Types of Obligations under the Civil Code of the Philippines

Below is a comprehensive discussion of the types of obligations under the Civil Code of the Philippines, primarily found in Book IV (Obligations and Contracts). This article aims to clarify each classification and discuss all relevant concepts, with references to the pertinent Articles of the Civil Code (Republic Act No. 386). Note that while the Civil Code’s text remains the ultimate authority, this exposition may help in understanding the broader legal and practical implications of each type of obligation.

I. Definition of Obligation and General Principles

A. Definition (Article 1156)

Under Article 1156 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, an obligation is defined as a “juridical necessity to give, to do, or not to do.” This establishes several core attributes:

  1. Juridical Necessity – The debtor (obligor) is legally bound to comply with the obligation, and noncompliance can give rise to judicial or extrajudicial remedies.
  2. Object of the Obligation – Performance may involve:
    • To give (real obligation) – Delivering a thing (e.g., payment of money, transfer of property).
    • To do (positive personal obligation) – Performing a service or an act (e.g., constructing a house).
    • Not to do (negative personal obligation) – Refraining from an act (e.g., non-competition agreement, prohibition against disclosure).

B. Sources of Obligations (Articles 1157–1158)

Although not a “type” of obligation in the strict sense, it is important to note that obligations under Philippine law can arise from:

  1. Law – Those expressly provided in statutes (e.g., obligations to pay taxes).
  2. Contracts – By agreement of parties, recognized as the principal source of private obligations.
  3. Quasi-Contracts – Arising from lawful, voluntary, and unilateral acts (e.g., solutio indebiti).
  4. Delicts or Crimes – Where criminal offense gives rise to civil liability for damages.
  5. Quasi-Delicts – Civil liability arising from acts or omissions causing damage to another, independent of contractual relations (Article 2176).

II. Classifications of Obligations

The Civil Code classifies obligations in various ways depending on conditions, subjects, or the nature of performance. Below are the key classifications:

A. Pure and Conditional Obligations (Articles 1179–1192)

  1. Pure Obligation

    • An obligation is pure when it is not subject to any condition or period. It is demandable at once.
    • Example: “I promise to pay you PHP 100,000.” Without qualification, the right to demand payment arises immediately.

  2. Conditional Obligations

    • The effectivity or extinguishment of the obligation depends on a future and uncertain event (the “condition”).

    • Types of Conditions:

      1. Suspensive Condition (Condition precedent) – The obligation only arises or becomes demandable upon the fulfillment of the condition.
        • Example: “I promise to pay you PHP 100,000 if I pass the bar exams.”
      2. Resolutory Condition (Condition subsequent) – The obligation already exists, but it is extinguished upon the happening of the condition.
        • Example: “I give you the right to use my land until I sell it. Once sold, your right ends.”

    • Effects of Conditional Obligations

      • Loss, deterioration, or improvement of the thing (Articles 1189–1190) – Special rules apply if the object of the obligation (a thing) is lost or damaged while the condition is pending. The party who bears the risk or fault (creditor or debtor) and the timing of such loss or damage affect whether or not the obligation is extinguished or demandable.

    • Potestative, Casual, and Mixed Conditions (Article 1182)

      1. Potestative – The condition depends solely on the will of one of the parties. If it depends solely on the will of the debtor, it is void if suspensive (no true obligation arises).
      2. Casual – Depends on chance or the will of a third person.
      3. Mixed – Depends partly on the will of one of the parties and partly on chance or the will of a third person.

B. Obligations with a Period or Term (Articles 1193–1198)

  1. Obligations with a Period

    • These are obligations whose demandability or extinguishment is subject to the lapse of a period or term.
    • Example: “I promise to pay you PHP 100,000 on December 31, 2025.”
    • A period is different from a condition in that the event is certain to happen (though the exact time may be uncertain), whereas a condition is an uncertain event.

  2. Kinds of Periods

    • Suspensive Period – The obligation becomes demandable only when the period arrives (e.g., payment date).
    • Resolutory Period – The obligation subsists up to a certain point, after which it is extinguished.
    • The period may be express (specifically stated) or tacit (implied by the nature of the obligation or surrounding circumstances).
    • Courts may fix the duration of the period if it depends on the will of the debtor and no clear guidance is provided by the parties (Article 1197).

C. Alternative and Facultative Obligations (Articles 1199–1206)

  1. Alternative Obligation

    • One where several prestations (things to be delivered or acts to be done) are due, but the performance of one of them is sufficient to extinguish the obligation.
    • Example: “I promise to deliver my car or my motorcycle.”
    • Right of Choice – Generally belongs to the debtor unless expressly granted to the creditor (Article 1200). The debtor must choose one of the prestations in good faith, and once chosen, the obligation is limited to that selected performance.

  2. Facultative Obligation

    • Only one prestation has been agreed upon, but the debtor may substitute it with another.
    • Example: “I promise to deliver my car, but I may deliver my motorcycle instead if I choose.”
    • In alternative obligations, multiple prestations are due from the outset, while in facultative obligations, only one is due with an option to substitute.

D. Joint and Solidary Obligations (Articles 1207–1222)

  1. Joint Obligation

    • Each debtor is liable pro rata (in proportion) to his share, and each creditor is entitled only to his share.
    • Example: If A and B jointly owe C PHP 100,000 (without any statement that it is solidary), each owes PHP 50,000, and C can only collect PHP 50,000 from each.
    • In case of multiple debtors, the default presumption is that the obligation is joint unless the law or the contract expressly provides otherwise (Article 1207).

  2. Solidary Obligation

    • Each debtor is liable for the entire obligation, and each creditor is entitled to demand full satisfaction of the claim.
    • Kinds of Solidarity
      1. Active Solidarity – Among creditors (each creditor can demand the full performance).
      2. Passive Solidarity – Among debtors (each debtor can be made to pay the entire amount).
      3. Mixed Solidarity – Solidarity among both creditors and debtors.
    • Solidarity must be expressly stated or provided by law. Common legal bases include tort liability among joint tortfeasors and contractual stipulations stating that “the parties bind themselves jointly and severally.”

  3. Effects of Solidarity

    • Demand by one creditor (in active solidarity) extinguishes the obligation up to the amount collected.
    • Demand against one debtor (in passive solidarity) does not prevent the creditor from going after another if the first debtor fails to pay.
    • Payment by one debtor in full extinguishes the entire obligation, subject to the right to recover from co-debtors their respective shares (Article 1217).

E. Divisible and Indivisible Obligations (Articles 1223–1225)

  1. Divisible Obligation

    • Susceptible of partial performance. The obligation can be performed or paid in parts.
    • Example: An obligation to deliver a certain quantity of fungible goods (e.g., 1,000 sacks of rice) may often be divisible.
    • Division depends on the nature of the prestation and intention of the parties.

  2. Indivisible Obligation

    • Cannot be validly performed in parts due to its nature or the stipulation of the parties.
    • Example: An obligation to deliver a specific car cannot be done partially; it is inherently indivisible.
    • If an obligation is indivisible but has multiple debtors (or creditors), noncompliance by one debtor may result in certain legal consequences for the other debtors.

F. Obligations with a Penal Clause (Articles 1226–1230)

  1. Definition and Purpose

    • An obligation containing a penal clause imposes a penalty in case of noncompliance or imperfect performance.
    • The penalty is generally a predetermined sum or prestation due in case of breach.

  2. Effect of Penal Clause

    • The penalty substitutes for damages and interest unless otherwise stipulated (Article 1226).
    • The creditor can demand either the principal obligation or the penalty, but not both (except when there is stipulation that both can be demanded cumulatively if partial breach is involved).

  3. Reduction of Penalty

    • Courts may reduce a penalty if it is iniquitous or unconscionable (Article 1229). This is a manifestation of the equitable power of courts to temper unreasonable stipulations.

G. Other Related Concepts

  1. Real vs. Personal Obligations

    • Real Obligation – The obligation to deliver a thing (to “give”).
    • Personal Obligation – The obligation to do (positive) or not to do (negative).

  2. Civil vs. Natural Obligations

    • Civil Obligation – Gives a right of action to compel performance.
    • Natural Obligation – Based on equity and moral justice, not enforceable in court but recognized in law. Example: A debt prescribed by the statute of limitations but voluntarily paid cannot be recovered.

  3. Legal Subrogation and Assignment of Credits

    • Though not a separate type of obligation, subrogation and assignment relate to the transfer of rights and/or obligations under a contract, thereby affecting how obligations are discharged or enforced.

III. Practical Importance in Philippine Legal Context

  1. Contract Drafting and Negotiation

    • Parties must be explicit when intending to create solidary obligations to avoid the presumption of joint obligations.
    • Conditions and periods should be clear to prevent disputes on demandability.

  2. Litigation and Enforcement

    • Understanding how conditions affect liability is crucial in determining when and how an obligation can be enforced.
    • Solidary vs. joint liabilities have significant impact on how creditors collect debts and how co-debtors share liability.

  3. Commercial Transactions

    • Creditors often insist on solidary liability among business partners or co-makers to ensure a higher chance of recovery.
    • Use of penal clauses in contracts as a deterrent to breach is common but must be reasonable to withstand judicial scrutiny.

  4. Risk Management

    • Divisible obligations allow partial fulfillment; indivisible obligations require the entire performance and may carry heavier risks if they cannot be subdivided or performed incrementally.
    • In obligations with conditions, clarifying fault or risk of loss is critical for goods in transit or items subject to uncertain events.

IV. Conclusion

The Civil Code of the Philippines provides a detailed framework for understanding, classifying, and enforcing obligations. Each type—pure, conditional, with a period, alternative or facultative, joint or solidary, divisible or indivisible, with a penal clause—serves to specify when, how, by whom, and to what extent the obligation must be performed. Mastery of these classifications is essential not only for legal practitioners but also for individuals and business entities entering into contracts and other juridical acts.

When dealing with obligations, careful drafting and clarity in stipulations regarding solidarity, conditions, periods, and possible penalties help avoid ambiguity and potential litigation. Where disputes do arise, the Civil Code provisions on obligations guide the courts, ensuring that legal obligations, as defined, are carried out in accordance with justice and good faith, core principles underlying Philippine civil law.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not substitute for professional legal advice. For specific concerns, consult a qualified attorney to address your unique situation.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login