Defending Against Harassment Claims

Below is a general, comprehensive overview of defending against harassment claims in the Philippine context. This discussion draws from relevant laws, regulations, and principles under Philippine jurisprudence. Please note that this is general information and not a substitute for advice from a qualified legal professional.

1. Overview of Harassment in Philippine Law

1.1. Key Legal Provisions

  1. Revised Penal Code (RPC)

    • Although the RPC does not define “harassment” as a stand-alone crime, several criminal offenses can be used to punish harassing behavior. Examples include:
      • Unjust Vexation (punishable under Article 287 of the RPC),
      • Slander by Deed (Article 359),
      • Acts of Lasciviousness (Article 336),
      • and other crimes depending on the nature and severity of the acts.

  2. Republic Act No. 7877 (Anti-Sexual Harassment Act of 1995)

    • Prohibits sexual harassment committed in a work, education, or training environment, where a person has authority or influence over another.
    • Requires institutions (e.g., companies, schools) to create rules and regulations, as well as a Committee on Decorum and Investigation (CODI).

  3. Republic Act No. 11313 (Safe Spaces Act or “Bawal Bastos” Law)

    • Addresses gender-based harassment in public spaces (e.g., streets, public parks, transportation), online spaces, and workplaces.
    • Expands coverage of punishable acts to include wolf-whistling, catcalling, misogynistic slurs, unwanted sexual advances, and other forms of harassment.
    • In a workplace context, it mandates employers to prevent and punish workplace harassment more comprehensively than RA 7877.

  4. Labor Code of the Philippines & Department Orders (DOLE)

    • The Labor Code mandates employers to maintain a safe working environment, which implicitly disallows harassment. DOLE has also issued guidelines (e.g., DOLE Department Order No. 208, s. 2020, on the Safe Spaces Act in the workplace) reinforcing anti-harassment policies.

1.2. Types of Harassment Claims

  • Workplace Sexual Harassment: Involves unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, or other verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature, particularly where the alleged harasser has authority or influence.
  • Online Harassment: Under RA 11313, online sexual harassment (cyberstalking, repeated unwanted messages, public shaming, etc.) can be grounds for a complaint.
  • Public/Street Harassment: Under RA 11313, gender-based harassment in public spaces (catcalling, lewd gestures) can lead to administrative or criminal liability.
  • Bullying/Hostile Environment: Though not always labeled “harassment,” repeated acts that cause another person mental or emotional distress may trigger claims under unjust vexation or similar offenses.

2. Elements of a Harassment Claim

2.1. Under RA 7877 (Sexual Harassment in Work/Education)

  1. There must be a demand, request, or requirement for sexual favor.
  2. The act must be unwelcome or offensive to the victim.
  3. The offender has moral ascendancy or influence over the victim (e.g., teacher-student, employer-employee).
  4. The sexual favor is made a condition of employment, promotion, or any benefit in the workplace or a condition for favorable grades or scholarships in an educational environment.

2.2. Under RA 11313 (Safe Spaces Act)

  1. Gender-based streets and public spaces sexual harassment: Includes catcalling, wolf-whistling, unwanted invitations, misogynistic remarks, persistent telling of sexual jokes, use of words or gestures ridiculing a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity, among others.
  2. Online sexual harassment: Acts committed using information and communications technology such as repeated, unwanted sexual, misogynistic, or homophobic comments, or publication of sexual rumors.
  3. Workplace sexual harassment: Broader scope than RA 7877, covering any act that creates an intimidating, hostile, or humiliating environment for the victim, whether or not the perpetrator has direct authority.

2.3. Under the Revised Penal Code

  • The complainant may try to prove unjust vexation or slander by deed by showing intent to cause annoyance, irritation, or emotional distress.
  • More serious acts may constitute acts of lasciviousness (if sexual in nature), threats, coercion, or other crimes.

3. Common Defenses Against Harassment Claims

When defending against a harassment claim, respondents generally seek to show that one or more elements of the alleged offense are absent, or that procedural requirements were not followed. Common strategies include:

  1. Lack of Authority or Moral Ascendancy (for RA 7877 claims)

    • The respondent may argue that there was no supervisory or professional relationship that could have coerced the complainant.
    • If the alleged harasser had no power to influence employment or academic standing, the claim under RA 7877 may fail.

  2. Consent or Lack of “Unwelcome” Element

    • One of the central points of a harassment claim is that the conduct was unwelcome or unsolicited.
    • If the respondent can prove the act was part of a consensual or mutual interaction (e.g., friendly banter, mutual flirting, or an established personal relationship), this may negate the “unwelcome” element.

  3. Absence of Offensive Conduct

    • If the alleged statement or gesture is ordinary, non-sexual, or out of context with no intent of harassment, the respondent can argue that it does not meet the threshold of harassment.
    • Documentation, context, or witness testimony can help show that the act was not harassing but rather normal workplace or social interaction.

  4. Lack of Evidence

    • A strong defense can include showing the lack of substantive proof (e.g., no witnesses, no texts, no CCTV footage).
    • Harassment claims often rely on credibility and witness accounts; the respondent can challenge contradictions in the complainant’s statements or highlight inconsistencies.

  5. Procedural Defects

    • Particularly in workplace or school settings, claimants must follow internal grievance procedures (e.g., timely filing of complaints with the CODI).
    • Failure to file a complaint within the time limit (prescriptive period) or failure to follow mandatory steps can be raised by the respondent.

  6. Good Faith / Legitimate Business Reason (in certain workplace scenarios)

    • Sometimes what may appear to be “harassing” behavior could be part of legitimate supervisory acts (e.g., performance management, disciplinary action).
    • If the respondent can prove that the complainant’s allegations are a reaction to a legitimate corrective measure or a workplace evaluation, it can weaken a harassment claim.

4. Defending Against Harassment Claims: Practical Steps

  1. Gather Evidence

    • Collect relevant documents (e.g., emails, messages, social media posts, official memos).
    • Look for video footage or any other electronic data that can demonstrate the context.
    • Talk to potential witnesses who can corroborate your version of events.

  2. Prepare a Clear Narrative

    • Write down a detailed account of the incident(s): date, time, place, participants, and any relevant context.
    • Having a consistent, factual narrative helps if the case escalates to formal investigation or litigation.

  3. Cooperate with the Investigation

    • In the workplace or school setting, respond promptly to inquiries from the CODI (Committee on Decorum and Investigation).
    • Provide documentation and witnesses that can support your claims.

  4. Maintain Professional Conduct

    • Avoid any retaliatory or confrontational behavior against the complainant; this can be used against you.
    • Comply with any no-contact orders, restraining orders, or warnings issued.

  5. Seek Legal Representation

    • Once a formal case is filed, consult with an experienced lawyer or your company’s legal counsel, especially for criminal cases or those that may result in significant damages or administrative penalties.
    • Legal counsel can help draft responses, attend hearings, and guide you through mediation or settlement discussions if needed.

  6. Observe Time Limits (Prescriptive Periods)

    • Different laws have different prescription periods. For instance, under the Revised Penal Code, certain offenses must be filed within specific time frames after discovery or commission.
    • Under RA 7877 and RA 11313, check if there is a particular administrative or judicial deadline.

  7. Documentation of Company Policies

    • If a workplace harassment policy is in place, ensure you are aware of and can reference its provisions that support your defense (e.g., definitions, protocols for complaint investigations).

5. Potential Consequences if Found Liable

If the defense is not successful, the consequences can range from administrative penalties to criminal liability, depending on the nature and severity of the harassment:

  1. Administrative Penalties (Workplace/School)

    • Suspension, dismissal, demotion, or mandatory training under RA 7877, RA 11313, or company/school policy.
    • Sanctions by professional regulatory bodies (e.g., PRC) for licensed professionals.

  2. Criminal Penalties

    • Fines or imprisonment, particularly under the Safe Spaces Act or if the offense is prosecuted as unjust vexation, acts of lasciviousness, or other crimes under the RPC.
    • Additional fines or penalties for repeat offenders or aggravated circumstances.

  3. Civil Liabilities

    • The complainant may claim moral damages, exemplary damages, or other forms of compensation if harassment caused emotional distress or reputational harm.

6. Preventive Measures and Best Practices

6.1. For Individuals

  • Adhere to Professional Conduct: Be mindful of language, gestures, and jokes to avoid creating a hostile or uncomfortable atmosphere.
  • Understand Consent: Always ensure any potentially personal or intimate interactions are clearly consensual.
  • Respect Personal Boundaries: Especially in online interactions, do not repeatedly send messages or requests if the other party shows disinterest.

6.2. For Employers / Institutions

  • Clear Anti-Harassment Policies: Develop written guidelines defining harassment, specifying reporting procedures, and detailing potential sanctions.
  • Training and Orientation: Conduct regular training sessions or seminars to raise awareness of laws like RA 7877 and RA 11313.
  • Effective Investigation Mechanisms: Form an independent and well-trained Committee on Decorum and Investigation (CODI) or an equivalent body to handle complaints objectively.
  • Prompt Action: Once a complaint is raised, act quickly to investigate and resolve the matter; delays can worsen the situation and lead to liability.

7. Summary and Key Takeaways

  1. Know the Laws: Harassment in the Philippines can be addressed by multiple legal frameworks—RA 7877, RA 11313, and the Revised Penal Code, among others.
  2. Check the Elements: Most harassment claims have specific requirements (unwelcome conduct, moral ascendancy, etc.). A valid defense often focuses on disproving one or more of these legal elements.
  3. Documentation is Crucial: Preserving evidence (witness statements, messages, CCTV footage) is key to refuting or establishing harassment.
  4. Proper Procedure: Whether under workplace rules or criminal/civil law, procedures and deadlines must be observed. Procedural lapses can invalidate or weaken a claim.
  5. Legal Counsel: Given the complexity and seriousness of harassment allegations, professional legal advice is typically the best approach in formulating a robust defense.

Important Disclaimer

This article provides general legal information and does not constitute legal advice. Harassment laws in the Philippines are nuanced; individual cases may differ greatly based on their specific facts and circumstances. If you are involved in a harassment claim—whether as a complainant or respondent—it is advisable to consult a qualified Philippine attorney to obtain advice tailored to your situation.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login