Threats and Harassment by Lending Apps Over Delayed Payment

Title: Understanding Threats and Harassment by Lending Apps Over Delayed Payments in the Philippines

In the Philippines, consumer lending has become more accessible with the rise of online and mobile-based lending applications (or “lending apps”). While these platforms can offer convenient credit to borrowers in financial need, there have been multiple reports of borrowers experiencing aggressive, threatening, or harassing collection practices—especially upon delayed payment. This article provides an overview of the issue, relevant Philippine laws and regulations, borrower rights, potential remedies, and other considerations.

1. The Rise of Lending Apps in the Philippines

  1. Convenience and Accessibility

    • Many people turn to lending apps because of the convenience of applying for loans online.
    • Approval can happen within hours or days, with minimal documentation compared to traditional bank loans.

  2. High Interest Rates and Short Repayment Periods

    • Some lending apps charge relatively high interest rates and require repayment within short periods.
    • When borrowers fail to pay on time, additional fees and penalties can accumulate rapidly.

  3. Increased Reports of Harassment

    • There have been widespread media and consumer-protection agency reports about borrowers receiving threatening messages, calls, or even social media shaming.
    • This behavior often violates various consumer protection and privacy laws in the Philippines.

2. Common Forms of Threats and Harassment

  1. Threatening Messages or Calls

    • Borrowers may receive calls or text messages from debt collectors threatening legal action, public shaming, or harm.
    • Some collectors may impersonate attorneys or government officials, warning of imminent arrest or court cases unless immediate payment is made.

  2. Harassment Through Social Media

    • Certain lending apps have accessed borrower contact lists or social media friends to send messages labeling the borrower a “delinquent” or “fraud.”
    • They may also threaten to post personal photos or details as a form of public shaming.

  3. Unauthorized Access to Contacts

    • A disturbing practice occurs when some apps request access to a borrower’s phone contacts during the application process. Later, collectors may message or call these contacts to shame the borrower into paying.
    • This often happens without explicit, informed consent—or even if there was initial consent, the manner of data usage may violate privacy laws.

  4. Misleading Legal Threats

    • Borrowers sometimes receive official-looking letters or emails claiming that the borrower is facing criminal charges for “estafa” or other offenses.
    • In many cases, the content is misleading, and no actual legal case has been filed.

3. Relevant Laws and Regulations in the Philippines

  1. Data Privacy Act of 2012 (Republic Act No. 10173)

    • Prohibits unauthorized processing or use of personal data.
    • Collection agencies or lending apps that misuse borrower information, such as contacting uninvolved parties or disclosing private information without consent, risk violating privacy laws.
    • The National Privacy Commission (NPC) has issued numerous warnings and fines to erring lending companies.

  2. BSP Circulars and the Financial Products and Services Consumer Protection Act

    • While the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) primarily regulates banks and other financial institutions, it has issued guidelines on fair debt collection practices.
    • BSP Circular No. 1048 provides guidelines on treating consumers fairly, which many interpret as also applying to digital lending platforms under certain conditions.
    • Republic Act No. 11765 (Financial Products and Services Consumer Protection Act) likewise provides mechanisms to protect consumers from unfair or abusive practices.

  3. Revised Penal Code Provisions on Threats and Other Offenses

    • Threatening physical harm or committing unwarranted shaming or defamation can be prosecuted under the Revised Penal Code.
    • Article 282 (Grave Threats) or Article 283 (Light Threats) may apply if the collector explicitly threatens harm.
    • Article 355 on libel may apply to defamatory statements made publicly, including on social media.

  4. Lending Company Regulation Act of 2007 (Republic Act No. 9474)

    • Governs lending companies and requires them to register with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
    • The SEC has authority to suspend or revoke the licenses of lending companies that engage in unfair collection practices or violate consumer rights.

  5. SEC Memorandum Circulars on Unfair Debt Collection

    • The SEC has issued memoranda clarifying prohibited debt collection practices, including harassment, the use of threats, obscene language, or false representation.
    • The SEC can impose administrative sanctions, fines, or even revoke the license of a lending company that violates these rules.

4. Legal Rights and Protections for Borrowers

  1. Right to Privacy and Data Protection

    • Under the Data Privacy Act, personal data should only be processed in ways consistent with legitimate purposes, and with adequate security.
    • Borrowers can file a complaint with the National Privacy Commission if a lending app misuses their data or contacts unrelated third parties.

  2. Right to Fair Debt Collection Practices

    • Collection agencies and lending apps must refrain from threats, harassment, and deceit.
    • This includes refraining from contacting relatives, friends, or employers who are not contractually liable for the debt.

  3. Right to Be Free from Defamation

    • Borrowers have the right to file civil and even criminal charges (e.g., libel) if false statements damaging their reputation are published or disseminated.

  4. Right to Due Process

    • Borrowers cannot be arbitrarily arrested for failing to pay a debt in a purely civil transaction.
    • Any legitimate legal action (such as a collection lawsuit) must go through the courts, with proper summons and opportunity to respond.

5. Possible Remedies for Borrowers Experiencing Harassment

  1. Filing a Complaint with the SEC

    • If the lending app is registered as a lending company, borrowers may submit a complaint detailing abusive or illegal collection practices.
    • Include evidence (e.g., screenshots of messages, call recordings, etc.).

  2. Filing a Complaint with the National Privacy Commission

    • If personal or contact data is being misused (e.g., your contacts are being harassed), lodge a formal complaint with the NPC.
    • Provide relevant details on how the data was allegedly processed without proper consent or authority.

  3. Seeking Assistance from the Philippine National Police (PNP) or NBI

    • If the harassment involves direct threats of harm, blackmail, or other criminal elements, report this to local law enforcement.
    • You may also coordinate with the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) Cybercrime Division if harassment occurs via digital means.

  4. Consulting a Lawyer / Public Attorney’s Office (PAO)

    • If you need legal advice, especially regarding the possibility of filing civil or criminal cases against the lending company, consult with a private lawyer or seek free legal aid from the Public Attorney’s Office.

  5. Documenting All Communication

    • Keep thorough records of calls, messages, screenshots, and any form of contact from collectors. These can serve as evidence if you decide to file a complaint or request legal remedies.

6. Lawful vs. Unlawful Collection Practices

  1. Lawful Collection

    • Sending reminders about due dates or requesting payment.
    • Explaining possible legal actions that are legitimately available under the law.
    • Providing detailed statements of account and official notices.

  2. Unlawful Collection

    • Making threats of harm or threats of non-existent criminal cases.
    • Using obscene or profane language to intimidate the borrower.
    • Publicly shaming borrowers, contacting unrelated third parties, or spreading false accusations.
    • Impersonating government authorities or legal professionals to scare the borrower.

7. Practical Tips for Borrowers Facing Harassment

  1. Know Your Rights

    • Familiarize yourself with the Data Privacy Act, SEC memoranda, and other consumer protection laws.

  2. Assert Your Rights During Calls

    • Politely inform the debt collector that their threats or harassing conduct is not permitted by law.
    • Clarify that you are aware of your rights and that you may seek recourse if they continue using illegal tactics.

  3. Negotiate Payment Arrangements

    • If you can repay but need more time, try to negotiate a feasible payment plan. Get any revised agreement in writing if possible.

  4. Limit or Block Harassing Contacts

    • If possible, record or take screenshots of harassment before blocking the number.
    • This evidence can support a complaint later.

  5. Stay Calm and Document Everything

    • Harassment can be stressful and emotionally draining, but maintaining a calm approach helps you respond clearly and logically.
    • Keep a record of all evidence that might prove useful should legal action or regulatory complaints become necessary.

8. The Role of Government Agencies

  1. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)

    • Oversees lending and financing companies.
    • Can impose sanctions on non-compliant companies and revoke licenses for repeated or serious violations.

  2. National Privacy Commission (NPC)

    • Ensures adherence to the Data Privacy Act.
    • Borrowers can file complaints regarding misuse of personal data or unauthorized sharing of contact information.

  3. Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP)

    • Though primarily regulating banks, the BSP has started collaborating with other agencies to supervise financial technology (fintech) firms, including some lending apps.
    • Also promulgates consumer protection policies.

  4. Department of Trade and Industry (DTI)

    • Oversees general consumer protection matters.
    • While the SEC has primary jurisdiction over lending companies, the DTI can coordinate on broader consumer rights concerns.

  5. Local Law Enforcement and Judiciary

    • Police and courts become involved when there are threats of harm, defamation, or other criminal violations.

9. Potential Consequences for Lending Apps Using Harassment

  1. Administrative Sanctions

    • Fines, penalties, and suspension or revocation of business licenses by the SEC.

  2. Civil Liability

    • Borrowers can pursue damages for defamation, invasion of privacy, and emotional distress, depending on the severity of the harassment.

  3. Criminal Liability

    • Collectors or representatives of lending companies may face criminal charges for threats, blackmail, libel, or unauthorized processing of data.

  4. Reputational Damage

    • Many borrowers share their experiences on social media and consumer forums, discouraging potential customers from using these services.

10. Final Thoughts

Threats and harassment by lending apps over delayed payment are not only unethical but often illegal under Philippine law. Borrowers have the right to fair treatment, protection of their privacy, and freedom from intimidation. Regulatory bodies like the SEC and the National Privacy Commission have stepped up oversight and sanctions against erring lenders, but borrowers must also take proactive measures:

  • Stay informed about your legal rights and obligations.
  • Document any abusive or threatening behavior.
  • Seek help from legal professionals, government agencies, or law enforcement if necessary.

While repaying debts remains a borrower’s legal responsibility, no one should be subjected to illegal or abusive debt collection practices. By understanding the legal landscape, borrowers can assert their rights and protect themselves against harassment.

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and regulations may change over time, and individual circumstances can vary. For specific concerns about your case, you should consult a licensed attorney in the Philippines.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login