Employer Liability for Floating Status Without Notice Philippines

Employer Liability for Floating Status Without Notice in the Philippines: A Comprehensive Overview

Disclaimer: The following article is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific concerns related to labor law, consult a qualified Philippine attorney or the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE).

1. Introduction

In the Philippines, the concept of “floating status” often arises in industries where the availability of work fluctuates (e.g., security services, manpower or project-based operations). Under Philippine labor laws and jurisprudence, employers are sometimes allowed to place employees on temporary “floating status” if there is a bona fide lack of available work. However, this arrangement is highly regulated to prevent abuse, protect workers’ rights, and ensure procedural due process.

One of the most important requirements in imposing floating status is providing proper notice to the affected employee. Placing an employee on floating status without complying with the notice and other procedural requirements can expose the employer to legal liability, typically for illegal (or constructive) dismissal.

This article outlines the essential legal principles governing floating status in the Philippines, with particular attention to potential employer liability when notice requirements are not met.

2. Definition of Floating Status

  1. General Description

    • Floating status is a period during which an employee is temporarily relieved from work due to a bona fide situation such as lack of available posts, lack of contracts, or the temporary suspension of the employer’s operations.
    • Commonly encountered in the security services industry, where security guards or personnel are reassigned or temporarily left without a post while the agency negotiates for a new client contract.

  2. Legal Basis

    • The Labor Code of the Philippines does not explicitly use the term “floating status,” but the concept is widely recognized in administrative regulations and Supreme Court decisions.
    • Jurisprudence provides that placing an employee on floating status may be valid if it is done in good faith and is only for a temporary period (generally up to six months).

  3. Maximum Period

    • Under established Supreme Court rulings, floating status cannot exceed six (6) months. If the employee is not recalled or provided work within that six-month period, the employee may be deemed constructively dismissed.

3. Legal and Regulatory Framework

  1. Labor Code of the Philippines

    • Articles 298-299 (formerly Articles 283-284): Governs authorized causes for termination (e.g., retrenchment, cessation of business operations). While these articles do not specifically mention “floating,” they outline conditions for suspending or reducing the workforce. Employers often rely on these provisions to justify temporary suspensions.

  2. DOLE Department Orders and Regulations

    • DOLE Department Order No. 147-15 sets guidelines on termination of employment and emphasizes that due process (both substantive and procedural) must be observed.
    • For industries regulated by special laws or department orders (e.g., private security agencies), guidelines typically require prompt written notices to employees when they are put on floating status.

  3. Relevant Supreme Court Decisions

    • Artemio Labayan v. Sebul Security and Detective Investigation Agency (a sample reference) clarifies that placing security guards on floating status is permissible only if it is temporary and based on the absence of work or post.
    • Philippine Industrial Security Agency Corporation v. Aguinaldo (another relevant case) underscores that failure to recall an employee to work within six months can be tantamount to constructive dismissal.
    • Case law also consistently requires notice to the employee to enable them to understand the reason for, and the duration of, the floating status.

4. Notice Requirements

4.1. Written Notice to the Employee

Placing an employee on floating status entails the following notice obligations:

  1. Reason for the Floating Status

    • The employer must disclose the bona fide reason (e.g., no available posts, contract termination by a client, temporary suspension of business operations).

  2. Expected Duration

    • The employer should inform the employee of the approximate duration of the floating status, which cannot exceed six months.

  3. Possibility of Recall

    • The employer should state that the employee will be recalled if and when a new post or task becomes available.

  4. Timeline for Notice

    • Although no uniform statutory timeline exists (unlike in dismissal for authorized causes which has a 30-day notice requirement), the notice should be given as soon as reasonably practicable so that the employee can prepare.
    • In security agencies, contracts often end abruptly, but immediate or prompt notice is still required once the need for floating status arises.

4.2. Notice to the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE)

  • If the employer’s action involves mass layoff or temporary suspension of more than a certain number of employees, the employer may have to report the suspension to the DOLE (particularly if it is akin to “temporary closure” or large-scale redundancy).
  • Specific industries, including security agencies, must comply with reporting requirements found in DOLE regulations or industry-specific department orders.

5. Consequences of Failing to Give Proper Notice

5.1. Constructive Dismissal

  • Definition
    • Constructive dismissal occurs when an employer’s acts amount to a dismissal in disguise, depriving the employee of work without a valid or authorized cause, or by failing to follow due process.
  • Impact
    • An employee who can prove constructive dismissal is generally entitled to the same relief as if they were illegally dismissed (e.g., full back wages, reinstatement, or separation pay in lieu of reinstatement).

5.2. Illegal Dismissal Liability

When floating status is imposed without notice, the following outcomes are likely:

  1. Reinstatement

    • If the court or labor arbiter finds that there was no valid placement on floating status, the employer may be ordered to reinstate the employee to his or her former position (or substantially equivalent position).

  2. Payment of Back Wages

    • The period during which the employee was effectively barred from work might be counted towards back wages.
    • Back wages are typically computed from the time of the employee’s dismissal (or constructive dismissal) until actual reinstatement or final resolution of the case.

  3. Separation Pay

    • If reinstatement is no longer feasible (e.g., closure of the business, strained relations), the employer may be ordered to pay separation pay instead of reinstating the employee.

  4. Moral and Exemplary Damages

    • In cases where bad faith or malice is proven, courts may award moral and exemplary damages, although these damages are granted under more exceptional circumstances.

5.3. Administrative Penalties

  • DOLE Penalties
    • Depending on the nature of the violation, DOLE can impose administrative fines, suspend operating licenses (in the case of security agencies), or issue compliance orders.
  • License and Accreditation Issues
    • Security agencies and other businesses licensed by the government may have their licenses revoked or suspended if they habitually fail to provide due notice when placing employees on floating status.

6. Best Practices for Employers

  1. Prior Planning
    • Employers should anticipate gaps in client contracts and plan reassignments or post availabilities promptly.
  2. Prompt Written Notice
    • Issue a written notice detailing the reason for floating status, approximate duration, and a statement of recall for future work.
  3. Maintain Good Faith
    • Ensure floating status is used only when necessary, and that the employee is returned to work as soon as possible.
  4. Document Everything
    • Keep a complete record of notices sent and received, employee acknowledgments, attempts to find suitable posts, and other relevant correspondence.
  5. Regularly Update Employees
    • Communicate any developments regarding possible reassignments or changes in the anticipated duration of floating status.

7. Remedies for Employees

  1. Demand Explanation from the Employer
    • If no notice was given, the employee should formally request an explanation (e.g., through a written letter or email).
  2. File a Complaint at the DOLE or NLRC
    • If the employer fails to address or rectify the situation, the employee may file a labor complaint for illegal dismissal or constructive dismissal.
  3. Seek Assistance from Unions or Legal Counsel
    • Unionized employees can seek union support. Non-unionized workers can consult a lawyer or approach the Public Attorney’s Office (PAO) for free legal assistance (if qualified).

8. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

  1. Can an employer place an employee on floating status for more than six months?

    • No. The Supreme Court has consistently ruled that floating status beyond six months is tantamount to constructive dismissal unless there is a justifiable reason (such as a force majeure that extends the suspension of operations). Even in extraordinary circumstances, the employer should still coordinate with the DOLE and properly notify the employee.

  2. Is it necessary to pay wages during the floating period?

    • Typically, wages are not required if the employee is legitimately on floating status (i.e., no work is provided). However, employees may be entitled to other benefits, particularly if provided by company policy or CBA (collective bargaining agreement). Some agreements provide allowances or partial pay for employees on floating status.

  3. What if the employer fails to recall the employee but does not formally dismiss them?

    • Failing to recall an employee before the six-month period lapses (or failing to provide valid notice and reasons) can be treated as constructive dismissal, exposing the employer to illegal dismissal liability.

  4. Do employees need to consent to floating status?

    • In principle, the employer must inform employees and ideally secure their acknowledgment. While explicit consent is not always required for a valid floating arrangement, the procedure must be done lawfully and with clear communication. Lack of objection does not cure an employer’s failure to provide notice.

9. Conclusion

Placing an employee on floating status is a recognized practice in certain industries where the availability of work is intermittent. However, to be valid, it must be carried out in strict compliance with legal and procedural requirements—chief among them the provision of adequate notice. Floating status that exceeds six months, or floating status imposed without proper notice, can amount to constructive or illegal dismissal. Such situations can lead to significant financial exposure for back wages, reinstatement or separation pay, and even damages, as well as administrative sanctions against the employer.

Therefore, employers in the Philippines must handle floating status judiciously: provide prompt written notices, clarify the reason and duration of suspension, recall employees as soon as feasible, and document all steps taken. Similarly, employees who find themselves suddenly “floating” without formal communication or for excessive durations should seek immediate clarification or legal recourse.

Ultimately, clear communication, good-faith compliance with DOLE rules, and respect for employees’ rights will help both parties navigate the complexities surrounding floating status in the Philippine setting.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login