Drafting a Binding Promissory Note

Below is a comprehensive legal article on drafting a binding promissory note in the Philippine context. This article aims to give an overview of the essential features, legal framework, and best practices for creating a valid and enforceable promissory note. Please note that this is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. If you require specific guidance, consult a qualified attorney in the Philippines.

1. Introduction

A promissory note is a written promise to pay a specified sum of money to a certain person or entity at a particular time (or on demand). It serves as a formal evidence of indebtedness. In the Philippines, promissory notes are governed primarily by the following:

  • The Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act No. 386, as amended);
  • The Negotiable Instruments Law (Act No. 2031);
  • Jurisprudence (court decisions) interpreting and applying these laws.

While the Negotiable Instruments Law covers broader rules on negotiable instruments (including promissory notes), parties should also consider relevant provisions of the Civil Code on obligations and contracts. Properly drafted promissory notes help avoid confusion, misunderstanding, and legal disputes between parties.

2. Definition and Characteristics

2.1 Definition

Under Act No. 2031 (Negotiable Instruments Law), a promissory note is defined as:

“An unconditional promise in writing made by one person to another, signed by the maker, engaging to pay on demand, or at a fixed or determinable future time, a sum certain in money, to order or to bearer.”

2.2 Key Characteristics of a Valid Promissory Note

  1. In Writing – The note must be in written form (handwritten, typed, or printed) to be enforceable.
  2. Unconditional Promise to Pay – It must contain a clear, unequivocal promise to pay.
  3. Definite Parties – The person who promises to pay (the “maker”) and the person to whom payment is promised (the “payee”) must be clearly identified.
  4. Fixed or Determinable Sum of Money – The amount must be clearly stated and unambiguous.
  5. Payable on Demand or at a Future Date – The payment terms must specify when the obligation is due.
  6. Signed by the Maker – The maker’s signature signifies acceptance of the obligations stated in the note.

Promissory notes can be negotiable or non-negotiable. A negotiable promissory note can be transferred to other parties (e.g., by endorsement), allowing the holder in due course to enforce the note under certain protections. A non-negotiable note does not enjoy these protections but still remains binding between the original parties.

3. Essential Elements in Drafting a Promissory Note

When drafting a binding promissory note in the Philippines, consider including the following elements:

  1. Title

    • Clearly label the document as a “Promissory Note.”

  2. Date and Place of Execution

    • Indicate the date when the note is executed.
    • Specifying the place of execution can also be helpful for jurisdictional or reference purposes.

  3. Names and Details of the Parties

    • Identify the maker (the one who promises to pay) and the payee (the person or entity entitled to receive payment).
    • Include addresses and other relevant contact details.

  4. Principal Amount

    • State the principal amount in both words and figures to minimize the risk of ambiguity or alteration.

  5. Payment Terms

    • Due Date(s): Clearly indicate whether the sum is payable on a specific date or on demand.
    • Installment Schedule (if applicable): If you agree on installment payments, provide a clear schedule (e.g., monthly, quarterly) and specify the due dates.
    • Interest Rate: Stipulate the agreed-upon interest rate. Although the Usury Law in the Philippines has been effectively suspended, courts may still step in to reduce unconscionable rates. A reasonable interest rate should be indicated.

  6. Default and Acceleration Clause

    • An acceleration clause allows the payee to declare the entire unpaid balance due if the maker defaults on any installment. This helps protect the payee if the maker fails to meet the payment schedule.

  7. Penalties and Late Charges

    • You may specify penalties or late charges for overdue payments (e.g., late payment penalty). Again, ensure these are not unconscionable or grossly excessive to avoid potential reduction by the courts.

  8. Mode of Payment

    • Stipulate the payment method (e.g., cash, check, bank deposit).
    • If paying by check, indicate whether post-dated checks are acceptable and any terms relating to them.

  9. Security or Collateral (if any)

    • If the note is secured by collateral (e.g., real property, personal property), include a clear reference and possibly attach or cite a separate security agreement.
    • Ensure you follow the appropriate laws for pledges, mortgages, or chattel mortgages, as applicable.

  10. Governing Law and Venue

    • State that the note is governed by Philippine laws.
    • Specify a venue for dispute resolution if litigation becomes necessary (though note that venue stipulations must still conform to Philippine Rules of Court requirements on proper venue).

  11. Waiver of Notice (if applicable)

    • The maker might waive certain notices, such as notice of dishonor or protest, but only if it aligns with law.

  12. Notarization (Optional but Recommended)

    • Philippine law generally does not require a promissory note to be notarized to be valid. However, notarization can strengthen the note’s evidentiary value in court by converting it into a public document, which has a higher presumption of validity.

  13. Signatures

    • The maker must sign. In some cases, the payee may also sign to acknowledge acceptance or understanding of the note.
    • If the maker is a corporation or a business entity, the authorized signatory must sign and indicate the position/title under the company’s authorization.

4. Legal Framework in the Philippines

4.1 Negotiable Instruments Law (Act No. 2031)

  • Enacted in 1911, this law governs the requirements and liabilities related to negotiable instruments such as checks, bills of exchange, and promissory notes.
  • Provides protections for a holder in due course, who acquires the note in good faith and for value, but it applies only if the promissory note meets the criteria for negotiability.

4.2 Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act No. 386)

  • Contains general provisions on obligations and contracts (Articles 1156 to 1304).
  • Sets out the basic requirements for a valid contract (consent, object certain, and cause).
  • Governs interest rate stipulations under Article 2209 and related jurisprudence.

4.3 Usury Law (Act No. 2655)

  • Although interest ceilings under the Usury Law are no longer strictly enforced due to circulars from the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) and Supreme Court rulings, an interest rate can be declared void for being unconscionable.
  • Courts have the authority to reduce an excessive interest rate.

4.4 Rules of Court

  • Relevant when enforcing the note through court action (e.g., jurisdiction, venue, and procedure for collection suits).

5. Enforceability and Remedies

5.1 Judicial Demand

If a maker defaults on payment, the payee may file a collection suit (also known as an action for sum of money) in the appropriate trial court. The court will require:

  • The original promissory note or a duly authenticated copy.
  • Evidence of default (e.g., past due amount, demand letters).
  • Proof of the total amount owed, including interest and penalties.

5.2 Extra-Judicial Remedies (Where Applicable)

  • Negotiation/Amicable Settlement: Parties may settle the debt without litigation.
  • Foreclosure (if collaterals are involved): If the promissory note is secured by a mortgage or a chattel mortgage, the payee might foreclose on the collateral in case of default, following legal foreclosure procedures.

5.3 Defenses of the Maker

Common defenses in a collection case include:

  1. Lack of Consideration: Arguing the note was executed without any real debt or money exchanged.
  2. Fraud or Duress: Alleging the note was signed due to deception or unlawful pressure.
  3. Forged Signature: Claiming the signature is not that of the purported maker.
  4. Alteration of the Note: Significant unauthorized changes made to the terms or amounts.
  5. Payment Already Made: Showing proof of payment or settlement that satisfies the obligation.

6. Negotiability vs. Non-Negotiability

6.1 Negotiable Promissory Notes

  • Can be freely transferred (endorsed) to a new holder, who becomes the new owner of the note.
  • A “holder in due course” enjoys certain protections if the note was acquired in good faith and for value (e.g., limited defenses against payment).

6.2 Non-Negotiable Promissory Notes

  • Not transferable in the same manner as negotiable instruments.
  • Still enforceable between the original parties based on general contract law.

A promissory note must comply strictly with the Negotiable Instruments Law to be considered negotiable (e.g., an unconditional promise to pay a sum certain, payable on demand or at a fixed time, etc.). If any condition or additional undertaking is attached, it may lose its negotiable character.

7. Drafting Tips and Best Practices

  1. Clarity is Key: Use clear and unambiguous language. Ambiguities can lead to protracted disputes.
  2. Consistency: State the amount both in words and numbers. If there is a discrepancy, the words generally prevail, but consistency eliminates confusion.
  3. Interest Rate Reasonableness: Keep interest and penalty rates within the realm of reasonableness to avoid potential court modification.
  4. Cross-Reference Collateral Agreements: If security documents exist, incorporate references to them in the note.
  5. Demand Letter Provisions: Clearly indicate whether the payee must send a formal demand letter or if the obligation becomes due automatically upon reaching the maturity date.
  6. Witnesses/Notarization: Although not mandatory, having witnesses and notarizing the document strengthens the note’s evidentiary value.
  7. Accurate Identity of Parties: For corporate entities, ensure that the signatory is duly authorized to bind the company.
  8. Legal Review: While promissory notes may seem straightforward, it is prudent to have a lawyer review or draft the document to ensure it meets all legal requirements.

8. Sample Outline of a Philippine Promissory Note

Below is a simplified template outline (not exhaustive). The details and language would vary depending on individual circumstances:

PROMISSORY NOTE

Date: [_______]
Place of Execution: [_______]

FOR VALUE RECEIVED, I, [Name of Maker], of legal age, Filipino, with residence at [Address], hereby promise to pay [Name of Payee], Filipino, of legal age, with residence/business address at [Address], the principal sum of [Amount in Words (Php ___)], subject to the following terms and conditions:

1. PAYMENT OF PRINCIPAL
   The total amount of [Php ___] shall be paid in full on [Date], or if no specific date, then on demand by the Payee.

2. INTEREST
   The outstanding principal shall earn interest at the rate of [___]% per annum, computed [monthly / annually], starting on [Date of effectivity].

3. PAYMENT SCHEDULE (if applicable)
   The Maker shall pay the principal and interest in [monthly/quarterly/annual] installments of [Php ___] each, due on the [day] of every [month/quarter/year], until fully paid.

4. DEFAULT AND ACCELERATION
   In the event the Maker fails to pay any installment within [___] days from due date, the remaining balance shall become immediately due and demandable.

5. PENALTIES (if any)
   A late payment penalty of [___]% per [month/day] shall be imposed on any overdue installment from the due date until fully paid.

6. SECURITY (if any)
   This Promissory Note is secured by [Nature of collateral, e.g. Real Estate Mortgage, Chattel Mortgage], executed on [Date], covering [Description of Collateral].

7. GOVERNING LAW
   This Note is governed by, and shall be construed in accordance with, the laws of the Republic of the Philippines. Any action or proceeding in connection with this Note shall be instituted in the proper courts of [City / Province], to the exclusion of all other venues, where such exclusivity is permitted by law.

8. WAIVER OF NOTICES (if applicable)
   The Maker waives presentment, demand, notice of dishonor, protest, and any other formality to the fullest extent permitted by law.

9. SEVERABILITY
   If any provision of this Note is held invalid or unenforceable, the remaining provisions shall remain in full force and effect.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Maker has signed this Promissory Note this [___] day of [Month], 20[__], in [City/Province], Philippines.

________________________
[Maker’s Signature]
[Name of Maker]

Optional:

WITH MY CONFORME:
________________________
[Payee’s Signature]
[Name of Payee]

Acknowledged before me this [___] day of [Month], [Year].

[Notary Public’s Signature and Seal, if notarized] ```

9. Conclusion and Practical Reminders

Drafting a binding promissory note in the Philippines requires a careful approach that complies with both the Civil Code and the Negotiable Instruments Law. Attention to detail in specifying payment terms, interest rates, default clauses, and collateral (if any) ensures clarity between parties and strengthens enforceability should litigation become necessary.

While the fundamental requirements are straightforward, nuances in usury laws, default provisions, and interest rate reasonableness can significantly affect the outcome in court. Thus, it is always prudent to:

  1. Use clear, concise, and unambiguous language.
  2. Consider having the promissory note reviewed by a lawyer.
  3. Ensure all parties understand their obligations.

A well-drafted promissory note can serve as a solid foundation for credit transactions, personal loans, or business deals, minimizing the risk of costly disputes down the line.

Disclaimer

This article is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and regulations may change, and court interpretations can evolve over time. Individuals and businesses should seek professional legal counsel for advice tailored to their specific circumstances.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login