Property Succession in Informal Settlements

Letter to a Lawyer

Dear Attorney,

I am writing to seek your advice regarding a property matter concerning my late mother. My mother resided for a long time in a house located in a squatter area. Unfortunately, she recently passed away. There is a disagreement within the family about who should inherit the house. I want to clarify if the property should go to my mother's children (her heirs) or if it could be claimed by her siblings.

Your guidance on this matter, especially within the framework of Philippine laws, would be greatly appreciated.

Sincerely,
A Concerned Individual

---

Legal Analysis on the Succession of Informal Settlement Properties in the Philippines

I. Introduction to Property Succession

In the Philippines, the rules governing succession are primarily found in the Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act No. 386). Succession refers to the legal transmission of rights, properties, and obligations from a deceased individual to their heirs. It applies to both formal and informal settlements, although complications arise in cases involving properties in squatter or informal settlements.

II. Legal Framework Governing Property Rights in Squatter Areas

In informal settlements, the principle of ownership becomes complicated due to the lack of formal land titles. However, possession of the house, improvements, and structures built thereon may still create personal property rights under certain conditions. This means that while the land might not be owned, the structures may still constitute inheritable property.

Relevant laws and doctrines that may apply include:

1. Urban Development and Housing Act (UDHA) of 1992 (Republic Act No. 7279)
   • Recognizes the rights of informal settlers to basic services and protection from eviction under specific conditions.
2. Civil Code of the Philippines
   • Articles 774 to 1105 detail the rules on succession and inheritance, which apply even when property is informal.
3. Possessory Rights
   • Informal settlers may claim long-term possessory rights, particularly if they have occupied the property peacefully and without interruption.

III. Who Inherits the House in Informal Settlements?

The determination of who inherits property (including structures in informal settlements) depends on whether the deceased left a will. In the absence of a will, the following rules apply under the Civil Code:

1. Legal or Intestate Succession
   Intestate succession occurs when a person dies without leaving a valid will. The order of heirs is as follows:

   • Children (Legitimate and Illegitimate)
     First in line are the children of the deceased. If the deceased has legitimate and illegitimate children, they inherit in proportion to their shares under the law (e.g., legitimate children receive twice as much as illegitimate children).
   • Surviving Spouse
     If there are no children, or if children co-inherit, the surviving spouse is next in line.
   • Parents
     If there are no children or spouse, the parents of the deceased inherit.
   • Siblings
     If there are no children, spouse, or parents, siblings are next in line.

   In your case, the legal heirs are your mother's children. Her siblings (your uncles or aunts) are not entitled to inherit unless none of her children or spouse exists.

2. Partition of the Property
   Once the rightful heirs are determined, the property (or rights to the structure) is divided among them according to their respective shares. For example, if your mother had three children, the house would be divided equally among them unless otherwise agreed.

IV. Special Considerations for Informal Settlements

While the Civil Code lays out clear rules, unique issues arise with properties in squatter areas:

1. Possession Without Title
   The house is typically built on land not owned by the settler. In such cases, inheritance involves only the structure and not the land.
2. Transfer of Possessory Rights
   While heirs may inherit the structure, they must also establish their rights to continue occupying the land. This often requires negotiation with landowners or compliance with government housing policies.
3. Risk of Eviction
   Inheritors must also consider the potential risk of eviction if the government or landowner enforces clearance or redevelopment.

V. Legal Remedies and Steps for Heirs

To formalize inheritance and secure rights to the property:

1. Execution of an Extrajudicial Settlement of Estate
   Heirs can execute an extrajudicial settlement, provided there is no dispute among them, and the estate is relatively small. This document will outline how the property is divided among the heirs.
2. Barangay Mediation
   If disputes arise, the issue should first be brought to barangay-level mediation to seek an amicable settlement.
3. Legal Actions in Court
   If mediation fails, heirs may file a petition in court for judicial settlement of the estate. This process involves litigation and court supervision of property distribution.
4. Registration of Inherited Rights
   While it is impossible to register ownership of untitled land, heirs can file affidavits or agreements to formalize the transfer of possessory or usufruct rights.

VI. Can Siblings of the Deceased Inherit in This Case?

Under Philippine law, the siblings of the deceased are not entitled to inherit if there are surviving children, spouse, or parents. As the children of the deceased are direct heirs, they are entitled to inherit ahead of the deceased’s siblings. For a sibling to claim inheritance, they must prove that no direct heirs exist.

VII. Role of Government Policies

The UDHA provides informal settlers with potential relocation rights or the opportunity to purchase the land they occupy if the government declares it as part of a socialized housing program. Heirs should monitor government programs or negotiate with landowners to protect their rights to remain on the property.

VIII. Practical Considerations

1. Documentary Evidence
   Heirs should gather all documents that support their claim, such as utility bills, barangay certificates, or proof of long-term residence.
2. Avoidance of Fraudulent Claims
   To prevent disputes, all heirs must be involved in the settlement process. Any agreements must be properly notarized.

IX. Conclusion

In your case, as children of the deceased, you are the rightful heirs to the property (structure) your mother left behind. Her siblings cannot claim the property unless no direct heirs exist. However, since the property is situated in a squatter area, you must navigate specific legal and practical challenges to secure your rights.

Consulting a lawyer to formalize the process and resolve disputes will ensure that your rights are protected.