Personal actions and real actions | Kinds of Actions | CIVIL PROCEDURE

Below is a comprehensive discussion of personal actions and real actions under Philippine law, particularly within the context of civil procedure. This outline is based on the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure (as amended), pertinent jurisprudence, and related legal principles.

I. OVERVIEW

In Philippine procedural law, actions are generally classified into two broad categories: real actions and personal actions. This classification is crucial for determining the proper venue, the nature of the relief sought, and certain procedural requirements. Although the basic definition of these actions stems from centuries-old civil law tradition, the controlling framework today is found primarily in the Rules of Court, specifically Rule 4 on Venue of Actions, supplemented by Supreme Court decisions interpreting these rules.

II. LEGAL BASIS AND DEFINITIONS

A. Statutory and Rule-Based Foundation

  1. Rule 4, Section 1 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure:

    • Real Actions: Those that affect title to or possession of real property, or interest therein.
    • Personal Actions: Those founded on privity of contract, damages for injuries to persons or property, and other rights or claims not involving real property.

  2. Civil Code of the Philippines: Though not explicitly categorizing real vs. personal actions in procedural terms, various provisions on property rights and obligations (Book II on Property, Ownership, and its Modifications; Book IV on Obligations and Contracts) inform when an action may be deemed real (affecting immovable property) or personal (affecting personal rights or obligations or movable property).

B. Key Distinction

  • A real action principally involves a real property right (ownership, possession, interest, foreclosure of real estate mortgage, partition, or any other suit where real property is the subject).
  • A personal action seeks enforcement of a personal obligation or liability, or recovery of personal property, or damages not directly tied to real property.

III. REAL ACTIONS

A. Definition and Nature

A real action is an action where the claim asserted involves title to, ownership, possession, or any interest in real property. The realty itself (or an interest therein) is the “object” of the litigation. Consequently, the judgment in a real action operates upon the thing or property itself and is binding against the whole world (or erga omnes).

  1. Examples:

    • Accion reivindicatoria: An action for the recovery of ownership of real property.
    • Accion publiciana: An action for the recovery of possession of real property when the dispossession has lasted for more than one year.
    • Accion interdictal or forcible entry / unlawful detainer (though these are summary in nature, they are still considered real actions involving possession).
    • Foreclosure of real estate mortgage: The action primarily involves the real property subject of the mortgage.
    • Partition suits: Where the property is sought to be physically or legally divided among co-owners.

  2. Venue:

    • Under Rule 4, Section 1, real actions “shall be commenced and tried in the proper court which has jurisdiction over the area where the real property or any part thereof is situated.”
    • This mandatory rule on venue is jurisdictional in real actions concerning immovable property.

  3. Effect on the Property:

    • In real actions, the court’s judgment often results in a directive affecting the status or ownership of specific real property (e.g., awarding ownership, ordering a partition, restoring possession).
    • Such judgment can be recorded on the title to provide notice to third persons (e.g., annotation on the Transfer Certificate of Title).

  4. Interest in Real Property:

    • The interest must be substantial or direct. Merely incidental issues (e.g., reference to land in determining damages or boundary, but no direct question of title or possession) do not automatically make the action real.

IV. PERSONAL ACTIONS

A. Definition and Nature

A personal action is one that does not directly involve or affect real property in terms of title or possession. Instead, it primarily seeks to enforce a personal obligation, recover money or damages, or compel the performance or omission of an act. The property in question, if any, is usually movable (personal property), or the action is purely for breach of contract, tort, or damages.

  1. Examples:

    • Actions for sum of money (collection suits, debts, unpaid loans, or obligations to pay).
    • Actions for damages (arising from contract or tortious conduct) that do not involve claims to real property.
    • Specific performance based on a contract where the subject matter is not real property (or does not directly affect title to land).
    • Rescission of contract (e.g., for the sale of personal property).
    • Quasi-delict claims under Article 2176 of the Civil Code, where the primary relief sought is indemnity or damages in personam.

  2. Venue:

    • Under Rule 4, Section 2, personal actions “may be commenced and tried where the plaintiff or any of the principal plaintiffs resides or where the defendant or any of the principal defendants resides, or in the case of a non-resident defendant, where the plaintiff resides, at the election of the plaintiff.”
    • This general rule is subject to stipulations as to venue in contracts (if not contrary to law, public policy, etc.) and is not jurisdictional unless specifically made so by law.

  3. In Personam vs. In Rem:

    • Most personal actions are in personam, directed against a particular person for the satisfaction of a personal claim or obligation.
    • This characteristic contrasts with in rem actions (many real actions are in rem or quasi in rem), which directly affect property and are binding upon the whole world.

  4. Relief Sought:

    • The main relief in personal actions is usually money damages, performance, or some personal liability.
    • The enforcement of judgment is typically against the person or personal/real property of the judgment debtor in a general sense (by levy, garnishment), rather than operating upon a specific real property as in real actions.

V. COMMON MISUNDERSTANDINGS AND CLARIFICATIONS

  1. When Real Property is Incidental:

    • Not every lawsuit mentioning land or buildings is necessarily a real action. For instance, an action for damages where real property damage is merely the result of a wrongful act, but the ownership or possession of the land is not in dispute, generally remains a personal action.

  2. Mixed Elements:

    • Some complaints may contain both real and personal claims (e.g., an action for partition that also seeks damages for the fruits or rentals). The dominant claim usually determines the classification. However, when in doubt, the safer approach is to treat it as a real action and file in the court of the situs of the property.

  3. Action to Nullify Deed over Land:

    • An action for declaration of nullity of a deed involving real property is typically a real action, since it directly affects title or an interest in the property.

  4. Partition of Estate:

    • A partition of an estate that includes real property is considered a real action with respect to the real property portion.

  5. Injunction or Prohibition:

    • Whether an injunction action is real or personal depends on the subject matter to be enjoined. If it involves preventing a person from encroaching on or further occupying land (affecting possession), it can be a real action; if it is simply enjoining a personal act (e.g., stopping publication of defamatory material), it is personal.

VI. PROCEDURAL EFFECTS AND STRATEGIC CONSIDERATIONS

  1. Venue Determination:

    • Correctly characterizing the action as real or personal is critical to avoid improper venue.
    • An incorrectly filed case may be subject to dismissal on the ground of improper venue.

  2. Jurisdictional Aspects:

    • For real actions involving real property where the assessed value or claims are above a certain threshold, the case must be filed in the proper court (generally the Regional Trial Court if the value is above what the Municipal Trial Courts can handle).
    • For personal actions, the determining factor is the amount of damages or claim; if it exceeds the jurisdictional amount of the first-level courts, it must be filed in the RTC.

  3. Annotations on Title (Real Actions):

    • In an action directly involving real property, a litigant may annotate a lis pendens on the Transfer Certificate of Title (TCT) or Original Certificate of Title (OCT) to give notice to third parties. This step is not applicable to purely personal actions.

  4. Provisional Remedies:

    • Provisional remedies (e.g., preliminary attachment, preliminary injunction, receivership, replevin) may be availed of in either real or personal actions, but the conditions differ. For instance:
      • Replevin is specific to personal property.
      • Attachment can apply to both personal and real actions but is typically employed in personal actions (collection of sums of money).

  5. Prescription:

    • The classification may also impact prescriptive periods (e.g., actions on real contracts vs. personal contracts, or actions to recover real property vs. purely personal suits).

VII. RELEVANT SUPREME COURT DECISIONS

  1. Heirs of Valeriano Concha, Sr. v. Spouses Lumocso (G.R. No. 177681, September 7, 2011)

    • Reiterated that an action involving ownership and recovery of possession of land is a real action and thus must be filed where the property is located.

  2. Sarmiento v. Court of Appeals (G.R. No. 126153, June 8, 2000)

    • Distinguished between an action for recovery of possession (real action) and an action for damages for trespass (personal action).

  3. Estate of Juliana Fernando v. Court of Appeals (G.R. No. 120802, April 12, 2000)

    • Clarified that a complaint primarily for damages where real property is merely incidental to the claim remains a personal action.

  4. Aldovino v. Alunan III (G.R. No. 182677, December 4, 2009)

    • Although focusing on other legal issues, the Court emphasized the importance of venue rules and the distinction between in rem/quasi in rem (often real actions) and in personam (personal actions).

VIII. SAMPLE LEGAL FORMS (OVERVIEW)

Although the exact formats of pleadings may vary depending on practice, below are general headings/forms illustrating distinctions in how complaints might be captioned and where they must be filed:

  1. Complaint for Sum of Money (Personal Action)

    • Title: “Complaint for Collection of Sum of Money”
    • Allegation focuses on the defendant’s obligation to pay money.
    • Venue: Where plaintiff or defendant resides, at plaintiff’s option.

  2. Complaint for Recovery of Ownership (Accion reivindicatoria) (Real Action)

    • Title: “Complaint for Recovery of Ownership (Accion reivindicatoria) involving Real Property”
    • Venue: RTC of the province/city/municipality where the property is located.
    • Relief: Declaration of ownership, issuance of new title, damages (if any).

  3. Complaint for Partition (Real Action)

    • Title: “Complaint for Partition of Real Property”
    • Must be filed in the place where the property is located.
    • Relief: Physical or legal partition, accounting of fruits, etc.

  4. Complaint for Breach of Contract of Sale of Personal Property (Personal Action)

    • Title: “Complaint for Specific Performance and Damages”
    • Venue: Plaintiff’s or defendant’s residence.
    • Relief: Payment of money or performance, not affecting real property title.

  5. Complaint for Foreclosure of Real Estate Mortgage (Real Action)

    • Title: “Complaint for Judicial Foreclosure of Real Estate Mortgage”
    • Venue: Location of the real property mortgaged.
    • Relief: Sale of property to satisfy the debt, deficiency judgment.

IX. CONCLUSION

The distinction between personal actions and real actions is foundational in Philippine civil procedure. It affects:

  • Venue (where the case must be filed);
  • Jurisdiction (which court will hear the case based on nature and amount);
  • Relief and nature of judgment (in rem vs. in personam);
  • Procedural strategies (e.g., whether to annotate a lis pendens, the possibility of replevin, etc.).

To properly file and prosecute a case, the material allegations of the complaint must be carefully evaluated to determine whether the dispute revolves around title to or possession of real property or simply enforces a personal right or obligation. This classification, though seemingly simple in principle, can become complex in fact-specific scenarios; hence, meticulous legal analysis and drafting are essential to avoid fatal procedural missteps.

Disclaimer: This discussion is intended for general informational and educational purposes. It does not constitute legal advice. For specific concerns and fact patterns, always consult with a qualified Philippine attorney or seek guidance from the appropriate judicial and administrative bodies.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login