DAR Clearance Requirements for Transfer of Agricultural Land Over 5 Hectares

Below is a comprehensive legal article discussing the Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR) clearance requirements for the transfer of agricultural land over five (5) hectares in the Philippine context. This article aims to cover the essential laws, regulations, procedures, requirements, and potential legal implications arising from noncompliance.

I. Introduction

The agrarian reform program in the Philippines is grounded on the 1987 Philippine Constitution, which mandates the equitable distribution of agricultural land. The Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Law (CARL), embodied in Republic Act (R.A.) No. 6657 (as amended by R.A. No. 9700), is the primary statute that governs land distribution, land ownership ceilings, and the responsibilities and authority of the Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR). One key regulatory mechanism within the country’s agrarian reform framework is the requirement for DAR clearance prior to transferring ownership of agricultural lands, particularly when such lands exceed five (5) hectares.

This article discusses the legal basis, documentation requirements, procedure, exemptions, and penalties associated with the DAR clearance requirement for transfers of agricultural land over five (5) hectares.

II. Legal Basis and Rationale

  1. 1987 Philippine Constitution

    • Social Justice and Agrarian Reform (Article XIII, Sections 4-5): The Constitution mandates the State to undertake an agrarian reform program that aims to promote social justice and industrialization. It empowers the government to determine the size of landholdings that owners may retain.
    • Equitable Access to Land: By limiting the size of landholdings and distributing excess lands to qualified beneficiaries, the Constitution ensures that agricultural resources are shared equitably.

  2. Republic Act (R.A.) No. 6657 (Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Law of 1988), as amended by R.A. No. 9700

    • Retention Limits (Section 6): Landowners are generally entitled to retain a maximum of five (5) hectares of agricultural land. Children of the landowner who are at least 15 years of age and are actually tilling or managing the land may also retain up to three (3) hectares each, subject to conditions set by DAR.
    • Prohibition Against Unlawful Transfers: Any transfer or disposition of private agricultural lands beyond the retention limit without DAR clearance can be declared null and void or in violation of agrarian laws.

  3. DAR Administrative Orders (AOs) and Memorandum Circulars

    • DAR periodically issues administrative orders, such as DAR A.O. No. 1, Series of 1989 (and subsequent AOs), providing guidelines on land transfers, retention rights, and the issuance of clearances.
    • These administrative issuances lay out detailed procedures, requirements, and grounds for approval or denial of DAR clearances.

Purpose of DAR Clearance

The DAR clearance requirement exists to ensure that any proposed transfer of agricultural land will not circumvent the goals of the agrarian reform program. In essence, DAR clearance:

  • Confirms that the land area to be transferred is within the allowable retention limit.
  • Verifies that the land is no longer covered by (or needed to implement) agrarian reform distribution.
  • Ensures that agricultural tenants or farmworkers’ rights are protected and that no violation of social justice principles is committed.

III. Scope of the DAR Clearance Requirement

  1. Agricultural Lands Over 5 Hectares

    • The key trigger is the size of the agricultural land. If the total landholding is over five (5) hectares, DAR clearance is almost always mandatory prior to any transfer (sale, donation, or otherwise).
    • Even if the property being transferred is a portion of a bigger agricultural landholding, DAR may still require clearance if the entire aggregated landholding of the seller exceeds five (5) hectares.

  2. Covered Transactions

    • Sale (or other forms of conveyance): Any transaction resulting in the conveyance of ownership, including deeds of sale, deeds of donation, deeds of exchange, and other contracts.
    • Involuntary Transfers: Transfers by reason of foreclosure, expropriation, or other legal processes may also require DAR clearance or certification to ensure no violation of agrarian reform laws.

  3. Exclusions and Exemptions

    • Land Reclassified as Non-Agricultural: If the local government unit (LGU), with the requisite approvals, has already reclassified the property as non-agricultural prior to June 15, 1988 (the effectivity date of R.A. No. 6657), a DAR conversion order or an equivalent clearance may suffice (instead of a regular DAR transfer clearance).
    • Retention Rights Already Fixed: If a landowner has been issued a DAR order affirming their retention area (e.g., five hectares or less) and the property for transfer is outside or part of the landowner’s retention area, the DAR may still conduct an evaluation. The existence of an approved retention may, however, speed up the clearance process.

IV. Documentary Requirements

While the exact list of documents can vary depending on the latest administrative issuances and the specific nature of the transaction, the standard documentary requirements for obtaining a DAR clearance typically include:

  1. Application Form

    • Accomplished DAR application form for land transfer clearance, indicating the nature of the transaction, parties involved, and property details.

  2. Certified True Copy of the Title (Transfer Certificate of Title / Original Certificate of Title)

    • Issued by the Registry of Deeds (ROD) showing the property’s current technical description and ownership.

  3. Certified True Copy of the Latest Tax Declaration

    • Issued by the Assessor’s Office to verify classification, property valuation, and boundaries.

  4. Location / Vicinity Map or Approved Survey Plan

    • Prepared by a licensed geodetic engineer, showing the boundaries, total area, and relevant improvements.

  5. Documentary Proof of Land Classification

    • If the land is claimed to be exempt from CARP coverage (such as reclassified land or awarded land under a previous agrarian law), relevant documents (e.g., DAR conversion order, reclassification documents) must be presented.

  6. Notarized Deed of Sale or Conveyance (If Already Executed)

    • Sometimes, DAR may require a draft copy for review; in other cases, a notarized deed is required, accompanied by a statement that the transfer is subject to obtaining DAR clearance.

  7. Certification from the Barangay Agrarian Reform Council (BARC), if applicable

    • Certifying whether the land has existing tenants, farmworkers, or agrarian reform beneficiaries whose rights might be affected.

  8. Affidavit of Non-Tenancy (if no tenants or farmworkers exist on the land)

    • Some DAR offices require an affidavit to confirm no tenants or agrarian beneficiaries will be adversely affected.

  9. Special Power of Attorney (If Represented by Another Person)

    • If the landowner or transferee designates another individual to process the clearance.

  10. Other DAR or LGU Documents

    • Depending on local DAR Provincial Office (PARO) or Municipal Agrarian Reform Office (MARO) regulations, the applicant may be asked to provide supplemental documents (e.g., proof of payment of real property taxes, sworn statements, etc.).

V. Procedure for Obtaining DAR Clearance

  1. Filing of Application

    • The landowner or his/her authorized representative files the application for DAR clearance at the DAR Provincial Office (PARO) or Municipal Agrarian Reform Office (MARO) having jurisdiction over the subject property.

  2. Preliminary Assessment

    • The DAR officer conducts a preliminary check to ensure the documents are complete. Any deficiencies or clarifications will be communicated to the applicant.

  3. Field Investigation / Ocular Inspection

    • A DAR field inspection team may conduct an on-site investigation to verify land use, boundaries, presence of tenants/farmworkers, and other pertinent details.

  4. Evaluation by the Legal / Technical Division

    • The DAR Legal Division (or designated officer) checks whether the land is still covered by or needed for land distribution under CARP. They also confirm whether the size being transferred adheres to retention rules and whether any rightful agrarian beneficiaries might be prejudiced.

  5. Issuance or Denial of Clearance

    • If the application meets all legal requirements, the DAR will issue a clearance (often in the form of a Certification of DAR Clearance).
    • If the property is found to be covered by agrarian reform or if the transfer violates the retention limit or the rights of agrarian reform beneficiaries, DAR may deny the application. In such cases, the transferee or landowner may have to file a motion for reconsideration or pursue other legal remedies.

  6. Registration of Clearance and Transfer

    • Upon receiving DAR clearance, the applicant proceeds to the Registry of Deeds (ROD) to register the approved deed of conveyance. The DAR clearance is usually presented along with other transfer documents (e.g., Transfer Tax payment, Capital Gains Tax receipt, Documentary Stamp Tax receipt) for the ROD’s processing of title transfer.

VI. Common Issues and Challenges

  1. Incomplete or Incorrect Documentation

    • Many applications are delayed due to missing, outdated, or incorrect documents (e.g., errors in the technical description, mismatched names on the title and the deed, outdated surveys).

  2. Existing Tenancy or Pending Agrarian Cases

    • The presence of tenancy relationships or pending agrarian disputes complicates the issuance of DAR clearance. Additional hearings or the resolution of these issues might be required before DAR can act on the transfer application.

  3. Overlapping Jurisdictions

    • Sometimes, local government units (LGUs) or landowners treat reclassified land as automatically exempt from DAR clearance. In reality, DAR retains the authority to verify and confirm that the reclassification is valid and that the land is indeed exempt from CARP coverage.

  4. Confusion Over Retention Rights

    • Landowners may believe they retain five hectares plus an additional three hectares for every heir. However, such children must meet specific criteria (at least 15 years old and directly managing or tilling the land) to be considered for additional retention. Failure to clarify or prove these details can result in denial of clearance or revocation of previously granted rights.

  5. Time Constraints and Processing Delays

    • Like many bureaucratic processes, obtaining DAR clearance can take several weeks or even months, especially in areas with high volumes of applications or limited DAR personnel.

VII. Legal Consequences for Non-Compliance

  1. Nullity of Transfer

    • A transfer of agricultural land above five hectares without DAR clearance can be declared null and void for violating R.A. No. 6657 and related regulations.

  2. Administrative Sanctions

    • The DAR may impose administrative fines or penalties on parties circumventing agrarian reform laws.

  3. Criminal Liability

    • If fraud or misrepresentation is involved (e.g., falsification of documents, intentionally hiding tenancy arrangements), the parties may be held criminally liable under pertinent laws (e.g., Revised Penal Code, other special laws).

  4. Possible Revocation of Title

    • The Register of Deeds can refuse to register the transaction if it lacks the required DAR clearance. If the transfer is already registered without DAR clearance, DAR can initiate legal action for the cancellation or revocation of the title.

VIII. Practical Tips for Landowners and Transferees

  1. Conduct Due Diligence Early

    • Prospective buyers should verify if the land is within the retention limit or if any agrarian beneficiaries have pending claims or if reclassification orders exist.

  2. Seek Professional Advice

    • Engaging a lawyer or a consultant who specializes in agrarian laws can help navigate documentary requirements, expedite the process, and resolve issues if they arise.

  3. Maintain Accurate Records

    • Landowners should always keep updated titles, tax declarations, and other relevant documents. Any boundary or technical description discrepancies discovered late can cause expensive delays.

  4. Verify Tenancy Situations

    • If the property has tenants or sharecroppers, discuss arrangements, ensure that their rights are not violated, or coordinate with DAR on the appropriate remedy (e.g., leasehold agreements, coverage under CARP, etc.).

  5. Follow Up with DAR Offices

    • Monitoring the progress of your clearance application is crucial. Regular communication with the MARO/PARO can help ensure a smoother process and prevent unforeseen delays.

IX. Conclusion

The requirement to secure a DAR clearance before transferring agricultural land over five hectares is a cornerstone of the Philippine agrarian reform program. It ensures that land transfers do not undermine agrarian reform’s aim of promoting social justice and equitable land distribution. Landowners and prospective buyers alike must understand and follow the legal procedures—from submission of complete documentation to timely compliance with DAR findings.

Given the complexity of agrarian laws, it is advisable to consult with legal counsel, agrarian reform experts, or DAR officials to navigate the clearance process. Ultimately, strict compliance not only safeguards the integrity of one’s property rights but also upholds the constitutional and legislative intent behind the country’s agrarian reform efforts.

References:

  • 1987 Philippine Constitution, Article XIII (Social Justice and Human Rights)
  • Republic Act No. 6657 (Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Law), as amended by Republic Act No. 9700
  • DAR Administrative Orders (e.g., A.O. No. 1, Series of 1989; subsequent AOs)
  • Various DAR Memorandum Circulars on land transfer and DAR clearance procedures
  • Relevant jurisprudence (e.g., Supreme Court decisions) clarifying coverage, retention rights, and DAR’s authority over agricultural land transfers.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal concerns or disputes, it is best to consult a qualified attorney or to coordinate directly with the Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR) and other relevant government agencies.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login