How to Prepare a Position Paper for NLRC Labor Disputes

How to Prepare a Position Paper for NLRC Labor Disputes in the Philippines

In Philippine labor practice, one of the key documents required by the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) or a Labor Arbiter is the Position Paper. This document lays down the parties’ respective factual and legal arguments and is crucial in resolving labor disputes. Below is an in-depth look at everything you need to know about preparing a Position Paper for NLRC labor disputes.

1. Overview of the NLRC and Its Proceedings

  1. What is the NLRC?
    The National Labor Relations Commission is a quasi-judicial body tasked with resolving labor and management disputes. It operates under the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) but functions independently and with adjudicatory powers.

  2. Nature of NLRC Proceedings
    The proceedings before the NLRC (and its Labor Arbiters) are generally less formal than in regular courts. While they are not strictly governed by the technical rules of evidence observed in regular trial courts, they must still observe due process and basic procedural rules set forth by the Labor Code of the Philippines and the Revised Rules of the NLRC.

  3. Why is the Position Paper Important?

    • In labor cases, hearings are often limited. The parties usually do not undergo full-blown trials with witness stand testimony as in civil or criminal courts.
    • The Labor Arbiter (or the Commission, on appeal) often relies heavily on the pleadings, documentary evidence, and position papers in determining the merits of the case.
    • A well-prepared Position Paper can clarify factual issues, present legal bases, and define the reliefs or remedies sought by each side, greatly influencing the Arbiter’s or Commission’s decision.

2. Legal and Procedural Basis

  1. Labor Code of the Philippines

    • The Labor Code (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended) provides the substantive and procedural framework for labor disputes, including how parties should present their claims and defenses.

  2. 2022 Revised Rules of the NLRC (or the latest version applicable)

    • These rules set out the detailed procedure on how a labor dispute proceeds from filing of the complaint to resolution by the Labor Arbiter and, if necessary, up to the Commission on appeal.
    • They specify when and how the Position Paper is required to be submitted, typically after the mandatory mediation/conciliation conference.

  3. Labor Arbiter’s Directive

    • After the initial conferences (which may include mandatory conciliation or mediation), the Labor Arbiter will issue an Order directing the parties to simultaneously file their verified Position Papers within a specific period (usually ten (10) calendar days, which may be extended at the Arbiter’s discretion).

3. Timing and Submission Requirements

  1. When to File

    • Typically, the Labor Arbiter will indicate the deadline for submission of the Position Paper in the Order issued after the preliminary or mandatory conference.
    • Be mindful of extensions: The Arbiter may or may not grant an extension for justifiable reasons.

  2. Verification and Certification

    • Verification: The Position Paper must be signed by the party (or its authorized representative) attesting to the truthfulness and correctness of the allegations based on personal knowledge or authentic records.
    • Certification of Non-Forum Shopping: Under Philippine procedural rules, pleadings must often include a certification stating that the party has not commenced or filed any similar action in other courts or agencies. Although the NLRC is more flexible, it is prudent to include a certification to avoid procedural questions later on.

  3. Number of Copies

    • The Labor Arbiter’s directive typically specifies the number of copies to be submitted. Generally, parties file an original plus at least two (2) copies—one for the Arbiter’s official file, one for the opposing party, and possibly additional copies if there are multiple respondents or complainants.

4. Structure and Contents of the Position Paper

A well-structured Position Paper typically contains the following sections:

  1. Heading/Caption

    • The caption follows the standard legal format, indicating the case title (e.g., “Juan Dela Cruz, Complainant, vs. ABC Corporation, Respondent”), the docket number assigned by the NLRC or Labor Arbiter, and the adjudicating office (e.g., “Before the Labor Arbiter,” “National Labor Relations Commission”).

  2. Statement of the Nature of the Case

    • A brief introduction stating whether the action is for illegal dismissal, monetary claims (like unpaid wages, 13th month pay, or separation pay), labor standard violations, or other matters.
    • This is where you give a concise summary of why the case was initiated.

  3. Statement of Facts

    • Lay down the facts chronologically and as clearly as possible.
    • Focus on relevant details: dates of hiring, nature of employment, details of dismissal or alleged violation, communications between the parties, and any important documentary or testimonial evidence.
    • Tip: Attach and reference pertinent documents (e.g., contract of employment, pay slips, company memos, notices of termination) as exhibits or annexes.

  4. Issues

    • Enumerate the main legal and factual issues to be resolved (e.g., “Whether complainant was dismissed for just or authorized cause,” “Whether due process was observed,” “Whether the employee is entitled to reinstatement or separation pay,” etc.).
    • Identifying the correct issues helps guide the Arbiter in analyzing the dispute.

  5. Arguments and Discussion

    • This is the heart of the Position Paper. Organize arguments under subheadings that address each issue.
    • Employers defending against illegal dismissal claims typically discuss:
      • The legal ground for dismissal (just or authorized cause under the Labor Code).
      • Observance of due process (e.g., “two-notice rule” and opportunity to be heard).
      • Proof of compliance with labor standards.
    • Employees alleging illegal dismissal typically discuss:
      • Lack of valid grounds (no just or authorized cause).
      • Failure to observe due process.
      • Any unpaid salaries, benefits, or damages.
    • Cite Relevant Laws and Jurisprudence: Reference the Labor Code, NLRC Rules, and Supreme Court decisions to support your points.

  6. Prayer/Relief Sought

    • Clearly state what you want the Arbiter or the NLRC to grant:
      • For employees: reinstatement, back wages, damages, attorney’s fees, etc.
      • For employers: dismissal of the complaint, or alternative reliefs (e.g., payment of separation pay instead of reinstatement).
    • End with a “catch-all” prayer for other remedies deemed just and equitable.

  7. Verification/Certification

    • Place the verification clause (usually titled “Verification”) and have it duly signed and sworn before a notary public.
    • If required, attach a “Certification of Non-Forum Shopping” to comply with procedural safeguards.

  8. Annexes/Exhibits

    • Attach all documentary evidence properly marked (e.g., “Annex A,” “Annex B,” etc.).
    • Provide a separate “List of Annexes” for easy reference.

5. Best Practices in Preparing a Position Paper

  1. Be Factual and Objective

    • Focus on verifiable facts. Avoid unsupported accusations or irrelevant assertions.
    • A chronological narrative helps the reader (including the Arbiter) follow the flow of events.

  2. Be Clear and Concise

    • Although you want to be thorough, avoid verbosity or overly technical language.
    • Keep sentences and paragraphs direct; highlight the most relevant points.

  3. Back Up Claims with Evidence

    • Under the NLRC’s simplified rules, documentary evidence can be vital.
    • Whenever possible, attach originals or certified true copies of documents to avoid challenges to authenticity.

  4. Use Legal Authority Appropriately

    • Cite the Labor Code and applicable jurisprudence from the Supreme Court.
    • Explain how these precedents directly apply to your case.

  5. Comply with Formatting and Technical Requirements

    • Use standard legal margins and font sizes.
    • The Arbiter’s directive (or the NLRC Rules) may specify additional format requirements.

  6. Observe Deadlines

    • Late submission can weaken your case or lead to procedural defaults.
    • If an extension is needed, file a motion before the deadline and specify valid grounds.

6. Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  1. Failure to Verify

    • An unverified Position Paper might be considered a mere scrap of paper and may risk being disregarded or stricken from the records.

  2. Omission of Critical Facts

    • Incomplete factual presentation can mislead the Arbiter or leave room for adverse inferences.
    • Both employees and employers should be thorough in presenting the totality of circumstances.

  3. No Attachment of Documentary Evidence

    • Supporting documents are crucial because labor cases often rely on them instead of live testimony.
    • If you fail to attach critical documents, you might not be allowed to introduce them later unless you have valid justifications.

  4. Unorganized Structure

    • A disorganized paper makes it harder for the Arbiter to identify the issues and arguments.
    • Always have a logical flow: Facts → Issues → Arguments → Prayer.

  5. Misstatements or Exaggerations

    • Credibility is paramount. Deliberate falsehood or extreme exaggeration can damage a party’s trustworthiness.

7. After Submission of the Position Paper

  1. Reply/Rejoinder

    • Often, the Arbiter will allow parties to file responsive pleadings (Reply, Rejoinder, or Sur-Rejoinder) within certain timelines to address new matters raised in the opposing party’s Position Paper.
    • Respond promptly to new or controversial points and attach any additional pertinent evidence.

  2. Clarificatory Hearings or Conferences

    • The Labor Arbiter may call the parties for a clarificatory hearing if certain points in the Position Papers need further explanation.
    • Prepare for possible questioning and have all your original documentary evidence on hand.

  3. Submission for Resolution

    • After the exchanges of pleadings (Position Paper, Reply, etc.) and any clarificatory hearings, the case is deemed submitted for decision.
    • Expect the Arbiter’s decision within the reglementary period, although actual issuance can vary.

  4. Appeal to the NLRC

    • If any party is dissatisfied with the Arbiter’s decision, they may appeal to the Commission (NLRC) within the period allowed by law (usually ten (10) calendar days from receipt of the Decision).
    • Even during appeal, the Position Paper remains a key reference, so thoroughness at the Arbiter’s level is critical.

8. Practical Tips and Reminders

  • Seek Legal Counsel: While the labor process is more informal, the guidance of a lawyer or a competent representative (e.g., a union official) greatly helps in preparing and organizing the Position Paper.
  • Keep a Paper Trail: In labor relations, written notices, memos, and payroll records may “make or break” a case. Always keep these records properly and present them in your Position Paper.
  • Maintain Professional Tone: Address the Arbiter respectfully and avoid unnecessary attacks on the opposing party.
  • Stay Updated: Labor laws and NLRC rules can be amended. Regularly check for the latest circulars or amendments.

9. Conclusion

Preparing a Position Paper for an NLRC labor dispute in the Philippines is a critical step that demands thoroughness, clarity, and legal grounding. Whether you are an employer defending a management decision or an employee asserting rights, the Position Paper will be a primary vehicle for presenting your side of the story. By organizing your facts, citing relevant laws and jurisprudence, and attaching pertinent evidence, you maximize your chances of a favorable resolution before the Labor Arbiter or the Commission.

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Labor laws and procedural rules may change, and specific cases can involve unique facts and considerations. If you require advice on a particular legal issue, it is advisable to consult a qualified Philippine labor lawyer.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login