Property Fraud: Unlawful Construction and Misrepresentation in Real Estate Sale

Disclaimer: This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and jurisprudence may change over time, and their application can vary based on specific factual circumstances. For advice on particular cases, consult a qualified attorney licensed to practice in the Philippines.

I. Introduction

Property fraud and unlawful construction are perennial concerns in the Philippine real estate sector. The rapid growth of housing developments and the rise of condominium and subdivision projects have led to increased incidences of misrepresentation, illegal construction, and other forms of real estate fraud. This article provides an overview of the key Philippine laws, common fraudulent practices, legal remedies, and preventive measures regarding property fraud and misrepresentations in real estate transactions.

II. Relevant Laws and Regulatory Framework

  1. Presidential Decree (PD) No. 957 (Subdivision and Condominium Buyers’ Protective Decree)

    • Governs the sale of subdivision lots and condominium units.
    • Requires developers to register projects with the appropriate regulatory body (formerly the HLURB, now the Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development or DHSUD).
    • Mandates that a License to Sell (LTS) be obtained before any development is marketed or offered for sale.
    • Stipulates rules for compliance with development plans, timelines, and advertising requirements to prevent misrepresentation.

  2. Republic Act (RA) No. 6552 (Maceda Law)

    • Provides protection to real estate buyers of residential real property on an installment basis.
    • Grants buyers certain rights (e.g., grace periods, refund mechanisms) if they default on payments under specific conditions.
    • Discourages sellers from misrepresenting terms of installment plans and protects buyers against unscrupulous cancellation.

  3. Civil Code of the Philippines (particularly Articles on Contracts and Obligations)

    • Governs contract law, including rules on consent, object, and cause of contracts.
    • Misrepresentation (fraud) that vitiates consent can render a contract voidable.
    • Provides for damages that may be claimed by an aggrieved party.

  4. Revised Penal Code (RPC), as amended

    • Provisions on estafa (swindling) can apply to property fraud and misrepresentation where a person defrauds another through false pretenses or deceit.

  5. Republic Act No. 9646 (Real Estate Service Act)

    • Requires real estate brokers, appraisers, and consultants to be duly licensed.
    • Engaging in real estate practice without a license, or misrepresentation by real estate practitioners, may result in criminal and administrative liabilities.

  6. National Building Code (Presidential Decree No. 1096)

    • Requires building permits and compliance with technical standards.
    • Construction without or contrary to the approved building permit (unlawful construction) may be penalized and subjected to demolition or administrative fines.

  7. Local Government Codes and Regulations

    • Local ordinances may impose additional requirements and penalties for illegal construction or zoning violations.
    • Building and occupancy permits must be secured from local building officials.

  8. DHSUD (Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development) Rules and Circulars

    • Issues guidelines on the sale and advertising of subdivision lots and condominium units.
    • Handles complaints against developers for non-compliance with PD 957 and other relevant laws.

III. Forms of Property Fraud and Unlawful Construction

  1. Unlawful Construction/No Valid Building Permit

    • Occurs when developers or property owners construct buildings without the required permits or in violation of approved plans.
    • May also involve false statements to secure permits or bribes to circumvent inspection requirements.

  2. Misrepresentation of Property Features

    • Advertising or representing a property’s size, location, amenities, or other attributes that are materially different from actual conditions.
    • Common examples:
      • Overstating floor area of a condo unit.
      • Misstating the property’s access to roads, utilities, or amenities.
      • Claiming that a property is free from liens or encumbrances when it is not.

  3. Double Sale of Property

    • Fraudulent practice where a seller, through deceit, sells the same property to multiple buyers.
    • The Philippine Civil Code (Art. 1544) provides rules on who has superior rights when two or more persons buy the same property in good faith.

  4. Use of Falsified Documents

    • Forging land titles, deeds of sale, or identity documents to pass off property ownership or to entice buyers to purchase.
    • Typically prosecuted under the Revised Penal Code (falsification of public documents) or as estafa (swindling).

  5. Unauthorized Agency or Brokerage

    • Non-licensed agents or brokers misrepresenting themselves as authorized professionals.
    • May provide incorrect or fraudulent information about the property or the developer’s license status.

  6. Failure to Deliver Titles or Transfer Documents

    • Some sellers accept payment (partial or full) but fail to transfer ownership or deliver titles.
    • This can lead to a breach of contract, estafa, or other fraudulent transactions.

IV. Legal Consequences and Remedies

  1. Civil Liability

    • Voidable Contracts: Under the Civil Code, a contract entered into based on fraud or misrepresentation can be annulled at the instance of the injured party.
    • Damages: The defrauded buyer may claim actual, moral, or even exemplary damages, depending on the extent of injury and bad faith involved.

  2. Criminal Liability

    • Estafa (Swindling) under the Revised Penal Code: If deceit is used to induce another to execute a contract, pay money, or deliver property, the wrongdoer can be charged criminally.
    • Falsification of Public Documents: Submitting fake certificates or forging titles can result in imprisonment and hefty fines.

  3. Administrative Sanctions

    • DHSUD (formerly HLURB) Proceedings: Can revoke or suspend a developer’s License to Sell or Certificate of Registration, impose fines, and order corrective measures (e.g., refunds or completion of promised facilities).
    • Professional Regulatory Commission (PRC): Real estate brokers, consultants, and appraisers engaged in misrepresentation may lose their license or face suspension.
    • Local Government Units (LGUs): Can issue demolition orders or stop-work orders for structures built without or in violation of permits.

  4. Specific Performance or Rescission

    • A buyer may file a complaint to compel the developer to correct any unauthorized or substandard construction (specific performance).
    • Alternatively, the buyer may opt for rescission of the contract and a return of payments if the seller fails to comply with contractual obligations.

  5. Maceda Law Protection (RA 6552)

    • For purchasers on installment, the Maceda Law grants specific rights such as a grace period to cure payment defaults and a refund of certain percentages of total payments if the contract is cancelled.
    • It helps protect buyers from abrupt cancellation and possible fraudulent or abusive practices by developers.

V. Enforcement Bodies and Dispute Resolution

  1. Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development (DHSUD)

    • Primary agency that regulates housing and real estate developments.
    • Has quasi-judicial powers to adjudicate complaints related to subdivision and condominium developments under PD 957.

  2. Local Government Units (LGUs)

    • Issue building permits, occupancy permits, and regulate local zoning.
    • Can inspect, condemn, or demolish unsafe or illegally constructed buildings.

  3. Regular Courts

    • Civil cases (annulment of contracts, damages, etc.) and criminal cases (estafa, falsification) are heard by the Regional Trial Courts (RTC).
    • Judicial recourse is also available for appeals from quasi-judicial bodies.

  4. Professional Regulatory Board (PRB) for Real Estate Service

    • Under the PRC, regulates the practice of real estate service professionals (brokers, appraisers, consultants).
    • Handles complaints and imposes administrative sanctions.

  5. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

    • Mediation or arbitration is sometimes used to resolve real estate disputes more swiftly and cost-effectively.
    • If the developer’s contract with buyers provides an arbitration clause, parties may be required to go through ADR before going to court.

VI. Preventive Measures and Best Practices

  1. Due Diligence

    • Check the Developer’s License: Verify if the developer has a valid License to Sell from DHSUD.
    • Review Registration Documents: Confirm that the project is registered with the local government and that building permits have been properly secured.
    • Title Verification: Conduct a title search at the Register of Deeds to ensure the property is free from liens or encumbrances.
    • Check Broker Credentials: Only deal with PRC-licensed real estate brokers and sales agents.

  2. Scrutiny of Contracts and Advertisements

    • Carefully review the Contract to Sell or Deed of Absolute Sale, ensuring that representations in brochures and ads match the contract’s stipulations.
    • Watch for disclaimers or fine print that may limit the developer’s responsibility.

  3. Site Inspection

    • Visit the property or site personally (or through a representative) to verify actual conditions (e.g., road access, amenities, construction quality).
    • Check if there is an on-site project billboard or sign indicating the building permit details (a requirement of the National Building Code).

  4. Keep Records

    • Maintain all receipts, official communications, and copies of signed documents.
    • Document any verbal commitments by developers or agents in writing, or request that they include such statements in official contracts.

  5. Engage Professional Assistance

    • If the transaction is significant in value, consider hiring a lawyer or a licensed real estate broker/appraiser to assist with documentation and negotiations.
    • Seek advice early if any red flags arise during the negotiation stage.

  6. Report Suspected Fraud

    • If you suspect any illegal construction or misrepresentation, report it to the local building official, the DHSUD, or the appropriate law enforcement agency.
    • Timely reporting can prevent others from becoming victims of the same scheme.

VII. Key Jurisprudence (Selected Examples)

  1. Gotesco Properties, Inc. v. Spouses Fajardo (G.R. No. 194304)

    • Emphasized the responsibility of developers under PD 957 to adhere to the approved subdivision plan and deliver on promised amenities.

  2. Cabrera v. Ching (G.R. No. 187448)

    • Clarified rules on double sales under Art. 1544 of the Civil Code; stressed that good faith registrants have priority over unregistered claimants.

  3. Pallada v. CA (G.R. No. 99046)

    • Highlighted the penal and civil liabilities of parties who engage in misrepresentation leading to voidable contracts.

  4. Realty Exchange Venture Corp. v. Sendino (G.R. No. 136041)

    • Discussed damages awarded to buyers in cases where the developer’s actions constituted fraud and violation of PD 957.

(Note: Jurisprudence can evolve. The cited cases are illustrative examples. Researchers should consult the latest Supreme Court rulings and official publications.)

VIII. Conclusion

Property fraud and unlawful construction in the Philippine real estate market remain a serious concern for buyers, developers, and regulatory authorities alike. By understanding the legal framework—ranging from PD 957, the Civil Code, the Maceda Law, and relevant criminal statutes—and being aware of common fraudulent schemes and preventive measures, prospective buyers and property owners can significantly reduce their risks.

Regulatory bodies like the DHSUD, PRC, and local government units play crucial roles in monitoring and enforcing compliance. Ultimately, vigilance, due diligence, and prompt legal recourse (when necessary) serve as the best defenses against property fraud and misrepresentation in the Philippines.

References and Additional Resources

  • Presidential Decree No. 957 (Subdivision and Condominium Buyers’ Protective Decree)
  • Republic Act No. 6552 (Realty Installment Buyer Protection Act or Maceda Law)
  • Civil Code of the Philippines
  • Revised Penal Code of the Philippines
  • Republic Act No. 9646 (Real Estate Service Act)
  • Presidential Decree No. 1096 (National Building Code)
  • Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development (DHSUD) Guidelines and Circulars
  • Supreme Court E-Library for case law

Important: For specific cases or disputes, consult a licensed Philippine attorney who can give professional advice tailored to your situation.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login