Separation Pay Entitlement for Security Guards

Below is a comprehensive discussion of Separation Pay Entitlement for Security Guards under Philippine law. This write-up explains the legal framework, jurisprudential guidelines, and practical considerations that affect security guards, who often find themselves in unique employment arrangements. While the Labor Code and relevant Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) issuances apply generally to most employees, security guards have particular nuances relating to their roles, which will be addressed in detail below.

1. Introduction

Security guards in the Philippines typically work under private security agencies (PSAs) regulated by Republic Act No. 5487, also known as the “Private Security Agency Law,” and its implementing rules, as well as by the Labor Code of the Philippines and various Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) issuances. Despite often being assigned to a client’s site (the principal), the employer-employee relationship usually exists between the security guard and the security agency.

When security guards are terminated, or if other circumstances arise requiring the payment of separation pay, their entitlements are governed by the Labor Code, pertinent DOLE department orders, and Supreme Court decisions that have clarified the law. Below is an in-depth view of:

  1. Grounds for termination of employment and corresponding separation pay;
  2. Calculation and rates of separation pay;
  3. Obligations of private security agencies regarding redeployment;
  4. Special considerations under Philippine jurisprudence; and
  5. Frequently asked questions and practical tips for security guards.

2. Legal Basis for Separation Pay

Under the Labor Code of the Philippines, particularly under Articles 298 and 299 (previously Articles 283 and 284), separation pay may be due to an employee under specific circumstances involving the lawful termination of employment. These generally include:

  1. Installation of labor-saving devices (Article 298, par. a);
  2. Redundancy (Article 298, par. b);
  3. Retrenchment (to prevent losses) (Article 298, par. c);
  4. Closure or cessation of operations (Article 298, par. d); or
  5. Disease or illness (Article 299).

Although these provisions apply to all employees, certain nuances arise in the case of security guards, due to:

  • Their assignment to various clients through a security agency;
  • The termination of the contract between the security agency and the principal;
  • The requirement under DOLE regulations to ensure continuity or redeployment of the security guard.

2.1 Termination for Authorized Causes

If the employer (i.e., the security agency) terminates the security guard’s employment for authorized causes such as redundancy, retrenchment, closure of the business, or installation of labor-saving devices, the guard is generally entitled to separation pay as specified in the Labor Code:

  • Closure or cessation of operations, redundancy, or labor-saving devices:
    • At least one (1) month pay or one (1) month pay per year of service, whichever is higher, per Article 298.
  • Retrenchment:
    • At least one-half (1/2) month pay for every year of service.
  • Termination due to disease:
    • At least one (1) month salary or one-half (1/2) month salary for every year of service, whichever is greater.

2.2 Termination for Just Causes

When termination is due to just causes under the Labor Code (Articles 297 and 299 [formerly 282 and 284]), such as gross misconduct, willful disobedience, or fraud, the employee (security guard) is not entitled to separation pay unless a more favorable company policy, collective bargaining agreement (CBA), or voluntary grant by the employer provides otherwise.

3. Effect of Contract Expiration Between Agency and Principal

A unique scenario for security guards arises when the contract between the security agency and the principal (client) expires or is terminated. It is a common misconception that the guard’s employment automatically ends when the client’s contract with the agency ends. The Supreme Court has consistently held that the security agency, as the employer, must either:

  1. Reassign or redeploy the guard to another client or post; or
  2. If no such post is available, validly terminate the guard’s employment on an authorized cause (e.g., redundancy or closure of business for that post).

If a security agency simply ends the relationship without redeployment or the observance of valid termination procedures, it may constitute illegal dismissal. When the dismissal is ruled illegal by labor tribunals:

  • The illegally dismissed security guard is entitled to reinstatement without loss of seniority rights, and full backwages.
  • If reinstatement is no longer possible (e.g., strained relations), the guard may receive separation pay in lieu of reinstatement, along with full backwages.

4. Security of Tenure for Security Guards

Security guards enjoy the same constitutional guarantee of security of tenure enjoyed by all regular employees. Being assigned to a particular client does not negate the guard’s regular status within the security agency. Even if the guard’s place of assignment changes, he/she remains a regular employee of the agency, provided the normal requirements for regular employment have been met.

Key points regarding security of tenure:

  1. Completion of probationary period: Once a security guard passes the probationary period and is considered a regular employee of the agency, he/she is entitled to security of tenure.
  2. Continuity of service: Transferring a guard from one client to another does not break the continuity of his/her employment with the security agency.
  3. Right to due process: If there is a valid ground to terminate the guard’s employment, the agency must follow the two-notice rule and hearing/meeting requirement per Philippine labor law.

5. Special DOLE Regulations and Department Orders

While the Labor Code is the overarching law, the DOLE has issued guidelines specifically addressing contractual arrangements and obligations of employers in relation to their employees. Of particular relevance are:

  • Department Order No. 174, Series of 2017 (DO 174-17): Governs contracting and subcontracting arrangements; underscores the legitimate status of private security agencies as independent contractors if they meet certain criteria.
  • DOLE Department Orders on the Regulation of Security Agencies: Emphasize that security agencies remain the direct employers of security guards. They must ensure the payment of wages, social security contributions, and lawful benefits.

These DOLE issuances reiterate that mere termination of a service contract with a principal does not automatically sever the employment of security guards. If a security agency fails to redeploy or otherwise terminates the guard without following the authorized or just cause procedures, it will be liable for illegal dismissal.

6. Computation of Separation Pay

In general, the following are common formulas for separation pay, anchored in Article 298 of the Labor Code:

  1. One-month pay per year of service
    For authorized causes such as redundancy, closure of business (not due to serious losses), or installation of labor-saving devices.

  2. Half-month pay per year of service
    For retrenchment or termination to prevent losses, and for termination due to disease.

6.1 Inclusion in “One Month Pay”

“One-month pay” in the context of separation pay typically includes the basic salary plus the regular allowances that the employee was receiving at the time of termination, if such allowances are granted in a fixed or regular manner (e.g., transportation allowance given monthly without conditions).

6.2 Rounding Off

In calculating “per year of service,” a fraction of at least six (6) months is typically considered as one whole year of service.

7. Separation Pay in Lieu of Reinstatement (Illegal Dismissal Cases)

If the security guard is illegally dismissed (i.e., there was no just or authorized cause or the employer violated due process), the general remedies are:

  1. Reinstatement without loss of seniority rights; and
  2. Full backwages.

However, if reinstatement is no longer viable (e.g., the company has ceased to operate, the relationship has become extremely strained, or a labor tribunal deems it impractical), separation pay in lieu of reinstatement is granted. The computation is commonly one month pay for every year of service, plus full backwages from the time of dismissal up to finality of the decision.

8. Common Scenarios for Security Guards

  1. End of Client Contract but Agency Still Operational

    • The agency must reassign or redeploy the guard to another post.
    • If no new post is available, the agency can resort to authorized cause termination with proper notice and payment of separation pay.

  2. Security Agency Closure

    • If the security agency closes or ceases operations, separation pay applies (one-month pay per year of service or at least one month pay, whichever is higher), unless closure is due to serious losses proven in accordance with the Labor Code.

  3. Retrenchment

    • If the agency is experiencing imminent or actual serious business losses, it may retrench employees, including security guards. The guard would then be entitled to half-month pay for every year of service.

  4. Dismissal for Just Cause

    • If the guard commits serious misconduct, insubordination, or other acts outlined as just causes under Article 297, the guard is not entitled to separation pay unless a more favorable policy or agreement applies.

  5. Medical/Incapacity Reasons

    • If the guard is found to be suffering from a disease not curable within six months and continued employment is prejudicial to health or the health of co-employees, the employer may terminate employment under Article 299. The guard is entitled to at least one month pay or half-month pay per year of service, whichever is greater.

9. Frequently Asked Questions and Practical Tips

Q1. If the client refuses to continue the security guard’s services, does that mean the guard is automatically terminated?
A1. No. The security guard’s employer is the security agency, not the client. The agency is obligated to reassign the guard elsewhere if possible, or otherwise go through valid termination procedures.

Q2. Does length of service reset when a security guard is deployed to a new client?
A2. No. The security guard’s service is continuous under the same security agency. Transferring from one client to another does not reset tenure.

Q3. Can a security guard get separation pay if dismissed for misconduct?
A3. Generally, no. Dismissal for just causes (e.g., serious misconduct, fraud) does not entitle the guard to separation pay. However, if the agency’s policies, a CBA, or an existing practice provides for it, then such separation pay may be given.

Q4. How should a security guard pursue claims if unlawfully terminated?
A4. The guard may file a complaint with the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) or seek assistance from DOLE (through the Single Entry Approach or SEnA) to settle disputes before escalating the matter.

Q5. What documents or evidence should a guard keep for a potential claim?
A5. Security guards should keep copies of their employment contract, payslips, deployment orders, notices from the agency, and any written communications about reassignment or termination. These documents can be critical in proving continuity of employment and the circumstances of dismissal or non-redeployment.

10. Summary

  1. Security guards are typically regular employees of security agencies once they complete their probationary status.
  2. They enjoy the same labor rights—including security of tenure and separation pay entitlement—as other employees under Philippine law.
  3. Contract termination with a principal does not automatically end the guard’s employment. The agency must reassign or validly terminate.
  4. Separation pay depends on the cause of termination:
    • Authorized causes: Ranging from half-month to one-month pay per year of service.
    • Just causes: No separation pay (unless provided by policy or agreement).
    • Illegal dismissal: Separation pay in lieu of reinstatement plus backwages may be awarded if reinstatement is no longer feasible.
  5. Compliance with due process is critical. Agencies must observe the two-notice rule if terminating for cause.
  6. Document retention and awareness of rights are crucial for security guards to ensure they can enforce any claims.

Overall, separation pay entitlement for security guards in the Philippines reflects the fundamental principles of the Labor Code: protection to labor, social justice, and fair compensation when employment is ended for reasons beyond the employee’s control. Security agencies must strictly comply with these laws and regulations, as failure to do so could result in liability for illegal dismissal and the corresponding monetary awards to the security guard.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login