Buying Property with Adverse Claims: Legal Considerations

Buying Property with Adverse Claims: Legal Considerations in the Philippine Context

Disclaimer: The following article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific concerns or questions regarding your situation, consult a qualified Philippine attorney.

1. Introduction

Real estate transactions in the Philippines can be complex, particularly when a property is burdened by an adverse claim. An adverse claim may appear as an annotation on a transfer certificate of title (TCT) or original certificate of title (OCT), indicating that a third party asserts a right or interest over the property in question. This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of what adverse claims are, their legal basis, how they affect real estate transactions, and what prospective buyers should do to protect themselves.

2. What Is an Adverse Claim?

An adverse claim is a formal assertion, recorded in the Registry of Deeds, that another person or entity—aside from the registered owner—claims a right, title, or interest in a particular piece of registered land. This generally arises after the original registration of the property.

Under Presidential Decree (PD) No. 1529 (the Property Registration Decree), specifically Section 70, whoever claims an interest in registered land adverse to the registered owner may file and register an adverse claim. The register of deeds will then annotate this claim on the property's certificate of title, signaling to third parties—such as potential buyers—that there is a pending or unresolved interest that could affect ownership.

3. Legal Basis and Purpose

The concept of adverse claim in the Philippine setting is grounded in:

  1. Presidential Decree No. 1529 (Property Registration Decree)

    • Section 70 covers the procedure for registering an adverse claim.
    • Section 69 provides for other forms of notice (e.g., lis pendens) but focuses mainly on pending court actions.

  2. Public Policy of Protecting Innocent Purchasers

    • The law seeks to protect innocent purchasers for value by ensuring that potential claims are recorded in a public registry.
    • Once annotated, an adverse claim serves as constructive notice to any would-be buyer or lender that a third party is asserting a competing right or interest.

The key purpose is to prevent clandestine or “hidden” interests from prejudicing subsequent purchasers. By placing an adverse claim on the title, the claimant formally alerts the world that the registered owner’s right is under challenge.

4. How Is an Adverse Claim Registered?

Filing an adverse claim involves the following steps:

  1. Preparation of a Notarized Statement
    The claimant must submit a written statement, signed and sworn before a notary public or another authorized official, detailing:

    • Their full name and residence or business address,
    • The nature of their alleged right or interest in the property,
    • The grounds or factual basis of that interest,
    • A request for the annotation of the adverse claim on the title.

  2. Submission to the Registry of Deeds
    The notarized statement is submitted to the Registry of Deeds where the property is registered. Upon compliance with documentary requirements and payment of the relevant fees, the Register of Deeds annotates the adverse claim on the TCT or OCT.

  3. Validity and Duration
    By law, an adverse claim remains effective for 30 days from the date of registration (PD 1529, Section 70). After 30 days, the registered owner may file a petition to cancel the adverse claim unless the claimant moves to extend or maintains a separate court action to protect the claim.

5. Effects of an Adverse Claim on Property Transactions

  1. Constructive Notice to Potential Buyers
    Once annotated, an adverse claim is deemed constructive notice to anyone interested in buying or otherwise transacting with the property. A prudent buyer must investigate the nature of the claim before proceeding.

  2. Potential Delay in Sale
    Because an adverse claim signals potential legal disputes or conflicting rights, buyers, banks, and financing institutions typically require resolution or cancellation of the annotation before finalizing the sale. The presence of an adverse claim can thus delay or prevent a swift transaction.

  3. Risk of Competing Rights
    Depending on the substance of the adverse claim, the buyer may be at risk of litigation, annulment of the sale, or other legal complications if they proceed without addressing the claim.

6. Due Diligence for Buyers

To minimize legal and financial risks, any prospective purchaser should:

  1. Secure a Current Certified True Copy of the Title
    Obtain the latest certified true copy of the TCT/OCT from the Registry of Deeds. Check for any annotations, including adverse claims, mortgages, liens, or notices of lis pendens.

  2. Request Relevant Documents from the Seller

    • Ask for documents proving the seller’s ownership, such as a Deed of Sale, Certificate Authorizing Registration (CAR), tax declarations, and real property tax receipts.
    • Request information about any adverse claims or pending legal disputes affecting the property.

  3. Investigate the Basis for the Adverse Claim

    • If an adverse claim is present, determine who the claimant is, the nature of their claim, and whether the claim has been resolved or is being contested in court.
    • Consult a lawyer to assess the legitimacy of the claim and possible resolution.

  4. Verify Real Property Tax Status
    Ensure that the seller has settled real property taxes. Though not directly linked to the adverse claim, unpaid taxes can lead to other liabilities or encumbrances.

  5. Include Protective Clauses in the Contract

    • If you decide to proceed despite the adverse claim, negotiate clauses in your contract of sale that provide for an indemnification or escrow arrangement until the adverse claim is canceled.
    • Some buyers require the seller to handle cancellation of the adverse claim as a condition precedent to final payment.

7. Remedies for Property Owners Facing an Adverse Claim

A registered owner who believes an adverse claim is unfounded or fraudulent has several legal remedies:

  1. Petition for Cancellation

    • After the 30-day period provided by law, the registered owner may file a verified petition to cancel the adverse claim. If the claimant fails to secure an extension or present proof of ongoing legal action, the Register of Deeds may cancel the annotation.
    • A court case may be necessary if the claimant actively contests the cancellation.

  2. Legal Action for Annulment of Annotation

    • If the adverse claim is part of a broader dispute, an owner may file an appropriate complaint in court (e.g., quieting of title) to resolve the conflicting interests and direct the Register of Deeds to remove the annotation.

  3. Negotiation or Settlement

    • In some cases, the adverse claim might stem from a misunderstanding or a legitimate but resolvable interest (e.g., unpaid obligations, co-ownership, or inheritance claims). An out-of-court settlement or compromise agreement can lead to the voluntary cancellation of the adverse claim.

8. Legal Remedies for Adverse Claimants

If you are the claimant asserting an adverse interest and you wish to protect it:

  1. File or Maintain a Court Action

    • If you believe your interest is substantial (e.g., partial ownership, breach of a prior sale agreement, or fraudulent title), secure your right by filing the appropriate complaint in court.
    • While the adverse claim itself is not a lawsuit, it alerts third parties that you are taking steps to protect your interest.

  2. Renew or Maintain the Annotation

    • Beyond the 30-day period, you may seek to maintain your claim through a court order, or by showing that legal proceedings are ongoing.
    • Work with an attorney to ensure compliance with procedural requirements to keep the claim on record.

9. Distinguishing Adverse Claim from Other Annotations

There are other types of encumbrances or notices that may appear on a title:

  • Notice of Lis Pendens: Indicates that there is ongoing litigation involving the property.
  • Mortgage or Real Estate Mortgage (REM): Secures a loan with the property as collateral.
  • Lien for Unpaid Taxes: A claim by the government for unpaid real property taxes.

An adverse claim differs by focusing on a third party’s alleged ownership interest or right that conflicts with or is adverse to that of the current registered owner. Each type of annotation carries unique legal implications.

10. Impact on “Innocent Purchaser for Value”

The Philippine Torrens system is designed to protect innocent purchasers who rely on the clean title of the seller. However, an innocent purchaser for value is generally not protected if:

  • They buy a property with a conspicuous adverse claim annotated on the title, or
  • They fail to exercise due diligence in the face of suspicious circumstances.

Courts typically rule that once an adverse claim (or similar annotation) is on the title, a buyer can no longer claim to be an innocent purchaser for value if they disregard the red flags and proceed blindly.

11. Practical Tips for Buyers

  1. Engage a Lawyer
    Hiring an experienced real estate attorney is recommended if you encounter an adverse claim. Legal counsel will help you understand the risks and draft the necessary protective clauses in any purchase agreement.

  2. Negotiate a Clear Title
    Ideally, insist that the seller secure the cancellation of the adverse claim before the transaction is concluded. You may hold part of the purchase price in escrow until the title is cleared.

  3. Check the Property’s Physical Possession
    Visit the property and see who is in actual possession. Sometimes, an adverse claim arises from a person already occupying the land under a claim of ownership or lease. Physical inspection can reveal potential disputes.

  4. Consider Title Insurance
    While not as common in the Philippines as in other jurisdictions, title insurance may provide additional protection if available through certain providers.

12. Conclusion

Purchasing property in the Philippines with an adverse claim annotated on the title demands rigorous due diligence and legal guidance. Adverse claims can significantly affect the marketability of the title and may expose a buyer to costly litigation or even loss of ownership if not handled correctly.

By understanding the legal framework for adverse claims—including how they are filed, their legal implications, and how they can be canceled—buyers and sellers alike can navigate real estate transactions more confidently. The safest route is always to confirm that the property’s title is free of adverse claims or to resolve such claims prior to finalizing any sale.

Key Takeaways

  • An adverse claim is an annotation on a land title indicating a third party’s conflicting right or interest.
  • Philippine law (PD 1529) allows for the registration of adverse claims to serve as constructive notice.
  • A buyer should always conduct thorough title checks and, if an adverse claim exists, investigate and resolve it or require its cancellation before proceeding.
  • Legal counsel is crucial to navigate the complexities and safeguard one’s interests in a property transaction involving an adverse claim.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login