOA:

  1. Confirm Tenure & Status

    • Check the date of the CLOA issuance to verify if the 10-year holding period has passed.
    • Confirm that the seller is the registered CLOA holder and has complied with amortization requirements.

  2. Check the Buyer’s Qualifications

    • Ensure you (as a buyer) are eligible to own or acquire agricultural property under agrarian laws. This can mean being a qualified agrarian reform beneficiary or meeting other DAR criteria.

  3. Secure DAR Clearance

    • File the necessary application and documents with the DAR office that has jurisdiction over the property.
    • This step verifies the validity of the sale and helps ensure no future legal complications.

  4. Obtain Land Bank and LGU Certifications

    • If the seller is still paying for the land through the Land Bank of the Philippines, verify that all obligations are settled or that the transaction is permissible under existing rules.
    • Check real property tax clearances with the local government (city or municipality).

  5. Execute the Deed of Sale or Transfer

    • Upon DAR approval and completion of all requirements, execute the deed before a notary public.
    • Make sure the deed states compliance with DAR conditions.

  6. Register the Transfer

    • The Register of Deeds will register the new ownership once you present proof of DAR approval, tax clearance, and other relevant documents.
    • A new title may be issued (with possible annotations stating it was originally under CLOA).

8. Practical Tips and Best Practices

  1. Consult an Attorney or DAR Office Early

    • Before committing to any agreement, seek professional advice from lawyers experienced in agrarian reform or consult local DAR offices for up-to-date regulations.

  2. Perform a Comprehensive Title Check

    • Verify if the CLOA is still in force, if the land is mortgaged, if there are existing encumbrances (e.g., liens), or if there is any ongoing dispute or cancellation proceeding.

  3. Budget for Possible Liabilities

    • Understand that transferring agricultural land might incur fees (DAR fees, taxes, land conversion fees if applicable, etc.).

  4. Keep All Documents Organized

    • Maintain a file of all relevant documents (CLOA copy, DAR clearances, receipts of payment, tax declarations, etc.) for easy reference if questions arise later.

9. Conclusion

Buying property under a Certificate of Land Ownership Award (CLOA) in the Philippines comes with unique legal requirements and restrictions tied to the agrarian reform program. Foremost among these are the 10-year holding period, the requirement that the buyer typically must be a qualified agrarian reform beneficiary, and the need for DAR clearance before finalizing any sale or transfer. Failure to observe these procedures can lead to the nullification of the transaction or cancellation of the CLOA.

When considering the purchase of CLOA land, due diligence is paramount. Prospective buyers should verify the seller’s compliance with DAR rules, confirm the buyer’s eligibility, and secure all necessary government approvals. Because legal and administrative stipulations surrounding CLOA property can be complex and subject to updates, it is advisable to engage professionals—lawyers, land-use consultants, and DAR personnel—to ensure that the acquisition process is valid and enforceable.

Remember: Always refer to the latest DAR administrative orders, local regulations, and consult knowledgeable legal professionals to ensure compliance with current laws and guidelines. This article does not replace individualized legal counsel.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login