Oral Defamation Law Philippines

Dear Attorney,

I would like to ask if I can file a case for oral defamation. Someone has been spreading false claims against me, including accusations that I committed fraud. This person has also been verbally insulting me with vulgar language. I want to know if this can be considered oral defamation and how I can take legal action.

Sincerely,
Concerned Individual

---

Insights

Understanding Oral Defamation in the Philippines

Oral defamation, or slander, is defined under Article 358 of the Revised Penal Code of the Philippines. It refers to malicious statements made publicly that harm a person's reputation. Defamation can be spoken (oral defamation) or written (libel). The law distinguishes between "serious" and "slight" oral defamation, depending on the nature of the remarks and the extent of the damage to the victim’s reputation.

Key Elements of Oral Defamation

To establish a case of oral defamation, the following elements must be proven:

1. Utterance of a Defamatory Statement: The statements must harm the reputation or character of the person targeted.
2. Publicity: The remarks must be made publicly or in front of third parties who are able to hear and understand the statements.
3. Malice: The statement must have been made with the intent to cause harm, or at least recklessly made, without regard for its truth or falsity.

Types of Oral Defamation

1. Serious Defamation (Grave Slander): If the defamatory statement is serious, affects the person's dignity, or is made in a context where it can have a damaging impact, it is considered serious. Grave slander may include accusations of crime, immorality, or any conduct that leads to public embarrassment.
2. Slight Defamation (Simple Slander): Remarks that may not significantly damage a person’s reputation but are nonetheless insulting can be classified as slight defamation. Simple name-calling or petty insults may fall under this category.

Defenses in Oral Defamation Cases

Several defenses may be available to a person accused of oral defamation:

1. Truth as a Defense: If the defamatory statement can be proven true, the defendant may avoid liability. However, in cases involving private individuals, truth alone may not suffice—there must also be a showing that the statement was made with good motives and for justifiable ends.
2. Privilege Communication: Statements made in certain situations, such as in judicial proceedings or in a privileged context, may not be actionable as defamation.
3. Lack of Malice: If the statement was not made with malicious intent or was made without the intent to harm, this may negate the defamation claim.

Penalties for Oral Defamation

Under the Revised Penal Code, penalties for oral defamation vary:

• Serious Defamation (Grave Slander): Imprisonment ranging from six months and one day to two years and four months, or a fine.
• Slight Defamation (Simple Slander): The penalty for slight defamation can be arresto menor, which may range from one day to 30 days of imprisonment, or a fine.

Filing an Oral Defamation Case

To file an oral defamation case in the Philippines, the victim must gather evidence, such as:

• Testimonies from witnesses who heard the defamatory statements.
• Any recording or documentation of the defamatory utterance (if available).

The complaint should be filed with the local prosecutor's office, where a preliminary investigation will determine whether there is probable cause to proceed with a case.

In conclusion, oral defamation is a serious offense that can severely affect a person’s reputation and standing in society. Filipino law offers recourse to individuals subjected to such malicious statements, providing them with an opportunity to restore their dignity through legal means.