Definition of Easement in Philippine Property Law

LEGAL ARTICLE: DEFINITION AND OVERVIEW OF EASEMENTS IN PHILIPPINE PROPERTY LAW

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal concerns, please consult a qualified attorney.

I. INTRODUCTION

An easement, under Philippine law, is a real right constituted over another person’s property (the servient estate) for the benefit of either a different property (the dominant estate) or a specific person or group (a personal easement). Easements are more traditionally referred to as servitudes in civil law jurisdictions and are governed primarily by the Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act No. 386).

Under the Civil Code, provisions on easements can be found in Articles 613 to 707. These articles outline how easements are created, defined, classified, and enforced, including the rights and obligations of both the owner of the servient estate and the beneficiary of the easement.

II. LEGAL BASIS

  1. Civil Code of the Philippines (Articles 613 to 707)

    • Articles 613–615: General provisions and definitions
    • Articles 616–640: Types, modes of creation, and rules on exercise
    • Articles 641–657: Legal easements (e.g., drainage of water, right of way)
    • Articles 658–666: Voluntary easements (e.g., easements created by agreement)
    • Articles 667–707: Specific regulations on party walls, light, and view easements, among others

  2. Jurisprudence

    • Judicial decisions of the Supreme Court often clarify the application of easement laws to particular fact patterns (e.g., rights of way, prescription, scope of easements).
    • Case law helps interpret the strict or liberal construction of easement provisions, especially regarding necessity, compensation, and location.

III. DEFINITIONS

  1. Easement/Servitude

    • A real right imposed on one property (servient estate) for the benefit of another property (dominant estate) or for a specific person or group.
    • It is real in nature because it attaches to the property itself, rather than to the owner’s personality.

  2. Dominant Estate

    • The property or person granted the benefit or advantage under the easement.
    • The owner of the dominant estate holds the beneficial use.

  3. Servient Estate

    • The property subject to the burden or encumbrance.
    • The owner of the servient estate must allow the easement to be exercised or refrain from acts inconsistent with the easement.

IV. CHARACTERISTICS AND NATURE OF EASEMENTS

  1. Real Right

    • Because an easement burdens the servient estate and benefits the dominant estate (or a person), it adheres to the property itself.
    • Successors-in-interest of both estates (heirs, buyers, etc.) are bound by the existing easement.

  2. Indivisible

    • An easement generally cannot be partially exercised. If it exists, it must be observed in total unless otherwise expressly limited in its constitution.

  3. Accessory Right

    • An easement is considered accessory to the dominant estate because it cannot exist independently if it is established to benefit another property.
    • By contrast, personal easements attach not to another property but to a person or entity; yet, they still maintain a real aspect in that they affect the servient estate.

  4. Limitations on Ownership

    • An easement limits the owner’s full enjoyment of the servient estate to the extent necessary for the enjoyment of the dominant estate (or the person entitled to the easement).

V. CLASSIFICATIONS OF EASEMENTS

Easements under Philippine law are categorized in various ways depending on how they are established and their purpose:

  1. As to Creation
    a. Legal Easements

    • Imposed by law for considerations of public interest or private necessity.
    • Common examples include easements of drainage of waters, right of way, light and view, party wall, and distance and intermediate spaces for certain constructions.

    b. Voluntary or Conventional Easements

    • Created by an act of agreement between parties (e.g., a contract in which the servient estate owner consents to the burden).
    • Must comply with the formalities of law, typically requiring a public instrument and registration if the easement is meant to affect third parties.

  2. As to the Beneficiary
    a. Real Easement (Predial Easement)

    • Constituted for the benefit of a dominant estate; the easement is inseparable from the property that benefits.

    b. Personal Easement

    • For the benefit of a particular person or entity, rather than a parcel of land.
    • It does not necessarily attach to any particular property of the beneficiary.

  3. As to Manner of Exercise
    a. Positive Easement

    • Entitles the dominant estate owner (or beneficiary) to perform certain acts on the servient estate (e.g., the right to lay down utility lines or pass through a portion of the property).

    b. Negative Easement

    • Requires the servient estate owner to refrain from doing something (e.g., building a structure above a certain height to keep an adjacent property’s view unobstructed).

  4. As to Apparent or Non-Apparent

    • Apparent easements exhibit external signs (e.g., a pathway, drainage canal) that show its use or existence.
    • Non-apparent easements are not readily visible (e.g., prohibition to build beyond a certain height).

VI. MODES OF CONSTITUTION

  1. Law

    • Legal easements arise by virtue of statutory mandates without any need for consent from the servient estate owner.

  2. Title or Contract

    • Express grant or agreement.
    • Must generally be in a public instrument to be binding on third parties and is typically subject to registration with the Registry of Property.

  3. Prescription

    • Certain easements, particularly apparent and continuous easements, may be acquired by continuous and uninterrupted use for the period prescribed by law (ordinarily 10 years, but always confirm the specific rules on prescription).

  4. Necessity

    • Some easements (e.g., right of way) can arise out of necessity if a property has no adequate outlet to a public road. The law may require the servient estate to provide a passage upon payment of just compensation.

VII. RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS OF THE PARTIES

  1. Owner of the Dominant Estate (or Beneficiary of the Easement)

    • Right to Use and Benefit: The holder is entitled to enjoy the easement strictly within the parameters established by law or agreement.
    • Preservation: The holder is generally responsible for repairs or maintenance necessary for the exercise of the easement (unless otherwise stipulated).

  2. Owner of the Servient Estate

    • Duty to Tolerate or Abstain: Must allow the easement’s exercise or refrain from acts that may impair it.
    • Right to Compensation: If the easement imposes expenses or diminishes the value of the servient estate beyond what the law deems acceptable, the servient estate owner may seek compensation, especially in cases of legal easements or rights of way.
    • Retention of Ownership: The servient estate owner retains ownership and may use the property in ways that do not encroach on the established easement.

  3. Limits on Use

    • Both parties should adhere to principles of good faith and reasonableness in exercising their respective rights.
    • If either party’s actions exceed lawful boundaries, the aggrieved party may seek injunctive relief or damages.

VIII. EXAMPLES OF COMMON LEGAL EASEMENTS

  1. Right of Way (Article 649, Civil Code)

    • Allows passage through a neighboring estate when a property has no suitable exit to a public road.
    • The location and the breadth of the right of way must cause the least damage to the servient estate and may be subject to just compensation.

  2. Drainage of Water (Article 637, Civil Code)

    • Lower estates are obliged to receive waters that naturally and without human intervention flow from higher estates.
    • Owners of higher estates cannot worsen or increase the burden of drainage beyond natural flow.

  3. Light and View (Articles 668–673, Civil Code)

    • Restrictions on servient estates may prevent constructions that obstruct light or view where there is a legal or agreed-upon easement.
    • Certain distances must be observed if openings (windows, balconies) overlook adjacent properties.

  4. Party Wall (Articles 658–666, Civil Code)

    • Common wall or fence dividing two adjacent lands.
    • Each owner can use the wall for construction up to half its thickness, subject to contribution to expenses.

IX. EXTINGUISHMENT OR TERMINATION OF EASEMENTS

Easements may be extinguished by any of the following:

  1. Merger

    • When ownership of both the dominant and servient estates is vested in the same person, the easement naturally extinguishes due to the impossibility of having an easement in one’s own property.

  2. Expiration of the Term or Condition

    • If the easement was constituted for a specific period or upon a certain condition which, once fulfilled, ends the easement.

  3. Abandonment or Renunciation

    • Express or tacit renunciation by the owner of the dominant estate (e.g., explicit statement or protracted non-use under circumstances suggesting abandonment).

  4. Prescription

    • Non-use of a continuous and apparent easement for ten (10) years can lead to its extinguishment.
    • For discontinuous easements (e.g., a right of way used only when needed), the prescriptive period typically starts from the day the easement was last used.

  5. Permanent Impossibility of Use

    • If an easement becomes permanently unusable (e.g., topographical changes or government expropriation), it may be deemed terminated.

X. RELEVANT PHILIPPINE JURISPRUDENCE

Over the years, the Supreme Court of the Philippines has interpreted easement laws in various cases. Although there are many decisions, a few key principles commonly reiterated include:

  1. Strict Necessity for a Right of Way

    • The courts generally require a showing that the dominant estate is genuinely landlocked or has no adequate route to the public highway. A mere convenience does not justify the imposition of a right of way.
    • Compensation must be just and reflect the burden to the servient estate.

  2. Good Faith in Prescription

    • Continuous, open, and public use (for a prescribed period) of an apparent easement may give rise to an easement by prescription if done in good faith and with knowledge (or constructive knowledge) of the servient estate owner.

  3. Least Prejudicial Condition

    • In cases of legal easements or judicially constituted easements, the location and manner of exercising the easement should be fixed such that it causes the least damage or inconvenience to the servient estate.

XI. PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS

  1. Documentation and Registration

    • Voluntary easements should be documented in writing (a public instrument), and when possible or required by law, registered with the Registry of Property (Register of Deeds). This ensures protection against third parties.

  2. Survey and Technical Description

    • In drafting easement agreements, a clear and accurate technical description (e.g., boundaries, coordinates) is critical to avoid future disputes.

  3. Neighborly Agreements vs. Judicial Action

    • Parties are encouraged to settle easement issues amicably. However, unresolved disputes may require judicial intervention, especially for establishing legal easements of necessity.

  4. Respect Local Zoning and Ordinances

    • Apart from the Civil Code, local ordinances and building codes may impose additional restrictions or guidelines. For instance, certain municipalities might have specific requirements regarding drainage easements or setbacks.

XII. CONCLUSION

Easements (or servitudes) are an integral part of Philippine property law, balancing individual ownership rights with the broader needs and benefits of neighboring properties or specific beneficiaries. By imposing a legally recognized encumbrance on one property for the benefit of another, easements help ensure equitable and practical use of land, ranging from essential access (rights of way) to protection of light and view.

The Civil Code of the Philippines (Articles 613–707) serves as the primary legal authority on the creation, classification, and extinguishment of easements, complemented by Supreme Court decisions that refine the application of these rules in real-world disputes. Proper documentation, adherence to legal requirements, and respectful negotiation between affected property owners remain the best practices to avoid and resolve conflicts regarding easements.

For tailored advice on easement matters—including drafting agreements, enforcing rights, or defending against improper claims—property owners and interested parties should consult legal counsel familiar with Philippine property law.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login