Employer's Right to Issue Disciplinary Memo for Holiday Absence

Below is a comprehensive overview of an employer’s right to issue a disciplinary memo when an employee is absent during a holiday in the Philippines. While this guide is intended to provide detailed information, it should not be taken as formal legal advice. For specific concerns, it is always best to consult an attorney or a labor law specialist.

1. Overview: Employer’s Right and Employee Responsibilities

  1. Management Prerogative

    • Under Philippine labor law, employers have what is commonly referred to as “management prerogative.” This allows them to regulate all aspects of employment according to the needs of the business, subject to the limitations imposed by law, employment contracts, and collective bargaining agreements (if any).
    • Part of this prerogative includes determining work rules, schedules, and the disciplinary measures that may be imposed for violations.

  2. Basic Employee Obligation

    • Employees, conversely, have the basic obligation to comply with employer directives and policies, including attendance requirements. Even if a given day is considered a holiday—regular or special non-working—an employee who is required to work or to be on standby and fails to report or obtain prior approval for an absence may be subject to disciplinary action.

2. Philippine Holidays and Work Obligations

  1. Classification of Philippine Holidays

    • Regular Holidays: These include holidays such as New Year’s Day, Araw ng Kagitingan, Maundy Thursday, Good Friday, Labor Day, Independence Day, National Heroes’ Day, Bonifacio Day, Christmas Day, Rizal Day, and others specifically declared by law.
    • Special Non-Working Holidays: These include holidays such as Ninoy Aquino Day, All Saints’ Day, and other dates declared by presidential proclamations each year.

  2. Work on Holidays

    • Employer’s Choice: The Labor Code generally allows employers to require employees to work on holidays if the nature of the business needs continuous operations or if the employer deems it necessary for critical tasks.
    • Holiday Premiums: For regular holidays, employees who work on these days must be paid double their regular rate for the first eight hours. For special non-working holidays, the usual premium is 130% of the daily rate.

  3. Absenteeism on a Holiday

    • While some employees might assume they automatically have the day off on a holiday, this depends on company policy and operational needs. If an employer has duly informed employees that work is required on a holiday, failure to report can lead to disciplinary measures if the absence is without valid justification or prior notice.

3. Grounds for Issuing a Disciplinary Memo

  1. Violation of Company Policy

    • Many companies have specific policies regarding attendance on holidays—especially for industries requiring continuous operations (e.g., hospitality, manufacturing, BPO, healthcare). These policies typically state if holiday work is mandatory, the procedure to request leave, or any prior notice needed if one cannot report.
    • An unexplained or unapproved absence on a designated holiday work schedule is considered a violation of company rules and can warrant a disciplinary memo.

  2. Willful Disobedience of Employer’s Lawful Order

    • Under the Labor Code (particularly under the just causes for termination, found in Article 297 [formerly 282]), “willful disobedience” of a lawful order from the employer can be a ground for disciplinary action, which can, in extreme or repeated cases, lead to dismissal.
    • If an employee is clearly directed to report on a holiday and intentionally chooses not to do so, that may be deemed willful disobedience.

  3. Abandonment of Duty

    • Repeated absences or absences coupled with failure to communicate any reason could be construed as abandonment, although abandonment typically requires an intent to sever the employment relationship. One or two absences over a holiday would not usually reach that level. Still, a disciplinary memo can be issued to document the attendance infraction.

  4. Negligence or Misconduct

    • If the absence on a holiday causes serious disruption to company operations or is done in bad faith, it might be classified under misconduct, especially when combined with other violations (e.g., taking company property, failing to turn over vital tasks, etc.).

4. Steps in Issuing a Disciplinary Memo (Due Process Requirements)

Philippine jurisprudence emphasizes due process in disciplinary actions, even for seemingly minor infractions such as a single day of absence. Typically, a two-notice rule is followed:

  1. Notice to Explain (NTE)

    • The employer issues a written notice asking the employee to explain why they were absent without prior approval or a valid reason. This is sometimes called a “show cause” memo.
    • The employee is given a reasonable period (often 48 to 72 hours) to provide a written explanation or justification.

  2. Opportunity to be Heard

    • Depending on the company’s policy, the employee may also be given a chance to defend themselves in a face-to-face meeting or hearing—especially for serious offenses, though many companies handle minor offenses via written correspondence.

  3. Decision Memo (Disciplinary Memo)

    • After evaluating the employee’s explanation, management issues a memo stating the findings, the rule violated, and the corresponding penalty (e.g., verbal warning, written reprimand, suspension, or, in worst cases, termination).
    • If the employee’s explanation is deemed acceptable (e.g., a valid medical emergency), management may opt to drop or lessen the disciplinary action.

  4. Proportionality of Penalty

    • In line with Philippine labor jurisprudence, the penalty imposed must be commensurate with the offense. For a single unauthorized holiday absence, a dismissal would likely be considered too severe and might be overturned by labor authorities if legally contested. A written warning or short suspension is more common.

5. Valid Defenses or Excuses for Holiday Absences

  1. Medical Reasons

    • If the employee or a family member is ill, and the employee can substantiate the absence with medical certificates or hospital records, companies generally consider this a valid excuse.

  2. Emergency Situations

    • Unexpected circumstances like a death in the family, natural calamities, or other urgent events may excuse an absence, especially if the employee makes a good-faith effort to inform the employer as soon as possible.

  3. Approved Leave

    • If the holiday absence was previously approved as part of the employee’s leave credits or an official company shutdown, no disciplinary action should be taken. Clear documentation of the leave approval is key.

  4. Ambiguity or Lack of Notice

    • If the employer failed to communicate that employees were required to work on a particular holiday, an employee could argue that no “willful disobedience” took place. Proper notice from management is critical for disciplinary measures to stand.

6. Common Misconceptions and Best Practices

  1. Misconception: Holidays = Automatic Day Off

    • Employees often assume they have a right to take the day off on a holiday. However, the employer may lawfully require work on those days if operationally necessary, as long as employees receive proper holiday pay and are notified of their obligation to work.

  2. Misconception: No Penalty Because It’s Just One Absence

    • Employers have the right to discipline employees even for a single unauthorized absence if it disrupts operations or violates a specific policy. While a single offense rarely results in immediate dismissal, it can still be documented.

  3. Best Practice: Clear Company Policies

    • Employers should craft clear attendance policies covering holidays, required notice periods, procedures to request leaves or to report absences, and the corresponding disciplinary actions for violations.
    • Employees should read and understand these policies to avoid inadvertent violations.

  4. Best Practice: Documentation

    • For employers, issuing a memo helps build a record of infractions in case of repeated violations. For employees, promptly submitting documentation or explanation for the absence is crucial to mitigating or avoiding penalties.

7. Potential Legal Consequences if Due Process Is Not Observed

  1. Illegal Dismissal Claims

    • If an employer imposes a heavy sanction (e.g., termination) without going through due process or without a valid cause, the employee may file an illegal dismissal case before the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) or the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC).

  2. Constructive Dismissal Claims

    • In rare cases, overly harsh or repeated unwarranted memos might be construed by the employee as a form of harassment. If proven that the employer’s actions create a working environment so unpleasant or difficult as to force the employee to resign, a constructive dismissal claim could arise.

  3. Damages and Back Wages

    • If a court or labor tribunal finds the employer in violation of labor laws (e.g., no due process, disproportional penalty), the employer could be ordered to pay back wages, separation pay (in lieu of reinstatement), or even moral and exemplary damages in extreme situations.

8. Practical Tips for Both Employers and Employees

  • For Employers:

    1. Publish clear holiday work schedules and guidelines well in advance.
    2. Remind employees of attendance requirements and the consequences of absences.
    3. Follow the two-notice rule and ensure a fair evaluation of each case before issuing disciplinary memos.
    4. Keep records of all communication and policy dissemination.

  • For Employees:

    1. Review and understand company policies regarding work on holidays.
    2. If you cannot report to work, inform management as soon as possible and provide valid documentation (e.g., medical certificates, emergency evidence).
    3. Respond promptly to any notice to explain and provide a truthful account of events.
    4. If you believe you are unfairly disciplined, consult with your HR department, union representative (if any), or a labor lawyer.

9. Conclusion

Employers in the Philippines generally hold the right to issue disciplinary memoranda to employees who are absent on holidays without valid or pre-approved reasons. This right stems from their management prerogative and the requirement for employees to comply with lawful company policies. However, for any disciplinary action to be valid, employers must observe substantive and procedural due process. On the other side, employees must be mindful that while holidays are typically days off, companies operating under specific labor requirements may lawfully mandate work on these days, provided employees receive proper premium pay and notice.

Ultimately, clear communication, adherence to established labor standards, and observance of due process protect both employers and employees. By understanding these principles, each party can foster a fair and efficient workplace. If uncertainty arises, consulting a legal professional knowledgeable in Philippine labor law is advisable.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login