Employment Law: Labor Rights and Unlawful Deductions

Employment Law in the Philippines: Labor Rights and Unlawful Deductions

Employment law in the Philippines is primarily governed by the Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended), along with various rules and regulations issued by the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) and jurisprudence (court decisions). In addition, the 1987 Philippine Constitution provides the guiding principles for workers’ rights, such as the right to security of tenure, just and humane conditions of work, and a living wage.

This article focuses on two major aspects of Philippine employment law:

  1. Labor Rights
  2. Unlawful Deductions

Below is a comprehensive overview of these interrelated topics.

1. LABOR RIGHTS IN THE PHILIPPINES

1.1. Constitutional and Statutory Basis

  1. Constitutional Basis

    • The 1987 Philippine Constitution underscores the duty of the State to afford full protection to labor, local and overseas.
    • Article XIII, Section 3 declares that “The State shall afford full protection to labor, local and overseas, organized and unorganized, and promote full employment and equality of employment opportunities for all. It shall guarantee the rights of all workers to self-organization, collective bargaining and negotiations, and peaceful concerted activities, including the right to strike in accordance with law.”

  2. Labor Code of the Philippines (PD 442, as amended)

    • Enacted to protect and promote the welfare of workers, balancing the interests of both labor and management.
    • Contains provisions on minimum wage, hours of work, rest days, holiday pay, service incentive leave, thirteenth-month pay (through related legislation), security of tenure, and other working conditions.

1.2. Fundamental Labor Rights

  1. Right to Security of Tenure

    • Employees cannot be terminated from employment except for just or authorized causes as provided by law (Articles 297-299 of the Labor Code).
    • The employer must follow due process, both substantive and procedural, before terminating an employee.

  2. Right to Just and Humane Conditions of Work

    • Encompasses the right to safe and healthful working conditions, rest periods, holiday benefits, leaves, and other statutory benefits.
    • The Occupational Safety and Health Standards (OSHS) provides guidelines to ensure safety in the workplace.

  3. Right to a Living Wage

    • Employers are obligated to pay employees at least the applicable minimum wage, which varies depending on region and industry classification.
    • Wage Orders issued by the Regional Tripartite Wages and Productivity Boards set the minimum wage levels in different regions.

  4. Right to Self-Organization and Collective Bargaining

    • Workers have the right to form and join labor organizations of their own choosing.
    • They may engage in collective bargaining with the employer regarding wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment.

  5. Right to Equal Work Opportunities

    • The Labor Code and other laws prohibit discrimination on the basis of sex, age, religion, political affiliation, and other grounds.
    • Women, in particular, are accorded various protections under the Labor Code (e.g., maternity benefits, protection against discrimination).

  6. Right to Just Share in the Fruits of Production

    • Workers, through mechanisms like profit-sharing or productivity-based incentives, may share in the success of the enterprise.
    • The law encourages workers’ participation in policy and decision-making processes affecting their rights and benefits.

2. UNLAWFUL DEDUCTIONS

2.1. Legal Framework

  1. General Principle Under the Labor Code

    • Article 113 (formerly Article 113 under the renumbered Labor Code) restricts the employer from making deductions from the wages of the employee, except:
      1. In cases where the employer is authorized by law or regulations issued by the Secretary of Labor and Employment;
      2. When the deductions are with the written authorization of the employee for payment to a third person (e.g., insurance premiums), and the employer agrees to do so.

  2. DOLE Regulations

    • The Department of Labor and Employment may issue guidelines or advisories clarifying lawful versus unlawful deductions.
    • Employers must ensure that any wage deduction falls squarely within the permitted exceptions and is properly documented.

2.2. Examples of Lawful Deductions

The following are generally considered lawful if they comply with the conditions set forth under the Labor Code and DOLE rules:

  1. Government Mandated Contributions

    • Deductions for SSS, PhilHealth, and Pag-IBIG contributions, which are required by law.
    • Withholding tax on compensation as mandated by the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR).

  2. Union Dues (If Authorized by the Employee)

    • If there is a valid union shop or closed shop provision in a Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA), deduction of union dues (or agency fees for non-union members covered by a CBA) is lawful.
    • Written authorization from the employee or a stipulation in the CBA is typically necessary.

  3. Insurance Premiums or Other Voluntary Contributions

    • Employees may authorize employers to deduct payment for group insurance policies, retirement plans, or cooperative shares.
    • Such authorization must be in writing.

  4. Company Loans or Salary Advances

    • Deductions for repayment of a loan or salary advance granted by the employer, provided the employee has explicitly consented to this arrangement.
    • The terms of repayment (e.g., schedule of deductions, interest) must be agreed upon in writing and must not reduce the employee’s take-home pay below the minimum wage.

2.3. Examples of Unlawful Deductions

Under Philippine law, certain deductions are deemed unlawful if they do not comply with legal requirements or exceed permissible limits:

  1. Deductions Without Employee’s Written Consent

    • Any deduction not mandated by law or authorized in writing by the employee constitutes an unlawful deduction.
    • For instance, arbitrarily deducting sums from wages due to alleged negligence or damage to company property without due process or employee consent is generally unlawful.

  2. Penalties and Fines Not Authorized by Law

    • Employers may not impose monetary penalties, fines, or wage forfeitures (e.g., for tardiness, poor performance, or infractions) unless expressly allowed by law or company policy that complies with the Labor Code.
    • Even where company policy allows certain penalties, these must still be reasonable, consistent with the law, and not diminish the minimum wage.

  3. Deductions for Tools, Materials, or Uniforms

    • As a general rule, if the use of tools or uniforms is required for the performance of work, the cost of such items should be shouldered by the employer.
    • Deducting the cost of uniforms, protective gear, or other necessary items (without the employee’s written consent or lawful justification) violates the prohibition against unauthorized wage deductions.

  4. Losses and Damages Imputable to Simple Negligence

    • Philippine labor jurisprudence typically holds that employers cannot charge employees for losses or damages due to simple negligence or circumstances beyond the employees’ control.
    • Proper legal procedure (administrative investigation, due process) must be followed to determine if an employee is truly at fault or liable before any deduction is considered. Even if found liable, the deduction must be lawful (e.g., with written authorization or pursuant to a court/judgment).

  5. Deductions Reducing Wages Below the Minimum

    • Any deduction that causes the employee’s wage to fall below the applicable minimum wage is almost invariably unlawful.
    • The obligation to pay at least the minimum wage is absolute, and employers who fail to do so may face administrative, civil, or even criminal liability.

2.4. Due Process in Imposing Deductions Related to Misconduct or Liability

  1. Notice and Hearing

    • If an employee is suspected of causing damage or incurring liability to the employer, the employee must be properly notified of the charge and given the opportunity to explain or defend themselves in an administrative hearing or investigation.
    • Failure to conduct due process can render any subsequent deduction invalid and unlawful.

  2. Written Authorization

    • Once liability is established and agreed upon, the employee may sign a written agreement authorizing the employer to deduct a certain amount from future wages, subject to legal limits (i.e., not falling below minimum wage).
    • In the absence of such written authorization or a final court/arbitration order, the employer cannot unilaterally deduct payment from the employee’s salary.

3. LIABILITY AND REMEDIES

3.1. Employer Liability for Unlawful Deductions

Employers who commit unlawful deductions face various forms of liability:

  1. Administrative Liability

    • The Department of Labor and Employment may impose sanctions, fines, or penalties on violators.
    • DOLE inspectors can issue compliance orders demanding the employer reimburse employees for unauthorized deductions.

  2. Civil Liability

    • Employees may file a complaint before the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) or the appropriate labor arbiter for recovery of the amount unlawfully deducted, plus damages and attorney’s fees, if warranted.
    • The Labor Arbiter’s decision can be elevated to the NLRC, Court of Appeals, and ultimately, the Supreme Court.

  3. Criminal Liability

    • Under certain circumstances—particularly involving deliberate and willful violations of minimum wage laws or repeated refusal to comply with lawful orders—criminal charges may be pursued.
    • Penalties can include fines and imprisonment, although such instances are less common in practice.

3.2. Employee Remedies

  1. Filing a Complaint with DOLE

    • Employees can report violations to the DOLE’s Regional Office or visit a field office to request assistance.
    • DOLE may conduct a labor standards inspection, leading to orders for correction of the violation.

  2. Filing a Labor Case before the NLRC

    • If the issue remains unresolved, employees may elevate the matter to the labor arbiter of the NLRC.
    • An employee may seek the return of the unlawfully deducted amounts and, in meritorious cases, claim moral and exemplary damages, as well as attorney’s fees (generally 10% of monetary awards).

  3. Filing a Criminal Complaint (in Specific Cases)

    • The Labor Code allows for criminal prosecution of employers who willfully and repeatedly refuse to comply with legal directives on wages or other labor standards.
    • The affected employee may coordinate with the City or Provincial Prosecutor’s Office, often assisted by DOLE or a private lawyer.

  4. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

    • Many labor disputes can be resolved through conciliation-mediation at the DOLE’s Single Entry Approach (SEnA) program.
    • The objective is an amicable settlement that rectifies the unlawful deductions and prevents protracted litigation.

4. BEST PRACTICES FOR EMPLOYERS AND EMPLOYEES

4.1. For Employers

  1. Maintain Clear Wage and Deduction Policies

    • Draft a clear, written policy outlining permissible wage deductions and ensure it complies with the Labor Code and DOLE regulations.
    • Provide employees with a copy of these policies upon hiring and whenever there are changes.

  2. Obtain Written Authorizations

    • Before deducting any amount beyond those mandated by law (e.g., SSS, PhilHealth, Pag-IBIG, tax), secure express written authorization from the employee.
    • Keep complete records of deductions, authorizations, and relevant proofs in employee files.

  3. Conduct Due Process Before Imposing Liabilities

    • If an employee is alleged to have caused damage or incurred a financial liability, investigate formally and provide notice and hearing.
    • Once guilt or liability is determined, secure a settlement or agreement in writing for any corresponding wage deductions.

  4. Observe Minimum Wage Requirements

    • Ensure that the net take-home pay after permissible deductions does not fall below the prevailing regional minimum wage.
    • Regularly check and comply with updated Wage Orders.

4.2. For Employees

  1. Know Your Rights

    • Familiarize yourself with provisions of the Labor Code and DOLE regulations on wages, benefits, and deductions.
    • Attend seminars or read materials from reliable sources (e.g., DOLE, labor unions, legitimate legal websites).

  2. Keep Copies of Employment Records

    • Preserve payslips, employment contracts, and any documents showing deductions.
    • Written evidence of unauthorized deductions is crucial if a complaint is pursued.

  3. Ask for Explanations

    • If you notice a deduction on your payslip that you do not recognize or disagree with, immediately ask your employer for clarification.
    • Request a breakdown of how the deduction was calculated and the legal basis or written authorization for it.

  4. Seek Legal Remedies Promptly

    • If you believe a deduction is unlawful and the employer refuses to correct it, file a complaint with DOLE or the NLRC.
    • Timely action preserves your right to recover the amounts and prevents ongoing violations.

5. CONCLUSION

Labor rights and the prohibition on unlawful deductions form a cornerstone of Philippine employment law. Both employers and employees are expected to understand and comply with the principles and processes set out in the Labor Code, DOLE issuances, and court decisions. Employers must ensure that wage deductions adhere strictly to the law—either mandated by statute or with the employee’s proper written consent—and do not reduce an employee’s pay below the applicable minimum wage. Meanwhile, employees who suspect illegal deductions or other labor rights violations should promptly seek clarification or take the necessary legal steps to protect their rights.

By upholding just and lawful employment practices, employers foster a stable and compliant work environment, while employees enjoy the benefits of the Constitution’s and the Labor Code’s protective mantle—leading to a more harmonious and productive workplace overall.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login