How to Claim Unreleased Employee Incentives from a Former Employer

How to Claim Unreleased Employee Incentives from a Former Employer (Philippine Context)
Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific concerns, consult a licensed attorney in the Philippines.

1. Introduction

Incentives or bonuses are often used by employers to reward productivity, encourage loyalty, and recognize the achievements of their employees. While Filipino labor laws do not explicitly require all employers to provide incentives beyond what is mandated by law (e.g., 13th month pay), many companies voluntarily adopt incentive programs. Problems can arise, however, when an employee leaves the company—voluntarily or involuntarily—and the incentives earned remain unreleased. This article discusses the legal framework in the Philippines for claiming these unreleased employee incentives and outlines practical steps to help former employees enforce their rights.

2. Understanding Employee Incentives in the Philippine Context

  1. Definition

    • Employee incentives generally refer to monetary or non-monetary benefits awarded to employees in addition to regular wages. They can take the form of performance bonuses, sales commissions, profit-sharing plans, stock options, or other forms of reward that are typically based on performance metrics.

  2. Legal Basis

    • Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442) primarily governs employer-employee relationships. However, the Labor Code does not explicitly regulate incentives that go beyond statutory benefits (e.g., 13th month pay, service incentive leave, etc.).
    • Contractual or Company Policy Basis: When an employer voluntarily provides incentives, the terms and conditions often come from the employment contract, company policies, or collective bargaining agreements (CBA) for unionized companies. Once these incentives are embedded in company policy or a contract, they may become enforceable obligations.

  3. Nature of Incentives

    • Discretionary vs. Non-Discretionary: Some incentives are purely discretionary, meaning the employer has the final say on whether to grant them and how much. Others are non-discretionary, governed by established criteria or formulas. Where the policy or employment contract outlines specific conditions for earning an incentive (e.g., sales commission rates, performance metrics), these may constitute a demandable right once the conditions are satisfied.

3. Common Reasons for Unreleased Incentives

  1. Resignation or Separation: Employers may argue that incentives are forfeited if an employee resigns before a certain date.
  2. Disputed Performance or Metrics: An employer might claim that the performance targets were not fully met or that the employee is not entitled to the full amount.
  3. Contractual Ambiguities: Vague or poorly worded incentive policies can lead to disputes over eligibility and computation.
  4. Administrative Delays: Sometimes incentives remain unclaimed due to processing backlogs or administrative oversight.
  5. Employer’s Financial Difficulties: An employer facing financial woes might delay or fail to release incentives entirely.

4. Determining Your Entitlement to the Incentive

Before pursuing a formal claim, you should determine if you have a legally enforceable right to the incentive:

  1. Review Your Employment Contract and Company Policies

    • Check whether the incentive is explicitly stated as part of your employment agreement, an addendum, or a documented company policy (e.g., an employee handbook or memorandum).
    • Assess the requirements for entitlement: Did you meet the performance metrics? Did you stay employed until the required “cut-off” date?

  2. Check Collective Bargaining Agreements (if applicable)

    • If you are part of a union, the CBA may include specific provisions on incentives or bonuses, and these provisions become binding on the employer.

  3. Gather Documentation

    • Collect evidence such as payslips, performance reports, emails from management, or any other documents that help show you fulfilled the conditions for earning the incentive.

  4. Company’s Historical Practice

    • Even if the incentive policy is not formally written, a history of consistently granting incentives to employees who meet certain criteria may establish a “company practice” recognized by jurisprudence. If such practice is proven, the incentive can become a demandable right.

5. Steps to Claim Unreleased Incentives

  1. Communicate with Your Former Employer

    • Begin with a polite and documented inquiry (e.g., email, letter) to your former employer’s HR or payroll department requesting the release of your incentive.
    • Provide supporting documents showing your eligibility.

  2. Send a Formal Demand Letter

    • If an informal request fails or is ignored, consider sending a Demand Letter stating the basis for your claim, the amount you believe is due, and a reasonable deadline for payment.
    • This letter should be clear, factual, and assertive about your right to the incentive under the company’s policy or contract.

  3. Attempt an Amicable Settlement

    • A settlement (sometimes called a “compromise agreement”) can save time and resources. If your former employer is open to negotiation, you might settle on a specific amount to avoid prolonged disputes.

  4. File a Complaint with the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE)

    • If negotiations fail, you may file a labor complaint. DOLE’s Single Entry Approach (SEnA) facilitates a 30-day mandatory conciliation-mediation period designed to help parties reach a settlement without going to litigation.
    • If no agreement is reached during SEnA, the complaint can be endorsed to the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) for adjudication.

  5. Proceed to the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC)

    • The NLRC has jurisdiction over money claims arising from employer-employee relationships, including unpaid wages, bonuses, and other benefits.
    • You will need to submit documentary evidence and possibly testify regarding your entitlement to the incentive. The employer will likewise present defenses.
    • An NLRC Labor Arbiter will decide on the merits of the case. Should you or the employer disagree with the decision, you can appeal to the NLRC Commission en banc, and subsequently to the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court under certain conditions.

  6. Consult with a Labor Lawyer

    • For complex cases or if you are unsure about any step, consulting a lawyer experienced in labor law is highly recommended. They can guide you on the strengths of your claim, proper documentation, and how best to present your case.

6. Legal Considerations and Potential Defenses by Employers

  1. Contractual Clauses

    • Some employment contracts or incentive policies specify that incentives or bonuses are forfeited if an employee leaves before a certain date. Courts typically uphold such clauses if they are clear, lawful, and mutually agreed upon.
    • However, if the employee has already earned the incentive before separation (e.g., fully met sales targets), a clause outright forfeiting it might be deemed unreasonable or void by labor tribunals, depending on the specific facts and the fairness of the policy.

  2. Condition Precedent

    • Employers may argue that you did not fulfill certain conditions (e.g., performance metrics, attendance record). Demonstrating that you met these conditions (e.g., meeting targets) is crucial to refuting this defense.

  3. Company Policy or Practice

    • Employers might claim that the incentive policy is purely discretionary. You must show that the policy or practice is non-discretionary or that it has evolved into a company practice binding on the employer.

  4. Time Bar (Prescription Period)

    • Under Article 305 of the Labor Code (previously Article 292), money claims prescribe in three (3) years from the time the cause of action accrued. If you delay filing beyond three years from the date the incentive should have been released, your claim may be barred.

7. Practical Tips

  1. Document Everything

    • Keep copies of employment contracts, payslips, performance appraisals, emails, or notices from HR.
    • Clear documentation strengthens your position significantly.

  2. Act Promptly

    • Do not wait too long to request or demand the release of your incentive. Remember the 3-year prescriptive period for money claims.

  3. Maintain Professionalism

    • Whether dealing directly with your former employer or going through the DOLE conciliation process, remain polite and factual.

  4. Consider the Cost-Benefit

    • Legal proceedings can be time-consuming and emotionally draining. Before filing a case, weigh the potential recovery against litigation costs and personal stress.

  5. Gather Witnesses (if needed)

    • If colleagues or supervisors can corroborate your performance or the existence of a consistent incentive practice, their testimony can be valuable during labor proceedings.

8. Summary and Conclusion

Claiming unreleased employee incentives in the Philippines revolves around proving you have a legally enforceable right to these benefits, whether through a contract, a documented policy, or a consistent company practice. If informal communications and demand letters fail, DOLE’s SEnA and the NLRC provide legal avenues for pursuing monetary claims.

To ensure the best possible outcome:

  • Verify that you have satisfied all the requirements for receiving the incentive.
  • Gather and organize all relevant documentation.
  • Initiate communication with your former employer, starting with a cordial request and escalating to a demand letter if necessary.
  • If amicable settlement fails, proceed to DOLE or NLRC within the applicable prescriptive period of three years.
  • Seek professional legal advice to navigate the nuances of labor laws and strengthen your case.

By following these steps and understanding your rights under Philippine labor laws, you stand a better chance of successfully claiming any unreleased incentives owed to you by a former employer.

Disclaimer: This article provides a general overview and may not cover specific nuances of each case. For a thorough legal assessment tailored to your situation, seek the advice of a qualified Philippine labor lawyer.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login