Preselling Condo and Extrajudicial Settlement Issues in the Philippines

Preselling Condo and Extrajudicial Settlement Issues in the Philippines: A Comprehensive Overview

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific concerns, please consult a licensed Philippine attorney.

I. Introduction

In the Philippine real estate market, preselling condominium projects have become increasingly popular, offering prospective buyers an opportunity to invest in a property that is still under construction. This arrangement can offer more affordable payment terms and the potential for capital appreciation, but it also raises legal and practical risks that buyers must understand.

Separately, extrajudicial settlement is a mechanism under Philippine law that allows heirs to settle the estate of a deceased person without resorting to a full-blown court proceeding, provided certain conditions are met. While these two topics may seem unrelated, they can intersect in the context of real property transactions—including condominium projects where ownership, titles, or shares in land may pass from a deceased owner or developer to heirs.

This article provides a comprehensive discussion of preselling condominiums and extrajudicial settlements in the Philippines, outlining the legal framework, potential pitfalls, and practical considerations that buyers, heirs, and other stakeholders should keep in mind.

II. Preselling Condominiums in the Philippines

A. Legal Framework

  1. Presidential Decree No. 957 (PD 957), also known as the Subdivision and Condominium Buyer’s Protective Decree

    • Governs the sale of condominium and subdivision projects in the Philippines.
    • Imposes requirements on developers, such as obtaining a License to Sell from the Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board (HLURB)—now under the Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development (DHSUD)—before marketing the project.

  2. Republic Act No. 4726 (The Condominium Act)

    • Governs the formation, management, and regulation of condominium corporations.
    • Defines what constitutes a condominium and provides the legal guidelines for creating condominium corporations.

  3. Maceda Law (Republic Act No. 6552)

    • Provides certain protections to buyers who purchase residential real estate on installment.
    • Offers rights such as a grace period and refunds under specific circumstances.

  4. HLURB (now DHSUD) Rules and Regulations

    • Stipulate the standards and procedures for developers to follow, including project registration, obtaining permits, project advertisements, and turnover procedures.

B. Definition of Preselling

“Preselling” refers to the practice of selling condominium units (or other real properties) while the project is still under construction or even at the planning stage. Buyers typically pay a lower “introductory price” during preselling, with payment schedules that stretch throughout the construction period.

C. Advantages of Buying a Preselling Condo

  1. Lower Introductory Prices
    • Units are often sold at a discount compared to completed properties.
  2. Flexible Payment Terms
    • Developers offer stretched-out, often interest-free down payment schemes.
  3. Potential for Value Appreciation
    • If the project is well-located and reputable, property values may increase by the time the condo is completed.

D. Common Risks and Issues

  1. Delayed Completion or Non-Completion
    • Financial or operational difficulties may lead developers to delay turnover or, in worst cases, abandon the project.
  2. Failure to Secure a License to Sell
    • Some developers might begin marketing units without proper government permits.
    • Buyers must verify that the developer has a valid License to Sell from DHSUD.
  3. Misrepresentation of Project Specifications
    • Model units and promotional materials may differ from the actual finished product.
  4. Questionable Title or Ownership
    • The land on which the condominium is built must have clear title. Buyers should conduct due diligence to avoid future disputes.
  5. Ongoing Obligations and Fees
    • Once the condominium is turned over, unit owners must pay monthly association dues and other fees, which can be higher than expected.

E. Legal Remedies for Buyers

  1. Contractual Remedies
    • Buyers can invoke contractual clauses on refunds, penalties, or rescission if the developer breaches the contract.
  2. Administrative Complaints with DHSUD
    • If a developer violates PD 957 or related rules, buyers can file complaints before DHSUD (previously HLURB).
  3. Court Litigation
    • In cases of fraud, breach of contract, or other legal infractions, buyers may file civil or criminal suits (depending on the circumstances) in regular courts.

III. Extrajudicial Settlement in the Philippines

A. Overview of the Legal Basis

  1. Rule 74 of the Rules of Court
    • Governs extrajudicial settlement of estate when the decedent has no will (or if the will is not contested) and the heirs are in agreement on how to distribute the estate.
  2. Civil Code Provisions on Succession
    • Outlines who are heirs and how inheritance is divided in intestate succession.

B. Conditions for Extrajudicial Settlement

  1. Intestate Succession or Uncontested Will
    • Generally used if the decedent died without leaving a will (“intestate”) or if there is a will but no opposition among the heirs.
  2. No Outstanding Debts
    • If the estate has debts, creditors must be properly notified, or the heirs must undertake to settle these debts.
  3. All Heirs of Legal Age
    • If minors are involved, the process becomes more complex and might require court approval or guardianship proceedings.
  4. Agreement Among Heirs
    • All heirs must consent and sign the extrajudicial settlement document.

C. Procedural Requirements

  1. Execution of a Deed of Extrajudicial Settlement
    • The legal heirs prepare a notarized instrument specifying how the estate is to be divided.
  2. Publication Requirement
    • The deed must be published once a week for three consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the province where the decedent last resided.
  3. Submission to the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR)
    • Heirs must file the estate tax return and pay the applicable estate tax before they can transfer the property to their names.
  4. Registration with the Registry of Deeds
    • After paying estate taxes and obtaining a Certificate Authorizing Registration (CAR) from the BIR, the heirs can register the transfer with the Registry of Deeds.

D. Benefits of Extrajudicial Settlement

  1. Faster Distribution of Assets
    • Avoids lengthy court proceedings if the heirs are in agreement.
  2. Less Expensive
    • Court fees are largely avoided, making extrajudicial settlement more cost-effective.
  3. Preserves Family Harmony
    • Reduces adversarial encounters among heirs when settlement is uncontested.

E. Potential Pitfalls

  1. Overlooking Creditors
    • If creditors surface after the settlement, heirs might become personally liable.
  2. Non-Consent of Some Heirs
    • If not all heirs participate, the settlement can be challenged or declared void.
  3. Under-declaration of Estate Value
    • Attempting to reduce estate taxes by undervaluing properties can result in penalties from the BIR.
  4. Fraud or Deception
    • Heirs who fail to disclose other heirs or property assets risk future legal disputes.

IV. Intersection Between Preselling Condominiums and Extrajudicial Settlement

While preselling and extrajudicial settlement processes are distinct, they can intersect in various ways:

  1. Developer Succession Issues
    • If a developer or the landowner dies during the construction phase, the heirs may have to settle the deceased’s estate extrajudicially before the project can continue. Delays or disputes can affect buyers’ interests.
  2. Title Issues in Joint Venture Projects
    • Some condominium projects are formed through joint ventures between a landowner and a developer. If the landowner passes away, the heirs might need to execute an extrajudicial settlement to transfer ownership rights properly, potentially impacting the project’s timeline.
  3. Inherited Units or Preconstruction Contracts
    • A buyer who dies before the turnover date leaves an incomplete contractual relationship. The heirs may need to undertake an extrajudicial settlement to effectively transfer the preselling condo unit rights (or continuing obligations) to themselves or to a new buyer.
  4. Buyers’ Due Diligence
    • Buyers should confirm that the landowner’s title is free from conflicting claims by heirs or unsettled estates. Title controversies can lead to protracted legal battles, risking both delays and financial loss.

V. Practical Tips for Buyers and Heirs

  1. Verify the Developer’s Credentials and Permits
    • Check if the developer has a valid License to Sell and if the project has been duly registered with the DHSUD.
  2. Review Contracts Thoroughly
    • Engage a lawyer to review the Contract to Sell and other relevant documents to ensure all terms are valid and enforceable.
  3. Conduct Title Verification
    • For preselling units, ensure the land title is clear of liens, encumbrances, or pending estate disputes.
  4. Keep Up-to-Date on Construction Progress
    • Visit the site periodically or request progress reports from the developer. Verify that construction is on schedule.
  5. Consider a Real Estate Due Diligence Checklist
    • Use a checklist (including corporate documents, permits, and financial statements) to vet the project’s viability.
  6. For Heirs: Plan Ahead
    • Where possible, ensure the original owner has clear estate documents. If the owner passes away, promptly initiate estate settlement (extrajudicial if uncontested). Delayed settlement can complicate real property transactions.
  7. Obtain Legal Counsel
    • Whether you are a buyer or an heir, consult a real estate lawyer for personalized guidance, particularly if complications arise (e.g., minors are involved, there are contested wills, or outstanding debts).

VI. Conclusion

Preselling condominium projects in the Philippines can offer an attractive path to property ownership and investment, but they come with inherent risks that must be carefully managed. Legal frameworks under PD 957 and the Condominium Act exist to protect buyers, yet due diligence and knowledge of one’s rights are crucial.

Meanwhile, extrajudicial settlement is a valuable process for efficiently settling an estate without court proceedings—provided that all heirs are in agreement and other legal requirements are met. The intersection of these topics becomes evident when issues of succession arise in the context of a condominium project, highlighting the importance of transparent, timely, and properly documented legal procedures.

By understanding both the preselling process and the intricacies of extrajudicial settlement, buyers, heirs, and real estate practitioners can protect their interests and navigate Philippine property transactions more confidently and securely.

Again, this article is meant for general information only. For tailored advice, always consult a qualified Philippine attorney or real estate professional.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login