Employment Dispute for Floating Workers: Delayed Salary, 13th Month Pay, and Referral Bonus Issues

Below is a comprehensive discussion of the issues surrounding employment disputes for “floating workers” in the Philippine setting, particularly as these relate to delayed salary, 13th month pay, and referral bonuses. This article aims to consolidate the pertinent laws, regulations, and jurisprudence that govern these matters, as well as to provide guidance for both employees and employers.

1. Definition of “Floating Status” in Philippine Labor Law

  1. General Concept

    • “Floating status” (sometimes called “temporary off-detail” or “temporary lay-off”) is typically applied to employees, especially security guards or project-based workers, when their services are not immediately needed. The most common scenario is when a security agency’s client contract ends and the agency has no immediate post or assignment for the security guard.
    • The Supreme Court of the Philippines recognizes “floating status” as a legitimate management prerogative under certain circumstances. However, this status has a maximum duration of six (6) months. If the employer does not recall the employee to work within this period (or does not provide a new assignment), it may be treated as constructive dismissal.

  2. Legal Basis

    • The Labor Code of the Philippines does not explicitly use the term “floating status,” but the concept arises from the provisions on suspension of employment under Articles 298 to 300 (formerly Articles 286 to 288) of the Labor Code.
    • Jurisprudence (e.g., Abbott Laboratories Philippines v. Alcaraz, G.R. No. 192571 [2013]) establishes that placing an employee on floating status is permissible only if justified by legitimate business reasons and cannot exceed six months.

2. Delayed Salary for Floating Workers

  1. General Rule on Payment of Wages

    • Under Article 103 of the Labor Code (as amended), wages must be paid at least once every two (2) weeks or twice within a month at intervals not exceeding sixteen (16) days. The frequency of payment must be in accordance with the payment schedule agreed upon and/or as provided by company policy or collective bargaining agreement (CBA).
    • If an employee is on floating status, no work is rendered—thus, typically, no wages are paid (because of the “no work, no pay” principle). However, if the employee is still required to perform certain tasks or remain on call, he or she may be entitled to compensation.

  2. Delay versus Nonpayment

    • Delayed Salary: Occurs when the employer fails to pay the employee’s salary on the agreed-upon pay date but eventually pays it. Even if an employee is on floating status, if there are wages due (e.g., for any work done before the floating period officially commenced), those wages must be paid promptly.
    • Nonpayment: If the employer refuses or fails outright to pay wages for work already rendered, the employee may file a labor complaint for unpaid wages.
    • Penalties: Failure to pay the salary within the prescribed period can subject the employer to administrative sanctions, including possible fines under the Labor Code and its Implementing Rules. In worst cases, criminal liability for illegal withholding of wages may be invoked under Article 288 (formerly Article 288-A) of the Labor Code.

  3. Employee Remedies for Delayed Salary

    • Filing a Complaint with the DOLE: The Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) handles complaints through its Single Entry Approach (SEnA) mechanism, aiming for an amicable settlement.
    • Filing a Complaint with the NLRC: If no settlement is reached under SEnA, the employee can elevate the complaint to the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC).
    • Constructive Dismissal Claim: If the “floating status” extends beyond six months without valid justification, an employee could sue for illegal dismissal.

3. 13th Month Pay Entitlement

  1. Legal Basis

    • Presidential Decree No. 851: All rank-and-file employees who have worked for at least one month during the calendar year are entitled to 13th month pay, regardless of their position, designation, or employment status (regular, contractual, project-based, seasonal, or casual), provided they receive basic pay.
    • DOLE’s Revised Guidelines on the Implementation of the 13th Month Pay Law (frequently updated through various Labor Advisories) affirm these principles.

  2. Coverage for Floating Workers

    • Even if an employee has been placed on floating status for part of the year, he or she may still be entitled to a pro-rated 13th month pay based on the actual wages earned during the calendar year.
    • The formula for 13th month pay remains:
      [ \text{13th Month Pay} = \frac{\text{Total Basic Salary Earned during the Year}}{12} ]

  3. Payment Deadlines

    • The law requires 13th month pay to be given on or before December 24 of each year.
    • Some employers opt to release half of it midyear (June) and the remaining half on or before December 24, though this is not mandatory—what is required is full payment by the statutory deadline.

  4. Penalties for Non-Compliance

    • The employer’s failure to pay the 13th month pay on time can subject it to administrative penalties. Employees may seek recourse through DOLE if the payment is withheld or delayed.

4. Referral Bonus Issues

  1. Nature of Referral Bonuses

    • Unlike wages and the 13th month pay, referral bonuses are generally not statutory benefits. They are typically offered at the discretion of the employer or under a company’s internal policy to incentivize employees to refer potential hires or new clients.
    • The terms and conditions (amount, eligibility, timeline for payment) are often set out in a company memorandum, employee handbook, or referral policy agreement.

  2. Enforceability

    • Once an employer publicly announces a referral bonus scheme (through a memo, a written policy, or an employment contract addendum), the employer is bound by that stipulation under the principle of mutuality of contracts (Article 1308 of the Civil Code).
    • If an employee meets the conditions for the bonus (e.g., successful referral, completion of probation of the referred employee, etc.), the company must grant the bonus as promised. Failure to do so can be considered a breach of the employment contract or company policy.

  3. Common Disputes

    • Disagreement on Eligibility: Employers sometimes contend that a floating worker is no longer entitled to the bonus if the worker is not “actively employed.” Employees, meanwhile, argue that the referral was successful before the floating status.
    • Timing of Payment: Some policies require that the referred employee must stay for a specific duration before the bonus is released. If that date coincides with the floating period (or if the referring employee has resigned/been terminated), disputes may arise.

  4. Legal Remedies

    • The employee can file a complaint for unpaid benefits (though a “referral bonus” is typically not viewed in the same light as mandatory benefits like wages or 13th month pay).
    • If the employer’s referral policy is part of a CBA or an employment contract, the employee has a stronger claim to treat non-payment as a contractual breach.
    • Resolution typically involves negotiation or mediation under SEnA before it escalates to the NLRC.

5. Constructive Dismissal Issues for Floating Workers

  1. Constructive Dismissal

    • Constructive dismissal occurs when an employer places an employee in a situation so intolerable or indefinite that it effectively amounts to termination without due process.
    • In the context of floating status, if no valid work or assignment is given to the employee for more than six months (the maximum allowed by law), it may amount to constructive dismissal.
    • Once deemed constructively dismissed, the employee is entitled to either reinstatement and back wages or separation pay in lieu of reinstatement (depending on the circumstances).

  2. Burden of Proof

    • In labor cases, the employer has the burden to prove that the floating status is valid and that it did not exceed the allowable period without a valid reason.
    • The employee, on the other hand, must show that the prolonged floating status (beyond six months) was unreasonable and tantamount to dismissal without due process.

  3. Legal Consequences

    • If the NLRC or a court of competent jurisdiction rules in favor of the employee, the employer may be required to pay full back wages, separation pay (if reinstatement is no longer feasible), and other benefits.

6. Filing and Resolving Employment Disputes

  1. Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE)

    • Through SEnA (Single Entry Approach), employees and employers are encouraged to settle disputes amicably within a 30-day mandatory conciliation-mediation period.
    • DOLE can issue compliance orders if the violation involves labor standards (e.g., nonpayment of wages, 13th month pay).

  2. National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC)

    • If no settlement is reached, the employee can file a formal complaint with the NLRC. The NLRC has the power to resolve labor disputes, including claims for unpaid wages, 13th month pay, illegal dismissal, and money claims.

  3. Court of Appeals and Supreme Court

    • If the party losing at the NLRC level wishes to appeal, they can bring the case to the Court of Appeals (and, under certain circumstances, to the Supreme Court). However, the case at the CA or SC level usually involves issues of law rather than fact-finding.

  4. Prescription Periods

    • Money claims (unpaid wages, 13th month pay, etc.) generally prescribe in three (3) years from the time the cause of action accrues.
    • Illegal dismissal claims must be filed within four (4) years from the time of dismissal.

7. Practical Tips for Employers and Employees

  1. For Employers

    • Maintain Clarity in Contracts: Specify the terms and conditions for floating status, referral bonuses, and compensation policies.
    • Comply with Payment Deadlines: Ensure that salaries and 13th month pay are disbursed on time.
    • Establish Clear Referral Policies: Document how and when referral bonuses are earned and paid to avoid ambiguity.
    • Monitor the Duration of Floating Status: Do not exceed six months; otherwise, risk exposure to constructive dismissal claims.

  2. For Employees

    • Understand Your Rights: Familiarize yourself with the Labor Code provisions and DOLE rules on wages, 13th month pay, and floating status.
    • Document Everything: Keep pay slips, employment contracts, and any written communications regarding floating status or bonus policies.
    • Communicate with the Employer: If there are delays in salary or bonuses, try to clarify in writing before filing a complaint.
    • Seek Legal Advice if Necessary: If no resolution is reached, consult with the DOLE or a lawyer to explore legal remedies.

8. Conclusion

In the Philippine context, disputes over delayed salary, 13th month pay, and referral bonuses for floating workers often arise from a combination of unclear policies, lack of communication, and non-compliance with statutory obligations. Employers should be vigilant about following labor regulations—especially the rules on payment schedules and the six-month limit for floating status—to avoid legal repercussions. Employees, meanwhile, should educate themselves on their rights and keep proper documentation to support their claims if disputes escalate.

While referral bonuses are not legally mandated benefits like salaries or 13th month pay, they become enforceable once incorporated into employment contracts or company policies. Ultimately, open communication, fair company practices, and adherence to Philippine labor laws are the best ways to prevent and resolve these employment disputes. If issues persist, the DOLE, NLRC, and the judiciary are available to ensure that both employers and employees receive fair treatment under the law.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login