Unlawful Business Interference Philippines

Dear Attorney,

I am facing undue pressure from certain family members, which is causing significant strain on my business. Due to this, I am falling deeper into debt and struggling to maintain my operations. I am trying to recover, but I am being financially and emotionally cornered. Is there any legal recourse for me to stop this interference and protect my business? What can I do to ensure my rights are protected?

Sincerely,
A Business Owner in Distress

---

Insights

Unlawful Interference in Business Operations

In the Philippines, unlawful interference in business, also known as "tortious interference," occurs when a third party intentionally causes harm to an individual or company’s business relationships or contracts, resulting in financial loss. This interference can take various forms, such as coercion, intimidation, or undue influence, and may lead to the disruption or collapse of a business.

Legal Grounds for Filing a Case

If a person feels their business is being deliberately sabotaged or unduly pressured by another party, they can potentially seek legal recourse through a civil case for damages under the principles of tort law. In particular, the aggrieved party may pursue remedies based on the following provisions of Philippine law:

1. Civil Code on Abuse of Rights (Article 19)
   This provision protects individuals from abuse by another party who acts with bad faith or in a manner that causes unnecessary harm. The "abuse of rights" doctrine prevents individuals from using their legal rights in a way that unfairly harms another.

2. Acts of Unlawful Coercion (Revised Penal Code, Article 286)
   If the interference involves threats or intimidation intended to force someone to act against their will, this may be classified as unlawful coercion. Such actions are punishable by law, especially if they impact the operation of a business or contract.

3. Moral and Exemplary Damages (Civil Code, Article 2219 and 2229)
   If a party suffers emotional distress or harm due to another's undue influence or harassment, the aggrieved party may be entitled to moral damages. In egregious cases, exemplary damages may also be awarded as a form of punishment and deterrence against further wrongful acts.

Possible Remedies

1. Filing a Civil Complaint
   A civil case for damages may be filed against the person or entity responsible for the unlawful interference. The injured party can seek compensation for financial losses, moral damages, and potentially punitive damages for particularly malicious actions.

2. Injunction and Temporary Restraining Orders (TROs)
   In cases where ongoing interference is causing irreparable harm, the aggrieved party can petition the court to issue an injunction or TRO to immediately stop the wrongful acts. This can be particularly useful when the business is at risk of collapse or severe financial damage.

3. Mediation and Settlement
   Prior to filing a case, it may be advisable to consider alternative dispute resolution mechanisms such as mediation. This allows both parties to reach a mutually beneficial resolution without the need for lengthy litigation. However, if coercion and bad faith are evident, the wronged party may have stronger grounds to pursue legal action.

Conclusion

In the Philippines, businesses have the right to operate without undue interference from external parties, including family members. If the interference is malicious and causes harm, legal remedies are available to protect the business owner’s interests. Consulting with a lawyer is essential to assess the situation, determine the best course of action, and safeguard one's rights under the law.