Labor Rights After NTE and Probationary Termination

Below is a comprehensive discussion of labor rights in the Philippines regarding (1) the issuance of a Notice to Explain (NTE) and its consequences; and (2) termination of employment during the probationary period. While each situation may have its own nuances depending on specific facts and circumstances, this overview provides general legal principles drawn from the Labor Code of the Philippines, Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) regulations, and established Philippine jurisprudence.

1. Notice to Explain (NTE) in the Context of Disciplinary Proceedings

A. Purpose and Legal Basis

  1. Due Process Requirement

    • Under Philippine labor law, every employee—whether regular, probationary, or casual—enjoys a degree of security of tenure.
    • The Constitutional guarantee (Article XIII, Section 3 of the 1987 Philippine Constitution) and the Labor Code require that the termination of employment or imposition of disciplinary sanctions must be based on valid grounds and must comply with due process.

  2. Twin Notice Rule

    • First Notice (NTE): In cases of potential disciplinary action, the employer must issue a written NTE stating the specific acts or omissions that may warrant dismissal or sanction.
    • Second Notice (Notice of Decision): After the employee has been given an opportunity to explain and/or attend a hearing, the employer must issue a second notice informing the employee of the employer’s decision (e.g., whether the employee is cleared, suspended, or terminated).

B. Contents of an NTE

  1. Specification of Acts or Omissions
    • The NTE must clearly state the alleged offense or violation of company rules or policies. A general or vague charge typically fails the requirement of specificity mandated by law and jurisprudence.
  2. Period to Respond
    • The NTE should grant a reasonable period (commonly 48 to 72 hours, though this may vary based on company policy or the complexity of the allegations) for the employee to submit a written explanation.
  3. Opportunity for Hearing
    • Although not always mandatory if the written explanation is sufficient, the employer should offer an opportunity for a formal or informal hearing if the employee requests it or if the circumstances warrant it (complex factual disputes, conflicting accounts, etc.).

C. Employee Rights After Receiving an NTE

  1. Right to Explain or Defend
    • The employee must be accorded the opportunity to respond, present evidence, or refute the charges. Failure to allow this could render any subsequent penalty or termination illegal.
  2. Right to Representation
    • Employees may request the presence of a representative (often a union representative) at any formal hearing or disciplinary meeting, if applicable.
  3. Right to Be Informed of the Decision
    • After the submission of the written explanation (and possible hearing), the employee has a right to be informed—in writing—of the employer’s decision and its legal/factual basis.

D. Consequences of Improperly Issued or Defective NTE

  1. Procedural Due Process Violation
    • If an NTE is improperly issued, or if the employer fails to issue an NTE entirely, the dismissal might be declared illegal or the employer may be liable for nominal damages for non-compliance with procedural due process.
  2. Potential Award of Damages or Reinstatement
    • In cases where the substantive ground for termination is valid but procedural due process is not observed, the employer may be ordered to pay nominal damages. If both substantive and procedural aspects are deficient, the employee could be entitled to full backwages and reinstatement.

2. Probationary Employment and Termination

A. Nature of Probationary Employment

  1. Definition
    • Probationary employees are those who, upon hiring, undergo a trial period (usually not exceeding six months under Article 296 [formerly 281] of the Labor Code) to determine their fitness for regular employment.
  2. Standards for Regularization
    • At the start of the probationary period (or upon commencement of work), the employer must communicate to the employee the reasonable standards or criteria for regularization.

B. Grounds for Termination of Probationary Employment

  1. Just Causes
    • A probationary employee may be dismissed for any of the “just causes” provided under Article 297 (formerly 282) of the Labor Code—e.g., serious misconduct, willful disobedience, gross and habitual neglect of duty, fraud, etc.
  2. Failure to Meet Reasonable Standards
    • A probationary employee may also be validly terminated if they fail to meet the reasonable standards for regular employment made known at the time of engagement.
  3. Authorized Causes
    • Probationary employees can also be terminated under “authorized causes” (Article 298 or 299, formerly 283 or 284) such as redundancy, retrenchment, closure of business, or disease not curable within six months—provided required notices and separation pays are given (where applicable).

C. Procedure for Termination of Probationary Employees

  1. Notice and Hearing Requirements
    • Even for probationary employees, procedural due process is required. Employers typically issue a Notice to Explain if there is an alleged breach of discipline or other just cause.
    • In cases of non-compliance with performance standards, the employee should still be informed—in writing—about deficiencies and given a chance to improve within the probationary period.
  2. Timing of Notice
    • If the cause is the failure to meet performance standards, the termination should be effected before the expiration of the six-month period or otherwise within the agreed probationary period. If the period lapses without valid termination, the employee is deemed regular.

D. Employee Rights After Probationary Termination

  1. Final Pay and Other Monetary Entitlements
    • Upon separation (whether due to just cause, authorized cause, or failure to qualify), the employer must pay all earned wages, pro-rated 13th month pay, and any unused leave conversions (if company policy or law grants such).
  2. Certificate of Employment (COE)
    • Under DOLE Department Order No. 19, series of 1993, and subsequent rules, employees have a right to request a COE that states the period of employment and the position(s) held.
  3. Separation Pay (If Applicable)
    • For dismissals based on just causes under Article 297, separation pay is generally not required. However, for authorized causes (redundancy, retrenchment, closure, etc.), separation pay may be mandated.
  4. Remedies in Case of Illegal Dismissal
    • If a probationary employee believes the termination was illegal (lack of valid ground or absence of due process), they may file a complaint before the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC). Potential remedies include reinstatement (or payment of full backwages in lieu of reinstatement) and other forms of damages.

3. Interaction of NTE and Probationary Termination

Because probationary employees are still covered by the same fundamental due process requirements (albeit applied with certain distinctions from regular employees), the Notice to Explain is a critical document in both disciplinary and performance-related termination scenarios:

  1. Disciplinary Grounds

    • An NTE is issued if the alleged cause for dismissal during the probationary period is akin to misconduct, insubordination, or other just causes.
    • The probationary employee then has the same rights to respond and to a hearing as a regular employee.

  2. Performance-Related Non-Regularization

    • If the probationary employee’s performance falls below company standards, the employer must have given clear performance metrics and offered feedback during the probation.
    • While a formal NTE is not always strictly required in performance-based dismissals, written notice that the employee has failed to meet performance metrics—and an opportunity to improve if time permits—is generally expected under the principle of due process.

  3. Consequences of Non-Compliance

    • If the employer fails to provide any notice or does not observe the required procedure, the probationary employee may have grounds to claim illegal dismissal despite not yet being a regular employee.

4. Practical Considerations and Best Practices

  1. Clear Communication of Standards
    • Employers should set and communicate performance standards in writing, at the start of probation, to avoid disputes regarding the basis of a probationary termination.
  2. Documentation
    • For both disciplinary and performance-related matters, documentation is key. Well-documented incident reports, performance evaluations, and coaching sessions help establish the factual basis for termination.
  3. Reasonable Opportunity to Respond or Improve
    • The probationary employee must be informed of any lapse or shortcoming and given a fair chance to respond (disciplinary) or to improve (performance-based), barring extremely grave offenses.
  4. Final Pay and Transition
    • Upon termination—probationary or otherwise—employers should promptly settle final pay to avoid additional legal exposure.
    • Employees, in turn, should be aware of their right to request a Certificate of Employment and ensure all due benefits are paid.

5. Key Legal References

  1. 1987 Philippine Constitution
    • Article XIII, Section 3: Guarantees the rights of workers, including security of tenure.
  2. Labor Code of the Philippines (Presidential Decree No. 442, as amended)
    • Article 296 (formerly 281): Probationary employment.
    • Article 297 (formerly 282): Just causes for termination.
    • Articles 298 & 299 (formerly 283 & 284): Authorized causes for termination.
  3. DOLE Regulations and Related Issuances
    • DOLE Department Order No. 19, S. 1993: Governing guidelines on the issuance of Certificate of Employment.
    • DOLE’s Implementing Rules of Book VI (Termination of Employment) further clarify due process requirements.
  4. Jurisprudence
    • Numerous Supreme Court decisions elaborate on the right to due process in employment and the standards for probationary termination, such as ABB, Inc. vs. NLRC, Globe Telecom vs. Florendo-Flores, Blue Dairy Corporation vs. NLRC, among others.

Conclusion

The Philippine legal framework upholds the principle that all employees—probationary or regular—are entitled to due process when facing potential dismissal or serious disciplinary action. The Notice to Explain (NTE) is a cornerstone of procedural due process, ensuring the employee is informed of the specific allegations and given a meaningful chance to respond. Probationary employment, while subject to a shorter period of tenure, also mandates that the employer lawfully observe the “just cause” or “failure to meet reasonable standards” basis and observe proper notice and hearing requirements.

When handled correctly, these mechanisms protect both employee rights and employer prerogatives. If these processes are disregarded, legal liabilities for the employer may arise, potentially including illegal dismissal rulings, awards of backwages, damages, and/or reinstatement. Employees who believe their rights have been violated may seek redress through the National Labor Relations Commission or other appropriate forums. Ultimately, clear communication of standards, thorough documentation, and adherence to the twin notice rule embody the best practices to ensure fair and lawful treatment of all employees, including those in their probationary period.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login