Claim for Denied Maternity Benefits in the Philippines

Below is a comprehensive discussion of claims for denied maternity benefits in the Philippines, covering the legal framework, eligibility criteria, reasons for denial, and remedies available. This guide aims to provide general information and should not be construed as legal advice. For specific concerns, consultation with a qualified Philippine lawyer is always recommended.

1. Introduction

Maternity benefits in the Philippines are primarily designed to protect women workers during pregnancy and childbirth. These benefits ensure that expectant mothers can focus on their health and well-being, without jeopardizing their employment or facing undue financial hardship. Unfortunately, some employees encounter difficulties in claiming these benefits or experience outright denial from their employers or from the Social Security System (SSS). Understanding the legal framework and available remedies is crucial for pursuing denied claims.

2. Legal Framework Governing Maternity Benefits

2.1. The 105-Day Expanded Maternity Leave Law (R.A. 11210)

Enacted in 2019, Republic Act No. 11210 significantly expanded the maternity leave period for women in both the government and private sectors:

  • 105 days of paid maternity leave for live childbirth, with an option to extend for an additional 30 days (without pay).
  • 120 days of paid maternity leave for miscarriage or emergency termination of pregnancy (60 days for abortion/miscarriage under older laws, but new directives vary).
  • 15 additional days for solo parents (as defined by R.A. 8972 or the Solo Parents’ Welfare Act).

2.2. Social Security Act of 2018 (R.A. 11199)

Under R.A. 11199, the Social Security System (SSS) administers the payment of daily cash maternity benefits to covered female members. Contributions and compliance with SSS regulations are essential for entitlement.

2.3. The Labor Code of the Philippines

While the Labor Code itself does not provide the expanded benefits that the newer laws do, it still guarantees that an employer cannot terminate a female employee due to pregnancy. It also recognizes protection and assistance for pregnant employees.

2.4. The Magna Carta of Women (R.A. 9710)

The Magna Carta of Women provides broader protections to women, including the right to health benefits, maternity care, and protection from discrimination in the workplace on account of pregnancy.

3. Coverage and Eligibility

3.1. Who are covered?

  1. Female employees in the private sector who are duly registered and making contributions to the SSS.
  2. Female government employees covered by the Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) and Civil Service Commission (CSC) rules.
  3. Self-employed and voluntary members (for SSS) who have met the required number of contributions.

3.2. Minimum contribution requirements

For SSS-covered members, there is a required minimum number of monthly contributions before the semester of childbirth or miscarriage. The standard rule under SSS Circulars is:

  • The employee must have at least three (3) monthly contributions within the 12-month period immediately preceding the semester of contingency (the semester of childbirth or miscarriage).

3.3. Employer obligations

Employers must:

  • Inform all female employees of their rights under the law.
  • Remit SSS contributions on time.
  • Process the necessary SSS maternity benefit claim forms, supporting documents, and ensure that employees receive the benefit in full.

4. Maternity Leave Entitlements

  1. Duration of Leave

    • 105 days for live birth (can be extended by 30 days without pay).
    • 120 days for a miscarriage or emergency termination of pregnancy (some interpretations or implementing rules may vary, but the law generally provides at least 60-78 days in older laws, while the new law increased coverage—employees should refer to the latest implementing rules).
    • Additional 15 days for solo parents.

  2. Maternity Benefit Computation

    • Paid maternity benefits are generally based on the average daily salary credit (ADSC) in SSS, multiplied by the number of compensable days.
    • The employer is required to advance the benefit to the employee, after which the SSS reimburses the employer (if the employee is covered by SSS).

  3. Non-Diminution of Benefits

    • Under the principle of non-diminution of benefits, no existing company policy or practice can reduce or remove an employee’s existing maternity benefits.

5. Common Reasons for Denial of Maternity Benefits

  1. Insufficient Contributions

    • Failing to meet the minimum required SSS monthly contributions in the 12-month period preceding the semester of delivery or miscarriage can lead to denial.

  2. Late or Non-Submission of Documents

    • Failing to file the appropriate notifications (e.g., SSS Form MAT-1) before giving birth, or submitting documents beyond the prescribed deadlines may result in denial.

  3. Employer Non-Compliance

    • Employers may fail to remit SSS contributions on time or refuse to process the employee’s maternity benefit claim forms.

  4. Falsification or Misrepresentation

    • If the SSS or employer finds that the claimant provided false information or submitted fraudulent documents, the claim could be denied.

  5. Improper Classification of Employment

    • In cases where an employer misclassifies a worker as an independent contractor or fails to register them as an employee with the SSS, it may complicate or lead to outright denial of benefits.

6. Legal Remedies When Maternity Benefits are Denied

When a claim is denied—whether by the employer, the SSS, or both—employees have legal avenues for redress. Below are the steps and remedies available:

6.1. File a Protest or Appeal with the SSS

  1. SSS Reconsideration

    • If the SSS denies your claim (e.g., due to insufficient contributions or late filing), you can submit a written request for reconsideration to the SSS branch that handled your application.
    • Attach any relevant documents that address the reason for denial (e.g., proof of remittances, medical certificates, or clarifications for late filing).

  2. SSS Appeals

    • If the denial is upheld, you can file an appeal with the SSS Commission. This is an administrative appeal requiring a formal written explanation of why the denial was incorrect.

6.2. Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) Complaint

  1. For Employer-Related Denials

    • If the employer refuses to grant the benefit despite clear eligibility or fails to process the necessary documents, you may file a complaint with the DOLE or National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) for money claims or for any labor standard violations.
    • DOLE may initiate an inspection or enforcement action if the employer is found violating labor laws.

  2. Filing a Labor Case with the NLRC

    • Employees who have been denied maternity benefits unlawfully may file a labor case for:
      • Non-payment of benefits
      • Damages and attorney’s fees, if applicable
    • The NLRC will conduct proceedings to determine if the denial was wrongful and can order the employer to pay the maternity benefit plus any applicable damages.

6.3. Civil or Criminal Actions (If Applicable)

  1. SSS Law Violations

    • Under the SSS Law (R.A. 11199), employers who fail to remit contributions or commit fraud can be held criminally liable.
    • Employees can coordinate with the SSS to file cases against non-compliant employers.

  2. Other Possible Civil Claims

    • In cases of serious misconduct or bad faith on the part of the employer (e.g., unjust termination due to pregnancy), civil suits for damages may also be initiated based on the Civil Code provisions on damages.

7. Best Practices to Avoid Denial

  1. Timely Notification

    • As soon as pregnancy is confirmed, notify the employer and file the SSS Maternity Notification (SSS Form MAT-1).

  2. Ensure Regular SSS Contributions

    • Keep track of monthly SSS contribution payments. Cross-check SSS records (through your My.SSS online account, if available).

  3. Maintain Proper Documentation

    • Secure medical certificates, ultrasound reports, birth certificates, or other relevant documents.
    • Keep copies of all forms submitted to the employer/SSS.

  4. Monitor Employer Compliance

    • If you suspect your employer is not remitting your contributions, immediately contact the SSS.
    • Keep payslips and any records indicating SSS deductions.

  5. Seek Legal Advice Early

    • If you sense potential denial or conflict, consult with an attorney or approach your local DOLE office for guidance.

8. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1. Can I still claim maternity benefits if I am separated from employment?
Yes, if you meet the minimum contribution requirements and your coverage with the SSS remains valid. Even if you are no longer employed, you may file as a voluntary or self-employed member, provided you have paid the required contributions.

Q2. Is the employer required to pay the entire maternity benefit if the employee is eligible?
Yes. Under the law, the employer shall advance the full maternity benefit to the employee. The employer then claims reimbursement from the SSS (for private sector employees).

Q3. What if my employer refuses to release my salary differential?
Some companies provide a salary differential if the SSS benefit does not cover the employee’s full salary. Under R.A. 11210’s Implementing Rules, certain establishments are required to pay a salary differential unless they are exempted. If the employer denies such benefits without valid exemption, you can file a complaint with DOLE or the NLRC.

Q4. Is there a deadline for filing maternity benefit claims with the SSS?
Yes. Generally, you must notify the SSS of your pregnancy (through your employer, if employed) at least 60 days from the date of conception and file the necessary documents after childbirth. Always check the latest SSS circulars for updated deadlines.

Q5. What happens if my employer did not remit my SSS contributions but made deductions from my salary?
You can report this to the SSS and DOLE. The employer faces liability for non-remittance. You may still be able to claim benefits if it can be shown that the employer actually deducted your contributions from your salary.

9. Conclusion

The Philippine legal framework strongly protects the rights of pregnant employees to receive maternity benefits. Denial of these benefits often arises from insufficient contributions, late submissions, or employer non-compliance. Knowing your rights, diligently monitoring your SSS records, and taking timely legal action are key steps in ensuring successful claims. If you find yourself facing a denied claim, you have recourse through the SSS reconsideration/appeal process, DOLE or NLRC complaints, and even legal actions for damages if warranted.

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For personalized guidance, consult a licensed attorney or contact your nearest Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) office or SSS branch.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login