How to Contest Wrongful Dismissal Over Commission Disputes

Disclaimer: The following information is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Labor laws can be complex and may change over time. If you require legal assistance or specific advice, consult a qualified lawyer in the Philippines.

How to Contest Wrongful Dismissal Over Commission Disputes in the Philippines

Wrongful (or illegal) dismissal refers to the termination of an employee’s services by an employer without just or authorized cause and/or without following due process as mandated by law. When wrongful dismissal occurs due to a dispute over commission, employees in the Philippines can invoke legal remedies under the Labor Code and applicable jurisprudence. Below is a comprehensive overview of what you should know about contesting wrongful dismissal over commission disputes.

1. Understanding Commissions Under Philippine Labor Law

  1. Commissions as Part of Wages

    • Under Philippine law, commissions may be considered part of an employee’s wage if they are guaranteed or integrated into the compensation package. The Supreme Court, in various decisions, has clarified that commissions form part of wages when they are not dependent solely on the employer’s discretion, but rather form part of the compensation agreed upon in the employment contract.
    • However, commissions that are purely discretionary (e.g., performance bonuses) might be treated differently. The nature of the commission—whether it is a standard incentive or purely discretionary—can affect how disputes and eventual claims are handled.

  2. Employment Contracts and Commission Schemes

    • Most employers detail commission schemes in employment contracts or separate written agreements. These often specify:
      • Commission rates (percentage or fixed amount per sale).
      • Targets and performance metrics (such as quotas).
      • Payment schedules (monthly, quarterly, etc.).
      • Conditions or prerequisites for earning a commission (e.g., when a sale is considered “closed” or “collected”).

  3. Importance of Documentation

    • Having a written agreement or documented proof of how commissions are calculated and paid is critical. Emails, payslips, and policy handbooks help establish the rightful entitlements of the employee.

2. What Constitutes Wrongful Dismissal in Commission Disputes

  1. Lack of Just or Authorized Cause

    • In the Philippines, the Labor Code (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended) enumerates just and authorized causes for termination.
    • Just causes include serious misconduct, willful disobedience, gross and habitual neglect of duties, fraud, commission of a crime, and other analogous causes.
    • Authorized causes include business closures, retrenchment for economic reasons, redundancy, or disease not curable within six months.

    If an employer terminates an employee due to a commission-related dispute that does not fall under these grounds, it may be deemed illegal (wrongful) dismissal.

  2. Violation of Due Process

    • Even if a valid cause exists, employers must provide substantive and procedural due process.
    • Substantive due process requires that a legitimate cause exists.
    • Procedural due process in the context of just causes typically requires:
      1. A first notice informing the employee of the specific acts or omissions that may warrant termination.
      2. An opportunity to be heard (i.e., a hearing or a chance to explain in writing).
      3. A second notice or final notice informing the employee of the employer’s decision.

    An employer who dismisses an employee immediately because of a disagreement over commission (for instance, the employee insists on receiving unpaid commissions) without following the above steps violates procedural due process.

  3. Constructive Dismissal

    • An employee may also claim constructive dismissal if an employer’s actions (such as withholding commissions without valid reason, demoting the employee unfairly, or drastically cutting working hours/conditions) effectively force the employee to resign.
    • Constructive dismissal is treated as illegal dismissal under Philippine law.

3. Common Scenarios Leading to Commission-Related Dismissals

  1. Non-Payment or Underpayment of Commissions

    • The employee raises a grievance or files a complaint about unpaid or underpaid commissions. If the employer reacts with retaliation, such as terminating the employee, this may be considered wrongful dismissal.

  2. Dispute Over Commission Structure

    • An employer unilaterally changes the commission rate without the employee’s consent, and subsequently fires the employee who protests or refuses to sign the new agreement.

  3. Accusations of Fraudulent Sales

    • An employer may claim an employee falsified sales or engaged in misconduct to inflate commissions. If the employer cannot prove just cause or fails to accord due process, the dismissal is illegal.

4. Steps to Contest Wrongful Dismissal Over Commission Disputes

  1. Gather Evidence

    • Employment Contract or Appointment Letter – Confirm the agreed-upon commission structure.
    • Payslips, Sales Reports, and Correspondence – Document the commissions earned and any disputes raised.
    • Company Policies or Handbooks – Refer to official guidelines on commission calculation and payment.
    • Letters or Emails – If there are written communications pertaining to the dispute, keep copies.

  2. Attempt an Amicable Settlement or Discussion

    • Philippine labor laws and practice often encourage settling disputes amicably. Speak with Human Resources or higher management to clarify any misunderstandings and try to arrive at a settlement or re-negotiation of the dispute.

  3. File a Complaint with the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC)

    • If discussions fail, the wrongfully dismissed employee can file a complaint for Illegal Dismissal (and claims for unpaid wages or commissions, if any) before the NLRC.
    • Filing Fee – Generally, filing fees for labor cases are nominal, especially for claims that do not exceed certain thresholds.
    • Mandatory Conciliation-Mediation – Upon filing, the case is typically referred to the Single Entry Approach (SEnA) for conciliation-mediation with the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE). If unresolved, it proceeds to the NLRC.

  4. Participate in NLRC Proceedings

    • Submission of Position Papers – Both parties present their positions, with supporting evidence and legal arguments.
    • Mandatory Conferences/Hearings – The parties may be called for clarificatory hearings.
    • Decision by Labor Arbiter – The Labor Arbiter will decide whether dismissal was illegal and the amount of monetary award.

  5. Appeal Mechanisms

    • If either party disagrees with the Arbiter’s decision, they can appeal to the NLRC Commission proper, then potentially to the Court of Appeals, and ultimately to the Supreme Court, subject to legal grounds.

5. Potential Remedies and Damages

  1. Reinstatement and Back Wages

    • If the Labor Arbiter or the NLRC finds that the termination was illegal, the employee is typically entitled to reinstatement to the former position without loss of seniority rights and payment of full back wages.

  2. Separation Pay (in lieu of Reinstatement)

    • In some cases, if reinstatement is no longer feasible (or the relations between employer and employee are too strained), the arbiter or commission may order separation pay instead.

  3. Unpaid Commissions

    • The employee can also claim any unpaid commissions owed, subject to proof that they have indeed earned them under the terms of the agreement.

  4. Damages

    • If the dismissal is made in bad faith or the employer acted oppressively, employees may be entitled to moral and exemplary damages.
    • Attorney’s fees of up to 10% of the total award may also be granted.

6. Defenses Available to Employers

  1. Valid Just or Authorized Cause
    • An employer might argue there was a legitimate reason to dismiss (e.g., fraud, willful disobedience, redundancy). They bear the burden of proving that cause.
  2. Proper Due Process
    • The employer may show they followed the twin notice requirement and gave the employee ample opportunity to explain.
  3. No Earned Commission
    • Where the dispute centers on commissions, the employer might claim the employee had not yet qualified for them—e.g., the sale was not finalized, or there was a return or cancellation.
  4. Good Faith Actions
    • If the employer can demonstrate actions were done in good faith and in the ordinary course of business, they may avoid liability for moral or exemplary damages.

7. Practical Tips for Employees

  1. Read and Understand Your Employment Contract

    • Always clarify commission rates, payment schedules, and targets.

  2. Keep Detailed Records

    • Maintain your own log of sales, quotas, and communications with supervisors or HR.

  3. Assert Your Rights Promptly

    • If unpaid commissions start accumulating, raise the issue formally. This documentation can help prove your case.

  4. Consult a Lawyer or Labor Consultant

    • Because labor law can be intricate, speaking to a legal professional ensures you understand your rights and obligations.

  5. Be Mindful of Time Limits

    • Labor complaints for illegal dismissal typically must be filed within four (4) years from the date of dismissal (though certain monetary claims can have different prescription periods). Filing sooner is always recommended.

8. Conclusion

Contesting wrongful dismissal over commission disputes in the Philippines requires a clear understanding of labor laws, contractual provisions, and due process requirements. Employees have strong legal protections against illegal termination and can file claims for reinstatement, back wages, and payment of rightful commissions. Proper documentation, prompt action, and legal guidance are key to a successful claim.

If you find yourself in a dispute regarding commissions and you suspect you’ve been wrongfully dismissed, gather your evidence, seek an amicable resolution if possible, and, if necessary, pursue legal remedies through the NLRC. As always, for specific advice tailored to your situation, consult a licensed Philippine attorney or labor law expert.

References and Relevant Laws:

  • Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended)
  • Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) Regulations
  • Supreme Court Decisions on Illegal Dismissal and Commission Disputes (e.g., rulings clarifying the inclusion of commissions in wages and due process in termination)

This article is intended only to provide general legal information. For personalized advice and the most current legal developments, always consult a qualified lawyer.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login