Delayed Salary Penalties Under the Philippine Penal Code

Delayed Salary Penalties Under Philippine Law
(Focusing on the interplay of the Labor Code and the Revised Penal Code)

1. Introduction

In the Philippines, workers enjoy robust legal protections to ensure timely payment of wages. These protections are primarily found not under the Revised Penal Code (RPC) but under labor legislation, particularly the Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended). While many people refer informally to “penalties under the Penal Code,” in practice, issues concerning delayed salaries (or non-payment of wages) are generally governed by specific penal provisions within the Labor Code itself and not by stand-alone articles of the Revised Penal Code.

This article will examine:

  1. Relevant provisions under the Labor Code that penalize delayed or non-payment of wages.
  2. The administrative, civil, and criminal liabilities that may arise from these violations.
  3. The limited instances where the Revised Penal Code may be invoked (e.g., if fraud or deceit is involved).
  4. Practical remedies for workers experiencing delayed salaries.

2. Legal Basis for Timely Payment of Wages

2.1. The Labor Code of the Philippines

The Labor Code provides the principal rules regarding payment of wages:

  1. Article 103 (Renumbered) – Time of Payment

    • Wages must be paid at least once every two (2) weeks or twice a month at intervals not exceeding sixteen (16) days.
    • Payment must be made within the working hours, and not outside the workplace, except in very specific circumstances allowed by regulations.

  2. Article 116 (Renumbered) – Withholding of Wages and Kickbacks

    • Prohibits the withholding of any part of the worker’s wages unless authorized by law.
    • Prohibits the employer from requiring employees to return or “kickback” any portion of their wages.

  3. Article 300 to 303 (Previously Articles 285 to 288) – Penalties and Enforcement

    • The Labor Code includes penal provisions that may impose fines or imprisonment for violations, including non-payment or delay in payment of wages.

Although people loosely refer to “the Penal Code,” the truth is that the Labor Code itself contains penal provisions—that is, criminal sanctions for certain labor law violations. These provisions function much like the provisions in the Revised Penal Code but are specific to labor offenses.

2.2. Revised Penal Code: Rare But Possible Overlap

While there is no direct article in the Revised Penal Code that punishes mere delayed salary payment as a crime, certain employer conduct surrounding non-payment or delayed payment may, in rare cases, lead to liability under the Revised Penal Code (e.g., if fraud, deceit, or illegal deductions are involved). For instance:

  • Estafa (Swindling) under Article 315, RPC: If an employer maliciously withholds wages through deceitful means (e.g., collecting funds purportedly for salaries but converting them to personal use), an aggrieved employee could, theoretically, file a criminal complaint for estafa.

However, most wage-related disputes—especially those involving delay—are handled administratively and civilly through labor tribunals (Department of Labor and Employment [DOLE], National Labor Relations Commission [NLRC]) rather than under the Revised Penal Code.

3. Penalties for Delayed Wages Under the Labor Code

Under the Labor Code, delayed or non-payment of wages can subject the employer to administrative, civil, or criminal liabilities:

  1. Administrative Liability

    • The Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) may impose administrative fines for failure to comply with labor standards on payment of wages.
    • Employers may be required to pay monetary relief to employees, including unpaid wages, interest, and sometimes additional damages.

  2. Civil Liability

    • An employee can file a complaint with the NLRC to recover unpaid wages, plus legal interest from the date the salary became due.
    • The Labor Arbiter can also award moral and/or exemplary damages if there is a finding of bad faith or malice.
    • Under certain circumstances, the Labor Arbiter or the NLRC may also order the payment of attorney’s fees equivalent to 10% of the total monetary award.

  3. Criminal Liability (Penal Provisions of the Labor Code)

    • If the employer’s refusal or failure to pay wages is found to be willful or done in bad faith, it may be deemed a criminal offense under the Labor Code’s penal provisions.
    • Article 303 (formerly Article 288) of the Labor Code provides:

      “Any violation of the provisions of this Title for which no penalty has been provided shall be punished with a fine of not less than ₱1,000 nor more than ₱10,000 or imprisonment of not less than three (3) months nor more than three (3) years, or both such fine and imprisonment at the discretion of the court.”

    • This can apply to employers who repeatedly or deliberately delay wages in defiance of lawful orders or who fail to pay after having been found liable by final judgment.

  4. Other Consequences

    • Closure or Suspension of Business Operations: The DOLE may issue a Work Stoppage Order or Closure Order against establishments that flagrantly violate labor standards.
    • Blacklisting for Government Projects: Contractors or suppliers dealing with the government might lose their eligibility if found guilty of labor standard violations.

4. Key Elements for Criminal Liability Under the Labor Code

To trigger the penal provisions of the Labor Code (which effectively function as a “penal code” for labor violations), the following must be proven:

  1. Existence of an employer-employee relationship.
  2. Willful and deliberate failure to pay or unjustified delay in the payment of wages.
  3. A violation of the mandated timelines under Article 103 (or relevant DOLE regulations).
  4. Non-compliance despite lawful orders, or existence of bad faith in withholding wages (e.g., the employer had the financial capacity to pay but intentionally withheld wages).

It is generally not enough that an employer simply lacked funds. A mere claim of financial difficulty is not a blanket defense if it is proven that the employer did have resources or misappropriated funds.

5. Filing Complaints and Remedies

Employees who suffer from delayed salaries can pursue the following avenues:

  1. Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) – Regional Offices

    • For smaller money claims or straightforward labor standard violations, employees can approach the nearest DOLE office.
    • DOLE labor inspectors may inspect the workplace and issue compliance orders.

  2. National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC)

    • For larger money claims or more complex disputes, employees may file a complaint with the NLRC.
    • The Labor Arbiter will conduct mandatory conciliation/mediation; if unresolved, the case proceeds to arbitration and decision.

  3. Criminal Complaint

    • If the violation is willful and covered by the penal provisions of the Labor Code, the employee (or DOLE) can file a criminal complaint before the Office of the Prosecutor.
    • The Prosecutor will determine if there is probable cause for criminal charges.

  4. Civil Action for Damages

    • In some instances, employees file a separate civil action for damages if they have suffered injury beyond the delayed wages (e.g., reputational harm, specific monetary losses due to non-payment).

6. Interest, Damages, and Attorney’s Fees

When wages are delayed or withheld without justification:

  • Legal Interest: The Supreme Court has ruled that monetary awards arising from unpaid wages typically earn 6% interest per annum (subject to changes in prevailing jurisprudence and relevant circulars).
  • Moral and Exemplary Damages: If the delay is in bad faith or accompanied by malice.
  • Attorney’s Fees: Commonly, labor cases allow for an award of attorney’s fees up to 10% of the total recovery.

7. Intersection with the Revised Penal Code

As noted, the Revised Penal Code (RPC) rarely applies to mere delays in salary payment. However, certain employer practices could cross over into RPC violations:

  • Estafa (Swindling): If an employer uses deceit to obtain labor without the intention of paying wages.
  • Other Forms of Deceit: If there is falsification of payrolls or fraudulent misrepresentation that leads employees to continue working without pay.

These scenarios, however, are exceptional and require clear evidence of criminal intent or fraudulent machination. Most delayed salary cases remain labor disputes under the Labor Code’s purview.

8. Practical Tips and Compliance Measures for Employers

  1. Set Clear Pay Schedules: Ensure compliance with the Labor Code requirement to pay at least twice a month at intervals not exceeding sixteen (16) days.
  2. Maintain Sufficient Cash Flow: Keep payroll funds segregated from other corporate accounts to avoid unintended use of salary funds.
  3. Document and Communicate: If delays are unavoidable (e.g., a banking systems glitch), inform employees promptly and in writing, while providing a definite timetable for release.
  4. Consult with Legal Counsel: In case of genuine financial difficulty, coordinate with DOLE for any remedial measures. Employers must be mindful that good faith alone may not exempt them from liability if wages remain unpaid beyond the allowable period.

9. Conclusion

Delayed salary payment is not typically litigated directly under the Revised Penal Code; instead, it falls under the penal provisions of the Labor Code, which carry possible fines and imprisonment. Philippine law imposes strict standards to protect employees’ rights to timely wages, reflecting the Constitution’s policy favoring labor. Although the door to RPC-based charges (like estafa) remains open if fraud or deceit is involved, most wage-related disputes—especially simple delays—will be addressed through administrative and labor litigation channels.

For workers facing delayed wages, the immediate remedy is to file a complaint with DOLE or the NLRC, which can order payment of salaries plus interest and damages. Where there is willful refusal to pay, employees and labor authorities can pursue criminal action under the Labor Code’s penal provisions. Ultimately, both employees and employers are advised to understand their rights and obligations under the Labor Code, remain compliant with wage-related laws, and seek timely legal advice to avoid protracted disputes and possible criminal liability.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login