Replacing Lost Extrajudicial Settlement Documents for BIR Requirements

Below is a general discussion of the key considerations, laws, and processes regarding replacing a lost Extrajudicial Settlement document for purposes of meeting Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) requirements in the Philippines. This is provided for informational purposes only and should not be taken as legal advice. If you need specific guidance, consult an attorney or a tax professional.

1. Overview of Extrajudicial Settlement in the Philippines

Extrajudicial Settlement is a procedure under Philippine law allowing heirs to settle a decedent’s estate without a full-blown court proceeding, provided certain legal conditions are met. These conditions commonly include:

  1. The deceased died intestate (i.e., without a will) or with a will that does not require probate.
  2. There are no known debts of the estate or the heirs have undertaken to settle any existing debts.
  3. All heirs are of legal age, or minors are properly represented.
  4. The heirs execute a sworn agreement (often titled “Affidavit of Extrajudicial Settlement”) detailing how to divide or distribute the decedent’s estate.

This extrajudicial settlement document must be notarized and typically published in a newspaper of general circulation once a week for three consecutive weeks. Afterward, the heirs must file appropriate documents with the BIR to pay the required estate taxes.

2. Why the Extrajudicial Settlement Document Matters for BIR Requirements

The Bureau of Internal Revenue requires either:

  • Extrajudicial Settlement (for intestate estates), or
  • Court-issued Documents (for judicial settlements or probate),

before the BIR will issue the Certificate Authorizing Registration (CAR) or the Electronic Certificate Authorizing Registration (eCAR). The CAR/eCAR essentially confirms that the estate tax (and other taxes, if applicable) has been settled, enabling the transfer of real property or personal assets in the name of the heirs.

The BIR will usually require:

  1. Original or certified true copy of the Extrajudicial Settlement document.
  2. Proof of publication (affidavit of the publisher or newspaper clippings).
  3. Estate tax return (BIR Form 1801) and related attachments.
  4. Other documentary requirements, such as the decedent’s death certificate, TIN of the estate, and relevant asset valuations.

If the original or your only copy of the Extrajudicial Settlement is lost, this poses a procedural hurdle. You need to provide a valid, verified, or certified copy to continue with the BIR process or to secure new certificates or registrations for transferred property. Thus, replacing the lost Extrajudicial Settlement document becomes essential.

3. Legal Bases and Rules Applicable to Lost Notarized Documents

  1. Notarial Practice:

    • Under the 2004 Rules on Notarial Practice (A.M. No. 02-8-13-SC), once a document is notarized, it is recorded in a notarial register by the notary public. This notarial register keeps details of every document the notary notarizes, including parties, type of document, and the date it was executed.
    • The notary public is required to keep and eventually turn over these records (and the documents, if applicable) to the clerk of court for safekeeping after their notarial commission expires.

  2. Certified True Copies from the Notary or the Clerk of Court:

    • Because a notarized document must be recorded in the notary’s register, it is possible to obtain a certified true copy from the notary public who conducted the notarization, if they are still in commission and still have the original.
    • If the notary’s commission has ended or if that notary is no longer available, copies may be on file with the Regional Trial Court (RTC) or the Executive Judge’s Office that oversees notarial commissions in the jurisdiction where the document was notarized.

  3. Registry of Deeds (if real property is involved):

    • Often, for property transfers, the Extrajudicial Settlement is also annotated on the transfer certificate of title or filed with the Registry of Deeds. If it was duly submitted, you may obtain certified true copies from the Registry of Deeds.

4. Steps to Replace a Lost Extrajudicial Settlement Document

Below is a commonly followed approach to reconstitute or replace a missing Extrajudicial Settlement document:

  1. Check the Notarial Register

    • If you know the notary public who notarized the document (and the notary is still active or within the same area), request a certified true copy from them. They should have recorded the Extrajudicial Settlement in their notarial logbook, along with a copy or at least the details needed.

  2. Contact the Court’s Notarial Section

    • If the notary is no longer practicing or if you cannot locate them, proceed to the Office of the Clerk of Court of the Regional Trial Court (RTC) or Metropolitan Trial Court (MeTC) that has jurisdiction over the place where the document was notarized. The records or duplicates of notarial acts may be archived there.
    • You can file a request or a motion (depending on local court procedure) to obtain a certified copy of the notarial records.

  3. Request from the Registry of Deeds

    • If the Extrajudicial Settlement was presented as part of registering real property in the names of heirs, or was annotated on a Transfer Certificate of Title (TCT) or Condominium Certificate of Title (CCT), go to the relevant Registry of Deeds. The office may have a copy or an annotation reference to the document. You can get a certified true copy of the settlement from that office, if it was duly submitted and recorded.

  4. Re-publish if Required

    • Typically, re-publication of an extrajudicial settlement is not required for the sole purpose of replacing a lost copy. Publication is a requirement for validating the extrajudicial settlement in the first place. However, if for any reason the BIR or another agency requires re-publication to demonstrate that heirs are fulfilling notice requirements, consult with counsel. In most instances, republication is unnecessary if the prior publication can be proven (e.g., newspaper clippings or a publisher’s affidavit).

  5. Secure a Judicial Order (if needed)

    • If the lost document cannot be reconstituted through the notarial register, the court’s archive, the Registry of Deeds, or other standard means, it may be necessary to file a petition for reconstitution in court (akin to reconstitution of lost or destroyed documents). This is relatively uncommon for extrajudicial settlement documents unless the entire set of notarial records is destroyed.
    • The court will typically require proof of (a) the existence of the original document, (b) the circumstances of its loss, and (c) the necessity of reconstitution.

5. Coordination with the BIR

Once you have acquired a new, valid, certified copy of the Extrajudicial Settlement, you can then submit it to the BIR as part of your estate-tax-related filings. Keep in mind:

  1. Deadline for Filing Estate Tax:

    • Generally, the estate tax return (BIR Form 1801) must be filed within one (1) year from the date of death (unless an extension is granted by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue). If the document was lost and the settlement process was delayed, you must address any potential penalties or surcharges.

  2. Proof of Publication:

    • The BIR typically requires proof of publication (affidavit of publisher and newspaper copies). If you have lost these, you may need to request a certification or affidavit from the newspaper publisher’s office confirming the details of prior publication.

  3. Payment of Taxes and Issuance of eCAR:

    • After verification of the extrajudicial settlement and computation of estate taxes, the BIR will issue the Certificate Authorizing Registration (CAR/eCAR). This certificate is necessary to transfer property titles or release funds in banks.

6. Potential Complications and Considerations

  1. Time and Expense

    • Obtaining a certified true copy from court archives or government offices can be time-consuming. Costs for copies, notarizations, and possible court fees should be factored in.

  2. Heirs or Other Parties Disputing

    • If there have been changes among the heirs (e.g., disputes, additional heirs come forward, or someone questions the validity of the original extrajudicial settlement), the process to reconstitute the document can become complicated. A judicial settlement might become necessary.

  3. Revisiting the Distribution

    • If, in the course of looking for the lost document, heirs discover that some aspects of the settlement are incomplete or outdated (for instance, new estate debts or additional properties), an amended settlement (or even a court proceeding) may be required.

  4. Penalties for Late Filing

    • The BIR imposes interest and surcharges on estate taxes not filed and paid within the prescribed periods. The search for a lost document can cause delays. Officially request BIR assistance or legal counsel early on to avoid or minimize additional penalties.

  5. Differences in Local Practice

    • Implementation procedures can vary among local BIR Revenue District Offices (RDOs) and local courts. Always verify local requirements with the appropriate government agency or legal professional.

7. Practical Tips

  1. Always Keep Multiple Copies

    • Once you have a properly notarized extrajudicial settlement, keep multiple certified photocopies. Also, keep proof of publication in secure storage.

  2. Record with the Registry of Deeds (if Real Property)

    • As soon as the BIR issues the eCAR, file your extrajudicial settlement and eCAR with the Registry of Deeds for title transfer. This helps ensure that an official copy is on file.

  3. Obtain a Digital Scan

    • Scan your original extrajudicial settlement and keep it in encrypted cloud storage or another digital format. While a mere digital copy is not a legal substitute for a notarized document, it can be helpful in proving that the document existed and guiding you to the correct notarial information (book number, page number, notary’s name, etc.).

  4. Consult Professional Assistance

    • If you encounter difficulties obtaining a copy or dealing with the BIR, engage a lawyer or a professional specializing in estate settlement. They can expedite searching notarial archives, liaising with court personnel, or petitioning the court if reconstitution is required.

8. Conclusion

Replacing a lost Extrajudicial Settlement document in the Philippines essentially involves verifying the notarial record or obtaining a certified copy from the court archives or the Registry of Deeds. Once you have the certified copy, you can comply with BIR requirements for estate tax filing and issuance of the Certificate Authorizing Registration. While it may involve extra time and costs, the process is fairly straightforward if the document was properly notarized and originally published.

Key takeaways:

  • Start by determining which notary public notarized the document and request a certified copy from their notarial records.
  • If the notary is unavailable, check with the Office of the Clerk of Court or the Registry of Deeds.
  • Gather proof of publication (or reacquire it from the newspaper’s archives).
  • Coordinate with the BIR to settle any outstanding estate taxes.
  • Seek legal advice promptly if complications arise, such as heirs disputing distributions or if no record of the document can be found.

Again, for personalized advice or if you encounter a complex situation, consult an attorney or a licensed tax professional.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login