Employer Withholding Salary While on Leave

Below is a comprehensive discussion of the legal framework, key considerations, and practical points regarding the withholding of salary while on leave in the Philippines. This guide is meant to be an overview; employees and employers facing specific concerns should consult official regulations or seek professional legal advice for personalized guidance.

1. Foundational Principles Under Philippine Labor Law

  1. No Work, No Pay Principle

    • Under Philippine labor law, the “no work, no pay” principle generally applies. This means that employees are entitled to pay only for days actually worked, except for days covered by paid leaves mandated by law or granted by company policy.
    • Authorized leaves mandated by Philippine law (e.g., Service Incentive Leave, Maternity Leave, Paternity Leave, Parental Leave for Solo Parents, etc.) typically require the employer to provide compensation during the leave period, as specified by law.

  2. Contract of Employment and Company Policy

    • Beyond statutory (government-mandated) benefits, some employers offer additional paid leaves under collective bargaining agreements, employment contracts, or company policies.
    • If the leave is recognized as a paid leave by law, contract, or policy, the employer generally cannot withhold the salary corresponding to that leave period.

  3. Obligation to Pay Wages

    • Article 103 of the Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended) provides that wages must be paid directly to the employees and in a manner prescribed by the Code.
    • Any illegal deduction or withholding of wages can be a ground for filing a labor complaint with the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) or the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC).

2. Types of Leaves in the Philippines and Payment Entitlement

2.1 Service Incentive Leave (SIL)

  • Legal Basis: Article 95 of the Labor Code.
  • Who Is Covered: Employees who have worked at least one year in a private establishment that is not otherwise exempt (e.g., some retail/service enterprises under a certain size).
  • Benefit: Five (5) days of paid leave per year, convertible to cash if unused at the end of the year (unless a more favorable company policy exists).
  • Withholding of Salary: During these SIL days, an employee’s wage should not be withheld. If the employee takes SIL, the employer is obligated to pay the regular wage for those days.

2.2 Maternity Leave

  • Legal Basis: Republic Act (R.A.) No. 11210 (Expanded Maternity Leave Law).
  • Coverage: 105 days of paid maternity leave for live childbirth (additional 15 days for solo parents), 60 days for miscarriage or emergency termination of pregnancy.
  • Funding/Payment: Maternity benefit is typically advanced by the employer but is reimbursable by the Social Security System (SSS). Employers cannot withhold this benefit if the employee meets the eligibility criteria (correct SSS contributions and timely submission of required documents).

2.3 Paternity Leave

  • Legal Basis: R.A. No. 8187 (Paternity Leave Act of 1996).
  • Coverage: Seven (7) days of paid leave for married male employees in the private sector for the first four (4) deliveries of a legitimate spouse.
  • Withholding of Salary: Employers are required to pay the employee’s salary for these days once eligibility criteria are satisfied (e.g., legitimate marriage, timely notice).

2.4 Solo Parent Leave

  • Legal Basis: R.A. No. 8972 (Solo Parents’ Welfare Act of 2000).
  • Coverage: Seven (7) days of paid leave per year for qualified solo parents who have rendered at least one year of service (continuous or broken).
  • Withholding of Salary: As this is a statutory paid leave, salary should not be withheld if the employee has submitted the required documents (Solo Parent ID, notification, etc.).

2.5 Special Leave for Women (Gynecological Leave)

  • Legal Basis: R.A. No. 9710 (Magna Carta of Women).
  • Coverage: Two (2) months of paid leave for women employees who undergo surgery caused by gynecological disorders, upon certification by a competent physician.
  • Withholding of Salary: The employer must pay this benefit to qualified female employees, with no salary withholding during the approved period.

2.6 Vacation and Sick Leave (Company-Granted or CBA-Granted)

  • Though not specifically mandated by law (beyond the 5-day SIL), many companies provide vacation and sick leave credits by policy or through collective bargaining agreements (CBA). If the policy states these leave credits are fully paid, the employer must comply accordingly.

3. Valid Grounds for Salary Deduction or Withholding

  1. Unauthorized Leaves/Absences

    • If the employee is absent without an approved leave or has exhausted all paid leaves (statutory or company-granted), the employer can lawfully apply the “no work, no pay” principle for those days.
    • Employers are not required to pay for any day an employee is absent without leave or beyond the allowable paid leave credits.

  2. Legal Deductions

    • The Labor Code and its Implementing Rules allow certain deductions from wages if authorized by law, e.g., SSS, PhilHealth, Pag-IBIG contributions, or union dues (if authorized in a CBA).
    • Deductions for payment of company loans, salary advances, or other financial obligations may also be permitted if there is written authorization from the employee.

  3. Disciplinary Suspensions

    • If an employee is suspended due to a valid disciplinary measure following due process (e.g., after being found guilty of a grave offense), the period of suspension is generally unpaid. This is, however, different from “withholding salary”—it is simply the application of the no-work-no-pay principle during the suspension.

4. When Withholding Salary Becomes Illegal

  1. Failure to Pay Statutory Leaves

    • If an employee takes a legally mandated paid leave (e.g., maternity leave, paternity leave, SIL, solo parent leave, etc.) and meets the eligibility requirements, the employer cannot refuse or withhold the corresponding wages.

  2. Deliberate or Unexplained Delays in Wage Payment

    • Article 103 of the Labor Code mandates that wages be paid at least once every two weeks or twice a month at intervals not exceeding sixteen (16) days. Employers that unjustifiably delay wages or hold them indefinitely can be penalized under labor laws.

  3. Unlawful Deductions

    • Any deduction that is not expressly authorized by the employee, by law, or by a valid CBA may be considered illegal. Examples include unauthorized deductions for losses (e.g., breakage, cashiering shortages) without due process or absent a legally valid agreement.

  4. Retaliation or Unfair Labor Practices

    • If the withholding is being used to retaliate against an employee (e.g., for joining a union, filing a complaint, or exercising statutory rights), that may constitute an unfair labor practice (ULP) under the Labor Code.

5. Legal Remedies for Employees

  1. Filing a Complaint with the DOLE

    • Employees can seek assistance from the DOLE for violations of wage and leave laws. The DOLE or its regional offices can initiate enforcement actions, hold mandatory conferences, or direct payments for unpaid wages or benefits.

  2. Filing a Case Before the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC)

    • For illegal withholding of wages or non-payment of statutory benefits, employees can file a labor case. The NLRC has jurisdiction to order the employer to pay the unpaid wages or benefits plus possible damages, attorney’s fees, and other remedies as appropriate.

  3. Small Claims or Regular Court Action

    • If the situation involves monetary claims below a certain threshold, the employee may file a small claims case in regular courts. However, labor issues are primarily under the jurisdiction of labor arbiters and the NLRC, so employees often first seek redress through labor tribunals.

  4. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

    • Sometimes, disputes are resolved faster through company-level grievance mechanisms or voluntary arbitration, especially if there is a CBA that covers dispute resolution processes.

6. Employer’s Perspective: Best Practices to Avoid Liability

  1. Establish and Communicate Clear Leave Policies

    • Having an updated employee handbook or HR manual ensures that employees know the rules for leave application, eligibility criteria, and wage payment schedules.

  2. Document Approvals and Denials of Leave

    • Keep a record of approved leaves (both statutory and company-granted) and the reasons for any denial. This documentation will be crucial should any conflict arise.

  3. Ensure Timely Wage Payment

    • Employers must pay wages on time for both actual workdays and valid paid leave days. Payroll personnel should be aware of all legally mandated leaves and their corresponding coverage.

  4. Seek Clarification from DOLE on Ambiguous Situations

    • If uncertain about a particular leave scenario (e.g., partial coverage by SSS, special leaves, or newly enacted regulations), employers can request guidance or clarifications from the DOLE or legal counsel.

7. Key Takeaways

  • Paid vs. Unpaid Leave: The right to pay during a leave depends on whether the leave is mandated by law or recognized as paid under company policy or contract.
  • Mandatory Leaves: Philippine law prescribes various paid leaves (e.g., SIL, maternity, paternity, solo parent, gynecological leave, etc.). Employers cannot validly withhold wages during these statutory leave periods if the employee meets eligibility requirements.
  • Unpaid Leaves: Leaves not mandated by law or not covered by a company-paid leave policy are generally unpaid, and the employer does not violate the law by applying “no work, no pay.”
  • Illegal Withholding: Withholding wages in bad faith, without due process, or contrary to law (e.g., refusing to pay for approved statutory leave) can expose employers to penalties and legal action.
  • Legal Remedies: Employees who believe their salary has been wrongfully withheld can file claims with the DOLE or the NLRC. Employers must be prepared to justify any deductions or non-payment.

References

  • Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended)
  • R.A. No. 11210 (Expanded Maternity Leave Law)
  • R.A. No. 8187 (Paternity Leave Act)
  • R.A. No. 8972 (Solo Parents’ Welfare Act)
  • R.A. No. 9710 (Magna Carta of Women)
  • Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) issuances and implementing rules
  • Relevant jurisprudence on wage and leave benefits from the Supreme Court and the NLRC

Conclusion

In the Philippine context, “Employer Withholding Salary While on Leave” boils down to whether the leave is paid under the law or the employer’s policies. For statutorily mandated paid leaves, employers are required to pay the corresponding salaries or benefits, subject to eligibility requirements. Withholding pay in these situations can amount to a labor violation. For unpaid leaves, the employer’s decision not to pay is generally legal under the “no work, no pay” principle, provided that there is no company policy or contract granting such leave with pay. Both employees and employers benefit from clearly understanding the legalities surrounding leaves and compensation, which reduces disputes and fosters fairness in the workplace.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login