Criminal Charges for Threatening a Paramour in the Philippines

Below is a general discussion of the legal framework in the Philippines regarding criminal charges for threatening a paramour. This overview references pertinent provisions of Philippine law, notably the Revised Penal Code and related special legislation. However, this information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Always consult a licensed Philippine attorney for guidance on specific circumstances.

1. Terminology and Context

  1. “Paramour” in Philippine Legal Usage

    • Commonly, “paramour” refers to a person who has an ongoing sexual or romantic relationship with someone who is already married to another individual.
    • There is no specific crime solely labeled “threatening a paramour” in the Revised Penal Code; instead, the act of threatening any person (including a paramour) may be covered under the laws on threats (Articles 282, 283, 285 of the Revised Penal Code), violence against women laws, or relevant special statutes depending on the nature of the threat.

  2. Marital Status and Context

    • In the Philippines, marital infidelity can itself be criminal under the crimes of Adultery or Concubinage (Articles 333 and 334, Revised Penal Code). But threatening a paramour is a separate matter. Regardless of whether the threatened individual is a spouse, an extramarital partner, or anyone else, the law on threats focuses on the nature and severity of the threat.

2. Relevant Laws on Threats

2.1. The Revised Penal Code Provisions on Threats

The Revised Penal Code classifies threats based on gravity and context:

  1. Grave Threats (Article 282)

    • Definition: A person commits Grave Threats by threatening another with the infliction of a crime, wrong, or harm amounting to a crime, such as serious physical injury, homicide, or other felonies.
    • Examples: “I will kill you,” or “I will burn your house down,” said with a serious intent to cause alarm or fear.
    • Penalty: The penalty depends on whether a condition (e.g., payment of money) is imposed. Grave Threats can be punished by imprisonment (prisión mayor to prision correccional in its medium and maximum periods), depending on whether the threat is unconditional or conditional.

  2. Light Threats (Article 283)

    • Definition: Light Threats involve threats to commit a wrong not constituting a crime (e.g., threatening to reveal a secret, cause reputational damage), or lesser forms of harm that do not rise to the level of Grave Threats, typically without conditions.
    • Penalty: Usually arresto menor or arresto mayor (ranging from a few days to a few months of imprisonment).

  3. Other Light Threats (Article 285)

    • Definition: This article includes specific circumstances such as threatening another in a heat of anger or using mild intimidation.
    • Penalty: Generally lower than for Light Threats under Article 283, and can be penalized by arresto menor or similar penalties.

2.2. Anti-Violence Against Women and Their Children Act (RA 9262)

If the threatened paramour is a woman who has or had a sexual or dating relationship with the perpetrator (or even if she shares a child with him), Republic Act No. 9262 (“VAWC Law”) may apply. RA 9262 penalizes various forms of physical, sexual, psychological, and economic abuse, including threats that cause mental or emotional suffering.

  • Acts covered:
    • Physical violence (actual harm or attempts)
    • Sexual violence (coercion or threats in a sexual context)
    • Psychological violence (includes causing mental or emotional suffering via threats, intimidation, or harassment)
  • Penalty: VAWC imposes heavier penalties than ordinary threats under the Revised Penal Code. Offenders, upon conviction, can face prison terms ranging from a few months (depending on the severity) to long-term imprisonment, as well as fines and issuance of protection orders.

2.3. Safe Spaces Act (RA 11313)

RA 11313, the “Safe Spaces Act,” mainly addresses gender-based harassment in public spaces, online spaces, and workplaces. While this law is typically invoked for catcalling or sexual harassment, it also penalizes acts that use threats or intimidation in certain contexts, including online. If the threat to a paramour (or to any individual) occurs through social media, texts, or electronic channels, RA 11313 could potentially apply.

3. Filing a Criminal Case for Threats

  1. Initial Steps:

    • Gather Evidence: If you have text messages, emails, call recordings, screenshots (for online threats), witness statements, or any documentation showing the threat, keep these as evidence.
    • Police Blotter or Barangay Report: For immediate threats, individuals may file a report at the nearest police station or barangay. In many cases, barangay mediation might be required for minor offenses before elevating it to the prosecutor’s office.

  2. Filing a Complaint with the Prosecutor’s Office:

    • The complainant (or their lawyer) submits a sworn statement (complaint-affidavit) detailing the incident, attaching relevant evidence.
    • The prosecutor evaluates whether there is probable cause to charge the suspect in court.

  3. Criminal Information and Trial:

    • If the prosecutor finds probable cause, an Information is filed in court.
    • The accused can then be arraigned, and trial proceeds unless the accused opts for a plea bargain (if allowed under the circumstances).

  4. Provisional Remedies:

    • Protection Orders: Under RA 9262, if the threatened person is a woman in an intimate relationship with the perpetrator, she can apply for a Barangay Protection Order (BPO), Temporary Protection Order (TPO), or Permanent Protection Order (PPO) to prohibit the accused from further threatening or harassing her.
    • No-Contact Directives: The threatened party may request conditions that the accused keep a certain distance, refrain from calls, or from any form of direct or indirect contact.

4. Defenses and Considerations for the Accused

  1. Absence of Actual Threat: The defense may argue that the accused did not utter or communicate a direct threat; rather, the complainant misinterpreted statements or there was no intent to cause fear.
  2. Lack of Specificity: In Grave Threats, the threat must be of a crime or serious harm. Vague or ambiguous language may not qualify.
  3. Self-Defense or Defense of Honor: In rare cases, the accused may claim they threatened a paramour under extreme provocation or in the heat of anger, attempting to prevent a more immediate harm. However, legal defenses must be carefully evaluated and backed by evidence.

5. Potential Penalties and Sentencing

  1. Imprisonment Ranges (Under the Revised Penal Code):

    • Grave Threats: Up to several years in prison (prisión mayor in its minimum period, or prision correccional in its medium and maximum periods, depending on circumstances).
    • Light Threats: Typically punished by short-term imprisonment (arresto menor or arresto mayor).

  2. Under RA 9262 (VAWC):

    • Penalties can be more severe compared to ordinary threats, with imprisonment that can range from a few months (in less serious cases) to many years, plus fines. Courts may also award civil damages.

  3. Other Consequences:

    • A criminal record, which can affect employment and other aspects of life.
    • Issuance of protection orders restricting movement and contact with the complainant.
    • Social stigma and personal repercussions on familial and communal relationships.

6. Practical Guidance

  1. For the Threatened Person (the Paramour):

    • Document everything: Save messages, screenshots, and gather witness accounts.
    • Report promptly: File a blotter at the barangay or report to the police, especially for immediate threats.
    • Seek protection: If the threatened individual qualifies under RA 9262 (e.g., a female with an intimate relationship), secure a protection order and seek help from women’s desks at local police stations or local government units.

  2. For the Accused or Potential Accused:

    • Do not escalate: Any further threats or aggressive behavior can worsen potential criminal charges.
    • Seek legal advice: Engage a lawyer immediately upon learning of a criminal complaint for threats.
    • Gather evidence: If there are circumstances or contexts that could negate or mitigate the alleged threat (e.g., lack of intent, misunderstanding), gather relevant proof.

  3. Alternative Dispute Resolution:

    • For minor threats (Light Threats or Other Light Threats), the barangay justice system often tries to mediate. A settlement can be reached at barangay level, though serious threats involving violence or intimidation typically move directly to the prosecutor’s office.

7. Key Takeaways

  1. Threatening anyone—including a paramour—can be criminal under the Revised Penal Code or special laws such as RA 9262 (if the threatened individual is a woman in an intimate relationship with the perpetrator).
  2. Severity of the penalty depends on whether the threat is classified as Grave, Light, or covered by RA 9262 (VAWC).
  3. Evidence is crucial—messages, witnesses, and documents can make or break a complaint for threats.
  4. Protection orders may be issued to shield the threatened person from further intimidation or violence.
  5. Consult a lawyer early for both the threatened party and the accused to understand rights, procedures, and defenses.

Disclaimer

The foregoing discussion is a general overview based on Philippine laws and does not substitute for formal legal counsel. Each case is unique, and anyone facing—or pursuing—charges of threats should seek professional legal advice from a qualified attorney in the Philippines.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login