Recognition of Foreign Divorce and Legitimizing Second Marriage in the Philippines

Below is a comprehensive discussion on the recognition of foreign divorce in the Philippines and its implications for legitimizing a second marriage under Philippine law. This article is intended for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. For specific concerns, you should consult a licensed attorney in the Philippines.

I. Introduction

In Philippine law, marriage is a special contract that is protected by the Constitution. As a rule, marriages validly contracted in the Philippines are presumed to be legal and binding unless annulled or declared void. When a marriage is dissolved by divorce obtained abroad, various questions arise regarding its effect in the Philippines—particularly because, under domestic law, absolute divorce between two Filipino citizens is generally not recognized.

However, Article 26 (Paragraph 2) of the Family Code of the Philippines provides an exception where the foreign divorce can be recognized in the Philippines in certain circumstances. Recognition of foreign divorce is crucial for determining the status of a Filipino spouse and whether that person may validly enter into a second marriage without incurring criminal liability (e.g., for bigamy).

II. Legal Basis for Recognizing a Foreign Divorce

A. Article 26 of the Family Code

The key provision is Article 26 (Paragraph 2) of the Family Code:

"Where a marriage between a Filipino citizen and a foreigner is validly celebrated and a divorce is thereafter validly obtained abroad by the alien spouse capacitating him or her to remarry, the Filipino spouse shall have the capacity to remarry under Philippine law."

Under this provision, if a foreign divorce is validly obtained abroad by the foreign spouse—thus allowing him or her to remarry under his/her national law—the Filipino spouse is similarly allowed to remarry in the Philippines, subject to obtaining a judicial recognition of that foreign divorce in Philippine courts.

B. Philippine Supreme Court Jurisprudence

The Supreme Court has clarified and expanded upon the requirements for recognition of foreign divorce decrees:

  1. Republic v. Orbecido III (G.R. No. 154380, October 5, 2005) – Recognized that if the Filipino spouse later acquires foreign citizenship, that spouse can also validly obtain a divorce abroad, which may be recognized in the Philippines.
  2. Garcia v. Recio (G.R. No. 138322, October 2, 2001) – Outlined procedural requirements for proving a foreign divorce, including submission of (a) the foreign judgment (divorce decree) and (b) proof of the foreign law under which the divorce was granted.
  3. Fujiki v. Marinay (G.R. No. 196049, June 26, 2013) – Further established the principle that recognition of foreign divorce decrees can be done through a petition for judicial recognition, clarifying the requirements for bringing such a case.

III. Who May Avail of Recognition of Foreign Divorce?

  1. Filipino Spouse Married to a Foreigner
    A Filipino citizen married to a foreign national can avail of recognition of foreign divorce if the foreign spouse obtains a valid divorce decree in another country.

  2. Former Filipino Who Became a Naturalized Foreigner
    A Filipino citizen who, subsequent to marriage, acquired a foreign citizenship and obtained a divorce in that new country of citizenship can also file for recognition of the foreign divorce decree in the Philippines, consistent with the Supreme Court’s ruling in Republic v. Orbecido III.

  3. Effect on Second Marriage
    The primary motivation to seek recognition of foreign divorce is to ensure that any subsequent marriage entered into by the Filipino spouse (whether in the Philippines or abroad) is valid. Without judicial recognition, the second marriage may face legal challenges and could potentially lead to a criminal charge of bigamy.

IV. Key Requirements and Procedure for Judicial Recognition

A. Required Documents

When filing a petition for recognition of a foreign divorce before the Regional Trial Court (Family Court) in the Philippines, the following documents (or their equivalents) are typically required:

  1. Authenticated Divorce Decree

    • This must be certified or authenticated according to the rules of the country where the divorce was obtained. Commonly, this involves obtaining an “apostille” or consular authentication, depending on that country’s agreement with the Philippines.

  2. Official Copy of the Foreign Law

    • The law under which the divorce was granted must be proven as a fact in Philippine courts. This is done by submitting an official publication of the foreign law or a certified copy of the law itself, along with a certified translation (if not in English).
    • An affidavit of an expert on foreign law or a certification from the foreign embassy/consulate might also be needed.

  3. Proof of Capacity of the Alien Spouse to Remarry

    • The foreign law showing that the alien spouse is indeed allowed to remarry under his or her national law must be adequately proven.

  4. Other Supporting Documents

    • Marriage Certificate (issued by the Philippine Statistics Authority [PSA])
    • Birth certificates of children, if any
    • Evidence of residency and other jurisdictional requirements (proof that the petitioner resides or is found within the court’s territorial jurisdiction)
    • Valid identification documents

B. Court Filing and Hearing

  1. Venue

    • The petition for recognition of foreign judgment (divorce decree) is filed in the Regional Trial Court (specifically, the designated Family Court) of the province or city where the petitioner resides, or where the marriage was registered, subject to prevailing rules of venue.

  2. Publication Requirements

    • As with other family law petitions, the petition might be subject to publication requirements to notify interested parties and ensure due process. Check local rules for details on the period and frequency of publication.

  3. Opposition

    • The Office of the Solicitor General (OSG) or the public prosecutor typically represents the State’s interest and may oppose the petition if the state attorney believes there are legal infirmities.

  4. Judicial Proceedings

    • The court will determine if the foreign court had jurisdiction to grant the divorce, whether the divorce decree is final, and whether the foreign law indeed allows the spouse to remarry.
    • The judge may require the presentation of witnesses, typically the petitioner, possibly an expert witness for foreign law, or the consular officer of the foreign country concerned.

C. Court Decision

  1. Recognition

    • If the court is satisfied with the evidence, it will issue a decision recognizing the foreign divorce.
    • This decision is binding upon Philippine government agencies.

  2. Annotation in the Civil Registry

    • After a favorable decision, the final order must be registered with the local civil registry and the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA).
    • The PSA will annotate the marriage certificate, reflecting that the marriage has been severed by virtue of the recognized foreign divorce decree. This ensures that the records are updated and clarifies the petitioner’s legal status for future marriages.

V. Legitimizing (Validating) a Second Marriage

A. Why Recognition Is Crucial

Without a judicial recognition of foreign divorce, a subsequent marriage (whether in the Philippines or abroad) could be considered bigamous under Article 349 of the Revised Penal Code, if the first marriage was still legally valid under Philippine law. Even if the marriage was dissolved abroad, the Philippines requires a formal recognition proceeding.

B. Effects on a Second Marriage

  1. Capacity to Contract a Second Marriage

    • Once the Filipino spouse obtains a court order recognizing the foreign divorce, he or she is considered legally “single” for purposes of entering a new marriage in the Philippines.

  2. Registration of Subsequent Marriage

    • The second marriage can be registered with the PSA without legal impediment. Before recognition, the civil registry would not register or annotate the second marriage properly, resulting in complications.

  3. Avoidance of Bigamy Charges

    • The recognized foreign divorce ensures that no crime of bigamy is committed when entering into a second marriage, since the first marriage is effectively dissolved.

C. Effects on Property Relations and Children

  1. Property Regime

    • Prior to recognition, any property relations tied to the first marriage remain in effect. Once recognition of the foreign divorce is granted, the property regime is terminated. The parties should then settle their property under Philippine law or, if applicable, under the law of the foreign jurisdiction.

  2. Legitimacy of Children

    • Children born before the recognition are still considered legitimate if they were born during a valid marriage. A recognized foreign divorce does not retroactively affect the legitimacy of children born during the subsisting marriage.

  3. Succession and Inheritance

    • The ex-spouses lose their respective rights of inheritance from each other upon recognition of the divorce, unless specific dispositions in wills or testaments are made.

VI. Special Considerations and Common Pitfalls

  1. Both Spouses Filipino at the Time of Marriage

    • If both spouses were Filipino citizens at the time of marriage, and neither subsequently acquires foreign citizenship, a foreign divorce obtained by one spouse alone will generally not be recognized by the Philippines. The marriage is typically considered valid unless an annulment or declaration of nullity is secured in the Philippines.

  2. Proof of Foreign Law

    • One of the most common grounds for denial of recognition is the failure to sufficiently prove the foreign law under which the divorce was obtained. Philippine courts cannot take judicial notice of foreign laws. They must be properly pleaded and proven as a fact, typically through official publications, certificates, or expert testimony.

  3. Mistaken Belief That Having the Foreign Divorce Decree Is Enough

    • Even with a valid foreign divorce decree, the Filipino spouse must still go through judicial recognition proceedings in the Philippines. Simply possessing the divorce papers does not automatically dissolve the marriage under Philippine law.

  4. Time and Cost

    • Recognition proceedings can be time-consuming and may involve fees for filing, publication, attorney’s fees, and document procurement (apostille or embassy authentication). Individuals should be prepared for these expenses and potential delays.

VII. Conclusion

The recognition of foreign divorce in the Philippines is a legally complex but critical procedure for Filipinos or former Filipinos who have obtained a divorce abroad and wish to remarry legally in the Philippines. The process ensures that the foreign divorce is aligned with Philippine conflict-of-laws rules and that the Filipino spouse’s civil status is beyond question, thus legitimizing any second marriage.

Key Takeaways

  1. Judicial recognition of the foreign divorce decree is mandatory for it to have legal effect in the Philippines.
  2. Article 26 of the Family Code allows a Filipino spouse to remarry if the foreign spouse obtains a valid divorce, capacitating that spouse to remarry under the foreign law.
  3. The procedure involves filing a petition in a Regional Trial Court (Family Court), with strict requirements for authenticated documents and proof of foreign law.
  4. Once recognized by a Philippine court, the final order should be registered with the local civil registry and the PSA to update civil status and avoid future legal complications.
  5. A second marriage entered into without obtaining judicial recognition could expose the Filipino spouse to criminal liability for bigamy.

For specific guidance, consulting an attorney experienced in family law and conflict of laws in the Philippines is strongly recommended. This helps ensure that all procedural and substantive requirements are met, thereby securing a valid and legally unassailable second marriage.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login