Termination Without Proper Records and Memo Validity After Each Year in the Philippines

Concern:
Can an employer terminate an employee without proper records or a written memo? Additionally, do all memos given to an employee lose validity at the end of each year, effectively resetting the record?

---

∇ Legal Contemplator

Initial Observations

• Let’s start simple: Philippine labor law heavily favors employee protection. This aligns with the Labor Code of the Philippines, which safeguards workers from unfair practices.
• Termination without proper records or notice seems like it would contradict this principle, but let’s examine why that might be.
• The question about memo validity resetting at the end of the year feels less straightforward. Is this governed by law, company policy, or some unstated cultural norm?

Now, let’s break this into atomic steps:

1. What does “proper records” mean?
   Proper documentation would include written memos, disciplinary notices, or signed agreements. These ensure that termination isn’t arbitrary.
2. Are written memos required?
   Verbal instructions or accusations are insufficient for legal termination under most circumstances.
3. What governs memo validity?
   This could involve laws, company-specific policies, or collective bargaining agreements (if applicable).

Unpacking the Legal Framework for Termination

The Labor Code of the Philippines specifies two broad types of employee termination:

1. Just Causes (Art. 297, formerly 282):

   • These are serious violations such as gross misconduct, fraud, or willful disobedience.
   • Even for just causes, due process is mandatory, which requires:
     • A written notice informing the employee of the allegations.
     • Ample opportunity for the employee to explain or defend themselves.
     • A second written notice detailing the decision to terminate.

2. Authorized Causes (Art. 298 and 299):

   • These include redundancy, retrenchment, or closure.
   • Again, written notice is critical, not just for the employee but also for DOLE (Department of Labor and Employment).

Does Termination Without Records Violate Labor Law?

• Yes, because the Labor Code enforces a structured process.
• Without records:
  • There’s no proof that due process was followed.
  • Employees could claim illegal dismissal and seek reinstatement or back wages.

Exploring Memo Validity

• Memos are disciplinary tools, documenting misconduct or warnings.
• Do they “expire”? That depends:
  • Legally: There’s no explicit law stating memos reset annually.
  • Practically: Some companies may adopt a "clean slate" policy, where minor infractions don’t carry over to the next year.
  • CBA or Company Rules: These could include provisions about the lifespan of memos, but they would need to comply with broader labor law.

Doubt and Reconsideration

Let’s revisit this memo issue.

• Memos serve as records of infractions. If a company policy allows for expiration, it might signal leniency but shouldn’t nullify serious violations.
• What if the concern stems from a misunderstanding? Could the “reset” concept reflect informal management practices rather than legal principles?

Possible Dead Ends

• Assuming memos lose validity universally across all workplaces is risky.
• The idea that termination can occur without records could only hold if both parties agree (e.g., mutual resignation). This scenario might not align with what’s being asked.

Iterative Reasoning

If the goal is to determine whether employees are unfairly terminated, memos are less about annual validity and more about proving due process. So, maybe the deeper issue is not whether memos expire but whether the employer uses them responsibly.

Further Questions to Explore

• Could an employer terminate someone without proper documentation if the employee consented (e.g., via resignation)?
• Are there any scenarios where memo expiration rules are explicitly codified in law?
• What happens when there’s no record of a warning but termination proceeds anyway?

---

Final Answer

1. Can an employer terminate without proper records or written memo?
   No. The Labor Code of the Philippines requires due process, including written notices and documentation of infractions. Without these, termination may be deemed illegal, and the employee can file a case for reinstatement or compensation.

2. Do all memos lose validity at the end of the year?
   Legally, there’s no provision for memos to “expire” annually. This depends on company policy or collective agreements. However, minor infractions might be disregarded over time as a goodwill practice, but this doesn’t apply to serious violations.