Determining Fair Market Value of Land in Daraga Albay Philippines

DETERMINING THE FAIR MARKET VALUE OF LAND IN DARAGA, ALBAY (PHILIPPINES): A LEGAL OVERVIEW

1. Introduction

Fair Market Value (FMV) lies at the heart of many real estate transactions in the Philippines, serving as the basis for taxation, sales, expropriation, and other property-related dealings. In Daraga, a municipality in the province of Albay, determining FMV must comply with Philippine laws and local ordinances. This article explores the legal framework, processes, and key considerations in establishing the fair market value of real property in Daraga, Albay, paying close attention to the relevant rules and regulations under Philippine law.

2. Definition of Fair Market Value

Under Philippine jurisprudence, Fair Market Value refers to the price at which a property—tangible or intangible—would be exchanged between a willing buyer and a willing seller, both having reasonable knowledge of all relevant facts, and neither under any compulsion to conclude the transaction. This definition is rooted in various Supreme Court rulings and is reflected in how local government units (LGUs) and other government agencies conduct property valuation.

3. Legal Framework Governing Real Property Valuation in the Philippines

  1. The 1987 Philippine Constitution

    • Mandates the State to promote the equitable distribution of property, protect property rights, and ensure just compensation in cases of expropriation.

  2. Local Government Code of 1991 (Republic Act No. 7160)

    • Provides comprehensive guidelines for local governments, including municipalities like Daraga, to create Schedules of Fair Market Values (SFMV) and to impose real property taxes based on these valuations.
    • Grants the Sanggunian (local legislative body) the power to periodically revise the SFMV to reflect current market conditions.
    • Empowers the Provincial or Municipal Assessor to conduct assessments of properties and recommend FMVs for tax purposes.

  3. Real Property Tax Code (Presidential Decree No. 464), as amended

    • Although partially superseded by RA 7160, it still provides certain foundational principles for property assessment and classification.

  4. Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) Regulations

    • The BIR issues Zonal Values which are used for tax purposes (e.g., computing capital gains tax, documentary stamp tax). While zonal values are indicative of market prices, they do not always match the actual open-market prices but serve as one benchmark in determining FMV.

  5. Relevant Supreme Court Decisions

    • The Supreme Court has consistently held that the determination of FMV must be grounded on evidence of actual market transactions, classification of the property (e.g., agricultural, residential, commercial), and other relevant factors such as location and improvements.

  6. Expropriation Laws (Rules of Court, Rule 67)

    • In cases where property is forcibly acquired by the government for public use, “just compensation” must be based on the fair market value of the property at the time of taking.
    • Courts consider various elements such as the property’s nature, actual use, classification, and improvements to determine compensation.

4. The Role of the Local Government of Daraga, Albay

  1. Municipal Assessor’s Office

    • The Municipal Assessor’s Office of Daraga is the primary body responsible for assessing real property for taxation.
    • The Assessor conducts field appraisals, investigates sales data, examines property records, and prepares assessment rolls.
    • These assessments form the basis for the Schedule of Fair Market Values approved by the Sangguniang Bayan (municipal council).

  2. Sangguniang Bayan

    • Approves ordinances adopting or updating the schedule of fair market values for different property classifications (residential, commercial, industrial, agricultural, etc.).
    • Revises these schedules periodically—ideally every three years or as needed—to ensure valuations keep pace with actual market conditions.

  3. Local Treasury Office

    • Utilizes these valuations to compute real property taxes.
    • Collects taxes that fund local government projects, services, and infrastructure.

5. Key Factors Influencing Land Valuation in Daraga

  1. Location and Neighborhood

    • Proximity to commercial centers, roads, schools, hospitals, and other public amenities can significantly affect land value.
    • In Daraga, lands near major thoroughfares or tourist areas (e.g., those with a view of Mayon Volcano) may command higher prices.

  2. Classification and Zoning

    • Properties are classified as residential, commercial, agricultural, or industrial under local zoning ordinances.
    • Agricultural lands, especially those used for rice or coconut farming, may have a different (typically lower) FMV compared to prime commercial lots in the town center.
    • Zoning reclassifications—such as conversion of agricultural land to residential or commercial use—can sharply increase FMV.

  3. Physical Characteristics of the Property

    • Size and shape of the lot
    • Topography and elevation (flood-prone areas might have lower value)
    • Presence of improvements such as buildings, fences, or irrigation systems

  4. Supply and Demand

    • As Daraga continues to develop (partly influenced by tourism, the Legazpi Airport nearby, and infrastructure projects), the demand for real estate may rise, pushing land values higher.

  5. Local Economic Factors

    • Job growth, commercial development, and local government initiatives (e.g., new roads or public markets) can boost demand for certain types of real estate, influencing FMVs.

6. Methods and Processes of Valuation

  1. Market Data (Comparable Sales) Approach

    • Involves analyzing recent sales of comparable properties to derive an estimate of the property’s likely selling price.
    • Requires the availability of reliable data on similar properties sold in or around Daraga.

  2. Cost Approach

    • Typically used when there are limited market transactions or the property has unique improvements.
    • Values land based on its estimated FMV and adds the cost of reproducing or replacing the improvements, less depreciation.

  3. Income Capitalization Approach

    • Relevant for properties that generate rental income, such as commercial buildings or agricultural land under lease.
    • Calculates the present worth of future income streams.

  4. Use of BIR Zonal Values

    • Although not definitive of actual FMV, BIR Zonal Values provide a reference point.
    • If the actual market data is scarce or difficult to verify, parties sometimes use zonal values as a starting benchmark.

  5. Local Assessor’s Schedule of Fair Market Values

    • Reflects average market prices within specific areas and classifications.
    • Is a product of studies, surveys, and consultations performed by the Assessor’s Office, then legislated by the Sangguniang Bayan.

7. Fair Market Value in Specific Legal Contexts

  1. Real Property Taxation

    • Real Property Tax (RPT) is computed based on the Assessed Value of the property, which is a percentage of its Fair Market Value as shown in the Local Schedule of Fair Market Values.
    • Property owners are required to pay annual RPT to the Daraga Municipal Treasurer.

  2. Expropriation (Just Compensation)

    • The government or its authorized agents can acquire private property for public use, following due process and payment of just compensation.
    • Courts typically appoint commissioners to determine FMV, considering evidence such as comparable sales and property characteristics.
    • “Just compensation” must reflect the fair market value at the time of the taking or the filing of the expropriation complaint, whichever is earlier.

  3. Inheritance and Donation Taxes

    • When property is transmitted by succession or donated, the BIR often relies on Zonal Values or the property’s declared FMV for tax computations (estate tax, donor’s tax).
    • If the declared FMV is lower than the BIR Zonal Value, the BIR generally uses the higher figure to assess taxes.

  4. Capital Gains Tax and Documentary Stamp Tax

    • For sales of real property, the capital gains tax (or creditable withholding tax for corporations) and documentary stamp tax are based on whichever is higher: the actual selling price, the zonal value, or the local Assessor’s FMV.

  5. Agrarian Reform

    • Agricultural lands may be covered by the Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program (CARP). If expropriated for agrarian reform, the land valuation follows DAR (Department of Agrarian Reform) guidelines.
    • These guidelines account for production, comparable sales in the area, and the land’s tax declaration value.

8. Challenges and Practical Considerations

  1. Inconsistent Data or Outdated Schedules

    • Local governments may not revise Schedules of Fair Market Values regularly, leading to outdated valuations.
    • In Daraga, as in many municipalities, data on recent property sales may be incomplete or unrecorded, hampering accurate market-based assessments.

  2. Undeclared or Under-declared Transactions

    • Some sellers and buyers under-declare property values to reduce taxes, distorting market data and making accurate FMV determination difficult.

  3. Political and Economic Factors

    • Changes in local governance can influence how soon valuations are updated.
    • Economic downturns or surges can cause rapid shifts in property values.

  4. Public Opposition to Higher Tax Assessments

    • Attempts to update FMVs (to reflect current market conditions) may face resistance from property owners concerned about higher property taxes.

9. Best Practices for Ensuring Accurate Valuations

  1. Regular Revision of Valuation Schedules

    • LGUs should update the Schedule of Fair Market Values at least once every three years, as recommended by the Local Government Code.

  2. Transparency and Proper Data Management

    • The Assessor’s Office should maintain a comprehensive database of recent property transactions, including declared sales prices and property characteristics.

  3. Professional Appraisal Methods

    • Engaging certified appraisers and valuation experts enhances credibility and accuracy.
    • Modern approaches, including Geographic Information Systems (GIS), can help track real-time sales data and property characteristics.

  4. Public Consultations and Education

    • The LGU should conduct public hearings and information campaigns whenever valuations are updated, fostering greater understanding and acceptance among stakeholders.

  5. Coordination with the BIR

    • Harmonizing the LGU’s valuation data with BIR zonal values can minimize discrepancies.
    • While they need not match exactly, regular coordination ensures both sets of values more accurately reflect local market realities.

10. Conclusion

Determining the fair market value of land in Daraga, Albay involves a complex interplay of legal requirements, administrative procedures, and market-based factors. Philippine law—primarily through the Local Government Code of 1991 and various BIR regulations—establishes the statutory framework for valuation. Local officials, particularly the Municipal Assessor and the Sangguniang Bayan, play a crucial role in crafting and approving Schedules of Fair Market Values reflective of real-world prices. Courts, in expropriation cases, ensure that property owners receive just compensation based on established principles.

Ultimately, accurate FMV determination rests on transparency, reliable market data, and regular updates to valuation schedules. As Daraga’s economy evolves, fair and current valuations benefit both the local government (through equitable tax collection) and property owners (through fair sales prices and just compensation, when applicable). By adhering to legal mandates and best practices in valuation, Daraga and its residents can promote equitable, efficient, and sustainable growth in the local real estate market.

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific concerns about real property valuation in Daraga or elsewhere in the Philippines, it is prudent to consult a qualified attorney, a licensed real estate appraiser, or the relevant government offices.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login