Summons (RULE 14) | CIVIL PROCEDURE

Below is a comprehensive discussion of Summons under Rule 14 of the Rules of Court in the Philippines, incorporating the latest amendments and jurisprudential guidelines. The goal is to cover everything a practitioner should know—concepts, procedures, types of service, effects, and related considerations under remedial law and legal ethics. While extensive, always consult the actual text of the Rules of Court and current Supreme Court circulars or decisions for precise language and any recent changes.

I. CONCEPT AND PURPOSE OF SUMMONS

  1. Definition
    Summons is the writ or process issued by the court informing a defendant (or respondent) that an action has been commenced against him or her. It also notifies the defendant to appear and answer the complaint within the time fixed by the Rules.

  2. Purpose

    • Jurisdictional Aspect: In actions in personam (where personal liability is sought), service of summons on the defendant is indispensable for the court to acquire jurisdiction over the person of the defendant.
    • Due Process: Summons ensures that the defendant’s constitutional right to due process is respected, giving the defendant an opportunity to be heard and defend.

  3. Who Issues the Summons

    • The Clerk of Court issues the summons upon filing of the complaint and payment of the docket and other fees.
    • If no summons is issued and served, any resulting judgment is null and void as to that unserved defendant (for an action in personam).

II. RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF RULE 14 (AS AMENDED)

Rule 14 of the Rules of Court (as amended by the 2019 Amendments, effective May 1, 2020) details the rules regarding issuance and service of summons.

  1. Section 1: Clerk to Issue Summons

    • Upon filing the complaint and payment of required fees, the Clerk of Court issues the summons, which must contain the name of the court, the names of the parties, the docket number, and a clear directive to the defendant to answer within the time fixed by the Rules (which, ordinarily, is 30 calendar days from receipt of summons, except as otherwise provided by law or special rules).

  2. Section 2: Contents of Summons

    • Summons must be signed by the Clerk of Court and bear the seal of the court.
    • Must also contain a warning that unless defendant so answers, plaintiff may take judgment by default and may be granted the relief prayed for in the complaint.

  3. Section 3: By Whom Served

    • Summons must be served by the sheriff or other proper court officer, or for justifiable reasons, by a person specially authorized by the court.
    • This ensures service is made by a neutral and authorized server.

  4. Section 4: Return of Summons

    • The officer or server of summons makes a return within five (5) days from service, stating the manner, place, and date of service and other relevant facts.
    • If the summons cannot be served within 30 calendar days from issuance, it must be returned with the reasons for failure to serve.

III. MODES OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS

A. Personal Service (Sec. 5)

  1. Primary Mode

    • The rules require personal service of summons on the defendant, whenever practicable.
    • Service is done by handing a copy of the summons and the complaint (and attached documents) to the defendant in person.

  2. Personal Delivery

    • If defendant refuses to receive the summons, service is effected by tendering it to the defendant.
    • The server must note the refusal in the return.

  3. Importance

    • Personal service is superior to substituted or any other mode. Substituted service can only be resorted to if personal service “cannot be made promptly” or if certain conditions exist.

B. Substituted Service (Sec. 6)

  1. When Allowed

    • The server must show that personal service cannot be made within a reasonable time despite diligent efforts and reasonable inquiries.
    • Diligent efforts include, for instance, attempts to find the defendant at home or office, verifying addresses, or ascertaining the whereabouts of the defendant from neighbors or co-workers.

  2. Manner of Substituted Service

    • (a) Leaving Copies at defendant’s residence with a person of sufficient age and discretion who resides therein; or
    • (b) Leaving Copies at defendant’s office or regular place of business with a competent person in charge.
    • It is crucial to ensure that the person served knows the defendant personally and is likely to deliver the summons to him or her.

  3. Proof of Impossibility

    • The officer’s return must detail the efforts made to personally serve and the circumstances warranting resort to substituted service.
    • Strict compliance with these requirements is demanded by jurisprudence; courts carefully scrutinize the proof of failure of personal service.

C. Service Upon Entities (Sec. 13 for Private Juridical Entities; Sec. 14 for Public Corporations)

  1. Domestic Private Juridical Entities (Sec. 13)

    • Summons may be served on the president, managing partner, general manager, corporate secretary, treasurer, or in-house counsel.
    • For partnerships, service may be made on a general partner or the person in charge of its principal place of business.

  2. Foreign Private Juridical Entities (Sec. 14)

    • If they are registered with the SEC, service is made on their resident agent designated in accordance with law.
    • If no such agent is designated, or the agent cannot be found, service may be made on the government official designated by law to receive summons (e.g., the SEC in certain cases), or by extraterritorial service if the action is in personam and defendant cannot be served in the Philippines.

  3. Public Corporations (Sec. 15)

    • Summons upon the Republic of the Philippines is served on the Solicitor General.
    • For local government units, on the executive head (e.g., mayor) or other official designated by law.
    • For a government instrumentality with separate juridical personality, on the officer or person designated by law to accept service.

D. Extraterritorial Service (Sec. 17)

  1. When Applicable

    • If the defendant does not reside and is not found in the Philippines, and the action involves the defendant’s property within the Philippines or the suit is in rem or quasi in rem (like actions for partition, property foreclosure, etc.), extraterritorial service may be resorted to.

  2. Modes of Extraterritorial Service

    • Personal service outside the Philippines, if practicable;
    • Publication in a newspaper of general circulation in the place where the action is pending, along with a copy of the summons and order of the court. Usually accompanied by registered mail to the last known address of the defendant;
    • Any other manner the court may deem sufficient (e.g., email, other electronic means, or a combination of publication and electronic service) to apprise defendant of the pendency of the action.

  3. Leave of Court Requirement

    • For extraterritorial service, the plaintiff must file a motion for leave to effect extraterritorial service, supported by affidavits or other proof showing that the defendant is outside the Philippines and the property or subject of the action is located within the jurisdiction.

  4. Effects

    • Generally, extraterritorial service vests jurisdiction over the res, not necessarily over the person (unless the defendant voluntarily appears), since the action is typically in rem or quasi in rem.

IV. ACTIONS IN PERSONAM, IN REM, AND QUASI IN REM

  1. In Personam

    • Seeks to impose personal liability on the defendant (e.g., collection of sum of money).
    • Valid service of summons on the defendant or the defendant’s voluntary appearance is required for the court to acquire jurisdiction over the person.

  2. In Rem or Quasi in Rem

    • Involves the status of the property or the person (e.g., annulment of marriage, actions involving property ownership, partition, etc.).
    • Jurisdiction is acquired by the court over the res (the property or status).
    • Summons is still required to comply with due process, but failure to serve summons may not deprive the court of jurisdiction over the res, provided extraterritorial or other appropriate service is undertaken consistent with the Rules.

V. PROOF AND RETURN OF SERVICE

  1. Return of Officer (Sec. 4, Rule 14)

    • The sheriff or process server must file a return with the court detailing (a) the manner, place, and date of service, (b) the name of the person served, and (c) any relevant circumstances.
    • If service was not effected, reasons must be stated in the return.

  2. Importance of a Valid Return

    • The return is a vital part of the court record. Courts rely on this to determine jurisdiction over the defendant or the res.
    • If the return is defective or lacks details, the court may order a new summons or direct the officer to clarify or correct.

  3. Affidavit of Server

    • In extraterritorial service or substituted service, the rules and jurisprudence generally require that the process server’s affidavit or return must detail the efforts taken to effect personal service, the method used, and confirm compliance with the specifics of the relevant rules.

VI. DEFECTIVE SERVICE OF SUMMONS AND CURES

  1. Effect of Defective or Invalid Service

    • In an in personam action, the court does not acquire jurisdiction over the defendant if service was invalid. Any resulting judgment is void as to the unserved defendant.

  2. Voluntary Appearance

    • A defendant’s voluntary appearance in court (e.g., filing a Motion to Dismiss on grounds other than lack of jurisdiction, or filing an Answer) is equivalent to service of summons, thus curing defects in service or even total lack of service.
    • However, a special appearance solely to question the court’s jurisdiction over the person does not waive the objection to defective or improper service.

  3. Amended or Alias Summons

    • If service is found improper, the court may order alias summons or corrected summons to be served properly.
    • This is often done if the summons is returned unserved or if there were procedural lapses in the original service.

VII. ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS AND BEST PRACTICES

  1. Diligence in Service

    • Sheriffs and process servers are expected to carry out service with utmost diligence and integrity. Fabricating or falsifying returns is a serious offense that can result in administrative sanctions, including dismissal from service or contempt.

  2. Candor to the Court

    • Lawyers must ensure that the addresses provided for the defendant are accurate and must promptly inform the court of any updated or additional addresses.
    • Under the Code of Professional Responsibility, counsel is duty-bound to employ fair and honest methods to expedite litigation, which includes providing correct and complete information for service.

  3. Non-Evasion

    • A defendant who takes active steps to evade service can be subject to substituted or extraterritorial service, and such behavior can be considered when assessing credibility or awarding costs.
    • Conversely, lawyers must not advise clients to “hide” or intentionally avoid service to derail the proceedings.

  4. Documentation

    • From a litigation standpoint, properly documenting the circumstances of service (photos, signed receipts, eyewitness affidavits) can avoid future disputes or allegations of improper service.

VIII. SPECIAL CASES AND RELATED PROVISIONS

  1. Service of Summons in Small Claims, Summary Procedure, and Other Special Rules

    • Some special rules (e.g., Rules on Summary Procedure, Small Claims Cases) incorporate expedited or simplified modes of service. However, the essence of notice to the defendant remains the same.
    • In small claims, for instance, the court often issues summons with a date for hearing, and personal service remains the primary rule. Substituted service still applies if personal service is impossible.

  2. E-Service Developments

    • The Supreme Court has begun to allow, in some instances, electronic means of service, subject to the court’s discretion and specific rules or guidelines (e.g., issuance of e-summons, service via email).
    • Always confirm the applicability of these new guidelines, as courts usually require a prior motion and demonstration that e-service is feasible, particularly where the defendant is known to maintain an active email address.

  3. Multiple Defendants

    • Each defendant must be served individually unless there is a recognized agent for co-defendants or the defendants are covered by the same notice in a quasi in rem action.
    • Failure to serve one defendant does not necessarily invalidate the summons to the others—each defendant’s case is assessed separately as to whether jurisdiction over that party was acquired.

IX. SUMMARY OF KEY POINTS

  1. Rule 14 comprehensively governs summons in civil actions.
  2. Personal service is the gold standard. Substituted service must be justified by an honest showing of impossibility to serve personally within a reasonable time.
  3. Service on juridical entities must be upon the enumerated officers or agents, and in their absence, other recognized modes (like extraterritorial service) may be utilized.
  4. Extraterritorial service is allowed for actions in rem or quasi in rem, or when defendant is outside the Philippines. This requires leave of court and strict compliance with the rules.
  5. Defective service in in personam actions results in lack of jurisdiction over the defendant; however, voluntary appearance by the defendant cures any defect.
  6. Proper return or proof of service is crucial; it must detail all relevant facts to support the validity of the service.
  7. Ethics: Lawyers and sheriffs must act with utmost good faith, candor, and diligence in effecting service; any manipulation or deception undermines due process and can lead to sanctions.

X. LEGAL FORMS (ILLUSTRATIVE SAMPLES)

Below are simplified examples. Always tailor them to your specific case and consult local practice or court requirements.

1. Summons (Regular Form)

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
[Branch], [Judicial Region]
[City/Province]

[Case Title]

CIVIL CASE NO. ______

SUMMONS

TO: [Name of Defendant]
    [Address]

GREETINGS:

You are hereby required, within thirty (30) calendar days from receipt of this Summons, to file with this Court and serve on Plaintiff your Answer to the attached Complaint. Failure to do so within the time fixed will authorize the Court to render judgment against you by default and grant the relief prayed for in the Complaint.

WITNESS my hand under the seal of the Court, this ____ day of ______, 20___ at [place].

__________________________
Clerk of Court
(Seal)

2. Sheriff’s Return (Personal Service)

SHERIFF’S RETURN

I, [Name of Sheriff/Process Server], hereby certify that on [date], at around [time], I personally served the Summons, together with a copy of the Complaint and its annexes, upon [Name of Defendant] at [address]. Defendant acknowledged receipt thereof by signing/ accepting the documents personally.

This Return is respectfully submitted this ____ day of ______, 20___ at [place].

_____________________
[Name and Signature]
Sheriff/Process Server

3. Sheriff’s Return (Substituted Service)

SHERIFF’S RETURN

I, [Name of Sheriff/Process Server], hereby certify that on [date], I attempted to serve the Summons with a copy of the Complaint and annexes upon [Defendant’s Name] at [address]. Despite diligent efforts, Defendant was not found. I made inquiries from neighbors/co-workers to determine his whereabouts, to no avail.

On [date of last attempt], at around [time], I left copies of the Summons, Complaint, and annexes with [Name of Person], a person of suitable age and discretion, residing/ in charge at the above address, who agreed to receive the same.

In view of the foregoing, substituted service was effected on [date], pursuant to Section 6, Rule 14 of the Rules of Court.

Respectfully submitted this ____ day of ______, 20___ at [place].

_____________________
[Name and Signature]
Sheriff/Process Server

These forms are for illustration only; different jurisdictions or courts might have their own formatting requirements or templates.

CONCLUSION

Under Rule 14 of the Philippine Rules of Court, Summons is a critical process that ensures compliance with due process and vests jurisdiction over the defendant (in in personam actions) or over the res (in actions in rem or quasi in rem). Strict adherence to the Rules—whether in personal, substituted, or extraterritorial service—is required. Proper return and proof of service are essential. Any lawyer or process server must act with diligence and honesty to uphold the integrity of judicial proceedings. By meticulously following Rule 14’s provisions and relevant jurisprudence, parties protect the fundamental rights of notice and hearing, and ensure that any resulting judgment stands on firm procedural grounds.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login