Illegal Dismissal Due to Non-Pre-Employment Requirements: Legal Assistance

Illegal Dismissal Due to Non-Pre-Employment Requirements: Legal Assistance in the Philippine Context

Disclaimer: The following discussion is for informational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice. For specific concerns, it is best to consult a qualified labor lawyer or the appropriate government agency.

I. Introduction

In the Philippines, the right of security of tenure is constitutionally guaranteed and further codified in the Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended). This means that employees, once they commence employment, cannot be dismissed except for just or authorized causes and only after following due process.

One of the issues that has arisen in practice involves conflicts over “pre-employment requirements.” These may include clearances (NBI or police), medical certificates, employment records, government documents (SSS, PhilHealth, and Pag-IBIG membership), tax identification numbers, or other documents requested before or shortly after hiring. Sometimes, an employer might invoke an employee’s failure or refusal to submit specific “pre-employment” documents as a reason to terminate the new hire. Whether such termination constitutes illegal dismissal depends on multiple factors, including the nature of the requirement, its timing, and the procedure followed by the employer.

This article outlines what constitutes an illegal dismissal due to non-pre-employment requirements, relevant legal frameworks, and steps for employees to seek assistance.

II. Understanding Employment Status and Security of Tenure

A. Commencement of Employment

  1. Definition: Employment typically begins once there is an agreement for hire (an offer and acceptance), and the employee starts performing tasks or otherwise commences duties.
  2. Implied and Express Employment: An employee may be regarded as hired even if no formal contract is signed, provided the parties act as employer and employee.

B. Security of Tenure

  1. Labor Code Provision: Articles 279-282 (now renumbered) of the Labor Code protect an employee’s right to security of tenure. Once hired on a regular basis (or upon completing the probationary period, or if the job is by nature regular), an employee can only be terminated for just or authorized causes.
  2. Probationary Employees: Even probationary employees have the right to due process and cannot be arbitrarily dismissed. Employers must specify the standards or conditions for regularization at the time of engagement. Failure to meet the published standards can be a valid ground for non-regularization, provided due process is observed.

III. Pre-Employment Requirements: When Are They Mandated?

Before an individual is officially on board as a regular (or even probationary) employee, many employers set out “pre-employment” requirements. Some are mandated by law, while others are policy-driven:

  1. Legally Mandated Documents

    • SSS, PhilHealth, and Pag-IBIG registrations and numbers
    • Tax Identification Number (TIN)
    • Medical Certificate or Fit-to-Work clearance under certain conditions, particularly for roles involving health or safety concerns

  2. Employer-Specific Requirements

    • NBI or Police Clearance (commonly required to verify the person’s background)
    • Drug tests in certain industries or roles
    • Previous employer clearances or certificates

  3. Non-Standard Requests

    • Some employers request unusual requirements or documents that are not typically mandated by law (e.g., certain personal or financial background data).

The timing and necessity of these documents are crucial. If the employee is already performing duties, it is likely that an employer-employee relationship exists—even if some “pre-employment” documents are still outstanding.

IV. Grounds for Termination and Illegality of Dismissal

Under Philippine law, termination of employment can only be valid for:

  1. Just Causes (Art. 297 of the Labor Code, formerly Art. 282)

    • Serious misconduct
    • Willful disobedience
    • Gross and habitual neglect of duties
    • Fraud or breach of trust
    • Commission of a crime against the employer or his representatives, etc.

  2. Authorized Causes (Art. 298-299 of the Labor Code, formerly Art. 283-284)

    • Redundancy
    • Retrenchment
    • Closure or cessation of business
    • Installation of labor-saving devices
    • Disease not curable within six months and continued employment is prejudicial to the health of the employee or co-employees

If an employer dismisses an employee solely because of the employee’s failure or refusal to submit certain documents—especially after the working relationship has effectively begun—this dismissal could be illegal if:

  • The missing documents are not mandated by law, or
  • The dismissal is not based on any valid just or authorized cause,
  • The employer fails to follow due process (i.e., notice and hearing).

A. Good Faith vs. Arbitrary Enforcement

In some cases, if the employer has a clear and reasonable company policy on specific pre-employment documents—and the employee, despite repeated requests, willfully refuses to comply—there might be a ground for discipline. However, employers must follow two notices (notice to explain and notice of decision) and give the employee an opportunity to correct or comply. Arbitrary dismissal without this due process is illegal.

B. Due Process Requirements

  • Notice to Explain (NTE): The employer must inform the employee of the specific acts or omissions that constitute grounds for termination, including the policy or rule violated.
  • Opportunity to be Heard: The employee must be given a reasonable chance to respond in writing, or sometimes in a hearing, if the employer’s policy so dictates.
  • Notice of Decision: The employer must inform the employee in writing of the decision to terminate, including the grounds on which it is based.

Failure to observe these steps can render a dismissal illegal—even if there is a potentially valid reason.

V. Effects of Illegal Dismissal

If an employee is found to have been illegally dismissed, the general rule under Philippine labor law is that the employer may be ordered to:

  1. Reinstate the Employee to his or her former position, without loss of seniority rights and other privileges.
  2. Pay Full Back Wages computed from the time of dismissal until the finality of the decision.
  3. Pay Other Monetary Benefits that the employee would have received if not unlawfully terminated (e.g., allowances, 13th month pay, etc.).

However, if reinstatement is no longer feasible (e.g., strained relations), the labor tribunal or courts may order separation pay instead of reinstatement, plus back wages.

VI. Filing a Complaint: Where and How

When an employee believes they have been illegally dismissed for not fulfilling certain pre-employment requirements, they can file a complaint with:

  1. Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) – for potential labor standard violations or if there is a desire for immediate assistance through the Single Entry Approach (SEnA).
  2. National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) – for compulsory arbitration of labor disputes, particularly illegal dismissal cases.

A. SEnA (Single Entry Approach)

  • An employee may first approach the nearest DOLE office and request assistance through SEnA.
  • A SEnA desk officer will summon both parties for a conference to try to settle the dispute amicably.

B. NLRC

  • If mediation fails, the employee can file a formal complaint at the NLRC.
  • The complaint will be docketed, and a labor arbiter will hear the case.
  • If the labor arbiter rules in favor of the employee and declares an illegal dismissal, the employer may appeal to the NLRC Commission en banc, the Court of Appeals, and ultimately the Supreme Court (if warranted).

VII. Legal Assistance and Practical Tips for Employees

  1. Document Everything:

    • Keep a written or digital trail of all communication with the employer (emails, text messages, notices, etc.).
    • Retain copies of letters (notice to explain, notice of decision) and any written justification demanded by the employer.

  2. Seek Professional Advice Early:

    • Consult with a labor lawyer or labor consultant to assess the merits of your case.
    • In some cases, law clinics or legal aid offices can offer free or subsidized counsel.

  3. Verify Company Policies:

    • Check the Employee Handbook or Company Policy Manual for stated rules on pre-employment documents.
    • If the rule was not communicated at the start or the requirement was introduced only after employment commenced, the employer might lack the proper basis for termination.

  4. Follow Due Process Requirements:

    • If you receive a Notice to Explain, respond promptly and clearly.
    • Failure to respond can be interpreted as negligence or disobedience. However, if the request for additional documents is unreasonable or beyond legal mandates, include this argument in your explanation.

  5. Stay Calm and Cooperative:

    • Despite disagreements, maintain professionalism and good faith in communications with your employer.
    • Attempt to comply if the requirement is legitimate, necessary, or mandated by law. If you believe the requirement is unlawful or irrelevant, articulate your reasons clearly—preferably in writing.

VIII. Relevant Jurisprudence and Legal References

  1. Labor Code of the Philippines (PD 442, as amended)
    • Articles 279-282 (now renumbered) governing security of tenure and dismissals.
  2. Philippine Constitution – Article XIII, Section 3, on the protection of labor and security of tenure.
  3. Jurisprudence:
    • Agabon vs. NLRC (G.R. No. 158693, November 17, 2004) – sets guidelines on procedural due process in dismissals.
    • Manalo vs. CSC and related rulings – discussing how new hires and probationary employees still have rights to due process.
    • Other Supreme Court decisions addressing the necessity for valid causes and due process in termination.

IX. Conclusion

Dismissal for failing to submit “pre-employment” documents—after the employment relationship has already commenced—can be legally questionable, especially if the requirements are not mandated by law or are imposed arbitrarily without clear company policy or due process. Under Philippine labor law, the overarching principle is security of tenure, and any termination must comply with valid grounds and procedural due process.

Employees who suspect they have been illegally dismissed should gather evidence, clarify the employer’s policies, and seek professional legal assistance. They may approach the NLRC to file an illegal dismissal complaint or seek DOLE intervention through SEnA for an expedited resolution. Ultimately, the law protects the rights of both employees and employers by balancing the need for fair disciplinary measures with the constitutional guarantee of security of tenure.

For tailored legal advice on a specific situation, always consult a duly licensed attorney or the appropriate government agency.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login