Father’s Consent Refusal in Child Adoption in the Philippines

Father’s Consent Refusal in Child Adoption in the Philippines
Note: This article is for general informational purposes and should not be taken as legal advice. For specific concerns, please consult a qualified legal professional.

1. Introduction

Child adoption in the Philippines is governed primarily by Republic Act No. 8552 (the Domestic Adoption Act of 1998), Republic Act No. 9523 (concerning the certification declaring a child legally available for adoption), related provisions of the Family Code of the Philippines, and the Rules of Court on adoption (particularly the Rule on Adoption under A.M. No. 02-6-02-SC, as amended). Under these laws and rules, obtaining the consent of both the biological (or legal) mother and father is typically required before an adoption can be finalized. However, problems may arise when a father refuses to give consent.

This article provides an overview of the legal considerations, exceptions, and processes surrounding a father’s refusal to consent to the adoption of a child in the Philippine context.

2. Legal Framework Governing Adoption

  1. Republic Act No. 8552 (Domestic Adoption Act of 1998)

    • Establishes policies, procedures, and safeguards for domestic adoption in the Philippines.
    • Stresses the “best interest of the child” principle as paramount in adoption proceedings.
    • Enumerates the persons who must give consent to an adoption, including the child’s biological parents (if known and with parental authority).

  2. Family Code of the Philippines

    • Covers parental authority over legitimate and illegitimate children (Title IX, Articles 209–233).
    • Specifies that both parents exercise parental authority over a legitimate child, whereas only the mother generally exercises parental authority over an illegitimate child (unless the father has recognized the child and certain conditions apply).

  3. Rule on Adoption (A.M. No. 02-6-02-SC)

    • Prescribes the judicial procedures for adoption in Philippine courts.
    • Details the requirements and sequence of steps, from filing a petition to the issuance of the decree of adoption.

  4. Other Related Laws and Issuances

    • R.A. 9523 requires a Certification Declaring a Child Legally Available for Adoption (CDCLAA) if the child is considered abandoned, neglected, or voluntarily committed by the parents or legal guardian.

In all these legal instruments, the consent of the child’s biological (or legal) father is recognized as an important factor, although not always mandatory if specific exceptions apply.

3. When Is the Father’s Consent Required?

Generally, under R.A. 8552 and the Rule on Adoption, the consent of the following persons is required before an adoption can proceed:

  1. The adoptee (if ten years of age or older).
  2. The biological parents (if they still hold parental authority and their rights have not been terminated or waived).
  3. The legal guardian (if the parents are absent, incompetent, or have relinquished their rights).
  4. The Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD), if the child is legally under its care or if the child has been abandoned or voluntarily committed.

Where the father is known, living, exercising parental authority, and has not waived or lost his rights, his consent is generally required. This is especially clear if:

  • The child is legitimate (i.e., born to married parents or legitimated by subsequent marriage).
  • The child is illegitimate but voluntarily recognized by the father and the father actively exercises parental authority (or has filed recognition in the civil registry, or there is an official acknowledgment).

The principle behind requiring paternal consent is the legal recognition of the father’s parental rights and authority over the child.

4. Scenarios Where Father’s Consent May Not Be Required

Despite the legal importance of paternal consent, there are scenarios in which a father’s consent may be dispensed with or deemed unnecessary:

  1. Father is Unknown or Cannot Be Located

    • If the father’s whereabouts are unknown after diligent search or inquiry, the court may proceed with the adoption without the father’s personal consent, typically requiring proof (e.g., proof of publication of notice, affidavits of search) to show due diligence in attempting to locate him.

  2. Father Has Abandoned the Child

    • Under R.A. 8552 and related adoption rules, a parent who has abandoned the child for a certain period (as determined by DSWD’s guidelines or by factual findings of the court) is considered to have forfeited his parental rights.
    • Once abandonment or neglect is proven, the DSWD may issue a CDCLAA (Certification Declaring a Child Legally Available for Adoption). In such cases, the father’s consent is not required.

  3. Father Has Lost or Been Stripped of Parental Authority

    • Parental authority can be terminated by a court order for reasons such as abuse, neglect, incapacity, or other grounds specified in the Family Code.
    • If a valid court decree has terminated the father’s parental authority, his consent to the adoption is no longer mandatory.

  4. Father Is Proven Mentally Incompetent or Incapacitated

    • If a court declares the father mentally incompetent or otherwise legally incapacitated to exercise parental rights, the court may dispense with his consent.
    • A legal declaration of incompetence must be obtained to ensure that the father cannot make informed decisions for the child.

  5. Father Voluntarily Waives His Rights

    • In some cases, a father may execute a notarized and court-validated document relinquishing his parental rights. Once the waiver is validly recognized by the court, no further paternal consent is necessary.

5. Effect of Father’s Refusal

5.1. General Rule: Refusal Can Halt or Delay the Adoption

If a father with intact parental authority refuses to consent, this refusal can stall or even entirely prevent the adoption process. The father’s refusal is generally respected by the courts, given the emphasis on the parents’ constitutionally protected rights over their children. A valid objection from a father typically compels the court to deny or at least suspend the adoption proceedings unless there are clear grounds to dispense with his consent.

5.2. Challenging the Refusal

However, if the refusal is deemed arbitrary or contrary to the best interest of the child, the prospective adoptive parents (or the mother, or any other interested party) can challenge it in court. They may argue that:

  1. The father has effectively abandoned or neglected the child.
  2. The father’s refusal is based on malice, harassment, or a desire to extort from the potential adoptive parents.
  3. The father is not truly exercising parental authority (e.g., no support, no contact, etc.).

The court may then conduct hearings to assess the real reasons behind the refusal. If the court is convinced that the refusal is unwarranted, it can decide either to terminate the father’s parental rights or to override the refusal, based on the best interest of the child. Such a move requires clear and convincing evidence and must strictly follow due process.

6. Court Procedures and Best Interest of the Child

  1. Petition for Adoption

    • The adoptive parents file a petition in the proper Family Court having jurisdiction over the child’s place of residence.
    • If the father is known and available, the petition should reflect efforts to secure his consent.

  2. Home Study and Investigations

    • The DSWD or an accredited social worker conducts a home study on both the child’s background and the adoptive parents’ qualifications.
    • If the father has refused consent, the social worker’s report may include observations on whether the father’s refusal is justified or detrimental to the child’s welfare.

  3. Supervised Trial Custody

    • If the adoption proceeds despite the father’s refusal (e.g., consent is deemed unnecessary or dispensed with), the child will usually be under a supervised trial custody with the adoptive family for at least six months before the final decree of adoption can be issued.

  4. Court Hearing and Decree

    • The judge hears testimony from all concerned parties (including, if available, the father).
    • If the court finds all legal requirements satisfied and the adoption to be in the child’s best interest, a decree of adoption is issued.
    • If the father’s valid refusal stands, the adoption may be denied.

  5. Appeal

    • Should any party be dissatisfied with the Family Court’s ruling—whether it allows or disallows the adoption—they may appeal to the Court of Appeals and, ultimately, to the Supreme Court if necessary.

In every stage, the guiding standard is the best interest of the child. Even in the face of paternal refusal, courts will not automatically dismiss an adoption if there is compelling evidence that the father’s continued custody or refusal to consent endangers or is contrary to the welfare of the child.

7. Practical Considerations and Recommendations

  1. Attempt Amicable Resolution

    • Prospective adoptive parents, together with the mother and the father, should consider mediation or counseling to address the father’s concerns.
    • An amicable settlement is ideal to avoid drawn-out litigation and emotional stress for the child.

  2. Document Proof of Abandonment or Neglect

    • If the father is absent or has refused to provide support and contact, gather tangible proof (e.g., records of non-support, records of attempts to contact, etc.).
    • This evidence may be crucial in demonstrating the father’s abandonment or lack of genuine parental involvement.

  3. Seek Professional Legal Advice

    • Each adoption case can have unique and complex factual circumstances.
    • Consulting with an experienced family law attorney ensures that all procedural and substantive requirements are correctly followed.

  4. Coordinate with DSWD

    • The DSWD plays an integral role in domestic adoption, especially regarding certifications of a child’s availability for adoption or verifying parental abandonment.
    • Early engagement with social workers and child welfare officers helps ensure a smoother process.

  5. Prioritize the Child’s Best Interests

    • Ultimately, the legal system weighs the “best interest of the child” more heavily than the preferences of the parents or the would-be adoptive parents, especially in contested adoption scenarios.

8. Conclusion

In Philippine law, a father who has recognized his child and retains parental authority generally must consent to an adoption—his refusal, if valid and in good faith, can prevent or delay the process. However, this refusal is neither absolute nor unassailable. When the father is absent, neglectful, incompetent, or has otherwise lost parental authority, the courts may dispense with his consent. In every adoption proceeding, the primary standard remains the best interest of the child—a principle that can override a father’s refusal if it is determined to be detrimental to the child’s welfare.

Anyone facing a situation involving paternal consent in adoption should seek personalized legal guidance. Adoption is a sensitive and detail-oriented legal process, and aligning all steps with statutory requirements and the child’s welfare is the surest path to a valid and beneficial outcome.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login