How to Dismiss a Case Based on an Annulled Marriage

Disclaimer: The following discussion is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional legal advice. If you need guidance on a specific case or situation, please consult a qualified attorney in the Philippines.

How to Dismiss a Case Based on an Annulled Marriage in the Philippines

Annulment of marriage—and the broader concept of declaring a marriage void—can have significant implications on existing or potential legal cases in the Philippines. When a court issues a final judgment declaring a marriage null and void or annulling it, certain claims or causes of action connected to that marriage may be rendered moot and dismissible. This article outlines (1) the relevant laws on null and voidable marriages, (2) the implications of an annulled or void marriage on pending cases, and (3) practical steps on seeking dismissal of a case premised on an annulled (or declared void) marriage.

1. Overview of Philippine Laws on Null and Voidable Marriages

1.1 The Family Code of the Philippines

The primary source of law governing marriage in the Philippines is the Family Code (Executive Order No. 209, as amended). Under the Family Code, two major legal concepts exist regarding the invalidity of marriage:

  1. Void (or void ab initio) Marriages – These marriages are considered never to have existed from the start. Examples of void marriages include:

    • Bigamous or polygamous marriages (Article 35[4]);
    • Marriages contracted by parties below eighteen (18) years of age (Article 35[1]);
    • Marriages performed without a valid marriage license (Article 35[3]), unless exempted by law;
    • Incestuous marriages (Article 37);
    • Marriages void by reason of public policy (Article 38);
    • Psychological incapacity under Article 36 (commonly referred to as “nullity” cases, though often colloquially lumped under ‘annulment’).

  2. Voidable (Annulable) Marriages – These marriages are considered valid until annulled by a competent court. Grounds include (Articles 45 and 46):

    • Lack of parental consent for individuals aged 18 to 21 at the time of marriage;
    • Either party of unsound mind (unless such party freely cohabited with the other after coming to reason);
    • Consent obtained by fraud (certain specific circumstances of fraud as enumerated by the Code);
    • Force, intimidation, or undue influence;
    • Physical incapability to consummate the marriage;
    • Sexually transmissible disease found to be serious and incurable.

Important Distinction

  • A void marriage is deemed non-existent from the beginning, although a judicial declaration of nullity is still required for practical and legal purposes (e.g., for remarriage, property registration).
  • A voidable (annulable) marriage is considered valid and existing until an annulment decree is issued. After a final judgment of annulment, the marriage is deemed invalid from inception.

For brevity, this article will use “annulment” to refer to both Declaration of Nullity (for void marriages) and Annulment (for voidable marriages). In practice, these are separate legal actions with distinct grounds.

2. Legal Effects of an Annulled or Void Marriage

Once a court issues a final judgment that a marriage is void or voidable and thus annulled, the marriage is treated as though it never existed. This has far-reaching consequences, including effects on:

  1. Status of the Parties

    • The parties are restored to their single status (though certain civil statuses, like legitime of children, may be preserved under specific conditions).

  2. Property Relations

    • The property regime is usually dissolved. The court will make determinations on how to liquidate or partition the properties, guided by the applicable property regime (e.g., absolute community or conjugal partnership of gains) prior to the decree.

  3. Support, Custody, and Succession

    • The court may order child support or decide custody matters if there are children.
    • Succession rights between spouses may also be affected since, legally, the marriage is treated as nonexistent.

  4. Pending Cases or Actions

    • If a case is premised on the validity of the marriage (e.g., certain civil or criminal actions), a final judgment declaring the marriage void or annulled may serve as a legal basis for dismissal.

3. Common Scenarios Where an Annulled Marriage Can Lead to Dismissal of a Case

3.1 Criminal Case for Bigamy

Under Article 349 of the Revised Penal Code, bigamy requires a valid, subsisting marriage at the time the second or subsequent marriage is contracted. If the first marriage is judicially declared void from the beginning, there was, in legal effect, no first marriage. Therefore, an accused may move to dismiss bigamy charges if:

  • The first marriage was declared void ab initio (e.g., for lack of a marriage license or for being a bigamous marriage in itself).
  • The accused obtains a final judgment of nullity showing that the supposed first marriage never existed in the eyes of the law.

Note: If the first marriage was only voidable, the scenario is more nuanced. A voidable marriage is considered valid until annulled. Thus, if a second marriage was contracted before the court’s final annulment decree, bigamy might still be committed.

3.2 Civil Cases Involving Spousal Rights

Some civil cases hinge on the existence of a valid marriage, for example:

  1. Support Claims: A spouse seeking support from the other spouse under Article 194 et seq. of the Family Code. If the marriage is declared void ab initio, the defendant may argue that no spousal support obligation existed from the start.
  2. Property Disputes: A suit concerning conjugal or community property may be rendered moot if the marriage is declared void. The property relations should be settled according to the rules for co-ownership (if void ab initio) or other applicable property regimes, effectively altering or nullifying the basis of a typical “spousal share” claim.
  3. Nullification of Marriage Settlement Agreements: A prenuptial or postnuptial agreement premised on the existence of a valid marriage may no longer be enforceable if that marriage is found to be void ab initio.

3.3 Inheritance Cases

Inheritance claims from a spouse generally rely on the validity of the marriage. If the marriage is declared null, a claim to inherit as a spouse might be dismissed or invalidated. While the “spouse” in a void marriage has no inheritance rights as a legal spouse, children’s rights are a separate matter protected by law (e.g., legitimate, illegitimate, or legitimated children, depending on circumstances).

4. Grounds for and Steps in Filing a Motion to Dismiss

When a party is sued (civil, criminal, or administrative) on the assumption of a valid marriage—and a final judgment or decree of annulment or nullity of marriage** is available—the party may file a Motion to Dismiss. Below are the general steps and legal considerations:

  1. Obtain a Certified True Copy of the Court Decree

    • Secure a certified true copy of the final judgment or decree of annulment/nullity from the court that issued it. Ensure that the Entry of Judgment is also obtained to prove finality.

  2. Attach the Decree to the Motion

    • In your motion to dismiss, attach the certified true copy of the decree and the certificate of finality as evidence. This demonstrates to the court that there is a conclusive legal finding that the marriage is void.

  3. Legal Basis in the Motion

    • For civil cases, cite Rule 16 of the Rules of Court (for a motion to dismiss) or a motion under the relevant procedural rule if the case is already beyond the pleadings stage.
    • Emphasize that the cause of action (or one of the key elements thereof) no longer exists, because the marriage, upon which the claim is based, is now conclusively declared null and void (or annulled).

  4. Argue Lack of Cause of Action or Mootness

    • In civil cases, a cause of action must exist at the time of the filing of the complaint. If the validity of the marriage is a prerequisite to that cause of action, the annulment/nullity judgment effectively negates it.
    • In criminal cases (e.g., bigamy), highlight that an essential element—“a prior valid marriage”—was legally non-existent.

  5. Await Court Resolution

    • The trial court will conduct a hearing on the motion to dismiss or resolve it based on the pleadings and documentary evidence submitted.
    • If granted, the case is dismissed. If denied, the defendant/accused may seek other remedies (e.g., certiorari, appeal, etc.) depending on the stage of litigation.

5. Other Relevant Considerations

  1. Timing:

    • It is critical that the annulment or nullity is already final and executory before it can be a valid ground for dismissal. Merely filing a petition for annulment is usually insufficient to dismiss a case.

  2. Good Faith in Second Marriage (Bigamy Cases):

    • In bigamy prosecutions, if the accused believed in good faith that the first marriage was void (or had taken legal steps but no final decree was issued yet), the court will still require a final judgment of nullity. Good faith may be invoked as a defense, but it typically does not negate the fact of bigamy absent a valid final decree at the time of contracting the second marriage.

  3. Recognition of Foreign Annulments or Divorces:

    • If the annulment or nullity decree was obtained abroad, judicial recognition of the foreign judgment in the Philippine courts is required before it can be used to dismiss a case.

  4. Effect on Children’s Status:

    • Under Article 54 of the Family Code, children conceived or born of a void marriage under Article 36 (psychological incapacity) or Article 53 (subsequent marriage without compliance with certain legal formalities) are still considered legitimate. This can be relevant in custody and support disputes but does not prevent dismissal of claims strictly reliant on the spousal relationship.

  5. Possibility of Partial Dismissal:

    • Courts may dismiss parts of a civil suit premised on the marriage’s validity but retain other parts that do not rely on that marriage. For instance, if there are alternative claims or multiple causes of action not solely anchored on the marriage, only those based on the spousal relationship might be dismissed.

6. Practical Tips

  1. Secure Legal Counsel

    • Dismissing a case on the ground of annulled or void marriage requires careful procedural steps. A lawyer can ensure proper filing, adherence to timelines, and correct argumentation before the court.

  2. Gather All Relevant Documents

    • Aside from the decree of nullity or annulment, gather the certificate of finality, marriage certificates (first and subsequent, if any), and other relevant records (e.g., property registry documents, birth certificates of children).

  3. Act Promptly

    • If you are a defendant in a civil case or the accused in a criminal case, do not delay in informing the court about the final nullity or annulment. Procedural rules may impose strict deadlines for raising certain defenses.

  4. Check for Possible Counterclaims or Other Liabilities

    • The opposing party may argue new grounds or amend their complaint. Ensure that you address any residual claims not strictly dependent on the marriage’s validity (e.g., child support obligations remain even if the marriage is declared void).

  5. Expect a Court Hearing

    • In many instances, courts will set a hearing on the motion to dismiss. Be prepared to present documents and possibly witnesses (if contested).

7. Conclusion

The annulment or declaration of nullity of marriage in the Philippines can serve as a powerful legal basis to dismiss cases hinging on the marriage’s validity—such as bigamy, claims for spousal support, certain property disputes, or inheritance actions. However, proper procedure must be followed:

  • Obtain and present the final decree of nullity or annulment, along with the certificate of finality.
  • File a motion to dismiss grounded on lack of cause of action or mootness.
  • Provide the court with sufficient evidence that the marriage was declared void ab initio or annulled by a competent court, making the claim unsustainable.

Ultimately, legal counsel is indispensable in ensuring correct application of the rules and leveraging a final annulment or nullity decree to secure a favorable outcome. If you believe your case or defense hinges on an annulled or void marriage, consult an experienced Philippine lawyer for detailed guidance specific to your circumstances.

References

  • Family Code of the Philippines (E.O. No. 209, as amended)
  • Rules of Court (particularly Rule 16 on Motions to Dismiss and other relevant rules)
  • Revised Penal Code of the Philippines (for criminal charges such as bigamy under Article 349)
  • Relevant Supreme Court jurisprudence on void and voidable marriages, such as Santos v. Bedia-Santos, Republic v. Molina, Ngo Te v. Yu-Te, and others.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login